- 1 - !" ! #$ " % &" ! $ '(')*+(' ** & ! "# $ ! "# % % & & ! "# " $! ! "# $% Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $$ ! "# # $% ! "# ' ( &&) * &+ ** ! % $ ( ) ( ) $% ! " ' ( * &*$) * "!$*) * $$$% #$$" * ** %$% "," ",! " - 3 - ", %"* *-,"$$" * & * $) . * * * + & (+ & ) /01 23404056 76839 3:4056 "!$ 5;9 01 ;0<38 => ?::7138 51$ 45 ?68 ! 45 06 5#$$" 236806@=3;5934/357945; 360590A0< 78@3?68 * 79?8 ?90106@ 574 5; 90B3 5$$$% 93@0143938 => ?B?<?6?@?95<0:3 4?405608?9;595;;36:3127601/?=<3 76839 13:40561 %$% "," ",!(?) " 9C 13:4056 %" 5; ?68 13:40561 % D " 5; 5C9> 95/0=04056 :4 C04/ ? 29?>39 45 E7?1/ 4/3 364093 295:33806@1 06 4/3 ?;5931?08 :?13?1?@?06144/3B $ 3?984/3<3?9638:57613<;594/32?94031 - 4 - % * 06 90B3 5$$$% C?1 93@0143938 => ?B?<?6?@?9 5<0:3 4?4056 08?9 ;59 4/3 ?;5931?08 5;;36:31 ?@?0614 33901/ /?69?F ?68 54/391 56 4/3 =?101 5; 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?4056 8?438 $$$$% 93:30A38 ;95B 9312568364 5$ /39306 C/5 01 4/3 C0;3 5; ?::7138 533901//?69?F " /3 25<0:3 ?;439 06A3140@?4056 /?A3 ;0<38 ? :/?9@3 1/334?1?@?0614$2391561?684/323404056391/39306?93 ?99?0@638?1?::713851$45 ?68!45064/3:/?9@3 1/334 /3 490?< :5794 ?;439 4?G06@ :5@60H?6:3 5; 4/3 :/?9@3 1/33438 5;;36:31 /?1 011738 17BB561 45 4/3 ?::7138 2391561 306@ ?@@903A38 => 4/3 0B27@638 :90B06?<295:33806@14/323404056391?93=3;5934/015794 3?9638:57613<;594/32340405639117=B0414/?44/3 23404056391 /39306 ?93 4/3 93<?40A31 5; ?::7138 5 680127438<> 9312568364 5$ /?1 132?9?438 ;95B /39 /71=?68?=574;579>3?91290594593@0149?40565;4/3* /3?<<3@?40565;?=7106@?68?11?7<406@;091406;59B?6456 "$$$ 01 56<> ?1 ?@?0614 ?::7138 5 /393 01 - 5 - ?=15<743<> 65 B?4390?< ?1 ?@?0614 4/3 23404056391 /39306 C/0:/ C57<8 ?449?:4 4/3 ?<<3@38 5;;36:327601/?=<376839 13:4056 "," 5; ?@?0614 4/3B 5 ;?9 ?1 4/3 5;;36:3 27601/?=<3 76839 13:4056 ",! 5; 01 :56:39638 4/3 ?<<3@?405693<?43145;579>3?91290594593@0149?40565;* ?6806A03C5;13:4056"!5;94/3490?<:5794:57<8 654 /?A3 4?G36 :5@60H?6:3 ;59 4/3 5;;36:3 27601/?=<3 76839 13:4056 ",! 5; ?@?0614 4/3 23404056391 ::59806@<>/329?>145?<<5C4/323404056 39 :5649? <3?9638 0@/ 5794 5A396B364 <3?839 ?68<3?9638:57613<;5993125683645$/?A352251384/3 23404056 # 3?9638:57613<;5993125683645$17=B0414/?406 A03C5;4/3F78@B3645;4/356.=<3 7293B35794064/3 :?135; 93259438 06 4/3 25<0:3 /?A3 F790180:4056 45 06A3140@?43 4/3 :?13 3A36 56 ? 25<0:3 :5B2<?064;595;;36:327601/?=<37683913:4056","5; 0; 4/3 :5B2<?064 :564?061 ?<<3@?40561 C/0:/ C57<8 ?449?:4 - 6 - 5;;36:327601/?=<37683913:4056",!5;/325<0:3 ?;439 06A3140@?4056 /?A3 ;0<38 :/?9@3 1/334 ?@?0614 $ 2391561 ?68 06 4/3 :/?9@3 1/334 04 01 ?<<3@38 4/?4 4/3 B?990?@3 5; ?::7138 5! C04/ ?::7138 5 C?1 239;59B38=>4/3?::71382391561106:34/3;091406;59B?64 /?8 ;?0<38 45 =906@ 85C9> ?1 83B?6838 => 4/3B /393;593 4/393 01 B?4390?< 45 295:338 ?@?0614 ?<< 4/3 ?::71382391561;595;;36:327601/?=<37683913:4056"," 5;::59806@<>/329?>145801B0114/323404056 ! 3971?< 5; 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?4056 8?438 $$$$% C57<8 @5 45 1/5C 4/?4 4/3 B?990?@3 5; 9312568364 5$ C04/4/3?::71385C?1239;59B3856$%$!6 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?4056 04 01 14?438 4/?4 29059 45 ;579 >3?91 ;95B 4/3 8?43 5; * 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?64 C?1 4/95C6 574 ;95B /39 B?490B560?< /5713 ?68 3A39 106:3 4/36 1/3 01 9310806@ 06 /39 2?9364.1 /5713 <<3@?4056 ?@?0614 4/3 23404056391 /39306 ?=574 0<< 493?406@ 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?64 06 4/3 B?490B560?< /5713 06 ;794/39?6:3 5; 83B?68 ;59 2?>B364 5; 85C9> 01 ;59 4/3 239058 C/36 4/3 ;0914 - 7 - 06;59B?64 C?1 14?>06@ 06 /39 B?490B560?< /5713 3:4056 "!5;9295A0831;592390585;<0B04?4056;594/3:5794 454?G3:5@60H?6:35;4/35;;36:31 3:4056"!93?81?1;5<<5C1 ! "#$ % &' ! '(! ) ) )* $+ ! " # ! $ ! % ! ! ! % ! ! ! " & ' ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! "( , /35;;36:37683913:4056",!5;0127601/?=<3 C04/0B290156B364;59?2390585;4/933>3?916A03C5; 13:4056 "!($)(:) 5; 9 4/3 239058 5; <0B04?4056 ;59 - 8 - 4?G06@ :5@60H?6:3 ;59 4/3 5;;36:3 76839 13:4056 ",! 5; 014/933>3?91 6 4/3 :?13 56 /?68 4/3 ?<<3@?4056 ?1 ?@?0614 4/3 23404056391 /39306 C/0:/ C57<8 ?449?:4 4/3 5;;36:3 27601/?=<3 76839 13:4056 ",! 5; 01 ;59 4/3 239058 C/36 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?64 C?1 14?>06@ 06 /39 B?490B560?< /5713C/0:/017680127438<>;579>3?9129059454/38?435; 93@0149?40565;* /393;59306B>:561083938A03C4/?44/3490?<:5794 :57<8 654 /?A3 4?G36 :5@60H?6:3 ;59 4/3 5;;36:3 27601/?=<37683913:4056",!?6813:40561%D"5;4/3 :4?1?@?06144/323404056391 $ 615;?9 ?1 4/3 13:568 ?<<3@?4056 C04/ 93@?98 45 4/3 06:083644/?4/?84?G362<?:356"$$$01:56:39638 23971?<5;4/3;091406;59B?4056?684/3:/?9@31/334C57<8 @5 45 1/5C 4/?4 4/01 ?<<3@?4056 01 B?83 => 4/3 ;0914 06;59B?64 56<> ?1 ?@?0614 /39 /71=?68 C/5 01 ?::7138 5 06 4/3 2931364 :?13 A36 06 93123:4 5; 4/3 1?08 - 9 - ?<<3@?4056 4/393 01 ? 83<?> 5; B564/1 06 ?2295?:/06@ 4/3 5<0:3 /3 ;0914 06;59B?4056 01 17=B04438 56 $$$$% C/393?1 4/3 ?<<3@38 <?14 06:08364 C/39306 ?::71385/?8?=7138?68?11?7<4384/3;091406;59B?64 /?84?G362<?:356"$$$ % /3 56.=<3 7293B3 5794 06 4/3 :?13 5; 4?43 5; , - . . / 1 ?4 2?9?@9?2/5%/?15=139A38?1;5<<5C1 )&*" #! + ! ! ' ,! - " . ' ,! - ! ! ! " / "# "( ($!) !$ - 10 - " /393;5934/3763I2<?063883<?>5;?=574B564/1 06 ?2295?:/06@ 4/3 5<0:3 01 ?<15 ;?4?< 45 4/3 :?13 5; 4/3 29513:74056 ?68 ?1G06@ 4/3 63?9 93<?40A31 5; 4/3 ?::7138 5 45 14?68 490?< ;59 4/3 ?<<3@38 5;;36:31 C/36 4/3 0659806?43 83<?> 5; B564/1 01 654 295239<> 3I2<?0638 C57<89317<40606F7140:3 5;?9?14/35;;36:327601/?=<37683913:4056","5; 01 :56:39638 23971?< 5; 4/3 :/?9@3 1/334 B?4390?< C57<8 @5 45 1/5C 4/?4 4/393 01 ?=15<743<> 65 B?4390?< ?A?0<?=<35693:598451/5C4/?44/323404056391/39306/?8 2?940:02?438064/3?<<3@38B?990?@35;?::71385C04/ ?::7138 5! C/0:/ C?1 239;59B38 56 ,$$$ ?1 14?438064/3:/?9@31/334/325<0:387906@4/3:579135; 06A3140@?4056/?A365493:598384/314?43B3645;?6>563 5;4/3C046311C/52?940:02?438064/3B?990?@3659/?A3 4/325<0:3:5<<3:438?6>B?4390?<C/0:/ !C57<8 @5 45 1/5C 4/?4 B?990?@3 5; ?::7138 5 C04/ ?::7138 5! C?1 239;59B38 56 ,$$$ ?4 1B?6?=?8 06 ?/?9?1/49? 4?43?1?<<3@38064/3:/?9@31/334 - 11 - 64/3?=136:35;?6>B?4390?<?A?0<?=<35693:59845 295A3 C/0:/ ! 1/5C1 4/?4 4/3 B?990?@3 5; ?::71385C04/?::71385!C?1239;59B38?1?<<3@38 06 4/3 :/?9@3 1/334 56 ,$$$ :564067?4056 5; 4/3 0B27@638 :90B06?< 295:33806@1 ?1 ?@?0614 4/3 23404056391 ;594/35;;36:3127601/?=<37683913:4056","5;C57<8 ?B5764 45 ?=713 5; 295:311 5; <?C 680127438<> 4/3 23404056391 ?93 ?<< 9310806@ 06 80;;39364 2<?:31 ?68 ?1G06@ 4/3B 45 14?68 490?< ;59 4/3 ?<<3@38 5;;36:31 C/36 4/3 :/?9@3 1/334 8531 654 :564?06 ! B?4390?< ?1 ?@?0614 4/3B ;59 4/3 :/?9@3 1/33438 5;;36:31 C57<8 ?B5764 45 ?=713 5; 295:311 5; <?C 6839 4/313 :09:7B14?6:314/3;5<<5C06@59839 ?) /390B06?<2340405601?<<5C38 =) /3 364093 295:33806@1 06 5#$$" 236806@ =3;593 4/3 5794 5; 36059 0A0< 78@3 ?68 * 79?8 ?90106@ 574 5; 90B3 - 12 - 5$$$%93@0143938=>?B?<?6?@?95<0:3 4?4056 08?9 ;59 5;;36:31 27601/?=<3 76839 13:40561 %$% "," ",!(?) " 9C 13:4056 %" 5;?6813:40561%D"5;5C9>95/0=04056 :4 01 /393=> E7?1/38 ?1 ?@?0614 4/3 23404056391/39306 ,+ ' % &" !* " 0145 <5%%