- 1 - !! " !#$# % $"$" ""&&'( !) * ! " ## $ %# " " & ! # ' ## ()(( LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.31 13:38:22 - 0800 - 2 - " ! " ## " * ## ()(+ $ %# "* ", "& %& " - ((! " ( # # * # # - " .#-- - 3 - $! %.#--& #/01232240/5/6789:/;<62=/193163>346?3@@/6 78 9:/ /=7/4 39 362040 01 "A ( 639/6 ((! 9:/ ?/9090A1/4@ 34/ 7/BA4/ 9:0@ A<49 @//C012/1:31D/=/19AB9:/DA=?/1@390A13=A<19 ( /346 9:/ E/341/6 DA<1@/E BA4 9:/ 3??/EE319@ 3169:/4/@?A16/19A ( :/ ?/9090A1/4@ DA19/16/6 9:39 A1 ((( 39 37A<9 +(( ?= A1 3C9:31 36>3E 4A36 9:/ 60@/3@/6 ??340360?03@40=<E<>3@?4AD//6012A1:0@ =A9A4D8DE/ 316 01 #<@ 7/34012 /2A ( F )!! D3=/ B4A= A??A@09/ 604/D90A1 01 :02: @?//6 316 DAEE06/6>09:9:/=A9A4D8DE/D3<@0129:/3DD06/19>:/4/01 9:/6/D/3@/6 3@40=<E<60/6399:/@?A9 D3@/D3=/9A 7/ 4/20@9/4/6 32301@9 7<@ 6405/4 E90=39/E8 9:/ D:342/ @://9 >3@ B0E/6 :/ ?/9090A1/4@ DA19/16/6 9:39 9:/ 6/D/3@/6 >3@ 32/6 37A<9 + 8/34@ >A4C012 3@ 3 =A9A4 - 4 - =/D:310D3163240D<E9<40@93169:/3DD06/19>3@6</9A9:/ 1/2E02/1D/ A1 9:/ ?349 AB 9:/ 6405/4 AB 9:/ 7<@ /1D/ 9:/8DE30=9:/DA=?/1@390A17/BA4/9:/407<13E ( :/ ?/9090A1 >3@ A??A@/6 78 9:/ 4/@?A16/19 A DA4?A4390A1 DA19/16012 9:39 9:/4/ >3@ 1A @<D: 1/2E02/1D/ A1 9:/ ?349 AB 9:/ 6405/4 AB 9:/ 7<@ 9 3E@A 6/10/69:/G<319<=AB9:/DA=?/1@390A1DA19/160129:39 9:/ DA=?/1@390A1 DE30=/6 0@ :02:E8 /HA4709319 0=3201348 316<19/137E/01E3>:/4/BA4/9:/?/9090A11//6@9A7/ 60@=0@@/6 ( :/ 407<13E B43=/6 3??4A?4039/ 0@@</@ 316 /506/1D/ >3@ E/6 >:/4/01 9:/ ?/9090A1/4 A >3@ /H3=01/6 3@ 316 H 9A >/4/ =34C/6 01 9:/ /506/1D/:/4/@?A16/196061A9E/36318/506/1D/ (! :/ 407<13E 3B9/4 :/34012 9:/ @<7=0@@0A1@ 78 7A9: @06/@ 3>346/6 DA=?/1@390A1 AB Rs.(((( <16/4 60BB/4/19:/36@3@7/EA> - 5 - E A /36@ A=?/1@390A1 >346/6 A>346@EA@@AB6/?/16/1D8 @)+((( A>346@EA@@ABEA5/316 3BB/D90A1 @(((( A>346@A@@AB@939/ @(((( A>346@B<1/43ED:342/@ @(((( A>346@DA1@A490<= @(((( ! A>346@9431@?A49390A1AB6/36 7A68 @(( A93E @(((( ( :0E/ DA=012 9A @<D: DA1DE<@0A1 9:/ 407<13E :/E69:399:/01DA=/AB9:/6/D/3@/6>3@@!((( ?/4 =A19: 316 :/ 7/012 + 8/34@ 9:/ 3??4A?4039/ =<E90?E0/4 >3@ (+ #/012 60@@390@B0/6 >09: 9:/ @306 ;<62=/19 316 3>3469:/?/9090A1/4@34/7/BA4/9:0@A<49 () :/ E/341/6 DA<1@/E 3??/34012 BA4 9:/ 3??/EE319@ DA19/16/6 9:39 9:/ 3DD06/19 ADD<44/6 01 9:/ 8/34 ( :/4/BA4/ 9:/ 1A90A13E 01DA=/ DA1@06/4/6 78 9:/407<13E39@.!((( ?/4=A19:0@378@=3EE8EA>316 0@ 3E@A 1A9 01 DA1@A131D/ >09: 9:/ >32/@ <16/4 9:/ 010=<=32/@ D9:/4/BA4/:/@//C@/1:31D/=/19AB 9:/DA=?/1@390A1 - 6 - ( :/ E/341/6 DA<1@/E 3??/34012 BA4 9:/ 4/@?A16/19 A >A<E6 @<7=09 9:39 9:/ DA=?/1@390A1 3>346/6 78 9:/ 407<13E 0@ ?4A?/4 316 :/ 6/B/16@ 9:/ @3=/ :/A1E8DA19/190A1430@/6789:/3??/EE319@0@ 9:39 9:/ 1A90A13E 01DA=/ AB 9:/ 6/D/3@/6 0@ 1A9 3??4A?4039/E8DA1@06/4/6789:/407<13E :/ 2<06/E01/@ 0@@</6 78 9:/ * BA4 @/99E/=/19 AB 60@?<9/@ 7/BA4/ AC 63E39: ?4/@D407/ 3 1A90A13E 01DA=/ AB @(( ?/4 =A19: BA4 9:/ 8/34 ( 1 <=?9//1 1<=7/4 AB ;<62=/19@ 9:0@ A<49 :3@ :/E6 9:39 9:/ 2<06/E01/@ 0@@</6 78 9:/ * 34/ 01 2/1/43E DA1BA4=098 >09: 9:/ >32/@ B0H/6 <16/4 9:/ 010=<= 32/@ D9 :/4/BA4/ 9:/8 34/ 3DD/?937E/ :/4/BA4/ 0@ D3ED<E39/6 3@ @%+((( I @.(( & H H H 9: J - 7 - 9 0@ >A49: 9A 1A9/ 9:/ B3D9 9:39 :/ :3@ E/B9 7/:016:0=(6/?/16/19@0@1A90160@?<9/:/4/BA4/9:/ ?/4@A13E 01DA=/ 0@ DA1@06/4/6 78 9:0@ A<49 39 9: 3@ 6A1/789:/407<13E :/ A1K7E/ <?4/=/ A<49 01 09@ ;<62=/19 01 9:/ D3@/ AB ! "#:3@:/E69:399:/4/@:3EE7//@D3E390A1AB (LA19:/DA15/190A13E:/36@0/EA@@AB/@939/B<1/43E /H?/1@/@ 316 9:/ EA@@ AB DA1@A490<= :/4/BA4/ @01D/ ) 8/34@ :35/ E3?@/6 3B9/4 9:/ @306 ?4A?A@090A1 7/012 E306 6A>1 9:/4/ @:3EE 7/ /@D3E390A1@ /1D/ 3 @<= AB Rs.$% <16/4 9:/ :/36 AB 3 @<=AB&$<16/49:/:/36AB ' 316 &$<16/49:/:/36ABEA@@AB/@939/,013EE3 @<= AB & 0@ 3>346/6 <16/4 DA15/190A13E :/36@ 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 8 - :/ 407<13E :3@ 3>346/6 4/3@A137E/ DA=?/1@390A1 3=A<19 9A>346@ ( :/@3=/ 1//61A97/60@9<47/6 ! :/4/BA4/ 9:/ DE30=319 0@ /1909E/6 BA4 9A93E /1:31D/6 DA=?/1@390A1 AB @+(( <16/4 9:/ BAEEA>012:/36@ E A /36@ A=?/1@390A1 >346/6 A>346@EA@@AB6/?/16/1D8 @!(( A>346@EA@@ABEA5/316 3BB/D90A1DA1@A490<= @((( A>346@A@@AB@939/ @)(( <1/43E/H?/1@/@ @)(( A93E /@@ >346/6789:/407<13E @+(!(( @(((( A93E1:31D/=/19 @+(( /1D/ 3??/3E 6/@/45/@ 9A 7/ 3EEA>/6 01 ?349 :/4/BA4/9:/BAEEA>012, - 9 - ! :/3??/3E0@3EEA>/601?349 :/ 3??/EE319@ 34/ /1909E/6 BA4 3 @<= AB @+(( 01366090A19A>:39:3@7//13>346/6 789:/407<13E3EA12>09:019/4/@9399:/439/AB!L ?3B4A=639/AB?/9090A190EE9:/639/AB6/?A@09 /@9 AB 9:/ A46/4 ?3@@/6 78 9:/ 407<13E 4/2346012 6/?A@09/9D4/=301<13E9/4/6 6 '$" ) $! *-- 0@9AEA *