Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10512 (KAR)
DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. SMT. LAXMI AND ORS
MFA/201508/2019 · 2025-01-20
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10512 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10512 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #
"
"
$$%&' &
! "#
! "
! $
! %
! %
! &
! '#
! LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.22 09:07:05 - 0800
- 2 -
$
! ("
! " &
)
*$#$ %+
+
($ "
*"
*+%# %+
$,
"
& , + *
%'
-
&'"'. "%'"'. & "'(
-
- ! ! / - -
- 3 -
" ! / - -
0123 450 6012703 89:7;06 1<<012=7> ?92 450 1<<066174 970 1<<012; ?92 450 20;<973074; 9 49 $ 0;<973074 9+ ;02@03 A=45 450 794=80 B:4 :720<20;07403 '" 50 20;<973074; 9 49 $ 120 450 861=C174; B0?920 450
33=4=9716 07=92 =@=6 -:3>0 173 9CC=;;=9702 ?92 C<69D00E; 9C<07;14=97 14 161B:21>= =7 9& "'( D F:3>C074 31403 &'"'. 450 9CC=;;=9702 51; 1A12303 1 89C<07;14=97 9? ;#$&'' * 173 ;133603 450 6=1B=6=4D :<97 450 20;<973074 9" * 7;:21780 9C<17D '% 50 20;<973074 9" G =7;:21780 89C<17D 897407303 4514 450 6=1B=6=4D 9? 450 =7;:21780 89C<17D A1;
976D 49 450 4:70 9? ;%''''' * <02 0C<69D00 <02 A92H02 974073=7> ;9 450 =7;:21780 89C<17D =; B0?920 45=; 9:24 =7 45=; 1<<016
- 4 -
'& 50 <04=4=9702; B0?920 450 9CC=;;=9702 A020 450 30<073074; 9? 450 30801;03 * 1>1DD1 A59 A5=60 02084=7> 450 060842=8 <960 ;:??0203 17 =7F:2D 3:0 49 450 ?166 9? 450 <960 173 3=03 50 20;<973074 9 B0?920 450 9CC=;;=9702 513 9B41=703 1 >29:< A92HC07 =7;:21780 <96=8D A5=85 =; <293:803 14 I
A5020=7 450 188=307416 30145 89@02 ?92 0185 A92H02 A1; 6=C=403 49
;%''''' * '$ 50 6012703 89:7;06 1<<012=7> ?92 450 1<<066174 A9:63 ;:BC=4 4514 459:>5 450 9CC=;;=9702 7940; 4514 =4 =; 1 <96=8D ?92 450 A92HC07 >29:< =7;:21780 <96=8D =4 ?1=603 49 794=80 450 6=C=4;
9? 6=1B=6=4D 5020?920 450 89C<07;14=97 1A12303 =7 0I80;; 9? 1 ;:C 9? ;%''''' * 51; 49 B0 <1=3 BD 450 0C<69D02 '+ 5=; 9:24 51; ?21C03 450 ?9669A=7> ;:B;4174=16 J:0;4=97 9? 61A BD 17 92302 31403 '('""'"&!*
! "#
- 5 -
'( 59:>5 794=80 A1; =;;:03 49 450 0C<69D02 A59 =; 450 20;<973074 9+ 5020=7 50 3=3 794 1<<012 50 20;<973074; 9 49 $ 51@0 1<<01203 4529:>5 450=2 6012703 89:7;06 50 208923; B0?920 450 9CC=;;=9702 51@0 B007 ;08:203 173 <02:;03 '# 4 =; @02D 86012 ?29C 450 <02:;16 9? I
4514 450 1<<066174 =; 6=1B60 49 <1D 1 ;:C 9? ;%''''' * =7 81;0 9? 30145 9?
17 0C<69D00 173 450 6=1B=6=4D =; 6=C=403 49 450 ;:85 ;9C0 976D 59:>5 <96=8D 89@02; +' A92H02;
=7@96@03 =7 @12=9:; <29F084; :730241H07 BD 450 20;<973074 9+ =4; 6=1B=6=4D ?92 0185 9? 450 A92H02 =;
;%''''' * 976D '. 4 =; <024=7074 49 7940 4514 6=H0 450 C9492 @05=860 188=3074 <96=8=0; 450 <96=8D 390; 794 89@02 17D ;414:492D 6=1B=6=4D 5020 =; 79 ;414:492D 6=1B=6=4D :7302 450 <96=8D ?92 450 =7;:21780 89C<17D 49 ;14=;?D 450 074=20 861=C 4514 89:63 12=;0 :7302 450 <96=8D 50 ;1C0 @=0A =;
- 6 -
897;=30203 =7 450 F:3>C074 9? 450 97EB60 <0I 9:24 =7 450 81;0 9? 5020?920 450 402C;
9? 450 <96=8D B0=7> 89742184:16 =7 714:20 B04A007 450 =7;:21780 89C<17D 173 450 20;<973074 9+ 450 9CC=;;=9702 51; 860126D 02203 =7 ;1336=7> 450 074=20 6=1B=6=4D :<97 450 =7;:21780 89C<17D 50 9CC=;;=9702 89:63 794 51@0 421@02;03 B0D973 450 ;89<0 9? 450 <96=8D ;=780 45020 B0=7> 79 <9A02 ?92 5=C :7302 450 <29@=;=97; 9? 450 84 5020?920 450 6=1B=6=4D 9? 450 1<<066174 5020=7 =; 976D 49 450 0I4074 9? ;%''''' * ?29C A5=85 50 =;
6=1B60 49 ;14=;?D 450 861=C 9? 450 <04=4=9702 50 20;4 9? 450 89C<07;14=97 1C9:74 30402C=703 BD 450 6012703 9CC=;;=9702 =786:3=7> 450 =74020;4 4502097 =; 6=1B60 49 B0 ;14=;?=03 BD 450 20;<973074 9+ A59 =; 450 0C<69D02 0780 450 1<<016 ;:88003; 88923=7>6D 450 ?9669A=7>,
1 $%%&'()*+,$
- 7 -
50 1<<016 =; 1669A03 50 1<<066174 G =7;:21780 89C<17D =; 6=1B60 49 <1D 1 ;:C 9? ;%''''' * 976D 49 450 20;<973074; 9 49 $ 50 20;4 9? 450 1C9:74 1A12303 BD 450 6012703 9CC=;;=9702 =786:3=7> 450 =74020;4 =; 9230203 49 B0 <1=3 BD 450 20;<973074 9+ 49 20;<973074; 9 49 $ 50 0I80;; 1C9:74 30<9;=403 BD 450 1<<066174 B0?920 450 9CC=;;=9702 =; 9230203 49 B0 20?:7303 49 450 1<<066174 G =7;:21780 89C<17D
3 * %
" '
"
-- =;4 9! 6 9! (( !