- 1 - ! "## $ ! ! " # $ #% ! & ' " "# " # " '' " " ' # ! !" " ( "#! # $)! '! *+ ' ! !" " "#! # $)! '! *+ "! !" " Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "#! # $)! '! *+ ( # ! !" " "#! # $)! '! *+ "# ! !" " , "#! # $)! '! *+ #" !'! ' '" " " *( , " ' " ! ! #% ! *+ & ' # # ,- * # '! ! - *# ,, " " ! ! ( ! . " %! #% ! + ( $! " " ! " " " %! # " ! "/' %! %" - 3 - # "/' %! %" "012. 301240. 5674803 199012:4; <62 =>0 19903314=*90=:=:6402 14. 301240. 5674803 199012:4; <62 208964.04=6,*487214506?914@ 089:=0 802A:50 6< 46=:50 =6 208964.04= 68 =6 =>0@ >1A0 46= 1990120. 14. 46=:50 =6 208964.04= 6 >18B004.:890480.C:=> >0 19903314= >020:4 C18 =>0 90=:=:6402 :4 :A:3 :85033140678 6( C>:5> 51?0 =6 B0 .:8?:880. B@ =>0 ..:=:6413 :8=2:5= %7.;0 #:D1@19721 B@ 62.02 .1=0. + ( >:8199013>1815>0E7020.>:8=62@ 08964.04= 68=6>020:4C020=>090=:=:64028:4#6 >0@ 1992615>0. =>0 2:B7413 800F:4; 56?90481=:64 64 155674= 6< .01=> 6< 640 7273:4;1991 ":20?1=> >0 81:. 7273:4;1991C1814:4?1=06<1D009B012:4;6"** 14. := 5633:.0. C:=> 146=>02 D009 B012:4; 6"** - 4 - 64 4 =>0 81:. 155:.04= 7273:4;1991 .:0.14.15180C1820;:8=020.1;1:48==>0.2:A026<=>0D009 B012:4; "** B7= 73=:?1=03@ =>0 5>12;0*8>00= C18 <:30. 1;1:48= =>0 .2:A02 6< =>0 D009 B012:4; 6"** C>:5>20873=0.:4=>0564A:5=:646<=>081:..2:A02 >0 90=:=:64028C>6<:30.1531:?90=:=:6474.0205=:646< =>0 6=62 #0>:530 5= <62 8>62= G# 5=H >1. :4:=:133@ 1221@0.=>06C4026<=>0D009B012:4;6"**18 208964.04=614.=>0!4:=0.4.:1487214506?914@18 208964.04= 6 = 1990128 =>1= =>0@ 2013:I0. =>1= =>0 208964.04=6J487214506?914@C18:4<15==>0:487202 6< =>0 A0>:530 B012:4; 6"** 14. =>020<620 =>0@ ;6= :?9301.0. =>0 6C402 6< 81:. A0>:530 640 21991 6 :..199113:F1218208964.04=6 >046=:50:8870.=6 208964.04= 6 5673. 46= B0 802A0. 64 >:8 1..2088 18 8>6C4:4=>0 '66F6<=>0A0>:530 >020<620=>0@=66F 91902*97B3:51=:64B@ C1@ 6< 87B8=:=7=0. 802A:50B@:4A6F:4; =>0 926A:8:648 6< 2.02*# 730* 6< 14. .089:=0 =>0 97B3:51=:64 6< 46=:50 =>0 81:. 21991 .:. 46= 199012 14. =>020<620 93150. >:? 0K*912=0 14. 926500.0. =6 5648:.02 - 5 - =>0 ?02:=8 6< =>0 5180 14. .:89680. 6< =>0 81?0 B@ 62.02 .1=0. >04 =>0 0K057=:64 90=:=:64 6< =>0 81:. 1C12. C18 :48=:=7=0. 14. 56025:A0 8=098 C020 :4:=:1=0. =>0 81:. 21991 51?0 =6 F46C 1B67= := 14. >0 <:30. 1 :A:3 :85 6( 74.02 2.02JL 730* 6< B0<620 =>0 2:B7413 564=04.:4; =>1= >0 >1. 46= B004 802A0. C:=> =>0 46=:5014.18875>=>00K*912=0D7.;?04=14.1C12.B080= 18:.014.>0?1@B0902?:==0.=697=<62=>>:8.0<0450 >0 2:B7413 1<=02 04E7:2@ :4 :A:3 :85 6( 51?0 =6 =>0 5645378:64 =>1= =>0 90=:=:6402 =>020:4 =>0 19903314= >020:4 >1. 46= ;6= >:8 1..2088 5>14;0. :4 =>0 '66F C>04 >0 8=12=0. =6 208:.0 1= >0.1;: #:331;0 6< 4.: 137F1 :8=2:5= #:D1@19721 >020<620 := >03. =>1= =>0 87B8=:=7=0. 802A:50 6< 46=:50 64 =>0 81:. 21991 C18 926902 14. =>020 :8 46 201864 =6 :4=02<020:41C12.91880.B@:=:4#6 - 6 - , '0:4; 1;;2:0A0. B@ =>0 81:. 62.02 :4 :A:3 :85 6( =>0 90=:=:6402 =>020:4 :8 B0<620 =>:8 672= :4 199013 + >0 301240. 5674803 199012:4; <62 =>0 90=:=:6402 C673. 87B?:= =>1= =>0 ?6.0 6< 802A:50 6< 46=:50 B@ C1@ 6< 87B8=:=7=0.802A:50:81C01F<62?6<802A:4;=>046=:504 <15=>0C18208:.:4;:4>0.1;:#:331;06<4.: 137F114.>0 C1846=:46319726<1>1218>=21=>020<620:=:8564=04.0. =>1==>046=:5097B3:8>0.:8:487<<:5:04=802A:5014.18875> =>0:?97;40.D7.;?04=:4#6B0:4;140K* 912=0 D7.;?04= B0 80= 18:.0 14. >0 ?1@ B0 >012. B0<620 9188:4; 14@ 875> 1C12. = :8 <72=>02 564=04.0. =>1= =>0 19903314= >020:4>181 5180 C>:5>400.8=6 B0 5648:.020. = :8 87B?:==0. =>1= =>0 2:B7413 :4 # 6 >18 >03. =>1= =>0 :48721450 963:5@ C>:5> C18 926.750. B@ =>0 90=:=:64028*531:?14=8 C18 1 <1F0 640 14. =>020<620 := <18=040. =>0 3:1B:3:=@ 7964 =>0 19903314= >020:4 = :8 87B?:==0. =>1= C>04 =>0 3:1B:3:=@ :8 <18=040. 7964 =>0 19903314=>020:4:=C1840508812@=>1=>08>673.>1A0B004 >012.14.>0>181 5180:4>:8<1A672=:81386 - 7 - 87B?:==0. =>1= =>0 62.02*8>00= 6< =>0 2:B7413 .608 46= ?04=:64 20;12.:4; =>0 562205= 8=1=78 6< 802A:50 6<46=:50=6 =>019903314=>020:414.875>B0:4;=>05180=>015509=1450 6<=>091902*97B3:51=:6414.9315:4;=>0208964.04=6:4 =>0531:?90=:=:64180K*912=0:8:330;13 301240. 5674803 199012:4; <62 208964.04= 6, J 48721450 6?914@ 87B?:=8 =>1= =>0 963:5@C1846=926.750.:4=>0#926500.:4;814.643@1 56A02*46=0 C18 :8870. 14. .0<0450 >18 B004 =1F04 B@ =>0 487214506?914@=>1==>081:.56A02*46=0.60846=B0364; =6=>0A0>:5306<=>019903314=>020:414.18875>=>020:846 201864=680=18:.0=>0:?97;40.1C12. =?78=B06B802A0.B@=>:8672==>1==>67;>=>0 155:.04=6557220.:4=>0@012=>0531:?14=812030<==6 87<<02 .089:=0 =>020 B0:4; =C6 A0>:5308 :4A63A0. :4 =>0 155:.04= C>:5> 6BA:6783@ >1A0 A:631=0. =>0 <74.1?04=13 92:45:93086<=>0#5==>1==>0@8>673.B056A020.B@14 :48721450 :=>02 =>0 6C402 62 =>0 :487202 6< =>0 D009 B012:4;68"*14.=>0D009B012:4;6"** - 8 - >1A0 46= B6=>020. =6 ;:A0 14@ 863150 =6 =>0 B0201A0. <1?:3@ = :8 74<62=741=0 =>1= 0A04 1<=02 @0128 .089:=0 =>020 B0:4; 1 .:205=:64 =6 =>0 19903314= >020:4 =6 .0968:= M6<=>056?90481=:641?674=>0>1846=56?93:0.C:=> =>081?014.18875>=>0564.75=6<=>019903314=:81386 46==>1=6<1927.04=902864C>6:81B:.:4;=>031C "1A:4; 81:. 86 := ?78= B0 6B802A0. =>1= =>0 90=:=:64C18<:30.74.0205=:646<=>0#5= >0 963:50 <:30. 5>12;0*8>00= 1;1:48= =>0 .2:A02 6< =>0 A0>:530 B012:4; 6"** BA:6783@ =>0 .050180. C18 =21A03:4;:4=>0D009B012:4;6"**=>020C1846 400.<62=>0531:?14=8=6<:30190=:=:6474.0205=:64 6< =>0 # 5= 0564.3@ := ?78= B0 6B802A0. =>1= =>0 90=:=:64028C0201386:33*1.A:80.:41221@:4;208964.04=6 208964.04=6>020:4C>6:86C4026<=>0A0>:530B012:4; 6"**C:=>67==>020B0:4;14:487202 = 1990128 =>1= =>0@ C020 ?:830. =6 B03:0A0 =>1= =>0 208964.04= 6, >020:4 * 48721450 6?914@ C18 =>0 :487202 6< "** 1=02 =>0@ 2013:I0. =>1= >0 :8 - 9 - :487202 6< =>0 A0>:530 B012:4; "** >0 90=:=:64 1386:846=5301264=>:818905= 6?:4;=6=>0?02:=86<=>0920804=199013:=:8 80==30.92:45:9306<31C=>1==>0802A:506<46=:50B@C1@6< 87B8=:=7=0.802A:50:81C01F<62?6<9266<6<802A:50 C6 =>:4;8 ?78= B0 81=:8<:0. =6 8>6C =>1= =>0 802A:50 B@ 87B8=:=7=0.:8926902 >0<:28=B0:4;=>1==>0912=@=6C>6? =>0802A:50:8=6B0?1.0:8208:.:4;:4=>01201C>020=>0 97B3:51=:64 :8 ?1.0 0564.3@ =>0 912=@ 64 C>6? =>0 87B8=:=7=0. 802A:50 C18 867;>= :8 9729680<733@ 0A1.:4; =>0 802A:506<=>046=:50<C0902780=>0?1=02:131A1:31B3064 20562. := :8 0A:.04= =>1= := :8 =>0 5648:8=04= 8=14. 6< =>0 19903314= >020:4 =>1= >0 C18 208:.:4; 1= >0.1;: #:331;0 6< 4.: 137F1B7=46= :4 631972 6< 1>1218>=21 < 567280 631972 :8=2:5= :4 1>1218>=21 14. #:D1@19721 :8=2:5= :4 1241=1F1 120 1.D6:4:4; =6 015> 6=>02 "6C0A02 =>0 97B3:51=:64 C18 ?1.0 :4 121=>: 0C891902 G)74D12 0=1H 97B3:8>0.<26?631972=1990128=>1==>081:.40C891902 :8 464*0K:8=04= 14. 803.6? 201. 40C891902 :4 =>1= 1201 >020<620=>020B0:4;46?1=02:13=68>6C=>1=:=>1.1C:.0 - 10 - 97B3:51=:64 :4 =>1= 1201 18 C033 18 :4 =>0 1201 C>020 =>0 19903314=>020:4531:?8=6B0208:.:4;1==>02030A14=96:4=6< =:?014.C>04=>019903314=>188>6C4=>1=>0C18208:.:4; 1= >0.1;: #:331;0 =>0 802A:50 51446= B0 >03. =6 B0 87<<:5:04=6206A02=>020:846=>:4;6420562.=68>6C=>1= =>019903314=>020:4C189729680<733@0A1.:4;=>0802A:506< 46=:50 !4.02 =>080 5:257?8=14508 =>0 <15= =>1= =>0 19903314=8>673.>1A05>14;0.>:81..2088:4=>0 '66F =6=>093150C>020>015=7133@208:.:4;14.=>020<620>0:8 46= 04=:=30. =6 800F 80==:4; 18:.0 =>0 :?97;40. 1C12. 91880.:4#61990128=6B0:4562205= >0 92:?12@ B72.04 6< 8>6C:4; =>1= =>0 19903314= >020:4 C18 208:.:4;:46319721>1218>=21=1=01==>02030A14=96:4= 6<=:?014.=>1=>0>1.0A1.0.=>0802A:506<46=:50C1864 =>090=:=:64028C>04=>0@<:30.141993:51=:6474.022.02*# 730* 6< B0<620 =>0 2:B7413 >:8 18905= 51446= B0 368=8:;>=6<C>04=>019903314=>020:41990120.B0<620=>0 2:B7413:4:A:3:856(14.93150.>:8;2:0A1450 !4.02=>0805:257?8=14508=>0:?97;40.62.02:4:A:3:85 6(.0802A08=6B080=18:.0 - 11 - ( 8 46=0. =>0 564.75= 6< =>0 19903314= >020:4 :4 46= .0968:=:4; M 6< =>0 56?90481=:64 1?674= B0<620=>:8672=8>6C8=>1=>0C1846=F004:49268057=:4; >:8 5180 !4.02 =>080 5:257?8=14508 568=8 >1A0 =6 B0 :?9680. 7964 =>0 19903314= C>:30 1336C:4; =>0 920804= 199013 4 =>1= A:0C =>0 :?97;40. 62.02 :4 :A:3 :85 6( 91880. B@ =>0 ..:=:6413 :8=2:5= %7.;0 #:D1@19721 .0802A08 =6 B0 80= 18:.0 =>020B@ 1336C:4; =>0 81:. 90=:=:64 14. 80==:4; 18:.0 =>0 D7.;?04= 14. 1C12. 91880. :4 # 6 14. 20?14.:4; =>0 ?1==02 B15F =6 =>0 2:B7413 <62 <208> 1.D7.:51=:64 1<=02 ;:A:4; 14 69962=74:=@=6=>019903314=>020:4"0450=>0<6336C:4; : >0199013:81336C0. :: >0 :?97;40. 62.02 .1=0. + .:8?:88:4;:A:3:856(:8>020B@ - 12 - 80= 18:.0 :A:3 :85 ( :8 1336C0. ::: 8156480E70450=>0D7.;?04=14.1C12. :4 # 6 :8 80= 18:.0 14. =>0 ?1==02:820?:==0.B15F=6=>0 2:B7413C:=> 1 .:205=:64 =6 =>0 2:B7413 =6 ;:A0 14 69962=74:=@ =6 =>0 19903314= >020:4 14. .:89680 6< =>0 ?1==02 C:=>:4 14 67=02 3:?:= 6<0:;>=?64=>8<26?=>0.1=06<2050:9=6< =>0 :A >0 19903314= 14. =>0 208964.04=8 120 .:205=0. =6 199012 B0<620 =>0 2:B7413 64 14.=>019903314=>020:4:846= 04=:=30. =6 B0 :8870. C:=> 46=:50 B@ =>0 2:B7413<6214@201864 A >0 19903314= =6 .0968:= 1 87? 6< 8* B0<620 =>0 2:B7413 B0<620 97==:4;<62=>>:8.0<045018568=8:?9680. :4=>:8199013 - 13 - A: = :8 0K905=0. <26? =>0 2:B7413 =>1= 14@ 926508808 =>1= 400. =6 B0 :8870. 0:=>02 =6 =>0531:?14=86214@6=>02208964.04=8120 =6 B0 1= =>0 568= 6< =>0 19903314= >020:4 643@ .* %# & # ' :8=636(