Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10233 (KAR)

SHRI BASALINGAPPA v. SRI GOVINDRAJ AND ANR

MFA/201650/2019 · 2025-01-17

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #!! $ % !" ! # $# % & &"# ' ( %" #% & "# !& !%# $ # " ' # LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.28 18:19:14 - 0800 - 2 - ) # * + &% #%' ( %" # , # # -) " # "% %" # %" " &# -) %" # &# %# &"# ') $ % % !)" ! # $# % & &"# ' ( %" #% & "# !& !%# - 3 - $ # " ' # ) # * + &% #%' ( %" , ' # # -) " # "% %" # %" " &# -) %" # &# %# &"# ' " &# # ! ! .% &# & ! !.% &# & %/012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ ;<==<1 >?62=/19 316 3@346 639/6 -) A3BB/6 01 <' 316 - 4 - ') <1 9:/ C0D/ <C 9:/ <?49 <C 9:/ 66090<13D 0B940;9 &?62/ 316 9:/ /=7/4 <9<4 ;;06/19 D30=B 407?13D 0>383A?43 C<4 B:<49 E 407?13DF 9:/ A/9090<1/4B;D30=319B34/7/C<4/9:0B<?49019:/B/3AA/3DB /346 D/341/6 ;<?1B/D 3AA/34012 C<4 9:/ 3AA/DD319B 316 9:/ D/341/6 ;<?1B/DB 3AA/34012 C<4 4/BA<16/19<G1B?431;/<=A318017<9:9:/3AA/3DB ) :/C3;9?3D=3940H<C9:/;3B/0B3B7/D<@! :/ 3AA/DD319 01 < @:< @3B 9:/ A/9090<1/4 01 <') 316 9:/ 3AA/DD319 01 < @:< @3B 9:/ A/9090<1/4 01 <' 4/BA/;905/D8 7/012 9:/ 406/4 316 A0DD0<1 406/4 <C =<9<4;8;D/ 7/34012 <' - <1 1/34 %3D3231?4<11?4 4<BB 39 )) A= @/4/ :09 78 3 34 @:0;: @3B ?16/4 3 9/=A<4348 4/20B94390<1 316 ?16/4 53D061B?431;/C4<=4/BA<16/19<G1B?431;/<=A318 :/A/9090<1/4B:35012B?CC/4/601>?40/B C0D/6;D30=A/9090<1B 7/C<4/9:/ 407?13D;<19/160129:399:/346405/464<5/9:/ B3=/0143B:3161/2D02/19=311/4316;3?B/69:/3;;06/19 - 5 - 3163BB?;: 9:/<@1/431601B?4/4<C9:/3434/D037D/9< A38;<=A/1B390<19<9:/= I :/A/9090<1B@/4/4/B0B9/6784/BA<16/19<G <@1/4<C9:/343164/BA<16/19<1B?431;/<=A318 ;<19/160129:399:/4/@3B1<1/2D02/1;/<19:/A349<C9:/ 6405/4 <C 9:/ 34 7?9 09 @3B 6?/ 9< 9:/ 1/2D02/1;/ <C 9:/ 406/4 @:<0B9:/A/9090<1/401<') :/83DB< 4/B0B9/69:/A/9090<178;<19/160129:399:/J?319?=<C9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 ;D30=/6 0B :02:D8 /H<4709319 0=3201348 316 ?19/137D/3166/10/63DB<9:/32/ 01;<=/316<;;?A390<1B <C9:/A/9090<1/4B /BA<16/19 < G 1B?431;/ <=A318 3DB< ;<19/16/69:399:/4/0B50<D390<1<C9:/9/4=B316;<16090<1B <C9:/A<D0;8784/BA<16/19<<@1/4<C9:/<CC/1601234 B01;/ 9:/5/:0;D/7/0123;37@3B1<9:35012353D06A/4=09 @:/19:/3;;06/199<<KAD3;/ :/4/7/0126/D3801C0D0129:/ ;<=AD3019 9:/ 3;;06/19 0B C0;9090<?B 316 3B B?;: 9:/ 1B?431;/<=A3187/37B<D5/6C4<=9:/D0370D098 - 6 - :/ 407?13D C43=/6 3AA4<A4039/ 0BB?/B 316 9:/ A/9090<1/4B @/4/ /H3=01/6 3B B 316 /60;3D CC0;/4 @:<3BB/BB/69:/60B370D098 @3B/H3=01/63B) HB 9< ) @/4/ =34K/6 01 /506/1;/ 1 7/:3DC <C 9:/ 4/BA<16/19B C05/ @091/BB/B @/4/ /H3=01/6 3B B 9< 316 HB 9< ' @/4/ =34K/6 C9/4 :/34012 9:/ 342?=/19B 9:/ 407?13D783@/DD4/3B<1/6>?62=/19 :/D6 9:39 9:/ 4/BA<16/19 < G 1B?431;/ <=A318 0B D037D/ 9< A38 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 316 9:/4/ @/4/ 1< 50<D390<1 <C 9:/ 9/4=B 316 ;<16090<1B <C 9:/ A<D0;8 316 3@346/6 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1?16/49:/C<DD<@012:/36B! 1<' 431BA<49390<1 B <<6 399/16319 L 1<?40B:=/19 B ) /60;3D HA/1B/B BI I I <BB<CC?9?4//341012B B 301L?CC/4012 B <BB<C3=/1090/B B <93D B ' -I 1<') 431BA<49390<1 B <<6 399/16319 L 1<?40B:=/19 B'I - 7 - ) /60;3D HA/1B/B BI - --' I <BB6?4012D306?AA/40<6 B) <BB<CC?9?4//341012B B) I 301L?CC/4012 B - <BB<C3=/1090/B B <93D B - '' - %/012 32240/5/6 78 9:/ B306 >?62=/19 9:/ A/9090<1/4B34/7/C<4/9:0B<?493BB30D0129:/J?319?=<C9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 3=<?19 9 0B A/4901/19 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/ J?/B90<1 4/2346012 9:/ D0370D098 <C 4/BA<16/19 < G 1B?431;/ <=A318 9< A38 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 :3B 399301/6 C013D0983169:/4/C<4/ 9:/B3=/0B1<90160BA?9/ ' /341/6 ;<?1B/D 3AA/34012 C<4 9:/ 3AA/DD319B B?7=09B 9:39 9:/ 3BB/BB=/19 <C 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 78 9:/ 407?13D014/BA/;9<C9:/60B370D0980B1<9A4<A/4316;<44/;9 :/9/B90=<18<C9:/)<;9<40B1<9A4<A/4D83AA4/;039/6 78 9:/ 407?13D 01 34405012 39 C?1;90<13D 60B370D098 <C 9:/ A/9090<1/4B / B?7=09B 9:39 9:/ 139?4/ <C 9:/ 01>?40/B B?CC/4/6789:/A/9090<1/4B @09:4/BA/;99<9:/0432/ 01;<=/ 316<;;?A390<1B34/1<9;<1B06/4/6019:/A4<A/4A/4BA/;905/ 9< 34405/ 39 C?1;90<13D 60B370D098 :/4/C<4/ :/ B//KB 4/3BB/BB=/19<C9:/;<=A/1B390<1789:0B<?49 - 8 - 9:/4/BA/;905/;<?1B/DBC<44/BA<16/19 < 01 9:/04 3AA/3DB @<?D6 B?7=09 9:39 9:/ 407?13D :3B B?CC0;0/19D8316/D37<439/D8:3B60B;?BB/637<?99:/01>?40/B B?CC/4/6 78 9:/ A/9090<1/4B 316 09 :3B 402:9D8 316 A4<A/4D8 3BB/BB/6 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1B ?16/4 60CC/4/19 :/36B 316 3B B?;: 9:/ 0=A?21/6 ;<==<1 >?62=/19 6< 1<9 4/J?04/ 318 016?D2/1;/789:0B<?49 9 0B 1/;/BB348 9< 1<9/ 9:39 9:/ 1<90<13D 01;<=/ ;<1B06/4/6 78 9:/ 407?13D 01 7<9: 9:/B/;3B/B 1//6B 34/ D<<K :/ 2?06/D01/B 0BB?/6 78 9:/ 341393K3 939/ /23D /450;/B ?9:<4098 C<4 B/99D/=/19 <C 9:/ 60BA?9/B 7/C<4/ 9:/ <K 63D39 A4/B;407/ 9:/ 1<90<13D 01;<=/ <C B C<4 9:/ 8/34 1 ?=A9//1 1?=7/4 <C 6/;0B0<1B 9:0B <?49 :3B :/D6 9:39 9:/ 2?06/D01/B 0BB?/6 78 34/:/D69<7/3;;/A937D/<19:/24<?169:399:/834/ 01 2/1/43D ;<1C<4=098 @09: 9:/ =010=?= @32/B C0H/6 ?16/4 9:/010=?=32/B;9 :/4/C<4/ 9:/1<90<13D01;<=/<C 9:/A/9090<1/40B3;;/A9/63B B' -A/4=<19: - 9 - 1<<' :/ @:< 0B 9:/ A/9090<1/4 01 9:0B ;3B/ :36 B?B9301/69:/01>?40/B3B7/D<@! %0=3DD/3D<4C43;9?4/<C402:931KD/, <=A4/BB0<1C43;9?4/<CI5/49/743, ) 743B0<1H;=402:9K1//,316 I 743B0<1H;= 402:9C<<9 /@3B01A390/19C<43A/40<6<C638B3B6/A0;9/601 HB' G 0B;:342/ ?==/48 / ;D30=B 9< 7/ 31 240;?D9?40B9 32/6 37<?9 8/34B ;;<46012 9< ) :/ :3BB?B9301/63A/4=31/1960B370D098<CM9<9:/BA01/316 360B370D098<CM9<9:/402:9D<@/4D0=7/6061<9B38 3189:01237<?99:/@:<D/7<6860B370D09890B@<49:9<1<9/ 9:/ 407?13D 3BB/BB/6 9:/ C?1;90<13D 60B370D098 39 M 9 3AA/34B 9:39 9:/ 407?13D C30D/6 9< ;<1B06/4 9:/ /CC/;9B <C ;<=A4/BB0<1C43;9?4/<CI5/49/743 @:0;:@<?D64/B?D9013 B/5/4/60B370D098C<49:/A/9090<1/4 @:<0B32/68/34B316 @<4K012 3B 31 240;?D9?40B9 :/4/C<4/ 01 9:/ ;<1B06/4/6 <A010<1<C9:0B<?49 9:/C?1;90<13D60B370D098@<?D6;<=/9< - 10 - M/5/10C@/:<D69:399:/60B370D0989<9:/D<@/4D0=70B BD02:9D8/H322/439/63BA/4) :/4/C<4/ 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 ?16/4 9:/ :/36 <C D<BB<CC?9?4//3410120B;3D;?D39/63B B' -HH)H M N B) ) 3B 32301B9 B 3@346/6 78 9:/ 407?13D <1B/J?/19D8 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 ?16/4 9:/ :/36<CD<BB<C/3410126?4012D306?AA/40<60B;3D;?D39/6C<4 9:4//=<19:B3=<?190129< B ) :/ 407?13D :3B 3@346/6 3 ;<=A/1B390<1 <C B 9<@346B A301 316 B?CC/4012 @:0;: 1//6B 9< 7/ /1:31;/69< B- 0=0D34D8 9:/;<=A/1B390<1?16/4 9:/ :/36B <C C<<6 316 399/16319FB ;:342/B 3@346/6 39 B 1//6B 9< 7/ 01;4/3B/6 9< B B 9:/ A/9090<1/4@3B01A390/19C<43A/40<6<C638B@09:5/49/743D 01>?48 9:/;<=A/1B390<1?16/49:/:/369431BA<49390<1316 01;06/193D/HA/1B/B0B/1:31;/69< B I B9:/A/9090<1/4@3B32/68/34B31609@<?D6 7/ 60CC0;?D9 C<4 :0= @09: BA013D 01>?48 9< ;3448 <1 :0B 638 - 11 - 9<638 @<4K 9:/4/C<4/ 3 B?= <C BI 0B 3@346/6 9< :0=?16/49:/:/36D<BB<C3=/1090/B3B32301B9 B :/ ;<=A/1B390<1 3@346/6 ?16/4 <9:/4 :/36B 6</B 1<9 4/J?04/ 318 019/4C/4/1;/ :?B 9:/ A/9090<1/4 0B /1909D/6C<4;<=A/1B390<13B7/D<@! D < /36 @346789:/ 407?13D @346789:0B <?49 301316B?CC/4012 B B- <<6316399/16319FB ;:342/B B B ) /60;3D HA/1B/B BI I BI I I <BB<CC?9?4//341012 B B) ) 431BA<49390<1316 01;06/193D;:342/B B B <BB<C3=/1090/B B BI - <BB<C01;<=/6?4012 D306?AA/40<6 B <93D B ' -I B ' I /BB!@346789:/ 407?13D B ' -I 1:31;/=/19 B) 1<<') :/ @:< 0B 9:/ A/9090<1/4 01 9:0B ;3B/ :36 B?B9301/69:/01>?40/B3B7/D<@! <@/4HI;=316)H;=<5/4D/C9D/2, 743B0<1)H;=<5/4C<4/:/36, - 12 - ) <=A<?16 ;<==?109/6 C43;9?4/ <C 7<9: 7<1/B D/C9D/2, I 43;9?4/<CD<@/4/16<C4360?B402:9B06/, 43;9?4/<C;D350;D/D/C9B06/, 43;9?4/<C<;;0A093D7<1/<1402:9B06/, - ?D90AD/ /=<44:32/ ;<19?B0<1B 01 7<9: C4<193DD<7/B,316 ' ?76?43D :/=<44:32/ 3B A/4 H <?16 /490C0;39/ - / @3B 01A390/19 C<4 3 A/40<6 <C ' 638B 3B A/4 9:/ 0B;:342/ ?==340/B 39 HB) 9< - / @3B 31 240;?D9?43D <<D0/ 32/6 37<?9 8/34B B A/4 9:/ 9/B90=<18 <C )<;9<4 9:/ 60B370D098 9< 9:/ D/C9 D/2 0B )M D/C9 B:<?D6/4 0B M 316 402:9 @40B9 0B -M 9 0B A/4901/199<1<9/9:39)0B9:/<;9<4@:<:3694/39/69:/ A/9090<1/4/1;/ 9:/4/0B1<4/3B<19<4/6?;/9:/60B370D098 B939/6 78 ) 316 :3B 9< 7/ 3;;/A9/6 3B 0B 6<1/ 78 9:/ 407?13D < C34 3B 9:/ 1<90<13D 01;<=/ 0B ;<1;/41/6 3B 60B;?BB/6 37<5/ 9:/ B3=/ :3B 9< 7/ ;<1B06/4/6 39 B' -/1;/ 9:/D<BB<CC?9?4//3410120B;3D;?D39/63B B' -HH'HIMN BI ) <1B/J?/19D8 - 13 - 9:/ D<BB <C 01;<=/ 6?4012 9:/ D306 ?A A/40<6 1//6B 9< 7/ ;<1B06/4/6 C<4 B0H =<19:B 9:39 0B B' - H N B ' :/ 407?13D :3B 3@346/6 3B ;<=A/1B390<1 <C B ?16/4 9:/ :/36 <C D<BB <C 3=/1090/B 01 D0C/ <1B06/4012 9:/ 139?4/ <C 9:/ 01>?40/B B?CC/4/6 78 9:/ A/9090<1/4399:/32/<C8/34B9<:0BD<@/4D0=7316402:9 @40B9@0DD3CC/;9:0=019:/C?9?4/<CD0C/ :/4/C<4/ 9:/B3=/ :3B 9< 7/ /1:31;/6 9< B <1B06/4012 9:/ A4<D<12/6 94/39=/19 3B 6/A0;9/6 C4<= 9:/ 0B;:342/ ?==340/B4/C/44/6B?A43 9:/;<=A/1B390<1?16/49:/:/36 9431BA<49390<131601;06/193D/HA/1B/B34/9<7//1:31;/69< B C4<= B :/)01:0B9/B90=<18:3BB939/69:399:/4/0B 31?1:/3D/601>?48316A390/19:36;<=AD301/6<C60B;:342/ C4<=9:/@<?16/3DB<B939/69:399:/4/0BB:<49/1012<C 9:/ D/2 78 I ;= :/4/C<4/ 9:/ A/9090<1/4 1//6B C?49:/4 94/39=/193163BB?;: 3B?=<C B) 0B3@346/69< :0= @:0;:@<?D61<9;3448318019/4/B9 - 14 - :/ ;<=A/1B390<1 ?16/4 9:/ =/60;3D :/36 6</B 1<94/J?04/318/1:31;/=/19316094/=301B?13D9/4/6 :/;<=A/1B390<13@346/6789:/ 407?13D?16/4 9:/ :/36 A301 316 B?CC/4012 1//6B 9< 7/ /1:31;/6 9< B C4<= B , 316 ?16/4 9:/ :/36 C<<6 1<?40B:=/19316399/16319;:342/B1//6B9<7//1:31;/69< B C4<= B'I 1 50/@ <C 9:/ 37<5/ 60B;?BB0<1 9:/ A/9090<1/4B 0B /1909D/6 C<4 ;<=A/1B390<1 3B 7/D<@! D < /36 @346789:/ 407?13D @346789:0B <?49 431BA<49390<1 B B <<6 399/16319 L 1<?40B:=/19 B'I B ) /60;3D HA/1B/B BI - --' BI - --' I <BB 6?4012 D306 ?A A/40<6 B) B <BB <C C?9?4/ /341012B B) I BI ) 301L?CC/4012 B B - <BB<C3=/1090/B B B ' ?9?4/ =/60;3D /HA/1B/B B) <93D B - '' B I '-' /BB!@346789:/ 407?13D B - '' 1:31;/=/19 B - - 15 - 150/@<C9:/37<5/ 9:/C<DD<@012! 0 %<9:9:/3AA/3DB34/3DD<@/601A349 00 :/ ;<==<1 0=A?21/6 >?62=/19 316 3@346 A3BB/6 78 9:/ 407?13D 0B :/4/78 =<60C0/6 000 :/ 3AA/DD319 01 < 9:/ A/9090<1/4 <' 0B /1909D/6 9< B) 316 9:/ 3AA/DD319 01<9:/A/9090<1/401 <) 0B /1909D/6 9< B - 01 366090<1 9< @:39 :3B 7//1 3@346/6 78 9:/ 407?13D @09: 019/4/B9 39 M A/4 311?= C4<= 9:/ 639/ <C A/9090<1 90DD 09B 6/A<B09 7/C<4/ 9:/ 407?13D - 16 - 05 :/ 4/B9 <C 9:/ 9/4=B 316 ;<16090<1B 4/23460126/A<B09316/9; <46/4/6789:/ 407?13D4/=301?13D9/4/6 5 /BA<16/19<G1B?431;/<=A3180B 604/;9/6 9< 6/A<B09 9:/ ;<=A/1B390<1 3=<?19 @09:01 C<?4 @//KB C4<= 9:/ 639/ <C 9:/ 4/;/0A9 <C 9:/ ;<A8 <C 9:0B >?62=/19 6 &! ' ! % 0B9<!D<!) !