Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10300 (KAR)

BHEEMAREDDY S/O ANANTHREDDY v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER

MFA/202921/2023 · 2025-02-18

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "" # $ $ %%& ' ( ) ! "## $ ! ! % # ## & &# # ## & ! " $ ! ! % # '$% # ## # # # !!( ( # # !!! !)*( ( ! Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # +# ! $ $ +# ! % , -./01/2 .3 4156/17 -.8/014 599156:/; 3.6 <.2= 2=1 9562:10 2=1 >52216 :0 25?1/ 89 3.6 3:/54 7:09.054 2=.8;= :2 :0 045217 3.6 7>:00:./! =:0 599154 :0 7:61-217 5;5:/02 2=1 @87;>1/2 5/7 5A567 75217 !!( ( 950017 :/ .!)*( ( <, 2=1 4156/17 6:/-:954 1/:.6 :B:4 87;1 5/7 1><16 :@5,59865 $=161:/53216 61316617 2. 50 C2=1 6:<8/54D 3.6 0=.62%! (! =1 912:2:./16 >12 A:2= 5/ 5--:71/2 ./ (! )!( ) A=:41 =1 A50 265B144:/; :/ & <80 <156:/; .!&((' 2. ;. 2. =56A57 36.> &545<865;:! =1 5--:71/2 .--86617 781 2. 2=1 /1;4:;1/-1 .3 2=1 <80 76:B16 50 2=1 05:7 <80 286/17 286241 :/ A=:-= 2=1 912:2:./16 08025:/17 :/@86:10! / 57>:00:./ 2. 2=1 .09:254 - 3 - 575; 5/7 2=1/ 0=:3217 2. .09:254 =56A57 :2 A50 3.8/7 2=52 =1 =57 08025:/17 21/716/100 .B16 2=1 -=102 5/7 0A144:/; ./ 2=1 6:;=2 2=:;= 5/7 E65, .3 2=1 6:;=2 2=:;= 7:0-4.017 365-2861 .3 89916 0=532 5/7 6:;=2 31>86 A:2= 7:0945-1>1/2 5/7 50 08-= =1 61>5:/17 :/952:1/2 36.> (! )!( ) 2. '! !( )! ! =1/ 2=1 -45:> 912:2:./ A50 3:417 <13.61 2=1 6:<8/54 :2 A50 610:0217 <, 2=1 6109./71/2.69.652:./ 7:0982:/; 2=1 /52861 .3 2=1 :/@86:10 5/7 2=1 5;1 :/-.>1 5/7 .--8952:./ .3 2=1 912:2:./16! *! 3216 2=1 1/F8:6, 786:/; A=:-= 2=1 A.8/7 -162:3:-521 =.09:254 >17:-54 <:440 9610-6:92:./0 E65,0 12-! 54./; A:2= .2=16 7.-8>1/20 A161 >56?17 2=1 6:<8/54 -5>1 2. 2=1 -./-480:./ 2=52 2=1 912:2:./16 :0 1/2:2417 3.6 5 -.>91/052:./ .3 0! 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 >17:-54 1G91/010 5/7 0!( 2.A5670 544 .2=16 =1570 5/7 2=161<, 5A56717 5 2.254 -.>91/052:./ .3 0!) 5/7 7:61-217 2=1 6109./71/2 2. 719.0:2 2=1 05>1! - 4 - ! 1:/; 7:0052:03:17 A:2= 2=1 F85/28> .3 -.>91/052:./ 2=1 912:2:./16 :0 <13.61 2=:0 .862 011?:/; 1/=5/-1>1/2 .3 -.>91/052:./! ! 1567 2=1 4156/17 -.8/014 599156:/; 3.6 2=1 5991445/2 5/7 2=1 4156/17 -.8/014 3.6 2=1 6109./71/2 .69.652:./! '! #156/17 -.8/014 599156:/; 3.6 2=1 5991445/2 A.847 08<>:2 2=52 2=1 -.>91/052:./ 5A56717 <, 2=1 6:<8/54 7. /.2 58;>1/2 A144 A:2= 2=1 /52861 .3 :/@86:10 08331617 <, 2=1 912:2:./16! B1/ 2=.8;= 2=1 912:2:./16 =57 /.2 0=.A/ 5/, 7:05<:4:2, ./ 2=1 -.8/2 .3 2=1 :/@86:10 08331617 <, =:> :2 A50 /1-10056, 2=52 2=1 6:<8/54 0=.847 =5B1 5A56717 571F8521 -.>91/052:./ 8/716 2=1 =1570 .3 95:/ 5/7 083316:/; 4.00 .3 5>1/:2:10 :/ 4:31 5221/75/2 -=56;10 -./B1,5/-1 12-! 5/7 4.00 .3 :/-.>1 786:/; 45:7 89 916:.7! 2 :0 08<>:2217 2=52 2=1 6:<8/54 16617 :/ 5A567:/; 5 ;4.<54 -.>91/052:./ .3 0!( 8/716 544 2=1 /./91-8/:56, =1570! - 5 - ! 16 -./265 4156/17 -.8/014 3.6 2=1 6109./71/2 7131/70 2=1 -.>91/052:./ 5A56717 <, 2=1 6:<8/54 05,:/; 2=52 :2 :0 5/ 571F8521 -.>91/052:./! )! / 9565 .3 2=1 :>98;/17 @87;>1/2 2=1 6:<8/54 /.2:-17 2=52 2=1 A.8/7 -162:3:-521 -521;.6:-544, >1/2:./ 2=52 2=161 A50 365-2861 .3 6:;=2 31>86 A:2= 7:0945-1>1/2 5/7 :2 540. /.2:-17 2=52 2=1 912:2:./16 A50 :/952:1/2 3.6 75,0! =1 >17:-54 61-.670 540. 719:-2 2=1 05>1! ./96.78-2:./ .3 2=1 7:05<:4:2, -162:3:-521 5/7 /.2 -45:>:/; 5/, -.>91/052:./ 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 4.00 .3 382861 :/-.>1 ./ 5--.8/2 .3 7:05<:4:2, -5//.2 <1 -./026817 2=52 2=1 912:2:./16 :0 /.2 1/2:2417 3.6 2=1 -.>91/052:./ 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 95:/ 5/7 083316:/; 5/7 08-= .2=16 =1570! =1613.61 -./0:716:/; 2=1 /52861 .3 2=1 :/@86:10 08331617 <, 2=1 912:2:./16 :2 A.847 <1 @802 5/7 96.916 2. 5A567 5 08> .3 0! 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 95:/ 5/7 083316:/; 0! 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 4.00 .3 :/-.>1 786:/; 45:7 89 916:.7 0! 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 4.00 .3 5>1/:2:10 :/ 4:31 -./0:716:/; 2=1 5;1 .3 2=1 912:2:./16 50 - 6 - ,1560 5/7 5 08> .3 0!( 8/716 2=1 =1570 .3 3..7 /.86:0=>1/2 -./B1,5/-1 5/7 5221/75/2 -=56;10! ! =1 -.>91/052:./ 5A56717 <, 2=1 6:<8/54 8/716 2=1 =157 .3 >17:-54 1G91/010 2. 2=1 28/1 .3 0! 7.10 /.2 -544 3.6 5/, :/2163161/-1 <, 2=:0 .862! ! 1/-1 2=1 5991445/2 :0 1/2:2417 3.6 2=1 >.7:3:17 -.>91/052:./ 8/716 7:33161/2 =1570 50 <14.A 5:/ 5/7 083316:/; 0! 17:-54 1G91/010 0! ..7 /.86:0=>1/2 -./B1,5/-1 5/7 5221/75/2 -=56;10 0!( #.00 .3 :/-.>1 786:/; 45:7 89 916:.7 0! #.00 .3 5>1/:2:10 0! .254 #100 5A56717 <, 6:<8/54 /=5/-1>1/2 0!( 0!) * =80 2=1 5991445/2 :0 1/2:2417 3.6 1/=5/-17 -.>91/052:./ .3 0! A:2= :/216102 5/7 2=1613.61 2=1 599154 71016B10 2. <1 544.A17 :/ 9562! 1/-1 2=1 3.44.A:/; - 7 - $:% =1 599154 :0 544.A17 :/ 9562! $::% =1 :>98;/17 @87;>1/2 5/7 5A567 950017 <, 2=1 6:<8/54 :0 >.7:3:17 <, 5A567:/; 5 08> .3 0! :/ 577:2:./ 2. A=52 =50 <11/ 5A56717 <, 2=1 6:<8/54 2.;12=16 A:2= :/216102 52 H 9!5! 36.> 2=1 7521 .3 912:2:./ 2:44 :20 6154:I52:./ 1G-487:/; :/216102 3.6 2=1 7145,17 916:.7 .3 75,0 :/ 3:4:/; 2=1 599154! $:::% =1 6109./71/2 J .69.652:./ :0 7:61-217 2. 719.0:2 2=1 1/2:61 -.>91/052:./ 5>.8/2 A:2=:/ 5 916:.7 .3 0:G A11?0 36.> 2=1 7521 .3 2=:0 .6716! $:B% 102 .3 2=1 .6716 950017 <, 2=1 6:<8/54 61>5:/0 8/5421617! 7 & $ ( $ # #:02 .! 4 .!