Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10545 (KAR)

SMT.GUNDAMMA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/202083/2018 · 2025-01-15

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $%" " & ' ! "# # $ % # $ % # # % % & $ ! & ## % & $ % # % % ' $ ( $ $ ! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ) # & $ % ! * %% & & $ % & & # ! # % # ! "# ( # % !!' !!+ % % # % % , # # ! ! +! + $ -! '+ , # # $ % % $ , % # % # ./ # - 3 - 0 ( ( 12 3245456728 19: ;19<<27=2> 97 68>28 ?29857= -! '+ >942> ! +! + 39::2> ?@ 82:367>274 6! 82A2;457= 97 93329< B5<2> ?@ 128 C7>28 2;4567 * 6B 412 987949D9 ;12>C<2> 9:42: ;12>C<2> 85?2: 97> 4128 9;DE98> <9::2: 2:28F94567 6B 336574G274: 24; ;4 -- B68 :1684 .412 ;4 6B -- / 12 19: 9<:6 :6C=14 B68 9 ;67:2HC27459< 82<52B 46 8257:4942 128 5746 :28F5;2 E541 BC<< ?9;D E9=2: ;67457C54@ 6B :28F5;2 E541 9<< 64128 ?272B54: ! 12 B9;4: 9: :4942> ?@ 412 3245456728 57 412 E854 32454567 982 4194 :12 E9: 93365742> 9: 97 ::5:4974 29;128 57 412 @298 --* C7>28 412 82:28F2> ;942=68@ 12 BC875:12> 128 ;9:42 97> 57;6G2 ;2845B5;942 5::C2> ?@ 412 AC85:>5;45679< 919:5<>98 E15;1 E9: B68E98>2> B68 F285B5;94567 12 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 8236842> 4194 412 3245456728 >5> 764 ?2<67= 46 412 ;9:42 E15;1 :12 ;<95G2> 67:2HC274<@ 412 3245456728 97> - 4 - :5G5<98<@ :54C942> 9::5:4974 429;128: E282 428G57942> 67 412 =86C7> 4194 412@ >5> 764 386>C;2 412 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942 12 3245456728 ;19<<27=2> 412 :95> 68>28 ?2B682 412 987949D9 >G575:48945F2 85?C79< 57 33<5;94567 6!!)! 12 85?C79< ?@ 68>28 >942> + '! ) >5:G5::2> 412 933<5;94567 ?C4 82:28F2> <5?284@ 46 412 3245456728 46 ;19<<27=2 412 823684 6B 412 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 57 97 93329< ;;68>57=<@ 412 3245456728 933869;12> 412 9332<<942 9C416854@ C7>28 2;4567 * 6B 412 ;4 6B -- 12 93329< B5<2> ?@ 412 3245456728 E9: 82A2;42> 57 428G: 6B 412 68>28 >942> ! +! + 12 9<:6 933869;12> 82:367>274 6* 16357= 46 6?4957 9 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942 9: 328 9 <24428 9>>82::2> ?@ 412 # C<?98=9 6E2F28 412 82:367>274 6* 5::C2> 97 27>68:2G274 4194 412 >6;CG274: E282 G682 4197 ! @298: 6<> 97> 41282B682 54 E9: 764 36::5?<2 46 5::C2 9 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942 12 3245456728 5: 41282B682 ?2B682 415: 6C84 ;19<<27=57= 412 68>28 >942> ! +! + 82A2;457= 412 93329< 97> 19: :6C=14 ;67:2HC27459< 82<52B: - 5 - ) 12 3245456728 ;67427>: 4194 57 412 G297E15<2 412 2;82498@ 46 412 6F287G274 6B 987949D9 F5>2 <24428 >942> ' --- 19> >582;42> 412 82:367>274: 764 46 428G57942 412 :28F5;2: 6B 2G3<6@22: E16:2 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942: E282 764 82;25F2> B86G 412 7;6G2 97> 9:42 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 672412<2:: 9 B2E 429;128: E282 82<52F2> 67 412 =86C7> 4194 412 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942: E282 764 82;25F2> 12 ;67427>: 4194 C7>28 416:2 ;58;CG:497;2: B6C8 :5G5<98<@ :54C942> ::5:4974 29;128: 933869;12> 412 987949D9 >G575:48945F2 85?C79< 57 33<5;94567 6:!!-! !!)+! !!)! 97> !!* ! E15;1 E282 >5:36:2> 6BB ?@ 68>28 >942> !* +! ! 16<>57= 4194 54 E9: 412 >C4@ 6B 412 >23984G274 46 6?4957 412 F285B5;94567F9<5>54@ 7 412 ?9:5: 6B 412 >582;4567: 5::C2> ?@ 412 85?C79< 412 82:367>274 6 ?@ 68>28 >942> ! ! * 19> 8257:4942> 97> 2I427>2> 9<< ;67:2HC27459< ?272B54: 46 412 3245456728: 4128257 12 3245456728 5: 41282B682 ?2B682 415: 6C84 ;19<<27=57= 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 82:367>274 6! 97> :22D: B68 9 BC84128 - 6 - >582;4567 46 412 82:367>274 6 46 8257:4942 128 5746 :28F5;2 * 29872> 27568 6C7:2< 82382:27457= 412 3245456728 ;67427>: 4194 412 987949D9 >G575:48945F2 85?C79< 57 412 ;9:2 6B 412 3245456728 97> 64128: 19> >582;42> 412 3245456728 46 933869;1 412 9332<<942 9C416854@ ;19<<27=57= 412 823684 6B 412 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 E15<2 57 :5G5<98 ;58;CG:497;2: 412 :9G2 85?C79< 19> 12<> 4194 54 5: 412 >C4@ 6B 412 2G3<6@28 46 6?4957 412 ;9:42 97> 57;6G2 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942 2 :C?G54: 4194 ?9:2> 67 412 <9428 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 85?C79< 412 9::5:4974 429;128: E16 E282 :5G5<98<@ :54C942> 9: 412 3245456728 E282 8257:4942> 5746 :28F5;2 2 41282B682 ;67427>: 4194 412 3245456728 5: 9<:6 27454<2> 46 ?2 482942> 9<5D2 97> 128 :28F5;2 5: 9<:6 46 ?2 82:4682> <29872> >>545679< 6F287G274 >F6;942 :C?G54: 4194 412 3245456728 >5> 764 ;19<<27=2 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 >G575:48945F2 85?C79< 57 33<5;94567 6!!)! ?C4 9<<6E2> 54 46 ?2;6G2 B579< 2 :C?G54: - 7 - 4194 B6<<6E57= 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 85?C79< 412 3245456728 B5<2> 97 93329< ?2B682 82:367>274 6! E15;1 39::2> 412 5G3C=72> 68>28 16<>57= 4194 3245456728 19> B5<2> 9 ?2<942> 93329< 97> >5> 764 386>C;2 412 823684 6B 412 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 97> 4194 82:367>274 6* 19> 5::C2> 97 27>68:2G274 4194 41282 E282 76 >6;CG274: 9F95<9?<2 E541 54 2 41282B682 :C?G54: 4194 412 3245456728 ;97764 76E 9::95< 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 987949D9 4942 >G575:48945F2 85?C79< 68 9442G34 46 >5<C42 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 85?C79< ?@ ;67427>57= 4194 412 85?C79< 19> 57 :5G5<98 ;58;CG:497;2: 49D27 9 >5BB28274 F52E 1C: 12 ;67427>: 4194 412 3245456728 5: 764 27454<2> 46 97@ 82<52B: 57 415: 32454567 ' 19F2 ;67:5>282> 412 :C?G5::567: 6B 412 <29872> 27568 6C7:2< B68 412 3245456728 97> 412 <29872> >>545679< 6F287G274 >F6;942 B68 412 82:367>274: + 4 5: 764 57 >5:3C42 4194 412 :28F5;2: 6B 412 3245456728 E9: 428G57942> 67 412 =86C7> 4194 E127 412 ;9:42 ;2845B5;942 6B 412 3245456728 E9: :274 B68 F285B5;94567 - 8 - 412 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 E9: 6B 412 6357567 4194 412 3245456728 >5> 764 ?2<67= 46 412 ;9:42 ;<95G2> ?@ 128 15: 68>28 6B 428G5794567 6B 412 :28F5;2 6B 412 3245456728 E9: ;19<<27=2> ?@ 412 3245456728 97> :5G5<98<@ :54C942> 328:67: 57 33<5;94567 6!!)! 97> 64128 933<5;94567: 12 987949D9 4942 >G575:48945F2 85?C79< 12<> 4194 97 93329< 5: 386F5>2> C7>28 2;4567 * 6B 412 ;4 6B -- 9=957:4 9 823684 6B 412 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 97> 41282B682 =89742> <5?284@ 46 412 3245456728 46 B5<2 97 93329< ?2B682 412 93386385942 9C416854@ %6<<6E57= 415: 68>28 412 3245456728 ;19<<27=2> 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 5:485;4 9:42 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 ?2B682 412 332<<942 C416854@ C7>28 2;4567 * 6B 412 ;4 6B -- 12 332<<942 C416854@ 466D 5746 ;67:5>2894567 9 ;6GGC75;94567 >942> ! !! !! * ?@ 412 82:367>274 6* 4194 41282 E282 76 >6;CG274: 9F95<9?<2 E541 54 97> 9<:6 19F57= 82=98> 46 412 B9;4 4194 412 3245456728 19> ?2<942><@ ;19<<27=2> 412 68>28 39::2> ?@ 412 9:42 97> 7;6G2 $285B5;94567 6GG54422 97> >5> 764 386>C;2 412 :95> 68>28 82A2;42> 412 93329< 6B - 9 - 412 3245456728 12 3245456728 19: 76E ;19<<27=2> 412 :95> 68>28 ?2B682 415: 6C84 57 415: 32454567 12 3245456728 5: 76E 48@57= 46 35==@ 85>2 67 412 68>28: 39::2> 57 412 ;9:2: 6B :5G5<98<@ :54C942> 328:67: E1282 412 85?C79< 19> 39::2> 97 68>28 16<>57= 4194 412 >C4@ 46 6?4957 9 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942 E9: C367 412 2G3<6@28 97> 764 67 412 2G3<6@22 97> 41282B682 412 68>28 428G579457= 412 2G3<6@22: 67 412 =86C7> 4194 412@ 19> 764 6?49572> 412 F9<5>54@ ;2845B5;942 E9: :24 94 79C=14 97> 412@ E282 68>282> 46 ?2 8257:4942> B 412 3245456728 5: C79?<2 46 2:49?<5:1 4194 :12 ?2<67=2> 46 9 39845;C<98 ;9:42 68 4194 128 57;6G2 E9: E2<< ?2<6E 412 <5G54 382:;85?2> 97> 41282B682 :12 E9: 27454<2> 46 ;<95G 412 ?272B54 6B 86C3 412 3245456728 ;97764 76E >89E 9 3989<<2< 97> ;67427> 4194 :5G5<98<@ :54C942> 429;128: E282 2I427>2> 412 ?272B54 - 4 5: 9<:6 82<2F974 46 7642 4194 C7>28 2;4567 * 6B 412 ;4 6B -- 412 ?C8>27 6B 386F57= 4194 9 328:67 68 15: 398274 68 =C98>597 ?2<67=: 46 ;12>C<2> - 10 - 9:42 ;12>C<2> 85?2: 68 64128 9;DE98> <9::2: 5: 67 412 933<5;974 4 E9: 41282B682 57;CG?274 C367 412 3245456728 46 19F2 386>C;2> >6;CG274: ?2B682 412 332<<942 C416854@ 46 2:49?<5:1 4194 :12 ?2<67=2> 46 9??9<5=9 ;9:42 97> 4194 128 57;6G2 E9: E2<< ?2<6E 412 <5G54 382:;85?2> B68 9 86C3 ;942=68@ 7 4194 F52E 6B 412 G94428 412 3245456728 5: 764 27454<2> 46 97@ 82<52B 57 415: E854 32454567 27;2 412 32454567 <9;D: G2854 97> 5: B 412 3245456728 5: 27454<2> 46 B5<2 97@ 82F5:567 C7>28 2;4567 *% 6B 412 ;4 6B -- :12 5: 94 <5?284@ 46 >6 :6 () &"' " # 5:4 6 < 6 !