Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10284 (KAR)

THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD v. SMT. BASAMMA AND ORS

MFA/201715/2019 · 2025-01-23

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #" $# # %% &' ( ) ! " # $! % ! & ' ( & ) *+! * ( % ( & & ,+ - " ( & ) *""! * + ( & ) *"! * LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.28 18:03:37 - 0800 - 2 - ! ( & ) *! * ( % ( & & ,+ - ( ! & *+! * & +( ."( % +" . ' ( & ! ( *! * ' & ( *"! * ' & ( *,! * ' ! ( *! * & % +" ( * * +( ."( % +" ( & *! * & - 3 - "(.( % +" # $! & & +$ '/ ( / &( +"" .$ 0' / & / &( +"" ' +$' & ! .", & (" ! & ! ! & * * 1 # $* 1 ' 234 566758 34 93:7;<79 5=53>4< <27 ?@9=A7>< 5>9 5B5:9 95<79 .", 654479 3> & C(" DE <27 875:>79 993<3C>58 7>3C: 3F38 @9=7 5>9 585D@:5=3 - 4 - " E <27 3A6@=>79 ?@9=A7>< <27 :3D@>58 254 5B5:97954@ACG4,(<C=7<27:B3<23><7:74<5< .H 65 54 ;CA67>45<3C> <C <27 67<3<3C>7:4 5>9 93:7;<79 :746C>97><C4"$5'5>9<27:73><C976C43<<2745A75< <27:5<3CCG*73>=5==:37F79DE<274539?@9=A7>< :746C>97>< C3>4@:5>;7 ;CA65>E 34 D7GC:7 <234 C@:< + 75:9 <27 875:>79 ;C@>478 56675:3>= GC: <27 5667885><C>756675:4GC:<27:746C>97><4 27 42C:< 6C3>< <25< 34 @:=79 DE <27 875:>79 ;C@>478 GC: <27 5667885>< 34 <25< :746C>97>< C D7GC:7 <27 :3D@>58 34 <27 5667885>< 27:73> 5>9 3< 259 344@79 835D383<E C>8E 6C83;E <CB5:94 <27 F723;87 D75:3>= C"(. B23;2 34 5 6:3F5<7 ;5: 27 97;75479 &77:5>>5):5>>5B545>C;;@65><CG<274539;5:5>9 2793793><27:C59<:5GG3;5;;397><CG<274539F723;87B3<2 5>C<27: F723;87 D75:3>= C+( ." CB>79 DE :746C>97>< C" D7GC:7 <27 :3D@>58 < 34 4@DA3<<79 DE <27 875:>79 ;C@>478 56675:3>= GC: <27 5667885>< <25< <27 5667885><>4@:5>;7 CA65>E 259 344@79 835D383<E C>8E - 5 - 6C83;E<C<273>4@:795>9<27:7GC:7<273>A5<74CG<274539 ;5: B7:7 >C< ;CF7:79 @>97: <27 6C83;E 2C@=2 4@;2 ;C><7><3C> B54 <5I7> @6 DE <27 5667885>< D7GC:7 <27 :3D@>58 5>9 7F397>;7 B54 879 DE 6:C9@;3>= <27 ;C6E CG <276C83;E54J<27:3D@>58254G53879<C;C>4397:<27 45A7 5>9 254 G54<7>79 H CG <27 835D383<E C> <27 5667885><27:73><344@DA3<<79<25<3> F37B CG <27 <7:A4 5>9;C>93<3C>4CG<276C83;E<273>A5<74CG<27;5:B7:7 >C<;CF7:79@>97: <276C83;E5>9 54 4@;2 <27 835D383<E <C 65E<27;CA67>45<3C>5AC@><254<CD7G54<7>79@6C><27 CB>7:(3>4@:79 27:358C@:<:7;C:9425F7D77>47;@:795>9 5 ;5:7G@8 67:@458 CG <27 :7;C:94 BC@89 :7F758 <25< <27 :3D@>58 254 G54<7>79 <27 835D383<E <C <27 7J<7>< CG H 75;2 C> <27 CB>7: CG <27 <BC F723;874 B23;2 B7:7 3>FC8F79 3> <27 5;;397>< 27 CGG7>93>= F723;87 37 776 D75:3>= C+( ." B54 >C< 3>4@:79 B3<2 5>E 3>4@:5>;7;CA65>E5>9<27:7GC:7<27835D383<E<C65EH CG <27 ;CA67>45<3C> B54 G54<7>79 @6C> :746C>97>< - 6 - C"$5' B2C 34 GC@>9 <C D7 <27 :7=34<7:79 CB>7: CG <27 F723;87 . 27 :7;C:94 584C :7F758 <25< <27 ;C><7><3C> CG <27 5667885>< 27:73> <25< <27 6C83;E 344@79 DE 3< B54 5 835D383<E C>8E 6C83;E B54 >C< 5:=@79 D7GC:7 <27 :3D@>58 27 :3D@>58 254 >C< D74<CB79 3<4 5<<7><3C> C> 4@;2 5 ;C><7><3C> CG <27 5667885>< CB7F7: <27 7F397>;7 CG <27 CGG3;358 CG <27 5667885>< ;5<7=C:3;588E A7><3C>4 <25<3<B54835D383<EC>8E6C83;E5>9<27:7GC:7<27>4@:5>;7 CA65>E34>C<835D87<C65E<27;CA67>45<3C> @;2 D73>= <27 7F397>;7 5F5385D87 C> :7;C:9 <27 G538@:7 C> <27 65:< CG <27 :3D@>58 <C 566:7;35<7 <27 ;C><7><3C> CG 5>9 J BC@89 97G3>3<78E B73=2 3> G5FC@:CG<275667885><<347F397><<25<<273>A5<74CG <27 ;5: 3>4@:79 DE <27 5667885>< B7:7 >C< ;CF7:79 @>97: <27 6C83;E <27:7GC:7 5>E 835D383<E 3> :7467;< CG 975<2 C: 3>?@:E<C5>ECG<273>A5<74CG<27;5:BC@8925F7<CD7 G54<7>79@6C><27CB>7:CG<27;5: - 7 - 5F3>= 4539 4C 3< 42C@89 D7 >C<79 <25< <27 CB>7: CG <27 5: D75:3>= +( ." 254 <C ;CA67>45<7<2767<3<3C>7:4;853A5><427:73>584C<D73>= <27;547CG;CA6C43<7>7=83=7>;7<273>A5<74CG<275: 25F3>= >C :C87 <C 685E 3> ;C><:3D@<C:E 5;< <27 ;853A5><4 ;5>=C5=53>4<5>EC>7CG<27<C:<G754C:45485399CB>DE <27 67JC@:<3><27;547CG 27:7GC:7 <27 :3D@>58 G53879 <C >C<7 <25< <27 ;853A5><4 B7:7 5< 83D7:<E <C =C 5=53>4< 5>E C>7 CG <27 <C:<G754C:4 5>9B2387D3G@:;5<3>=<27835D383<E3<939>C<>C<3;7<25<<27 5667885><259:53479<27;C><7><3C>CG<27>C>;CF7:5=7CG <27 6C83;E 54 3< B54 5 5;< 6C83;E > <25< F37B CG <27 A5<<7:<275667589747:F74<CD7588CB79 , 7>;7<27GC88CB3>=* $3' 2756675834588CB79 1 (2015) 9 Supreme Court Cases 273 - 8 - $33' 273A6@=>79?@9=A7><5>95B5:9654479DE <27 :3D@>58 34 AC93G379 DE 5D4C8F3>= <27 835D383<E CG <27 5667885>< 27:73> <C 65E 5>E ;CA67>45<3C> $333' 27 ;CA67>45<3C> 42588 >CB D7 6539 ?C3><8E 5>9 47F7:588E DE :746C>97>< C. 5>9 :746C>97>< C 5>9 <27 835D383<E 5AC>=:746C>97><C. 5>9:746C>97><C 342789<CD7H75;2 $3F' 27 5AC@>< 3> 976C43< D7GC:7 <234 C@:< 34 C:97:79<CD7:7G@>979<C<275667885>< 9( &# ( # 34<C* 8C*+.