- 1 - ! "#" $! % #!!! " & % #!#! ! !$$ '( ) !! "# $ ! %& !! "# % ! $' Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! "# ! " !" " ( " "! ()* " $+&$$&$% "! $&) ", !" ! " ! ! -! -! # -! ./01/2/34500/5672876/9:;4./065734788:/8<1/4./ "5=76;<>14565:>15?75??17/@/9:;4./<19/10522/9:; 4./ "5=76; <>14 A./1/:; 74 .52 971/B4/9 4< 1/4>13 4./ 065734<:2/1@73?4.54<>14.523<C>17297B47<34</34/14573 4./2>74245473?4.544./2>7472:511/9734/1=2<8/B47<3+ <8 4./ "5=76; <>142 B4 ()* 539 85662 <>4279/ 4./ C>17297B47<3<85"5=76;<>14 - 3 - $ ./05147/251/1/8/11/94<:;4./71153D:/8<1/ 4./1756<>14 % 65734788.59876/9 2>742//D73?8<159/B651547<3 4.549/8/39534<723<44./6/?566;A/99/9A78/<84./ 0657347885399/8/39534<2$539%51/3<44./B.7691/3<8 4./065734788">14./1065734788.592<>?.48<1052273?<853 <19/14<1/2415739/8/39534<81<=B657=73?./12/6852 4./A78/<84./0657347885399/8/39534<2$539%4<:/ 1/241573/981<=B657=73?4./=2/6@/252B.7691/395>?.4/12 <8 065734788 :; ?153473? 5 9/B1// <8 0/10/4>56 73C>3B47<3 5?573244./= * ./85B4252522/14/9734./06573451/4.54376 724./6/?566;A/99/9A78/<84./065734788539065734788.52 :/?<44/34.1//B.7691/381<=A74.734./2579A/96<BD ./20/B787BB52/<84./0657347884.549/8/39534 < .59 =5117/9 <3/ .5?5@534.515;5 562./44; 539 9/8/39534 <2$ 539 % 51/ B.7691/3 :<13 81<= A74.73 4./ 2579 A/96<BD :/4A//3 9/8/39534 < 539 - 4 - .5?5@534.515;5 4 72 8>14./1 2>:=744/9 4.54 2579 =5417=<3756 1/6547<32.70 :/4A//3 9/8/39534 < 539 .5?5@534.515;5 B5=/ 4< :/ 9722<6@/9 :; 5 9/B1// <8 B<32/34:;87673?0/4747<3>39/1/B47<3%E<84./739> !51175?/B473!<'$&& ' 4724./8>14./1B52/4.549/8/39534<4./3 24514/9 522/1473? 4.54 2./ .59 =5117/9 4./ 065734788 <3 &&()+ 539 9/8/39534 <2$ 539 % 51/ 4./ B.7691/3 :<1381<=4./2579A/96<BD + ./ 065734 B5=/ 4< :/ 1/4>13/9 54 4./ 47=/ <8 87356./5173?<84./2>742<6/6;<34./6/?56B<34/347<34.54 4./ 2>74 85662 <>4279/ 4./ 0>1@7/A <8 C>17297B47<3 <8 4./ "5=76; <>14 A.7B. 72 5>4.<172/9 4< 45D/ >0 =544/12 52 2470>654/9>39/1/B47<3+<84./"5=76;<>142B4./ 59C>97B547<3 :; 4./ "5=76; <>14 72 2<6/6; <3 4./ 734/101/4547<3 <8 /F0653547<3 4< /B47<3 + <8 4./ "5=76; <>142 B4 ./ <>14 .52 562< 45D/3 3<4/ <8 53<4./1 B<34/347<31/65473?4<4./354>1/<81/67/8:/73?53/?547@/ 9/B651547<3./"5=76;<>14.521/8/11/94</F0653547<3 - 5 - 4</B47<3+<84./"5=76;<>142B4539.52./694.544./ "5=76; <>14 .52 ?<4 C>17297B47<3 4< /34/14573 4./ 2>74 A.7B.<36;85662A74.734./2B<0/<8/B47<3+73B6>973?4./ /F0653547<34<4./25792/B47<3./<>1473742<19/1.52 <:2/1@/94.5453/?547@/9/B651547<3722<>?.48<153973 4/1=2 <8 4./ C>9?=/34 <8 4./ 7@727<3 /3B. 73 2>B.1/67/8727=0/1=7227:6/ ) ./ 2579 <19/1 72 >39/1 B.566/3?/ :/8<1/ 4.72 <>14 539 4./ 6/513/9 B<>32/6 8<1 4./ 500/66534 2>:=742 4.54 4./ 1/67/8 2<>?.4 4.<>?. 2G>51/6; B<=/2 A74.73 4./ 0>1@7/A <8 /B47<3 + <8 4./ "5=76; <>142 B4 539 73 20/B787B4.//F0653547<3:4</B47<3+B<@/122>B.2>742 52856673?A74.734./C>17297B47<3<84./"5=76;<>142B4 4 72 2>:=744/9 4.54 73 5 2>74 52 1/?5192 4./ =5417=<3756 2454>2 <8 53; 0/12<3 72 5 =544/1 856673? A74.73 4./ C>17297B47<3<84./"5=76;<>14B44728>14./12>:=744/9 4.54734./01/2/34B52/4./1/67/82<>?.48<11/654/24<4./ - 6 - =5417=<37562454>2<89/8/39534<A.<B657=24<:/4./ A78/<806573478853952A/66524./2454>2<84./B.7691/3<8 9/8/39534 < A.7B. .52 5 971/B4 :/5173? <3 4./ 9/4/1=73547<3 <8 4./ =5417=<3756 2454>2 <8 4./ 87124 9/8/39534A.<566/?/96;B657=24.542./724./A78/<84./ 0657347884728>14./12>:=744/94.544./6/?560<2747<352 1/?5192 4./ :51 8<1 87673? 2>742 2//D73? 3/?547@/ 1/67/82 72 3<A 2/446/9 :; @714>/ <8 4./ C>9?=/34 73 4./ B52/ <8 73 7@76 00/56 <*&&$&'517273?<>4<8 <)&+'$& ( /513/9 B<>32/6 8<1 1/20<39/34 < A.< 72 4./9/8/39534<2>:=7424.544./065734788725.1724753 539 4./ 01<B//973?2 <>?.4 4< .5@/ ://3 7374754/9 >39/1 4./01<@727<32<80/B756!51175?/B4 & /519:<4.279/2 ./ 85B42 51/ 3<4 73 9720>4/ ./ 9/8/39534 < B657=2 4< :/ 4./ A78/ <8 4./ 065734788 539 9/8/39534 - 7 - <2$539%51/4./B.7691/3:<1381<=4./2579=51175?/ ./0<7348<1B<3279/1547<3734./01/2/34500/5672 !" # " $ % &'( $ ./ 065734 A52 876/9 2//D73? 8<1 4./ 8<66<A73? 1/67/82 ) * + ",, -) ) . / ! ! , -/!!!0 1 /" !) -)./" ) )#",/ !)( % 0/1>256<84./2579015;/1=5D/274B6/514.54 4./ 2>74 1/654/2 4< 4./ 6/?56 =5417=<3756 2454>2 <8 4./ 0657347885399/8/39534<3;873973?21/?51973?2579 - 8 - =5417=<3756 2454>2 A<>69 562< .5@/ 5 :/5173? 732<851 52 4./ 2454>2 <8 9/8/39534 <2$ 539 % A.7B. 72 5 B<32/G>/34756873973?32<851524./2B<0/<82>7424<:/ /34/14573/9:;4./"5=76;<>14272?<@/13/9:;/B47<3+ <84./"5=76;<>142B4A.7B.1/592528<66<A2 2$/0 #+ !" 2 033/ /" " " / 0 ",!/ 435 / / !+ 3 ,+/+ !"/+/0 , !" 3) 43)2. /6 ,+!"72 /, ! " ! !/0+ !" /+ ! !5 - 9 - / 0"!!! "5 /, !," !5 !!5 !""5 !5 " + +"!) $/ 0 #+ !" 032 3//"8 *9 ! ,+ !:+%-%5 /!"/ /""!)( ! * 4 72 4< :/ 3<47B/9 4.54 4./ /F0653547<3 4< /B47<3+<84./"5=76;<>142B401<@79/24.544./2>742 539 01<B//973?2 1/8/11/9 4< 73 2>:E2/B47<3 51/ 2>742 539 - 10 - 01<B//973?2 <8 354>1/ 9/4576/9 73 4./ /F0653547<3 539 /F0653547<3 : 72 <8 7==/9754/ 1/6/@53B/ 73 4./ 01/2/34 B52/472B6/51<351/5973?<8/F0653547<3:4</B47<3 + <8 4./ "5=76; <>142 B4 /F415B4/9 5:<@/ 4.54 5 2>74 1/65473? 4< =5417=<3756 2454>2 <8 53; 0/12<3 A<>69 :/ 5 2>74 856673? A74.73 4./ 2B<0/ <8 /B47<3 + <8 4./ "5=76; <>142B4:51/0/1>256<84./065734523<47B/95:<@/ 1/654/2 4< =5417=<3756 2454>2 <8 9/8/39534 < A74. 4./ 065734788 ./ 1/6547<32.70 <8 9/8/39534 <2$ 539 % 562< 9/0/392<35873973?<34./=5417=<37562454>2<8065734788 539 9/8/39534 < 52 .>2:539 539 A78/ 52 522/14/9 :; 9/8/39534< 32<851524./873973?4.544./2>7472:511/9:; @714>/ <8 .5@73? 2<>?.4 8<1 5 3/?547@/ 9/B651547<3 :; 1/6753B/<34./C>9?=/34734./B52/<8;0,0) 0 + 73 67?.4 <8 4./ C>9?=/34 <8 4./ 0/F <>1473 @ A.7B. .<692 4.54 2>B. 015;/1 A<>69 :/ =57345735:6/ 4./ 6544/1 @7/AA<>6901/@576 - 11 - ' ./0/F<>14734./B52/<8 73 7@76 00/56 <*&&$&' A.76/ B<3279/173? 79/347B56 85B4>56 =5417F A74. :<4. 6/?56 B<34/347<323<47B/95:<@/.5273742<:2/1@547<325405152E '539+./694.54784./1/7259720>4/<34./=5417=<3756 2454>2<853;0/12<359/B651547<3734.541/?519.524<:/ 2<>?.4 <36; :/8<1/ 4./ "5=76; <>14 539 74 A<>69 3<4 =544/1 A./4./1 74 72 53 58871=547@/ 1/67/8 <1 5 3/?547@/ 1/67/8 5152E' 539 + <8 4./ 2579 C>9?=/34 1/592 52 8<66<A2 ) $ !" #+ < 00#, ! 0 ,) . $,76 =) # 0 0 6 . 0 # 0 , " , " , ! / " ! 0/"0", #)= %) > $ % 43 /+ $ 0"/ - 12 - !!!, 30 !" + $<+0 $ % 3 ! 0, 0 ) * + !! " + / " / !" )*!? ,!00) ! !! ) $ 0, , , 0 ?+ !" #+<+0,)( + 3 67?.4 <8 4./ 5:<@/ 3<47B73? 4.54 4./ 2>74 1/654/2 4< =5417=<3756 2454>2 <8 9/8/39534 < A74. 4./ 0657347884./873973?<84./"5=76;<>1472/11<3/<>253972 675:6/4<:/2/45279/7367?.4<84./972B>227<3=59/5:<@/ 32<851 52 3/?547@/ 1/67/8 2<>?.4 8<1 4./ 0/F <>14 .52 ./69 4.54 74 9</2 3<4 =5D/ 53; 9788/1/3B/ /@/3 78 2>B. 3/?547@/1/67/8722<>?.48<1 ) BB<1973?6; 4./ 0<734 8<1 B<3279/1547<3 72 532A/1/9734./58871=547@/./500/5672566<A/9./ <19/1<84./"5=76;<>14722/45279/<34./2<6/?1<>39 - 13 - 4.544./B<3B6>27<35117@/9544.542>749</23<48566A74.73 4./ 0>1@7/A <8 /B47<3 + <8 4./ "5=76; <>142 B4 72 /11<3/<>2 539 B<32/G>/346; 4./ 065734 72 971/B4/9 4< :/ 45D/3<31/B<1953901<B//973?251/4<:/1/2>=/9 5147/2 4< =51D 4./71 500/5153B/ :/8<1/ 4./ "5=76; <>14A74.<>48>14./13<47B/<3!" #" "#"$ !*+ '!! " &( # !*+ '#! ( # 724<6<% E