- 1 - ! " " #$ % & '% " $ ()(*+,)( ++ ' ! ! " #$ $ ! ! %$ & ' # $$ ( $ Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! ) $ %$ & $ $# ! ' $ # *! # $ $ + $ !!* $ , ,# $!!* # $ !!* $ # ## $ !*!**- -) ) *#$ $# ., , &$ ., , ' $/010123/4564/7/824/09152:40:3;/4/<0123*!4$ =109 6 >46?/4 02 @:659 09/ /3014/ >42<//;13A5 13 41B/ 2!!*4/A150/4/;7?:46C:306$2D1</0601236D67:46A1 15041<0 824 09/ 288/3</5 >:315967D/ :3;/4 /<01235 ! *! **- -) )4/6;=109 *$641513A2:028$2!!* >/3;13A7/824/09/2:40281E1D,:;A/F,#/;6B - 3 - ! /64; 09/ D/643/; 2:35/D 824 09/ >/010123/45 63; 09/ D/643/; $ 824 4/5>23;/30 32 /5>23;/30 32! =92 15 5/4E/;1309/B600/49654/B613/;:34/>4/5/30/;7/824/0915 2:40 /5>23;/30 32! 96; 81D/; 6 >41E60/ <2B>D6130 13 $2!!*7/824/09/2:40281E1D,:;A/F,#/;6B 6A6135009/>/010123/459/4/13=91<9=654/8/44/;0209/>2D1</ 7? 09/ G:415;1<01236D 6A150460/ :3;/4 /<0123 (& ' 4$ 9/ :46C:306 >2D1</ 130:43 96E/ 4/A150/4/; # 13 41B/ 2!!* 824 09/ 6824/561; 288/3</5 6A61350 09/ >/010123/45 9/4/13 765/; 23 5:<9 4/8/4/3</ 24;/4 >655/; 13 $2!!* /13A 6AA41/E/; 7? 09/ 56B/ 09/ >/010123/45 64/7/824/09152:40 * /643/; 2:35/D 824 09/ >/010123/45 5:7B105 0960 09/ ;15>:0/7/0=//309/>6401/515>:4/D?<1E1D13360:4/9/4/64/ <1E1D;15>:0/5>/3;13A7/824/09/1E1D2:4002:<913A09/41A905 2809/>6401/59/4/1532<2B>D163</28/<0123*&'F& ' 284$1309/>4/5/30<65/63;09/<2B>D61363096532081D/; 09/ 6881;6E10 6D23A =109 09/ >41E60/ <2B>D6130 =91<9 15 09/ 4/@:14/B/3028D6=65275/4E/;7?09/ 23H7D/:>4/B/2:40 - 4 - 13 09/ <65/ 28 $ " & & - & - . ! !)<<24;13AD?9/ >46?5026DD2=09/>/010123 $/4 <23046 D/643/; $ 965 2>>25/; 09/ >/010123 / 5:7B105 0960 13E/501A60123 28 09/ <65/ 15 :3;/4 >42A4/55 63; >41B6 86<1/ <65/ 824 09/ 6DD/A/; 288/3</5 15 B6;/ 2:0 6A61350 09/6<<:5/;<<24;13AD?9/>46?502;15B15509/>/010123 ( $/4:56D2809/B60/416D234/<24;=2:D;A202592=0960 09/ <2B>63? C32=3 65 5 $ /;1<64/ $E0 0; 15 09/ 5:<</558:D 71;;/4 13 09/ 6:<0123 0960 =65 9/D; 7? /B/30 24>2460123 28 3;16 824 09/ >:4>25/ 28 ;15B630D13A 09/14 </B/30 >D630 60 646C:306 /;6B 6D:C 63; 41A905 =/4/ A4630/; 02 09/ 6824/561; <2B>63? 02 ;15B630D/ 09/ >D630 0 6>>/6450960>/010123/4325F!64/09/ 14/<0245285$ /;1<64/$E00;63;>/010123/432 1509/14/B>D2?//5 $/;1<64/$E00;96;/I/<:0/;636A4//B/301386E2:4 28 :46D1 415936 824 ;15B630D13A 09/ </B/30 >D630 63; 64463A13A 824 56D/ 28 ;15B630D/; B60/416D 63; 130:43 :46D1 415936 6>>/645 02 96E/ /I/<:0/; 63 6A4//B/30 13 86E2:4 28 09/<2B>D6136304/5>23;/3032! - 5 - - 3 09/ >41E60/ <2B>D6130 0960 15 81D/; 23 !!!* 10 5060/; 0960 6<<:5/; 325 F ! 6D23A =109 09/14 B/3 13<D:;13A 6<<:5/; 32 96; /30/4/; 09/ </B/30 >D630 23 !!!!* =9/4/ 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 =65 <644?13A 23 =24C 28 ;15B630D13A 09/ >D630 63; 7? :513A <41B136D 824</ 63 600/B>0 =65B6;/02D18009/5<46>B60/416D=91<9=65;15B630D/;63; C/>01351;/09/>D63063;=9/309/561;600/B>0=652>>25/; 09/ 6<<:5/; >/45235 6DD/A/;D? A6E/ 094/60 02 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 63; 10 15 13 0915 76<CA42:3; 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D61363096;81D/;09/>41E60/<2B>D6130 $/4:56D 28 09/ 6E/4B/305 B6;/ 13 09/ >41E60/ <2B>D6130 ;60/;!!!*=2:D;A202592=096065060/B/3015B6;/ 7?09/;/86<02<2B>D61363009609/96;6>>426<9/;:46C:306 $2D1</ 060123 1BB/;160/D? 680/4 09/ 6DD/A/; 13<1;/30 0960 96; 06C/3>D6</23-!!!*63;513</09/$=653206E61D67D/ 13 09/ 060123 9/ 96; 09/4/824/ 6>>426<9/; 09/ $ /;6B 7:009/?96;4/8:5/;024/</1E/915<2B>D613063;09/4/680/4 9/ 96; A23/ 02 09/ :>/4130/3;/30 28 $2D1</ 63; 35>/<024 /3/46D28$2D1</6D67:46A163;=9/3/E/309/?96;4/8:5/; - 6 - 024/</1E/915<2B>D61309/=65<23504613/;0281D/09/>41E60/ <2B>D6130 ) 92:A9 5:<9 63 6E/4B/30 15 B6;/ 13 09/ >41E60/ <2B>D613009/4/1532B60/416D>42;:</;6D23A=10909/>41E60/ <2B>D6130 02 592= 0960 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 96; 6>>426<9/; 09/ >2D1</ 5060123 63; 09/4/680/4 09/ 91A9/4 2881</45655060/;13915>41E60/<2B>D61304/6;13A28/<0123 *& ' 28 4$ =2:D; B6C/ 10 E/4? <D/64 0960 18 09/ >2D1</ 2881</413<964A/2809/>2D1</50601239654/8:5/;024/</1E/09/ 8145013824B60123842B09/6AA41/E/;>640?09/6AA41/E/;>640? B6? 824=64; 09/ 13824B60123 13 =41013A 02 09/ 91A9/4 2881</45 0942:A9>250:<963/I/4<15/6>>/6450296E/3207//3B6;/ 1309/>4/5/30<65/=91<9=2:D;>41B686<1/A202592=0960 09/4/1532<2B>D163</28/<0123*&'F& '284$1309/ >4/5/30<65/ /643/; 2:35/D 824 09/ >/010123/45 965 742:A90 02 09/ 3201</2809152:400960>41E60/<2B>D6130153206<<2B>631/; =109 63 6881;6E10 28 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 9/ 23H7D/ :>4/B/ 2:40 13 $41?63C6 41E6506E6H5 <65/ 5:>46 13 >646A46>9!-965275/4E/;65:3;/4 - 7 - J!-32:4<2351;/4/;2>131236506A/965<2B/ 13 0915 <2:304? =9/4/ /<0123 (& '4$ 6>>D1<601235 64/ 02 7/ 5:>>240/; 7? 63 6881;6E10 ;:D? 5=2437?09/6>>D1<630=925//C509/13E2<601232809/ G:415;1<0123 28 09/ 6A150460/ 960 6>640 13 63 6>>42>4160/<65/09/D/643/;6A150460/=2:D;7/=/DD 6;E15/; 02 E/418? 09/ 04:09 63; 6D52 <63 E/418? 09/ E/46<10?2809/6DD/A601235 915 6881;6E10 <63B6C/09/ 6>>D1<630B24/4/5>23517D//64/<2B>/DD/;0256?52 655:<9C13;286>>D1<60123564/7/13A81D/;13642:013/ B633/4 =1092:0 06C13A 63? 4/5>235171D10? =96052/E/4 23D? 02 964655 </40613 >/45235 960 6>640 10 7/<2B/5 B24/;150:4713A63;6D64B13A=9/323/041/502>1<C:> >/2>D/ =92 64/ >65513A 24;/45 :3;/4 6 5060:024? >42E15123=91<9<637/<96DD/3A/;:3;/409/846B/=24C 28 561; <0 24 :3;/4401<D/ !!(28 09/ 235010:0123 28 3;16:010<633207/;23/0206C/:3;:/6;E6306A/13 6<41B136D<2:40651852B/72;?15;/0/4B13/;025/00D/ 09/5<24/5/96E/6D4/6;?13;1<60/;096009/4/96502 7/ >4124 6>>D1<601235 :3;/4 /<0123 *&' 63; *& ' =91D/ 81D13A 6 >/010123 :3;/4 /<0123 (& ' 209 09/ 65>/<05592:D;7/<D/64D?5>/D02:01309/6>>D1<6012363; 3/</5564? ;2<:B/305 02 0960 /88/<0 596DD 7/ 81D/; 9/ =644630 824 A1E13A 6 ;14/<0123 0960 63 09/ 6>>D1<60123 :3;/4 /<0123 (& ' 7/ 5:>>240/; 7? 63 6881;6E10 52 0960 09/ >/4523 B6C13A 09/ 6>>D1<60123 592:D; 7/ <235<12:5 63; 6D52 /3;/6E2:4 02 5// 0960 32 86D5/ 6881;6E1015B6;/0157/<6:5/23</636881;6E101582:3; 02 7/ 86D5/ 9/ =1DD 7/ D167D/ 824 >425/<:0123 13 6<<24;63</ =109 D6= 915 =1DD ;/0/4 91B 02 <65:6DD? 13E2C/ 09/ 6:092410? 28 09/ 6A150460/ :3;/4 /<0123 - 8 - (& ' 960 6>640 =/ 96E/ 6D4/6;? 5060/; 0960 09/ E/46<10?2809/56B/<636D527/E/4181/;7?09/D/643/; 6A150460/ 4/A64; 7/13A 96; 02 09/ 360:4/ 28 6DD/A6012352809/<65//64/<2B>/DD/;0256?52656 3:B7/428<65/5>/4061313A02815<6D5>9/4/B6041B2316D ;15>:0/86B1D? ;15>:0/5 <2BB/4<16D 288/3</5 B/;1<6D 3/AD1A/3</<65/5<244:>0123<65/563;09/<65/5=9/4/ 09/4/ 15 67324B6D ;/D6?D6<9/5 13 131016013A <41B136D >425/<:01236564/1DD:50460/;136D106:B64164/7/13A 81D/;9606>64009/D/643/; 6A150460/ =2:D;6D527/ 6=64/2809/;/D6?13D2;A13A2809/#" 13</09/4/1532<2B>D163</2809/561;4/@:14/B/3009/ D/643/; 6A150460/ <2:D; 320 96E/ 4/8/44/; 09/ >41E60/ <2B>D61300209/>2D1</:3;/4/<0123(& '284$ ! 36;;101230209/56B/09/B60/416D234/<24;=2:D;A2 02592=0960>41240209/;/86<02<2B>D6136306>>426<913A09/ G:415;1<01236D 6A150460/ 7? 81D13A 6 >41E60/ <2B>D6130 9/ 965 6D4/6;? 81D/; 2*!!!* 7/824/ 09/ G:415;1<01236D 1E1D 2:4063;1015742:A900209/3201</2809152:400960092:A96 >46?/4824A463013A0/B>2464?13G:3<0123=65B6;/7?91B09/ 56B/=65320A4630/;63;23D?/B/4A/303201</=65155:/;23 09/ 6>>D1<60123 81D/; 5//C13A 0/B>2464? 13G:3<0123 63; 09/4/680/4 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 96; 81D/; 09/ >41E60/ <2B>D6130 - 9 - 3 09/ >D6130 13 2*!!!* 6 5>/<181< B/30123 15 B6;/ 0960 23 -!!!* 09/ 6<<:5/; >/45235 96; /30/4/; 09/ >4/B15/5 28 09/ </B/30 >D630 63; 041/; 02 502> =24C 28 ;15B630D/ 63; 041/; 02 D180 09/ 5<46> 7? A1E13A 094/60 02 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 2=/E/4 32 B/30123 965 7//3 B6;/ 672:0 09/ 600/B>0 B6;/ 7? 09/ ;/86<02 <2B>D613630 13 6>>426<913A 09/ >2D1</ 1BB/;160/D? 680/4 09/ 6DD/A/; 13<1;/30 01582409/8145001B/5:<9636E/4B/3015B6;/1309/>41E60/ <2B>D6130 0960 15 81D/; 5:75/@:/30 02 09/ 81D13A 28 2*!!!* * #24 09/ 6824/561;4/65235 <23013:60123 28 09/ 1B>:A3/; <41B136D >42<//;13A5 6A61350 09/ >/010123/45 =2:D; 6B2:30 02 67:5/ 28 09/ >42</55 28 D6= 3;/4 09/ <14<:B5063</5 10 15 3/</5564? 02 @:659 09/ 1B>:A3/; <41B136D >42<//;13A5 <<24;13AD?09/82DD2=13A24;/4 $/010123 15 6DD2=/; 9/ /3014/ >42<//;13A5 13 41B/ 2!!*4/A150/4/;7?:46C:306$2D1</0601236D67:46A1 15041<0 824 09/ 288/3</5 >:315967D/ :3;/4 /<01235 ! *! **- -) )4/6;=109 *$641513A2:028$2!!* - 10 - >/3;13A 7/824/ 09/ 2:40 28 1E1D ,:;A/ F ,# /;6B 15 9/4/7?@:659/; /, ( & '% "+ %