- 1 - !! "#$$# % &&'&(&) * !"# $ % % & '" !"# $ % ( ) % Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (( *' ( ( ( #* ( & + ###" % + +( #* ( (( & ( + ( ( + & % ,++- $# ,++- ./0123456(/60788154/09:7.1;1<1=;5=7 > /=./0/=;/?/;354@585@/7:5=;540>50412546186101=757/?1 ><;1<1=;5=7 >@.5441=2/=27.1A3;2B1=75=;;1@611 85001;9:7.176/54>367;1@611/=27.103/7<>68567/7/>= 5=; 01856571 8>00100/>= >< .54< 0.561 /= 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167: - 3 - (>6 7.1 05C1 >< @>=?1=/1=@1 7.1 8567/10 561 61<1661;7>9:7.1/665=C091<>617.16/54>367 " 7 /0 7.1 @501 >< 7.1 845/=7/<< 7.57 0.1 5=; ;1<1=;5=7 >5610/94/=20.1/60/07165=/C5/;/1; /00314100 3/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 D161 5=@107654 5=; A>/=7 <5B/4: 86>8167/10 >< 845/=7/<< 5=; ;1<1=;5=7 > .5?/=2 /=.16/71; 9: 7.1/6 <57.16 <6>B ./0 5=@107>60 1<1=;5=7 > /0 7.1 0>= >< ;1<1=;5=7 > /=@1 0>B1 >< 7.1 86>8167/10 561 B37571; /= 7.1 =5B1 >< ;1<1=;5=7 >.1/0B5;158567:7>7.103/7 <716 ./0 ;157. 7.1: 561 /= A>/=7 8>00100/>= 5=; @347/?57/>= >< 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 1<1=;5=7 >301;7>2/?1.54<0.561/=7.1@6>8065/01;/=7.1 03/7 0@.1;34186>8167/10 < 4571.1 .50 =>72/?1=.16 0.561 = ?16/</@57/>= >< 7.1 61?1=31 61@>6;0 845/=7/<< 6154/E1; 7.57 7> ;1<653; 7.1 0.561 >< 7.1 845/=7/<< 7.1 =5B10 >< ;1<1=;5=70 561 B37571; /= 7.1 61?1=31 61@>6;0/1 >37><5@610 23=750>< : >* >< - 4 - ./6>44/5=1F71=7><5@61023=750/=7.1=5B1>< ;1<1=;5=7 > 5@610 # 23=750 /= 7.1 =5B1 >< 845/=7/<<5=;G5@610""23=750/=7.1=5B1><;1<1=;5=7 >7D50;>=191./=;7.195@C><845/=7/<<.1:561 540>610765/=/=27.1845/=7/<<<6>B?/0/7/=27.103/745=;0 .161<>61845/=7/<<61H31071;;1<1=;5=7 >7>2/?1.16 0.561D./@..161<301;5=;.1=@17.103/7 1<1=;5=70</41;D6/771=07571B1=705;B/77/=2 7.1 61457/>=0./8 917D11= 7.1 8567/10 5=; 7.57 03/7 0@.1;34186>8167/10D161/=.16/71;9:<57.16><845/=7/<< 5=;;1<1=;5=7 > <6>B./0 5=@107>60 >D1?167.1: .5?1;1=/1;7.57845/=7/<<5=;;1<1=;5=70561B1B9160 >< 3=;/?/;1; A>/=7 <5B/4: 5=; 5<716 7.1 ;157. >< .16 <57.160.1/0/=A>/=78>00100/>=5=;1=A>:B1=75=;D50 2/?1= 1H354 0.561 /= 7.1 @6>80 65/01; 7.161/= /=@1 <6>B .16 B566/521 D./@. 7>>C 845@1 59>37 # :1560 95@C 7.1 845/=7/<< /0 610/;/=2 018565714: 57 3=A5625 .1 =1?16 1=A>:1; 7.1 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 A>/=74: - 5 - 7 /0 ;1=/1; 7.57 845/=7/<< 5=; ;1<1=;5=7 > 561 7.1 41254.1/60><7.1/6<57.16 <716 7.1 ;157. >< 7.1 <57.16 >< 845/=7/<< 5=; ;1<1=;5=7 >/7/0;1<1=;5=7 > 5=; D.> 561/= A>/=7 8>00100/>= 5=; 1=A>:B1=7 >< 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 7 /0 540> ;1=/1; 7.57 845/=7/<< ;1B5=;1; 0.561/=03/70@.1;34186>8167/107/076317.575@610 #23=750D502/?1=7>845/=7/<<4>=295@C50;1B5=;1; 9: .16 /= : >* >< ./6>44/ G 5@610 "" 23=750 075=;/=2 /= 7.1 =5B1 >< ;1<1=;5=7 > .161 /0 => @5301><5@7/>=<>67.103/75=;544121;>=1/0<54015=; 865:7>;/0B/007.103/7 ' 501; >= 7.101 8415;/=20 7.1 76/54 >367 <65B1;7.1<>44>D/=2/00310 &.17.16 845/=7/<< 86>?10 7.57 845/=7/<< 5=; ;1<1=;5=70 @>=07/73710 A>/=7 /=;3 <5B/4: 5=; 7.1 3/7 @.1;341 6>8167/10 561 7.1 5=@107654 5=; A>/=7 <5B/4: 86>8167/10><845/=7/<<5=;;1<1=;5=70I - 6 - &.17.16 845/=7/<< /0 1=7/741; <>6 614/1<J0 0>32.7<>6I " &.57 6;16>6 1@611I G 77.176/54845/=7/<<1F5B/=1;.16014<50& 5=; 7D> D/7=10010 50 & 5=; &" .1 614/1; 38>= F7>G ! = 7.1 >7.16 .5=; >= 91.54< >< ;1<1=;5=70 /=@43;/=2 ;1<1=;5=7 > <>36 D/7=10010 561 1F5B/=1; 50 & 7> & > ;>@3B1=70 561 B56C1; >= 7.1/6 91.54< * %/;17.1/B832=1;A3;2B1=75=;;1@6117.1 76/54>367;1@611;7.103/7 # 226/1?1; 9: 7.1 05B1 ;1<1=;5=7 > /0 91<>61 7./0 >367 @>=71=;/=2 7.57 7.1 /B832=1; A3;2B1=75=;;1@611/0/441254569/7656:5=;@>=7656:7> 7.145D5=;<5@70 37><036?1: >*B15036/=2 5@610 23=750 7> 5= 1F71=7 >< ' 5@610 ;/08371 /0 - 7 - 81=;/=291<>6145=;61<>6B076/93=54.161<>6103/7/0 =>7 B5/=75/=5941 37 >< 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 5@610#23=750/0544>771;7>7.10.561><845/=7/<<5=; 7.161<>61 936;1= /0 >= .16 7> 86>?1 7.57 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/1056107/44A>/=7 =@1525/=03/7<>68567/7/>=/0 =>7 B5/=75/=5941 5=; /7 /0 95661; 9: ;>@76/=1 >< 107>881403/7/0540>95661;9:4/B/757/>= #.103/7</41;9:71=5=7><: >*K /= >"# <>6 816B5=1=7 /=A3=@7/>= D50 ;/0B/001; >*#! </41; 525/=07 /7 /0 81=;/=2 5=; 7.161<>61 7.1 /B832=1; A3;2B1=7 D/44 610347 /= @>=<4/@7 >< >6;160 1<1=;5=70 .5?1 /=@3661; .321 1F81=010 <>6 ;1<1=;/=2 7.1 86>8167/10 91<>61 7.1 45=; 76/93=54 %/1D1; <6>B 5=: 5=241 7.1 /B832=1; A3;2B1=75=;;1@611561=>703075/=59415=;0>32.7<>6 0177/=250/;17.105B15=;;/0B/007.103/7 156; 5623B1=70 >< 9>7. 7.1 0/;10 5=; 816301;7.161@>6;0 - 8 - .161457/>=0./8917D11=7.18567/10/0=>7 /= ;/08371 &./41 ;1<1=;5=70 561 <57.16 5=; 0>= 845/=7/<</07.1:>3=2160/0716><;1<1=;5=7 >.1/6 5=>7.16 0/0716 9:=5B1 5=/C 5/ ;/1;/00314100 7 /0 540> =>7 /= ;/08371 7.57 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 D161 /=.16/71; 9: 7.1 <57.16 >< 845/=7/<< 5=; ;1<1=;5=7 > <6>B./05=@107>60=<5@7;36/=2./0@6>001F5B/=57/>= ;1<1=;5=7 >D.>/01F5B/=1;50 &.505;B/771; 7.57 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 D161 /=.16/71; <6>B ./0 265=;<57.16 >=;165> 5=; 58567 <6>B 7.1 05/; 86>8167/10 ./0 <57.16 .50 =>7 5@H3/61; 5=: >7.16 86>8167/10 " 1<1=;5=70 .5?1 =>7 8415;1; 7.57 7.1 8567/7/>= .50 911= 75C1= 845@1 D/7. 61256; 7> 7.1 03/7 0@.1;34186>8167/10>=01H31=74:5081601@7/>='>< 7.1/=;33@@100/>=B1=;B1=7@7##D./@.@5B1 /=7> <>6@1 D/7. 1<<1@7 <6>B #*#*## 5 ;532.716 >< @>856@1=16 9: 9/67. 91@>B1 5 @>856@1=16 /= .16 >D= - 9 - 6/2.7/=7.105B1B5==16507.10>=5?/=261256;7> 7.1 <5@7 7.57 ;1<1=;5=70 .5?1 =>7 8415;1; 8567/7/>= 91<>61 @>B/=2 /=7> <>6@1 >< /=;3 3@@100/>= B1=;B1=7@7##845/=7/<</0540>5@>856@1=169: 9/67. 5=; 0.1 /0 1=7/741; <>6 1H354 0.561 54>=2 D/7. ;1<1=;5=7 > 7/0544121;9:7.1845/=7/<<7.5791./=;.16 95@C ;1<1=;5=70 .5?1 2>7 B37571; .16 =5B1 7> 5= 1F71=7 >< 5@610 # 23=750 /= : >* = 7./0 61256; /= 7.1 D6/771= 07571B1=7 7.1 ;1<1=;5=70 .5?1 07571;7.575@610#23=750D502/?1=7>845/=7/<<4>=2 95@C50;1B5=;1;9:.16/=: >*><./6>44/.1 ;1<1=;5=70 .5?1 76/1; 7> 86>A1@7 50 7.>32. 5@610 # 23=750D502/?1=507.10.561><845/=7/<<=<5@7;36/=2 7.1@>3601><./01?/;1=@1 &.50;18>01;7.570.561 .50911=2/?1=7>7.1845/=7/<<.>32.;1<1=;5=7 > /0 1F5B/=1; 50 & .1 .50 =>7 039A1@71; ./B014< <>6 @6>00 1F5B/=57/>= 5=; 7.161<>61 7.1 05B1 @5==>7 91 - 10 - 75C1= /=7> @>=0/;1657/>= = 7.1 4/2.7 >< 7.1 <5@7 7.57 ;1<1=;5=70.5?1=>78415;1;7.5758567/7/>=.5075C1= 845@1 917D11= 845/=7/<< 5=; ;1<1=;5=70 7.1 <5@7 >< 1=716/=27.1=5B1><845/=7/<<7>5=1F71=7><5@610# 23=750@5==>79175C1=5;?5=7521><9:7.1;1<1=;5=70 507.>32.8567/7/>=.5075C1=845@1 (>6 7.1 </607 7/B1 ;36/=2 7.1 1?/;1=@1 >< & 5=; " /7 /0 ;18>01; 7.57 57 7.1 7/B1 B566/521 >< 845/=7/<<039075=7/54@50.5=;2>4;D502/?1=9:D5:>< 2/<7 5=; 50 03@. 0.1 /0 =>7 1=7/741; <>6 0.561 F@187 7.1/6014<016?/=207571B1=77.161/0=>1?/;1=@17>7.57 1<<1@7 = 7.1 4/2.7 >< 7.1 5B1=;B1=7 >< ## ;1<1=;5=70@5==>775C103@.5;1<1=@1 ' 45/=7/<< .50 8415;1; 7.57 ;108/71 .16 B566/521 0.1 5=; .16 .3095=; 075:1; /= ./6>44/ 5=; @>=7/=31 7> 1=A>: 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 A>/=74: D/7. ;1<1=;5=70 = 7.1 >7.16 .5=;0 ;1<1=;5=70 .5?1 @45/B1;7.570/=@1.16B566/521D./@.7>>C845@159>37 - 11 - #:156086/>67>7.1</4/=2><7.103/7845/=7/<</0=>7/= 8>00100/>= >< 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 5=; 7.161<>61 /=;/61@74: 7.1: 561 @45/B/=2 >30716 >D1?16 7.1 ;>@3B1=70 86>;3@1; 9: 7.1 845/=7/<< 107594/0. 7.1 <5@7 7.57 0.1 .16 .3095=; 5=; @./4;61= 561 610/;/=2 57 ./6>44/ = <5@7 &" 5=; .5?1 5;B/771; 7.57 845/=7/<<J0 55;.56 @56; 5=; 657/>= @56; 561 >< ./6>44/ ?/44521 ?1= >7.16D/01 /= 5 /=;3 A>/=7 <5B/4: 7.1 8>00100/>= 9: 7.1 @>856@1=16 /0 <>6 5=; >= 91.54< >< >7.16B1B91605=;/7/0A>/=75=;01?1654=41005=; 3=7/4 >30716 /0 86>?1; ;1<1=;5=70 @5==>7 @45/B 7.57 845/=7/<</0=>7/=A>/=78>00100/>=5=;1=A>:B1=7><03/7 0@.1;34186>8167/10 G 5?/=261256;7>7.1<5@77.57845/=7/<<5=; ;1<1=;5=70 561 B1B9160 >< @>856@1=56: 5=; 03/7 0@.1;341 86>8167/10 561 7.1/6 5=@107654 5=; A>/=7 <5B/4: 86>8167/10 5=; => 8567/7/>= .50 75C1= 845@1 917D11= 7.1B 58861@/57/=2 7.1 >654 5=; ;>@3B1=756: 1?/;1=@1 - 12 - 845@1;>=61@>6;7.176/54>367.506/2.74:;1@611;7.1 03/7.1</=;/=20><7.176/54>367561@>=0/071=7D/7. 7.11?/;1=@1>=61@>6;./0>367</=;0=>816?160/7: /= 7.1 @>=@430/>=0 566/?1; 57 9: 7.1 76/54 >367 >=01H31=74: 7.1 588154 /0 4/5941 7> 91 ;/0B/001; 5=; 5@@>6;/=24:7.1<>44>D/=2 / 88154 </41; 9: ;1<1=;5=70 /0 ;/0B/001; // .1 /B832=1;A3;2B1=75=;;1@611 ;571;###"/= >#* >= 7.1 </41 >< 1=/>6 /?/4 +3;21 K +(./=@.>4//0@>=</6B1; /// 1=; 95@C 7.1 76/54 >367 61@>6;0 54>=2 D/7. @>8: >< 7./0 A3;2B1=7 <>67.D/7. +( '$# %) $ /07 >4 >#