Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10466 (KAR)

SYED RIZWAN v. ASGAR AND ORS

CRL.A/200233/2024 · 2025-02-24

Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#$ % "#$$ #!! &'&(!)*&) + ! "" # $ % & ' ' & " " "" Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ' !" # $& () "" ""& '% "" & '* & " # % +' & # % " & , " & ' * + + "" $ " ' & + ' * '+ & " " "" " & " " "" & $ - $ - $ # #" - % ./012231425363553789:.3;/<:/=1>1/?0::.3@A7>=3?: 210037 /? B ' 71:37 * + + 89 :.3 77/:/B?14 /0:5/<: 1?7 300/B?0 A7>3 1: 1418A51>/ #.353/?16:35 53635537 :B 10 :.3 C4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3D% E.35389 :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 1<FA/::37 :.3 1<<A037 B0 1?7 ' 6B5 :.3 B663?<30 2A?/0.1843 A?735 3<:/B?0 ' * 1?7 +5E03<:/B?'+B6" - 3 - 85/7>3761<:0B6:.325B03<A:/B?<103153:.1:) ? G * H 1: H' 2= E.3? " I937 /JE1? 14B?>E/:. +:BGE3530:1?7/?>/?65B?:B618815&A?<:/B? 1441:1418A51>/1<<A037B1?7'5302B?73?:0B1?7 14B?>E/:.#1<<A037B1>1/?0:E.B=:.3<103/0024/:A2% ;/0/:37 :.3 01/7 02B: E/:. 1 .3? " FA30:/B?37 1<<A037 B .3 5324/37 0:1:/?> .3 ;/0/:37 :B <431? :.3 24B: .BE3;35 :.3 <B?;3501:/B? 437 :B 1 5BE &B44BE/?> E./<. 1<<A037 B 18A037 1?7 2.90/<1449 1001A4:37 " E/:. 1? /5B? 5B7 B? ./0 .317 1<<A037 B 1/737 89 1001A4:/?> E/:. <4A8B?./0436:0.BA4735436:214=5/>.::./>.1?7E1/0:E./43 1<<A037 B' 6/0:37 B? ./0 5/>.: 393 .39 <B443<:/;349 1::3=2:37:BK/44./=E.3?" 1::3=2:37:B6433895A??/?> :BE1570 :.3 6A?<:/B? .144 6A5:.35 :.3 1<<A037 <B443<:/;349 <1A>.: .B47 B6 ./= 1?7 1001A4:37 ./= E/:. :.3/5 8153 .1?70 BE3;35 0+:BG21</6/37:.3FA155341?7:.35316:35" 17=/::37/?:.3B02/:14 ' 1037 B? 65B= B;35?=3?: B02/:14 B? G * H1:18BA:2=" 53<B5737:.30:1:3=3?: B6;/<:/=1223441?:10235L"1?753>/0:3537:.3&1>1/?0: :.3 1<<A037 /? 5/=3 BH H 71:37 G * H 6B5 :.3 - 4 - B663?<302A?/0.1843A?7353<:/B?0' *1?7 +5E3<:/B?'+ B6"10235L"+ + A803FA3?:49 " G 1?7 H <B?7A<:37 :.3 /?;30:/>1:/B? 1?7 H 41/7 :.3 <.15>3 0.33: 1>1/?0: 5302B?73?:01<<A037 B0 1?7 ' 6B5 :.3 B663?<30 2A?/0.1843 A?7353<:/B?0' *1?7 +5E3<:/B?'+B6"836B53:.3 <B==/::14 BA5: #0/?<3 <103 1>1/?0: 1<<A037 B 024/: A2 836B53:.301/7BA5:% <<B57/?>49<1031>1/?0:1<<A037B0 1?7'<B==/::37836B53:.3300/B?0BA5: ?<B==/::14B6:.3<103836B53:.3300/B?0BA5: :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 651=37 :.3 <.15>30 1>1/?0: :.3 5302B?73?:01<<A037 B0 1?7 ' 6B5 :.3 16B53=3?:/B?37 B663?<301?75317B;35;3581:/=:B:.3=.31<<A0372431737 ?B:>A/4:91?7<41/=37:B83:5/37 G ? B5735 :B 25B;3 :.3 <.15>30 43;34437 1>1/?0: :.3 5302B?73?:01<<A037B01?7' :.325B03<A:/B?<B443<:/;349 3L1=/?37 G E/:?30030 10 " :B G =15K37 + 7B<A=3?:0 10 L" :B L"+ 1?7 /73?:/6/37 =1:35/14 B8@3<:0 10 1?7 - 5 - * "B0: <B=243:/B? B6 :.3 :5/14 :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 5317 B;35 :.3 /?<5/=/?1:/?> 2B5:/B? B6 :.3 3;/73?<3 B6 E/:?30030:B:.31<<A037A?735:.325B;/0/B?0B63<:/B?''B6 5"1?7:.31<<A03773?/37:.301=3.37363?03B6:.3 1<<A037/0B6180B4A:373?/141?7:.1:B661403/=24/<1:/B? .3 300/B?0 BA5: 16:35 <B?0/735/?> :.3 3;/73?<3 B?53<B571<FA/::37:.35302B?73?:01<<A037B01?7'6B5 :.3 <.15>30 43;34437 1>1/?0: :.3= .3 01/7 @A7>=3?: B6 1<FA/::14/0<.1443?>37A?735:./012231489:.3;/<:/=I" H 3.1;3.3157:.34315?37<BA?0345/1.1?:30. 301/6B5:.31223441?:;/<:/=1?74315?37<BA?0345/ 0.BK A41>3 6B5 5302B?73?:01<<A037 1?7 4315?37 774 "" 5/ /7714/?>""1:/46B5:.3:1:35302B?73?:B' .3 25/=159 <B?:3?:/B? B6 :.3 4315?37 <BA?034 6B5 :.3 1223441?: /0 :.1: :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 .10 >5B0049 35537 E./43 1<FA/::/?> :.3 1<<A037 6B5 :.3 <.15>30 43;34437 1>1/?0: :.3= E/:.BA: 12253</1:/?> :.3 3;/73?<3 B6 =1:35/14 E/:?30030/?15/>.:235023<:/;33EBA47<B?:3?7:.1::.3B514 :30:/=B?9 B6 " /?@A537 <431549 <B55B8B51:30 :B :.3 =37/<14 3;/73?<3B6" +IB<:B5E.B3L1=/?37./=1?7/00A37EBA?7 - 6 - <35:/6/<1:3 10 235 L"' &A5:.35 " 0' 1?7 :.3 393E/:?30030:B:.3/?</73?:140B<1:3>B5/<14490:1:3718BA::.3 1001A4: =173 89 1<<A037 B0 :B ' :B " ? 0A<. </5<A=0:1?<3 :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 1<FA/::37 :.3 1<<A037B?4981037B?0A5=/031?7<B?@3<:A533EBA47140B <B?:3?7 :.1: :.3 25B03<A:/B? 140B 25B;37 :.3 =B:/;3 6B5 :.3 1443>37/?</73?::.1::.353E1017/02A:383:E33?:.31<<A037 B'1?7" /?53023<:B60.153/?1641:E./<.0:1?70/?:.3 ?1=3 B6 " ? 0A<. </5<A=0:1?<3 :.3 25B03<A:/B? .10 241<370A66/</3?:=1:35/14:B25B;3:.3<.15>3043;344371>1/?0: :.31<<A037?02/:3B6:.301=3:.34315?37300/B?0A7>3 1<FA/::37 :.3 1<<A037 E./<. <1A037 >531: /?@A0:/<3 :B :.3 ;/<:/=I" <<B57/?>49 .3 25190 :B 144BE :.3 122314 89 03::/?> 10/73 :.3 /=2A>?37 @A7>=3?: 1?7 :B <B?;/<: :.3 1<<A0376B5:.3<.15>3043;344371>1/?0::.3= 4315?37 <BA?034 6B5 :.3 5302B?73?:01<<A037 0A8=/::37 :.1: :.3 @A7>=3?: A?735 :./0 122314 7B30 ?B: 0A66350 65B= 1?9 235;350/:9 B5 /443>14/:9 0/?<3 :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 16:35 =3:/<A4BA049 3L1=/?/?> :.3 3;/73?<3 B? 53<B57 210037 1 E344 5310B?37 @A7>=3?: 89 1<FA/::/?> :.3 1<<A037 3 EBA47 6A5:.35 <B?:3?7 :.1: :.353 - 7 - 153 =1@B5 7/0<5321?</30 /? :.3 3;/73?<3 B6 " 0 :B ' /? 53023<:B6:.3;359/?</73?:1?7:.3=1??35/?E./<.:.301=3 01/7:B.1;3833?B<<A5537&A5:.35" +IB<:B5E.B:531:37 :.3/?@A537.1017=/::37/?.35<5B00I3L1=/?1:/B?:.1::.353/0 1?B;35E5/:/?>E/:.53>157:B:.371:3B617=/00/B?B6" 10 /?21:/3?: :B :.3 B02/:14 &A5:.35 " 0 ' 1?7 .1;3 ?B: 0:1:37 :.3 023</6/< B;35: 1<: B6 1<<A037 B0 1?7 ' 0 17=/::3789:.3=:.3/?@A5901/7:B.1;3833?<1A037:B./= 89 1<<A037 B 1?7 :.3 B;35: 1<: 1443>37 1>1/?0: :.303 5302B?73?:0:.1::.39E35325303?:/?:.30<3?3B6B<<A553?<3 1?76/0:37:.3.1?70B6" 44:.3031023<:0153=3:/<A4BA049 3L1=/?37 89 :.3 4315?37 300/B?0 A7>3 1?7 1<FA/::37 :.3 1<<A0376B5:.3<.15>3043;344371>1/?0::.3= <<B57/?>49.3 25190:B7/0=/00:.3122314 3 .1;3 >/;3? BA5 1?L/BA0 <B?0/7351:/B? 8B:. B? :.315>A=3?:17;1?<3789:.38B:.:.34315?37<BA?0346B5:.3 215:/30 0B 140B <B=253.3?0/;349 235A037 :.3 3;/73?<3 B? 53<B57.32B/?::.1:0A561<36B5BA5<B?0/7351:/B?/0 - 8 - ' 0<BA4783033?65B=:.353<B570/?B5735:B25B;3 :.3 <.15>30 43;3437 1>1/?0: :.3 1<<A037 :.3 25B03<A:/B? .10 2537B=/?1?:49534/37:.33;/73?<3B6" <B=241/?1?:;/<:/= 1?7" 0'1?7I:.3393E/:?30030:B:.3/?</73?: ?<1536A4 235A014 B6 :.3 3;/73?<3 B6 " .3 .10 732B037 :.1: B? G H 1: 18BA: HIH' 1= :.3 1<<A037 B <1=3 :B :.3 24B: E/:. 1 E.3? .3 FA30:/B?37 ./= 1<<A037 B 1001A4:37B?./0.317E/:.15B71?71<<A037B01?7'140B @B/?37 1?7 1001A4:37 ./= BE3;35 /? :.3 <5B00 3L1=/?1:/B? .3.1017=/::37:.1:.3.10?B0A<./44IE/44E/:.1<<A037B' E.B/01?>/?3358925B6300/B?&A5:.351<<B57/?>:B./=./0 85B:.35/0:.30<5/83B6L"I<B=241/?:1?7.3.10?B:0:1:37 /? L" 18BA: :.3 1001A4: =173 89 1<<A037 B' 3?<3 1<<B57/?> :B " :.3 023</6/< B;35: 1<: 1::5/8A:30 1>1/?0: 1<<A037B0/?<3.3.17<1A037:.3.317/?@A59:B./=.3 393E/:?30030 " 0' 1?7 :.BA>. 0A22B5:37 :.3 <103 B6 25B03<A:/B? 732B037 /? :.3/5 <5B00I3L1=/?1:/B? :.1: :.3 1443>37/?</73?:<1A037?31518815&A?<:/B?144 <<B57/?>:B " :.3 /?</73?: <1A037 /? 65B?: B6 :.3 641: 0/:A1:37 /? 9B G1:1418A51>/&A5:.35/:/0140B17=/::37:.1::.353 /017/02A:323?7/?>83:E33?" 1?71<<A037B/?53023<: - 9 - B6 1 641: 10 0A<. 1<<A037 B E3?: ?315 :.3 641: /? 1 7=/::3749 1<<A037 B0 1?7 ' E353 ?B: ;/0/:37 :.3 02B: 14B?> E/:. 1<<A037 B &A5:.35 8B:. " 0' 1?7 E353 0:1:37:.1::.397/7?B:=1731?91::3=2::B0./6:" :B:.3 B02/:14 16:35 :.3 /?</73?: <<B57/?> :B :.3= :.39 8B:. 7/7 ?B: >/;3 :.3/5 0:1:3=3?: 836B53 :.3 1223441?:I"B4/<3 A?735 3<:/B? G B6 5" 3;35:.34300 10 5/>.:49 <B?:3?737 89 :.3 4315?37 <BA?034 6B5 :.3 5302B?73?: " +IB<:B5 E.B :531:37 " .10 17=/::37 /? .35 3;/73?<3 :.1: :.353 /0 1? B;35E5/:/?> E/:. 53>157 :B 71:3 B6 17=/00/B? B6 " /? :.3 B02/:14 1?7 0.3 <1??B: 019 :.3 1>3 B6 651<:A53 ? 0A<. </5<A=0:1?<3:.35315/0317BA8:/?:.3>3?30/0B6:.3<5/=3 3?<3 B;35144 235A014 B6 :.3 3;/73?<3 :.3 215:/</21:/B? B6 :.303 5302B?73?:0 /? :.3 1443>37 /?</73?: /0 1223150 :B 83 7BA8:6A4 ./0 83/?> :.3 122314 1>1/?0: 1<FA/::14 :.3 B?D843 23LBA5:/?:.3<103B6 532B5:37 /? 0A==15/J37 :.325/?</2430:B3L35</03:.32BE3589:.3 223441:3BA5::B /?:356353/?:.3B5735B6:.3300/B?0BA5:/?2151>512.BH 10A?735 - 10 - ! " #$ " # ! % ! ! & " # ! ' ! ! " # $ ! %! ( ! " ) % " # ! & #*%!! + %!&" # % ) % %! ! + + + + , + +% " # ! + & " #!%! (+& #! + + (+ %- %! (+& # + %! " # ! %! %+ (. + &A5:.35 :.3 B?D843 23L BA5: /? :.3 <103 B6 !!"" # 532B5:37 /? $ $$ E./430A==15/J/?>:.325/?</2430/?7314/?> E/:. :.3 122314 1>1/?0: 1<FA/::14 /? 2151>512. B+ .347 10 A?735 $, + + - 11 - " % ! % & ! /"-01/21 #314! + 5 6 78 " % + % 9 % % : 78 % % : 78 - # % ! %! + % + !: 7%8-%!& # + %! + %! % : 7%8 - # % ) % % + & # % : 7%8- % % # % ! & #. 3?<3B?<B44B<1:/?>:.325/?</24300A==15/J37/? :.3 18B;3 @A7>=3?: :B :.3 61<:0 1?7 </5<A=0:1?<30 B6 :./0 <103 E3 153 B6 :.3 <B?0/73537 ;/3E :.1: :.3 25B03<A:/B? .10 61/437:B241<30A66/</3?:3;/73?<3:B25B;3:.3<.15>3043;34437 - 12 - 1>1/?0: :.3 1<<A0375302B?73?:0 B 1?7 839B?7 5310B?18437BA8: G ?:.1:;/3EB6:.3=1::35E373<4/?3:B/?:356353/? :.3 @A7>=3?: 210037 89 :.3 300/B?0 BA5: <<B57/?>49 E3 1?0E35:.32B/?:51/03718B;3/?:.3166/5=1:/;31?725B<337:B 2100:.36B44BE/?> .35/=/?14 22314/0%&% ,* & %) $ ,* &$ ) $ $ /0:B4B "