- 1 - ! "#" $ %# & '# " % ()(*+,)( ++ ' !" # $ " " Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! % & ' ($!$) ($!$) % & ' #! * ! ) #! $)# $) ) # # +&+ ' + ,++ - 3 - & ,++' --./01 2/ 32 " 450 607250 389/ 2.53 .:105 0-392: #! 27 5 ;938 4 <54=05 32 >.4/8 380 0:3950 <52-0019:?/ 9: 59@0 2! ) 50?9/30501 6= 4A46.54?993=2@0: 2A9-034392: 4A46.54?9725380 2770:-0/<.:9/846A0.:1050-392:/#!($)#$) )5041;9380-392:#27 4:10-392:/4:1#27 2;5= 528969392: -3 ;89-8 9/ <0:19:? -2:/91054392: 607250 380 2.53 27 119392:4A 9B9A +.1?0 &+5 :'4:1+ 4A46.54?9 0451A045:01-2.:/0A725380<45390/ 9: 59@0 2! ) ;4/ 50?9/30501 6= 4A46.54?9 93= 2@0: 2A9-0 34392: 4A46.54?9 725 380 47250/491 2770:-0/ 4?49:/3 380 <039392:05/ 80509: 2: 380 64/9/ 27 380 795/3 9:725@4392: 14301 ))) 50-09B01 752@ 50/<2:10:3 2 80509: ;82 9/ 380 ;970 <039392:05 2 4--./01 2 09:? 4??590B01 6= 380 9@<.?:01 - 4 - -59@9:4A<52-0019:?/380<039392:05/450607250389/2.53 32>.4/8380/4@0 # 045:01 -2.:/0A 725 380 <039392:05/ 84B9:? 5093054301 380 ?52.:1/ .5?01 9: 380 <039392: /.6@93/ 3843 50/<2:10:3284/ @410 74A/04:164/0A0//4AA0?4392:/ 4?49:/3 805 8./64:1 4:1 89/ 50A439B0/ 2:A= ;938 4: 9:30:392: 32 -205-0 4:1 8454// 380@ 0/<2:10:3 2 84/A073380-2@<4:=278058./64:14:184/34C0:/80A305 9:805<450:3/D82./00/.6@93/38432:A=?0:054A4:1 2@:96./4AA0?4392:/45072.:14/4?49:/3<039392:052/ 32" 4--./012/32"9:380795/39:725@4392:;82450 -A2/0 50A439B0/ 27 <039392:05 2 4--./01 2 --2519:?A=80<54=/324AA2;380<039392: $ 05 -2:354 A045:01 9?8 2.53 2B05:@0:3 A04105 4<<0459:? 725 50/<2:10:3 2 4:1 A045:01 -2.:/0A4<<0459:?72550/<2:10:3284B02<<2/01380 <039392: 80= /.6@93 3843 50/<2:10:3 2 84/ 4AA0?4392:/9:380795/39:725@4392:4?49:/34AA3804--./01 <05/2:/ 4:1 380507250 9:B0/39?4392: 9: 380 9@<.?:01 - 5 - -59@9:4A<52-0019:?/-4::2360/-.33A01--2519:?A=380= <54=3219/@9//380<039392: 05./4A 27 380 795/3 9:725@4392: ;2.A1 ?2 32 /82; 3843 @45594?0 27 4--./01 2 <039392:05 2 ;938 50/<2:10:3 2 ;4/ /2A0@:9E01 6= 380 74@9A= @0@605/ 27 6238 380 <45390/ 2: ")#) 039392:05 2 4--./0124:150/<2:10:326238450>.4A97901 12-325/ 3 9/ 4AA0?01 9: 380 795/3 9:725@4392: 3843 43 380 39@0 27 @45594?0 4--./01 <05/2:/ 841 50-09B01 12;5= 752@38074@9A=@0@605/2750/<2:10:32:/<93027 380/4@050/<2:10:32;4/4AA0?01A=609:?9AA(3504301 9: 805 @4359@2:94A 82./0 9: 7.538054:-0 27 10@4:1 725 4119392:4A12;5=:380795/39:725@4392:/8084//34301 3843 9: 380 @2:38 27 +4:.45= ) /80 841 ?2:0 32 0:?4A.5. 725 7.53805 /3.190/ 4:1 3805047305 93 4<<045/ /80 ;4/ :23 50/919:? 9: 805 @4359@2:94A 82./0 43 4A46.54?9 : )) /80 4AA0?01A= -4@0 752@ 0:?4A.5. 32 4A46.54?9 4:1 2: )) /80 4A2:? ;938 805 74@9A= @0@605/ 841 ?2:0 32 805 @4359@2:94A - 6 - 82./04:12:380/49114303804--./01<05/2:/4AA0?01A= 46./014:14//4.A3018054:180574@9A=@0@605/:380 795/3 9:725@4392: 38050 450 :2 10/-59<392:/ 462.3 4:= /<0-979- 9:-910:3 3843 841 4AA0?01A= 34C0: <A4-0 9: 380 @4359@2:94A 82./0 27 50/<2:10:3 2 9: ;89-8 4--./01 <05/2:/ 841 9AA(3504301 805 :A= ?0:054A 4:1 2@:96./ 4AA0?4392:/ 450 @410 4:1 380 /491 4AA0?4392:/ 4/ 4?49:/3 4--./01 2/ 32 " 50A430/ 32 380 <05921 <5925 32 ) :19/<.301A= 752@ 380 @2:38 27 +4:.45= ) 2:;451/ 39AA 380 @2:38 27 +4:.45= ) 50/<2:10:3 2 ;4/ /34=9:? 43 0:?4A.5. 4:1 /80 ;4/ :23 /34=9:? 9: 805 @4359@2:94A 82./0 039392:05 2/ 32 " 450 4AA 4?01 <05/2:/ 4:1 380= 84B0 600: 4554=01 4/ 4--./01 9: 380 <50/0:3 -4/0 6= @4C9:? 2@:96./ 4AA0?4392:/ 2:A= 725 380 504/2: 3843 380= 450 -A2/0 50A439B0/ 27 <039392:05 2 4--./01 2 ;82 9/ 380 8./64:1 27 50/<2:10:3 280509: - 7 - " 80 2:,6A0 .<50@0 2.53 9: 380 -4/0 27 84/80A14/72AA2;/ ! "# $%&' &))'"" - 8 - ( ) $ * ( ) + ( ( , # # - # ( ( ! - 9 - . ! ) + ! .538053802:,6A0.<50@02.539:3804/0 27 4:1 9: 380 -4/0 27 84/ 26/05B01 3843 9: 380 46/0:-0 27 /<0-979- 4AA0?4392:/ ;89-8 ;2.A1 43354-3 380 2770:-0/ 4: 4330@<3 32 9@<A9-430 380 :045 50A439B0/ 27 380 8./64:1 -4::23 60 <05@93301 89/ 2.53 9: 380 -4/0 27 2 &)'#$ 3 &)'!# - 10 - 84/ 80A1 3843 ;80: 380 @430594A 2: 50-251 ;2.A1 ?2 32 /82; 3843 380 <039392:05/ ;82 450 -A2/0 50A439B0/278./64:1450@4559014:150/919:?/0<45430A= 4:1;80:380-2@<A49:3A4-C//<0-979-4AA0?4392://24/32 9@<A9-430 380 <039392:05/ 725 380 2770:-0/ 4AA0?01 4?49:/3 380@ /.-8 -59@9:4A <52/0-.392: /84AA :23 60 4AA2;01 32 -2:39:.0 ) : 380 -4/0 2: 84:1 ?0:054A 4:1 2@:96./ 4AA0?4392:/ 450 72.:1 4/ 4?49:/3 <039392:05 2/ 32 " 4--./012/32"4:164/012:/.-84AA0?4392:/97380 9@<.?:01-59@9:4A<52-0019:?/9/4AA2;013260-2:39:.01 4/ 4?49:/3 380@93 ;2.A14@2.:3 3246./027<52-0//27 A4;--2519:?A=72AA2;9:?251059/<4//01 80-59@9:4A<039392:9/<453A=4AA2;018059@9:4A <039392: 9/ 19/@9//01 4?49:/3 <039392:05 2 4:1 4AA2;01 4/4?49:/3<039392:052/32" 4 ))&' +) - 11 - 80 0:3950 <52-0019:?/ 9: 59@0 2! ) 50?9/30501 6= 4A46.54?9 93= 2@0: 2A9-0 34392: 4A46.54?9 725 380 2770:-0/ <.:9/846A0 .:105 0-392:/ #!( $)# $) ) 5041 ;938 0-392: # 27 4:1 0-392:/ 4:1 # 27 2;5= 528969392: -3 ;89-8 9/ <0:19:? -2:/91054392: 607250 380 2.53 27 119392:4A 9B9A +.1?0 &+5 :' 4:1 + 4A46.54?9 4/ 4?49:/3 <039392:05 2/ 32 " 4--./01 2/ 32 " /34:1/ >.4/801 -, ( & '# "+ # 9/32A2