Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10394 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER v. SMT.SHOBHA AND ANR
MFA/202054/2019 · 2025-02-12
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10394 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10394 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! "
#
#
$$%& '
! " #$%
$
% !!! #$&
$#
# ' ##
(&)
! ) ! ! # ! '
"#! %%)%)*
"#
"! ##
)%)(
' ! ! #
! #
#
"#! $
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.13 10:52:12 - 0800
- 2 -
!$ +!"
!"
# $ +!"
!"
,-./0.12314256/-.1473785291,21,2.0--38:2;-< 0=1,4. 7/:1:-2<.2.0-579$
! "
#$ ! %
&' % ,- 82>1/25 02>?@:7/3< 78 1,- >2.- 4. 1,21 73 %)%)( 1,- <->-2.-<2A2.,-?,2: 92. 97:?43@ 2. 2 <:4B-: /3<-: 1,- 2CC-55231
7:C7:21473 23< 9,45- ,- 92. C:7>--<43@ 1792:<. 43<,23/: 0= <:4B43@ 1,- 0/. 7 1,-:- 92. 2 >7554.473 941, 1,- 57::= 0-2:43@ 7&** 23< </- 17 1,- 2>>4<-31 ,- ./>>/;0-<171,-43A/:4-. ,- <-C-3<-31. 78 1,- <->-2.-< 2CC:72>,-< 1,- 5-2:3-<
7;;4..473-: /3<-: 1,- C:7B4.473. 78 1,-
- 3 -
;C57=--. 7;C-3.21473 >1 ,-:-43281-: :-8-::-< 17 2. D
>1E87:.,7:1.--?43@>7;C-3.21473 & ,- 5-2:3-<
7;;4..473-: 281-: C-:/.43@ 1,- -B4<-3>-C52>-<731,-:->7:<9,4>,4.431,-87:;781,- C2= .54C 4../-< 0= 1,- 2CC-55231 ,-:-43 >2;- 17 1,- >73>5/.473 1,21 1,- 92@-. 78 1,- <->-2.-< 92. 17 1,- -F1-31 78 .%)( C-: ;731, 23< 292:<-< 2 >7;C-3.2147378.%%)(%%(
-43@ 2@@:4-B-< 0= 1,- .24< A/<@;-31 1,- :-.C73<-31-;C57=-:
7:C7:21473 4. 0-87:- 1,4. 7/:1 43 1,4.C:-.-312CC-25
,- 5-2:3-< >7/3.-5 2CC-2:43@ 87: 1,- 2CC-55231
7:C7:21473 ./0;41. 1,21 1,- 5-2:3-< 7;;4..473-: .,7/5< ,2B- 12?-3 1,- 92@-. 78 1,- <->-2.-<2.C-:1,-371484>214734../-<0=1,-#7B-:3;-31 783<42/3<-:->1473&781,-
>10/1731,- 71,-:,23<1,-
7;;4..473-:,2.2>>-C1-<1,-92@-.2. C-: 1,- C2= .54C 21 F 23< 1,-:-87:- 1,- 4;C/@3-< A/<@;-314.371./.1243205-43529
- 4 -
G - ./0;41. 1,21 1,- C:7B4.473. 78 ->1473 & 78 1,-
>1 4. ;23<217:= 43 321/:- 23< 1,-:-87:- 1,-
7;;4..473-: >7/5< 371 ,2B- 12?-3 1,- 43>7;-21.%)(2.;731,5=43>7;- ( >2:-8/5 C-:/.25 78 ->1473 & 78 1,-
>1 <4.>57.-. 1,21 1,-
-31:25 #7B-:3;-31 ;2= 4../- 2 371484>21473/3<-:->1473&781,-
>1439,4>, >2.-1,-92@-.2:-170-12?-321.()))C-:;731,43 1,-20.-3>-7823=>7@-31-B4<-3>-14.170-70.-:B-< 1,21 9,-:-B-: 1,- 92@-. 78 1,- 97:?;-3 -;C57=-< 0= B2:47/. -;C57=-:. 4. 20=.;255= 579 23< 4. 371 43 2>>7:<23>-941,1,-C:7B4.473.781,-;434;/;92@-.>1 1,-371484>214734../-</3<-:->1473&9455,2B-1,- :-5-B23>- 8 1,- 2>1/25 92@-. 4. ;7:- 1,23 1,- 92@-. 371484-</3<-:.->1473&1,-:-4.3702:17>73.4<-:
./>, 92@-. 87: 1,- C/:C7.- 78 >25>/521473 78 1,- >7;C-3.21473 ,-:-87:- 9,-3 1,- 70A->14B-. 78 1,- C:7B4.473. 78 1,-
>1 C2:14>/52:5= ->1473 & 78 1,- >1 4. 2CC:->421-< 41 4. -B4<-31 1,21 1,-:- 4. 37
- 5 -
;23<21- 17 1,- 5-2:3-<
7;;4..473-: 17 >73.4<-: 1,- 92@-. 84F-< /3<-: ->1473 & 78 1,-
>1 735= ,-
7;;4..473-: 4. 21 540-:1= 17 >73.4<-: 1,- ,4@,-:
92@-. 48 1,-:- 4. -B4<-3>- 17 1,21 -88->1 3<-: 1,-.- >4:>/;.123>-. 1,- ./0.1231425 6/-.1473 78 529 :24.-< ,2.
17 0- 23.9-:-< 43 1,- 2884:;214B- ,- 5-2:3-< 7;;4..473-: 92. A/.1484-< 43 >73.4<-:43@ 1,- 43>7;- 78 1,- <->-2.-<2A2.,-?,2: 21 .%)( C-: ;731, 23< 1,-:-0=43292:<43@1,-./;78.%%)(%%(-3>-1,- 2CC-25 4. 0-:-81 78 23= ;-:41. 23< 2. ./>, 1,- .2;- 4. 54205-170-<4.;4..-< * -3>-1,-
< %
# & # ! 4.1 7$5 7$G $