- 1 - !" #$ %# " $ &'&()*+&)) % ! " #$ %#&& %#&' $#() ! * %' #() * * * ) &(&) * * + * * Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '# ! &! ! * (&(&(& * * ,#$ &()) * * + * &#(&&(&) * * ** )$)#& * * - - ! ) ./0 1/2/345 67/0/83 69/9/83 :3;61 6<9/83 %' 164; =/9. 6<9/83 #() 8> 1 /0 >/56; ?@ 4<<:06; 4004/5/3A 9.6 B:;A2639 43; 81;61 8> <837/<9/83 43; 063963<6 ;496; &#(&&(&)/38,#$ &())C4006;?@9.68:198>1/3</C45 /7/5:;A643;*/;4143;9.6B:;A263943;81;61;496; (&(&(& /3 158) &(&) C4006; ?@ 9.6 8:19 8> 1/3</C45/091/<943;600/830:;A6/;41 & 641;9.6564136;<8:3065>819.6C419/60 - 3 - 60C83;639 .616/3 .4; /3/9/496; C18<66;/3A0 4A4/309 9.6 C69/9/8361 ?6>816 9.6 1/45 8:19 /3 8,#$ &()) >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 )$ 8> 9.6 <9 <839639/3A 9.49 C69/9/8361 .4; ?8118=6; 4 .43; 5843 8> 0 54D.0 43; 98=41;0 16C4@2639 8> 9.6 04/; 428:39 .6 .4; /00:6;<.6E:6?641/3A8%%;496;()(%&()$;14=383 81C8149/83 43D /;41 /3 ./0>478:1 .63 9.6 04/; <.6E:6 =40 C1606396; >81 1645/F49/83 9.6 ;14=66 ?43D .4; 169:136; 9.6 04/; <.6E:6 =/9. 63;81062639 G4<<8:39 >166F6;+ .6164>961 4 56A45 389/<6 =40 A89 /00:6; 83 ?6.45> 8> 9.6 160C83;639989.6C69/9/8361=./<.=4006176;83))&&(($ 69/9/8361.4;A89/00:6;416C5@;496;(()&((%16>:0/3A98 C4@ 9.6 428:39 <87616; :3;61 9.6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 .616>816160C83;639.4;4CC184<.6;9.6B:1/0;/<9/8345 8:19 43;.4;>/56;4C1/7496<82C54/394A4/3099.6C69/9/8361>819.6 8>>63<6C:3/0.4?56:3;616<9/83)$8>9.6<9/3<69.6 C69/9/8361 .4; C564;6; 389 A:/59@ /3 9.6 04/; C18<66;/3A0 98 0:?09439/496 ./0 <406 160C83;639 .4; 6H42/36; ./2065> 40 )43;A89241D6;)(;8<:2639040H)98)( 3?6.45> 8> 9.6 ;6>63<6 C69/9/8361 A89 6H42/36; ./2065> 40 ) 43; 836 2816 =/93600 40 & 43; A89 241D6; 836 ;8<:2639 40 - 4 - H) .6 1/45 8:19 4>961 .641/3A 41A:26390 4;;16006; 83 ?89.0/;60<837/<96;9.6C69/9/8361>819.68>>63<6C:3/0.4?56 :3;616<9/83)$8>9.6<97/;69.6/2C:A36;B:;A2639 43;81;618><837/<9/8343;063963<6;496;&#(&&(&)C4006; /3 8,#$ &()) 43; 063963<6; ./2 98 C4@ >/36 8> 0#&((( 43;/3;6>4:5998:3;61A80/2C56/2C1/0832639 >814C61/8;8>9.1662839.0.604/;B:;A263943;81;618> <837/<9/83 43; 063963<6 C4006; ?@ 9.6 1/45 8:19 =40 :30:<<600>:55@<.45563A6;?@9.6C69/9/8361/3158) &(&) ?6>816 9.6 1/3</C45 /091/<9 43; 600/830 :;A6 /;41 43; 9.616>816.6/0?6>8169./08:19 # 64136;<8:3065>819.6C69/9/83610:?2/909.499.616=40 38 914304<9/83 ?69=663 C69/9/8361 43; 9.6 160C83;639 .6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 =40 /00:6; 40 4 06<:1/9@ 83 ?6.45> 8> 836 1/ 4A4;/0. =.8 .4; >/56; 8$) &(( 43; /3 9.6 04/; 0:/9 160C83;639 43; ./0 289.61 =616 ;6>63;4390 .6 C18C806; 0699562639 /3 8$) &(( .4; >4/56; 43; 9.6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 =./<. =40 /00:6; ;:1/3A 9.6 <8:106 8> 36A89/49/83 >81 0699562639 .40 ?663 2/0:06; ?@ 9.6 160C83;639.61/458:1943;9.6CC6554968:19.476>4/56; 98 4CC16</496 9.6 ;6>63<6 C:9 >81=41; 83 ?6.45> 8> 9.6 - 5 - C69/9/8361 .476 6116; /3 <837/<9/3A ./2 <<81;/3A5@ .6 C14@0 984558=9.6C69/9/83 61 <83914 564136; <8:3065 >81 9.6 160C83;639 .40 41A:6; /3 0:CC819 8> 9.6 /2C:A36; B:;A2639 43; 81;61 8> <837/<9/83 43; 063963<6 43; 0:?2/90 9.49 9=8 8:190 .476 <83<:116395@ .65; 4A4/309 9.6 C69/9/8361 69/9/8361 .40 389 C18?4?45/06;./0;6>63<643;9.616>8169.61/458:1943;9.6 CC6554968:19=616B:09/>/6;/3<837/<9/3A./2<<81;/3A5@.6 C14@098;/02/009.6C69/9/83 , 9/09.60C6</>/<<4068>9.6160C83;639 <82C54/34399.49 C69/9/8361 .4; ?8118=6; 4 0:2 8> 0 54D.0 >182 ./2 43; 98=41;0 16C4@2639 8> 9.6 04/; 428:39 C69/9/8361 .4; /00:6; 9.6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 /3 ./0 >478:1 43; 83 C16063949/83 >81 1645/F49/83 9.6 04/; <.6E:6 =40 ;/0.838:16; .6 <8396390 8> 9.6 <.6E:6 43; 9.6 0/A349:16 >8:3; 83 9.6 <.6E:6 /0 389 /3 ;/0C:969/04508389/3;/0C:969.499.6<.6E:6/3E:609/83/0 ;14=3 83 9.6 4<<8:39 8> 9.6 C69/9/8361 24/394/36; ?@ ./2 /3 81C8149/83 43D /;41 143<. .616>816 4 C160:2C9/83 41/060404A4/309C69/9/8361:3;616<9/83)%8><943; :356009.60426/016?:996;?@C:99/3A:C4C18?4?56;6>63<6 - 6 - C69/9/8361 /0 5/4?56 98 ?6 <837/<96; >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 )$ 8> 9.6 <9 3 9.6 C160639 <406 160C83;639.406H42/36;./2065>40)43;A89241D6;)( ;8<:2639040H)98)(/30:CC8198>./0<406H)/09.6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 43; H) 4! /0 9.6 0/A349:16 8> 9.6 C69/9/8361839.604/;<.6E:6H/09.6<.6E:6169:132628 43;H'/09.6;6243;389/<6H)(/09.616C5@389/<6A89 /00:6;83?6.45>8>9.6C69/9/83611/7496<82C54/39.40 ?663 >/56; /3 9.6 C160639 <406 4>961 <82C5@/3A 9.6 0949:981@ 16E:/1626390 43; 40 09496; 6415/61 4 C160:2C9/83 :3;61 6<9/83)%8>9.6<9;86041/064A4/3099.6C69/9/8361/3 9.6 C160639 <406 35600 .6 C:90 :C 4 C18?4?56 ;6>63<6 16?:99/3A9.6C160:2C9/83474/54?564A4/309./2.6/05/4?5698 ?6.65;A:/59@>819.64556A6;8>>63<6 ' .8:A.9.6C69/9/8361.40C:9>81=41;4;6>63<69.499.6 <.6E:6/3E:609/83=40/00:6;40406<:1/9@;:1/3A9.6<8:106 8>36A89/49/83>81<82C182/06/3 8$) &(&83?6.45>8> 4A4;/0. =.8 =40 C54/39/>> /3 8$) &(& 98 9.6 160C83;639.616/3=.8/0;6>63;4398&/3 8$) &(& .6.40>4/56;98C18?4?45/069.604/;;6>63<6?@6H42/3/3A9.6 24961/45=/936006043;4508C18;:</3A36<60041@;8<:26390/3 - 7 - 0:CC8198>./0;6>63<6<<81;/3A989.6C69/9/83619.6<.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 =40 .43;6; 8761 ?@ ./2 98 & =.8 /0 43 4;78<496 =.8 .4; 36A89/496; 83 ?6.45> 8> 9.6 160C83;639 >81 0699562639 /3 8$) &(& .6 04/; <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 4556A6;5@ =40 /00:6; 40 4 06<:1/9@ 83 ?6.45> 8> 9.6 4A4;/0. =.8/09.6C54/39/>>/3 8$) &(&.8:A.9.61/458:19 .40 A/763 2:59/C56 8CC819:3/9/60 98 9.6 C69/9/8361 98 6H42/36 9.6 4>81604/; 4A4;/0. 40 4 =/93600 /3 9.6 C160639 <406 9.6 C69/9/8361 .40 >4/56; 98 6H42/36 4A4;/0. 40 4 =/93600 /3 9.6 C160639<406=.8=8:5;.476?6639.6?609=/93600980C64D 4?8:99.6;6>63<6C:9>81=41;?@9.6C69/9/8361 $ <<81;/3A 98 9.6 C69/9/8361 .6 .4; 639616; /398 43 A1662639>81456=/9.9.64>81604/;4A4;/0.43;9.616>816 .6.4;0988;404A:414396683?6.45>8>4A4;/0.43;/00:6; 9.6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 ;:1/3A 9.6 <8:106 8> 36A89/49/83 /3 8$) &((<8C@8>9.64556A6;4A166263904/;98.476 ?663 6H6<:96; ?69=663 4A4;/0. 43; 9.6 C69/9/8361 .616/3 ;496;&(#&((=40C18;:<6;?6>8169.61/458:19?@9.6 C69/9/8361 3 9.6 04/; 4A1662639 /9 /0 2639/836; 9.49 C800600/83 8> 9.6 C18C619@ =./<. /0 9.6 0:?B6<9 249961 8> 8$) &((=40.43;6;8761989.6C69/9/8361?@4A4;/0. - 8 - /3<6 9.6 04/; 4A1662639 =40 389 C18C615@ 0942C6; 9.6 1/45 8:19 4CC6410 98 .476 C4006; 43 81;61 /2C8:3;/3A 9.6 04/; 4A1662639C61:0458>9.604/;4A1662639=./<./0474/54?56 8316<81;=8:5;A8980.8=9.4904/;4A1662639/09@C6;/34 C54/3 C4C61 43; 9.616 /0 38 2639/83 4?8:9 9.6 6H6<:9/83 8> 0:<.4A1662639?69=6634A4;/0.43;9.6C69/9/8361.616/3/3 9.616C5@389/<6H)(&:160..43;14/09.64;78<496 98=.829.6<.6E:6/3E:609/83=404556A6;5@.43;6;876183 ?6.45>8>9.6C69/9/83614006<:1/9@989.6C18C806;<82C182/06 /3 8$) &((./0=/93600.404;2/996;9.49.6=40389 4CC641/3A>8143@8>9.6C419/60/3 8$) &(( 64508.40 09496; 9.49 4>961 9.6 ;6<166 =40 C4006; /3 8$) &(( <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 =./<. =40 /3 ./0 C800600/83 =40 .43;6; 8761 ?@ ./2 98 160C83;639 4>961 .6 A89 16A/09616; 4 <1/2/345 <4064A4/309./2?:93824961/45/0C18;:<6;980.8=9.4943@ 0:<. <1/2/345 <406 =40 16A/09616; 83 9.6 <82C54/39 8> 160C83;6394A4/309& % 69/9/8361 ;:1/3A 9.6 <8:106 8> ./0 67/;63<6 .40 09496; 9.49 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 =40 .43;6; 8761 ?@ ./2 98 836 4;78<496 D38=3 40 :160. /3;6 ?:9 9.6 C61083 =.8 =40 6H42/36; 40 & /0 836 :160. .43;14 8 .43D41148 - 9 - <<81;/3A989.6C69/9/8361.6.4;639616;/39843A1662639 >81456=/9.4A4;/0.=.8=40C54/39/>>/3 8$) &((?:9 9.6<8C@8>9.64A1662639>810456;496;&(#&((=./<./0 474/54?56 83 16<81; =8:5; A8 98 0.8= 9.49 04/; 4A1662639 /0 ?69=663 836 4A43349. 43; 9.6 C69/9/8361 43; 9.6 3426 8> 4A4;/0. /0 389 >8:3; /3 9.6 04/; 4A1662639 .6 0:/9 =40 ;6<166; 2:<. C1/81 98 & .43;/3A 8761 9.6 <.6E:6 /3 E:609/83 98 160C83;639 <<81;/3A 98 9.6 C69/9/8361 <.6E:6 =40 /00:6; 40 06<:1/9@ ;:1/3A 9.6 <8:106 8> 36A89/49/83 >81 0699562639 /3 8$) &(( 3;/0C:96;5@ 9.6 04/; 0699562639.4;>4/56;43;9.6164>9610:/9=40;6<166;.6E:6 .4; 1624/36; /3 <:098;@ 8> & 43; 38 6HC54349/83 =.49086761 /0 8>>616; 40 98 =.@ 38 096C0 =616 94D63 98 94D6 ?4<D9.6<.6E:6>182&67634>9619.6;6<166=40C4006;/3 8$) &((.616>816/9/04CC416399.499.6;6>63<6C:9 >81=41; 83 ?6.45> 8> 9.6 C69/9/8361 /0 389 C18?4?45/06; ?@ C54</3A 36<60041@ 24961/45 ?6>816 9.6 1/45 8:19 43; 160:594395@C160:2C9/839.49418064A4/3099.6C69/9/83610988; :316?:996; 3;61 9.6 </1<:20943<60 9.6 1/45 8:19 43; 9.6 CC6554968:19=616>:55@B:09/>/6;/3<837/<9/3A9.6C69/9/8361 >819.64556A6;8>>63<67639.6063963<6/2C806;?@9.61/45 - 10 - 8:194A4/3099.6C69/9/8361/0B:0943;1640834?56.616>816 42 8> 9.6 8C/3/83 9.49 9.6 167/0/83 C69/9/83 54<D0 261/9 <<81;/3A5@C69/9/83/0;/02/006; ,* &$ %# ) # /098)58%