- 1 - !"! # $" ! % $" " ##& ' () ##* ## ##+ ## ## ##,, "* " " "+ "+ ( ) !" # # $ "%" " #& & # %## ' !" # $ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + ,' " # " )%', *( ) ' !" # # $ ' # + #& % ## -& '( " +% " . #& % ## -& '( !" # $ - 3 - % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + '' *'%', " # " ( ) !" # # $ % #& & # % ## -& '( !" # $ % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + ,' " # - 4 - " ,%', +( ) !" # # $ % # # #& & # % ## -& '( !" # $ % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + ,' " # " '%', ( ) - 5 - !" # # $ " % #& % ## -& '( !" # $ % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + '(' *)%', " # " ( ) ' ' " " # (' # # " - 6 - # " # (' ) " " # (' /# ) #'' !" # # $ # + #& % ## -& '( !" # $ % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + )'' " # " %', - 7 - ,,( ) ' ' " " # (' # # " # " # (' ) " " # (' /# ) #'' !" # # $ # %" # " ' " +% # # #& & + % ## # -& '( #" +% # # #& & + % ## # - 8 - -& '( % # # #&' & # % ## # -& '( ) % # # #&)( & # % ## # -& '( !" # $ % ()!'$ # " *' # + " # + )'' " # " '%', *( ) %" # " & # % ## # -& !" # $ ' - 9 - ' " " # ('' # # " # " # ('' ) " " # ('' /# ) # '' !" # # $ )' ## # + )%'%' " # " %', + ,(,%* ( ) # %" # " - 10 - ' " +% # # # ") &+ '" #" +% # # # ", &+ ' % # # # "' & # ' % # # # ")( & # % ## # -& '( " !" # $ ' ' " " # ('' # # " # " # ('' ) " " # ('' - 11 - /# ) # '' !" # # $ )' ## # + )%'%' " # " '%', + ,(,%* ( ) % # # # " & # % ## # -& " !" # $ !" # # $ )' ## # + %,%' " - 12 - # " '%', + ,(,%* +( ) " % # ") & # % ## # -& '( " !" # $ ' !" # # $ )' ## # + '%(%' " # " )%', + ,(,%* - 13 - +( ) " " % # ") & # % ## # -& " !" # $ ' !" # # $ )' ## # + '%(%' " # " ,%', + ,(,%* # #+ & & 0" 0" - 14 - " !&0" $ 11 23454 6774615 684 9:14; <= >43619 <9 234 74?:61 6=; ?@A:5:2:<= 99:?48 7748 8:53=6 8<B4?2 !$ 1C622:?611:=D:=@A452:<=?<884?2=455<9234<8;485<9234 849484=?4<A8276554;:=?<CC<= 34 6774615 684 9:14; >E 234 2624 ?36114=D:=D 234 <8;485 76554; >E 234 849484=?4 <A82 := <5'%', )%', '%', ,%', '%', )%',6=;%', =2346><F456:;C622485234849484=?4<A82 36;;:57<54;<99234849484=?46771:?62:<=5G:2384574?22< 234 16=;5 <9 6DD<; :116D4 2362 G65 =<2:9:4; 65 748 7841:C:=68E =<2:9:?62:<= ;624; ' G:23 84D68; 2< A1G6; :92 88:D62:<= ?34C4 26D4 <9 34 =<2:9:?62:<=5 36F:=D >44= C6;4 <= ' 234 849484=?46771:?62:<=G659:14;A=;484?2:<=)!'$<9234 6=; ?@A:5:2:<= ?2 ' !9<8 53<82 H234 ?2I$ = 611 - 15 - 23454 C622485 2< 5A>526=2:624 234:8 ?16:C 234 ?16:C6=25 36; 142*:= :=;474=;4=2 4F:;4=?4 2< ?16:C ?<C74=562:<= 6><F4 234 6C<A=2 65 6G68;4; >E 234 6=; ?@A:5:2:<= 99:?48 >E 841E:=D <= ?<CC<= 4J4C71685 := 611 23454 C622485 34 849484=?4 <A82 := F68:<A5 >62?345 36F4 ;:57<54;<99234849484=?45>E4=36=?:=D?<C74=562:<=2< 5%* 748 6?84 := 611 23454 C622485 65 615< 6G68;:=D G:23 ?<=54@A4=2:61 5262A2<8E >4=49:25 3454 <8;485<9234849484=?4<A8236F4>44=?36114=D4;:=234 78454=2>62?3<96774615 ) 34 2624 365 86:54; F68:<A5 ?<=24=2:<=5 G3:14 ?<=24=;:=D 2362 234 6G68; <9 234 849484=?4 <A82 :5 4J<8>:26=2 2362 234 5614 ;44;5 841:4; A7<= 62 J5) ( ,6=;'G34846584D68;556149<8+:=;<G488<B4?2 :4=;A528:617A87<546=;6??<8;:=D1E56C4?<A1;=<2>4 26K4= 65 6= 4J4C7168 :=5<968 234 78454=2 ?654 2 :5 9A823485A>C:224;23622344*42214C4=2 A23<8:2E<AD32 2< 36F4 26K4= =<24 <9 5614 ;44;5 ;A8:=D 234 784?4;:=D 23844E46852:5615<?<=24=;4;23622345614;44;5841:4; - 16 - A7<= >E 234 ?16:C6=25 65 :5 6;C:224; >E +' G65 G:23 84574?2 2< ?<=F4E6=?4 9<8 ?<CC48?:61 7A87<54 6=; 6??<8;:=D1E?<A1;=<236F4>44=26K4==<24<96=;F68:<A5 <2348 ?<=24=2:<=5 36F4 >44= 86:54; ??<8;:=D1E :2 :5 5A>C:224;2362234<8;48<9234849484=?4<A82:52<>4542 65:;4 468=4; ?<A=541 677468:=D 9<8 234 ?8<55* <>B4?2<85%8457<=;4=25*?16:C6=255A>C:22362:=5<96865234 56C4 =<2:9:?62:<=6584D68;5;8E16=;5<96DD<;:116D4 9<8 234 56C4 78<B4?2 234 <8;48 <9 234 849484=?4 <A82 76554;:= <5''))(),'(('6=; <9 ', G484 ?36114=D4; >E 234 2624 := <5' ,'( ' ,6=;,<96=;61156:; 6774615G484;:57<54;<99>E<8;48;624;'')6=; := 1:D32 <9 234 56:; <8;485 76554; := 234 6774615 G:23 84574?2 2< 234 16=;5 84162:=D 2< 234 56C4 F:116D4 56C4 7A87<546=;56C4=<2:9:?62:<=A73<1;:=D234<8;48<9234 849484=?4<A82234F61A4<923416=;625%*748 - 17 - 6?84:52<>44J24=;4;>E;:5C:55:=D23478454=26774615 615<2:59A823485A>C:224;2362234<8;48:=2346774615 := <'% 6=; ?<==4?24; C622485 36F:=D 6226:=4; 9:=61:2E A73<1;:=D 234 C68K42 F61A4 <9 5%*7486?849:J4;>E234849484=?4<A826C4 <AD32 2< >4 4J24=;4; <= 768:2E := 234 78454=2 C622485 615< 468=4; ?<A=541 9<8 234 6774116=25 9A82348 5A>C:252362:=2344F4=2234<8;48<9234849484=?4<A82 :5A7341;26K:=D=<24<9234<8;48:= <'% 6=;?<==4?24;C6224856=;234C68K42F61A4:5699:8C4;62 5%* 748 6?84 G:23 611 <2348 5262A2<8E >4=49:25 234EG<A1;=<278455234?8<55<>B4?2:<=5 ( 468=4; # :5 A=6>14 2< ?<=28<F482 5A?3 655482:<= >E 234 1468=4; ?<A=541 9<8 234 6774116=25 6=; 5A>C:25 2362 234 <8;485 841:4; A7<= >E 234 6774116=25 :=?1A;:=D:= <'%6=;?<==4?24;C622485 684C622485<984?<8; - 18 - 347<:=29<8?<=5:;4862:<=& +34234823467746156842<>4;:5C:554;26K:=D =<24<9234<8;485:= <'%L , 2:5=<2:?4;2362234<8;48576554;:=234>62?3 := <'% 6=; ?<==4?24; C622485 8416242< 234 16=;5 <9 6DD<; :116D4 65 84D68;5 234 56C4 =<2:9:?62:<= <= ' = 234 78454=2 ?654 234 1468=4;?<A=5419<82346774116=255A>C:252362234=62A84 <9 16=;5 65 := <'% 6=; ?<==4?24; C622485G65;45?8:>4;65;8E16=;56=;:884574?2:F4<9234 =62A84<923416=;5:=23478454=267746156774116=25684 846;E2<6??472234?<C74=562:<=>E28462:=D234C68K42 F61A4<9;8E16=;565<=46??4726>142<234C ' = 1:D32 <9 234 <8;485 76554; := <'%6=;?<==4?24;C62248526K:=D=<242362 23478454=2?65465G41123416=;56845:2A624;:=23456C4 F:116D4 6=; 684 ;45?8:>4; 2< >4 ;8E 16=;5 6=; 234 =<2:9:?62:<= 8494884; 2< 65 <9 ' 6=; 2362 234 - 19 - 5A>B4?2C62248<916=;5:=23478454=26774615G65615<234 5A>B4?2 C62248 <9 ?<CC<= 6G68; >E 234 74?:61 6=; ?@A:5:2:<=99:?48:=?1A;:=D6584D68;523<5416=;5G3:?3 G484 5A>B4?2 C62248 := <'% 6=; ?<==4?24; C622485 = 768:2E 234 78454=2 6774116=25 684 615< 4=2:214; 9<8 4J24=;:=D 234 C68K42 F61A4 <9 5%*7486?84:=23478454=2C62248565G411 '' = 1:D32 <9 234 6><F4 ;:5?A55:<= 234 7<:=2 9<8 ?<=5:;4862:<=:56=5G484;:=234;:99:8C62:F4L ' ??<8;:=D1E 234 78454=2 6774615 <9 234 2624 684699:8C:=D234<8;485<9234849484=?4<A82 26K:=D =<24 2362 234 <8;485 <9 234 849484=?4 <A82 9:J:=D :;4=2:?61 86245 65 9:J4; := 234 78454=2 <8;485 <9 234 849484=?4 <A82 G:23 84574?2 2< 234 16=;5 <9 234 56C4 F:116D4 365 >44= A7341; := <'% 6=; ?<==4?24;C622485=1:D32<9234526=;6=;C4C<9:14; ?8<55 <>B4?2:<=5 684 !"# $ G:23 6 9A82348;:84?2:<=<9849A=;<9<A829445:=248C5<94?2:<= - 20 - !$!?$<923468=626K6<A824456=;A:2561A62:<= ?2', -( & ! %' " -( &" ' " :52<&'1<& &