Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10520 (KAR)

SMT. KAVITA AND ORS v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/201693/2022 · 2025-01-06

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $%" " & ' ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - " # $ % # & % $ ' (# - 3 - ) * + (# ' & & (% (! ' $$ & & (# , ( (# ! , (# ) * & $ (( (- & $ ( ((!+ $ ! " $ $ $ ' ! $ '%( ' $ $ - 4 - '(#%( ,($ $ + $ ! $ ' , $ $ ! ! $ ,( ! # $ $ %#% $ $ ' $& ' $ ./ 0& & 12324545672891:;296<=14>68:?854574127:4<82 6>@284568:8546A<:9141257@6B3C242:?:8D3:992DEF412 829367D274 6 57 $5C2 6'%( D:42D ! :7D 46 D2@C:82 412 @6792A<2745:C :3386;:C 6> 412 :?:8D 57 $5C2 6'(#%( :9 :8E548:8F :7D @6748:8F 46 412 D<2 386@299 6> C:? 12F 1:;2 :C96 96<=14 >68 ?854 57 412 7:4<82 6> B:7D:B<9 46 D582@4 412 829367D2749 46 57545:42 :3386385:42 386@22D57=9 >68 :@A<5857= 412 2G4274 6> C:7D9 6> 412 32454567289 :9 82@6BB27D2D EF 412 829367D274 69 :7D ! 57 :CC - 5 - B2:9<857= :@829 ! =<74:9 EF @6795D2857= 412 823829274:45679 6> 412 32454567289 D:42D ! :7D # CC 412 32454567289 @67427D 41:4 412F :82 412 6?72896>;:856<92G42746>C:7D9576@1:H:71:CC5 5CC:=2 :=D:C 6EC5 5D:8 :C<H 12F @67427D 41:4 41258 C:7D9 ?2829<EB28=2D<7D28412:8:7I:86I2@4D<857=412F2:8 %#(# 12F @C:5B2D 41:4 41282 ?:9 76 :@A<5954567 57 82932@46>41258C:7DE<4?282D2385;2D6>549<9:=212 32454567289 41282>682 9<EB5442D 823829274:45679 46 829367D27469 :7D!12829367D27469:7D!4127 82@6BB27D2D >68 :@A<5954567 6> :DD54567:C C:7D 57 F69 " " " ( :7D B2:9<857= :@829 ! =<74:9 ;5D2 @68829367D27@2 D:42D #! :DD82992D46412829367D2746 12 23<4F 6BB59956728 41282:>428 96<=14 3:845@<C:89 >86B 412 829367D274 6 82=:8D57= 412 D594:7@2 :7D 412 2G4274 6> 3863284F 9<EB28=2D 57 412 E:@H?:4289 6> :8:7I: 86I2@4 12 829367D274 6 - 6 - 82@6BB27D2D 57545:4567 6> 386@22D57=9 46 :@A<582 412 :DD54567:C2G42746>C:7D9<EB28=2D<7D28412386I2@4:7D ><875912D D24:5C2D 2G3C:7:4567 46 412 23<4F 6BB59956728;5D2159@68829367D27@2D:42D#" 12 32454567289 @67427D 41:4 412 23<4F 6BB59956728 D582@42D 412 :195CD:8 5D:8 46 16CD : 9364 3:7@1:7:B: 5D2745>F57=4122G42746>C:7D9<EB28=2D@@68D57=CF412 :195CD:8><875912D:3:7@1:7:B:932@5>F57=4127:B296> 32454567289 :7D 412 2G4274 6> C:7D 41:4 ?:9 9<EB28=2D 1232454567289@67427D41:4416<=1:386369:C?:9B:D2 46 57545:42 :@A<5954567 6> :DD54567:C 2G4274 6> :@829 ! =<74:9 412 829367D274 6 D5D 764 57545:42 :7F 386@22D57=9 >68 :@A<5954567 E<4 829485@42D 54 57 82932@4 6> F6# B2:9<857= :@82 :7D F6% B2:9<857= :@829 :7D 67 ! :7 :?:8D ?:9 3:992D D2428B5757= 412 @6B3279:4567 3:F:EC2 57 82932@4 6> :@829 6> C:7D 12 32454567289 D599:459>52D ?541 412 B:8H24 ;:C<2 D2428B572D EF 412 829367D274 6 >5C2D 823829274:4567 D:42D ! 82A<29457= 412 829367D274 6 46 57545:42 :@A<5954567 386@22D57=9 57 - 7 - 82932@4 6> 2745822G4274 6> C:7D 41:4 ?:9 9<EB28=2D :7D :9 8236842D EF 829367D274 69 :7D ! ><84128 823829274:4567 ?:9 :C96 >5C2D 67 # 12 32454567289 41282>682 @67427D 41:4 957@2 41258 823829274:45679:82764@6795D282D829367D27465946 E2 D582@42D 46 @6795D28 412 823829274:45679 96 41:4 9<54:EC2 386@22D57=9 :82 57545:42D 46 :@A<582 412 C:7D B2:9<857= :@82 !=<74:9E2C67=57=4641232454567289 57942:D6>:@829:994:42D:E6;2 12 C2:872D @6<792C >68 412 32454567289 825428:42D 412 :>6829:5D @6742745679 :7D @67427D2D 41:4 412C:7D6>41232454567289599<EB28=2D<7D28?:428:7D 412829367D274659E6<7D46@6B3279:42>68412C:7D <45C5J2D>684129:5D386I2@4 12C2:872D@6<792C>68412829367D27469 :7D ! 9<EB549 41:4 412823829274:45679 6> 412 32454567289 D:42D !:7D#?6<CDE2@6795D282D57 412 C5=14 6> 412 823684 9<EB5442D EF 412 :195CD:8 5D:8 :7D412829367D27469:7D!:994:42D:E6;2 - 8 - ! 7 ;52? 6> 412 :>6829:5D 9<EB599567 4159 ?854 32454567 D2928;29 46 E2 D593692D 6>> ?541 412 >6CC6?57= D582@45679 5+ 12 829367D274 6 59 D582@42D 46 @6795D28 412 823829274:4567 6> 412 32454567289 :9 94:42D :E6;2 57412C5=146>4128236846>412:195CD:8:9?2CC:9 823684 6> 829367D274 69 :7D ! :7D 3:99 :3386385:42 68D289 82=:8D57= :@A<5954567 6> 412 C:7D E2C67=57= 46 412 32454567289 :7D 3:F @6B3279:4567:9328412B:8H24;:C<2:7D:49<@1 8:429 :9 3829@85E2D <7D28 412 9@12D<C2 46 412 5=14 46 $:58 6B3279:4567 :7D 8:793:827@F 57 :7D @A<5954567 21:E5C54:4567 :7D 29244C2B274 @4 55+ 12:>6829:5D2G28@59291:CCE2@6B3C242D?54157: 32856D6>41822B67419>86B412D:426>82@25346> :@63F6>415968D28 555+ 12 82A<294 6> 412 32454567289 46?:8D9 D:B:=29 >68 412 @8639 C699 91:CC E2 @6795D282D :>428 412 829367D274 6 3:9929 :3386385:42 68D289 82=:8D57= 412 @6B3279:4567 3:F:EC2 46 412 32454567289 :7D 412 9:B2 59 H234 6327 46 E2 @6795D282D :4 :7 :3386385:42 94:=2 4 59 B:D2 @C2:8 41:4 5> 412 @6B3279:4567 59 :?:8D2D :9 328 - 9 - 412 @4 4127 412 32454567289 91:CC 764 E2 27454C2D46@C:5BD:B:=29 () &"' " 5946C6 !