Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10230 (KAR)
THE PROPRIETOR v. SRI. MASHAKSAB AND ORS
MFA/201863/2019 · 2025-02-13
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10230 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10230 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#
$
$
%%&'(
)
! "
! #
! $% $ #
&
% !#! ! $% $ #
&
' ! ! #
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$! $
#
&
"
! (( '" ( !) ! ! !( !! ( !) ! *#%*% ! ! ! ( ( ! $ !$
+ !! $ $
+ !!"
,-./0,-.1,/23415,0-66,-.71893.:;,-66,00-1: -1/6,.45,/:;,<-:,.7-0-=-70->0,31.,23./
% ;75 -66,-0 75 -8-715: :;, ?4/8<,1: -1/ -@-./ /-:,/%6-55,/71
3*#%*>A:;,34.:39 :;, ,173. 7=70 4/8, -1/ !( -1/ :;, 3<<755731,. 93. <603A,,5 3<6,15-:731 -: 71/-87 93. 5;3.: B:;, 3<<755731,.)" @;,.,>A :;, 3<<755731,. -@-./,/ -
- 3 -
23<6,15-:731 39 5* *%# :3 :;, 6,:7:731,.5 -1/ /7.,2:,/ :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 @;3 @-5 .,5631/,1:
3% >,93.,:;,.7>41-0 :36-A:;,23<6,15-:731 ' ;, 54>5:-1:7-0 C4,5:731 39 0-@ 93. 23157/,.-:731 9.-<,/>A:;7534.:31%%%75-5>,03@$
* ;,6-.:7,5@700>,.,9,..,/:3-56,.:;,7..-1D718 >,93., :;, 3<<755731,.93. :;,5-D, 39 231=,17,12, ;, -66,00-1:;,.,71@-5.,5631/,1:
3% :;,.,5631/,1:
35 -1/ % ;,.,71 @,., 6,:7:731,.5 -1/ .,5631/,1:
3' ;,.,71 @-5.,5631/,1:
3>,93.,:;,3<<755731,. ;,9-2:4-0<-:.7E39:;,2-5, :;-:75.,0,=-1:93. :;,64.635,39/75635-039:;75-66,-0-.,$ -" ;,6,:7:731,.5 @;3-.,:;,6-.,1:539/,2,-5,/ -78-<>-. !400- -66.3-2;,/ :;, 3<<755731,. 41/,. - 4 -
<603A,,5 3<6,15-:731 2: 5,,D718 .,/.,55-0 93. :;, /,-:; 39 :;, 5-7/ -78-<>-. !400- 71 -1 -227/,1: :;-:
3224..,/ 31 F% 71=30=718 :;, :.-2:3.:.-70,.417:
>,-.718
3 %#%F : @-5 231:,1/,/ :;-: 31 F% -: ->34: *' 6< @;,1 :;, /,2,-5,/ -78-<>-. @-5 @3.D718 -5 - 0->34. 71 :;, 5-7/ =,;720, 3@1,/>A.,5631/,1:
3G!-D:4<6-:,0 :;,5-7/=,;720, :4.1,/:4.:0,-1/:;,/,2,-5,/5:42D41/,.:;,5:31,@;72; :;,:.-2:3.@-5:.-1563.:718-1/;,/7,/4.7186,1/,12A 39 :;, 6.32,,/7185 .,5631/,1:
3% @;3 75 :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 @-5 7<60,-/,/ ;, 6,:7:731,.5 231:,1/,/ :;-: :;, /,2,-5,/ @-5 @3.D718 41/,..,5631/,1:
3 93. @-8,5-:
5%# 6,. /-A -1/ :;,.,@-5 -.,0-:7315;76 39,<603A,, -1/ ,<603A,. -1/ :;,.,93., :;,A -., ,1:7:0,/ 93. :;, 23<6,15-:731 >" ;, 6,:7:731 @-5 36635,/ >A .,5631/,1:
3 @;,.,>A ;, /,17,/ :;, .,0-:7315;76 39 ,<603A,. -1/ ,<603A,, 1 -//7:731 ;, 231:,1/,/ :;-: :;, =,;720, @-5 3@1,/>A.,5631/,1:
3%-1/:;,/,2,-5,/-78-<>-./7,/
- 5 -
71:;,5-7/-227/,1:71=30=718:;,:.-2:3. @;72;@-53@1,/ >A.,5631/,1:
3 2" ,:7:731,. 3 @-5 ,E-<71,/ -5 -1/ -13:;,. @7:1,55 @-5 ,E-<71,/ -5 % 31 >,;-09 39 :;, 6,:7:731,.5-1/E5:3@,.,<-.D,/71,=7/,12,;, .,5631/,1:
3,E-<71,/;7<5,09-5-1/E5:3 @,., <-.D,/ 9:,. ;,-.718 :;, -.84<,1:5 93. >3:;57/,5 :;348;:;,3<<755731,.;,0/:;-:/,2,-5,//7,//4,:3:;, -227/,1: /4.718 234.5, 39 :;, ,<603A<,1: 9-5:,1,/ :;, 07->707:A31.,5631/,/
3% 71@;35,1-<,:;,:.-2:3.5:33/ -5 31 /-:, 39 :;, -227/,1: >=73450A .,5631/,1:
3% /,567:, 5,.=72, 39 13:72, ;-/ 13: -66,-.,/ >,93., :;, 3<<755731,.-1/;-/.,575:,/:;,6,:7:731
,718 -88.7,=,/ >A 9-5:,1718 39 :;, 07->707:A -5 -8-715: .,5631/,1:
3% :;, .36.7,:3.
39 :;, 97.< ;-5 -66.3-2;,/:;7534.:71:;75-66,-0 F ,567:, 5,.=72, 39 13:72, :;, 6,:7:731,.5 -1/ .,5631/,1:
3;-=,13:-66,-.,/>,93.,:;7534.:
- 6 -
;, 0,-.1,/ 23415,0 -66,-.718 93. :;, -66,00-1: 54><7:5 :;-: :;, -66,00-1: @-5 :;, .36.7,:3. 39 ;-=-17 8.31871,,.718,.=72, @;72;75/,-0718@7:;:;,5-0,5-1/ 5,.=72,5 39 :;, @-.-? .-2:3.5 -1/ 7: ;-/ 530/ :;, :.-2:3. @;72; 75 71=30=,/ 71 :;, -227/,1: :3 .,5631/,1:
3 -1/ 5331 -9:,. 542; 5-0, 31 F% 7: @-5 A,: :3 >, .,875:,.,/ 71 :;, 1-<, 39 .,5631/,1:
3 4.718 :;, 71:,..,814<:;,-227/,1:;-/3224..,/,54><7:5:;-::;, 6,:7:731,.5;-/1,=,.60,-/,/3.6.3=,/:;-::;,.,@-5-1A 542; .,0-:7315;76 39 :;, ,<603A,. -1/ ,<603A,, @7:; .,5631/,1:
3% -1/ ,=,1 :;,1 :;,3<<755731,. 9-5:,1,/ :;,07->707:A31.,5631/,1:
3%,94.:;,.54><7:5:;-::;, /324<,1:5 6.3/42,/ >A :;, 6,:7:731,.5 :;,<5,0=,5 5;3@ :;-: :;, =,;720, @-5 530/ 31 F% -1/ :;, .7<71-0 34.:;-/.,0,-5,/:;,:.-2:3.719-=34.39.,5631/,1:
3 : 75 54><7::,/ :;-: :;, .7<71-0 34.: ;-/ 13: 23157/,.,/ :;, 6,27-0 3@,. 39 ::3.1,A ,E,24:,/ >A :;, -66,00-1: 71 9-=34. 39 .,5631/,1:
3 >4: 7: .,07,/ 31 :;, :,<63.-.A ,875:.-:731 ,.:7972-:, -1/ :;, -0, ,.:7972-:, 7554,/ >A .,5631/,1:
3% -1/ :;,.,93., -66,00-1:.,5631/,1:
3%
- 7 -
@-513::;,3@1,.39:;,=,;720,-531/-:,39:;,-227/,1: ,231:,1/5:;-::;,.,5631/,1:
3713./,.:3,52-6,:;, 07->707:A ;-5 .,575:,/ :;, 20-7< 6,:7:731 >,93., :;, 3<<755731,.-1/:;75-56,2:@-513:6.36,.0A-66.,27-:,/ >A;7< H 6,.45-0 39 :;, 6,:7:731 /752035,5 :;-: 7: 75 :;, 56,279722-5,39:;,6,:7:731,.5:;-::;,/,2,-5,/-78-<>-. !400-@-5-1,<603A,,39.,5631/,1:
3
3@;,., :;,., 75 -1A 60,-/7185 :;-: :;, -66,00-1: .,5631/,1:
3% @-5 :;,,<603A,.39:;,/,2,-5,/
,231/0A :;, ,=7/,12, 39 @;3 ;-66,15 :3 >, :;, 9-:;,. 39 :;, /,2,-5,/ @340/ /752035, :;-: ;, .,7:,.-:,/:;,231:,1:7315:-D,14671:;,6,:7:731 -1/71:;, 2.355,E-<71-:731 7: @-5 5488,5:,/ :3 ;7< >A .,5631/,1:
3 :;-: :;, :.-2:3. @-5 3@1,/ >A ;-=-17 8.3 1871,,.718 ,.=72, :;, 5-7/ :;, 5488,5:731 ;-5 13: >,,1 -/<7::,/ >A ;7< >4: ;, 5-7/ :;-: ;, 75 7813.-1: ->34: 7:
4.73450A :;,.,75135488,5:731>A.,5631/,1:
3:3 :;-::;,/,2,-5,/@-513:-1,<603A,,39.,5631/,1:
3 ;, 231:,1:731 39 :;, 6,:7:731,.5 :;-: :;,., ,E75:,/ :;,
- 8 -
.,0-:7315;7639,<603A,,-1/,<603A,.;-513:>,,1/,17,/ 71 :;, 2.355,E-<71-:731 ;,.,93., 7: 75 ,=7/,1: :;-: -00 -0318:;,231:,1:73139.,5631/,1:
3@-5:;-:;,@-513: :;,3@1,.39:;,=,;720,
1 :;, -997/-=7: ,=7/,12, 39 :;, :;348; ;, 231:,1/5 :;-: :;,., @-5 13 542; .,0-:7315;76 39 ,<603A,, -1/ ,<603A,.
71 :;, 2.355,E-<71-:731 ;, -/<7:5 :;-: :;, =,;720,@-583:.,0,-5,/31:;,>-57539:;,-0,5,.:7972-:, 7554,/ >A .,5631/,1:
3% ;-=-17 8.3 1871,,.718 ,.=72,;,6,:7:731,.5;-=,56,27972-00A5488,5:,/:;, :;-:/,2,-5,/-78-<>-.@-5-1,<603A,,41/,.;7< % ;,/324<,1:56.3/42,/>A:;,6,:7:731,.571:;, 93.< 39 ( 2;-.8,5;,,: -1/ 3:;,. 63072, 6-6,.5 @340/ /752035, :;-: :;, -66,00-1: ;-=-17 8.3 1871,,.718 ,.=72, ;-/ 7554,/ - -0,5 ,.:7972-:, 71 93.<
3% :3 .,5631/,1:
3G!-D:4<6-:,0#3-;,>6-:,03072,6-:,0 31 F% 9:,. .,2,7=718 :;, =,;720, -5 @,00 -5 :;, -0,5 ,.:7972-:, 7: @-5 13: 7<<,/7-:,0A .,875:,.,/ 71 :;, 1-<, 39 .,5631/,1:
3 G !-D:4<6-:,0 :,<63.-.A ,875:.-:731,.:7972-:,@-57554,/>A:;,2312,.1,/31
- 9 -
%H%;,.7<71-034.:8.-1:,/:;,71:,.7<245:3/A 39:;,=,;720,719-=34.39.,5631/,1:
3!-D:4<6-:,0>A 7:53./,./-:,/H%;,3./,.39:;,.7<71-034.: 5;3@5:;-:7:@-5-1,@=,;720,;,:,<63.-.A,875:.-:731 ,.:7972-:,;-5-053>,,16,.45,/>A:;,.7<71-034.:@;70, 8.-1:718 :;, 71:,.7< 245:3/A ;, :,<63.-.A ,875:.-:731 ,.:7972-:,7:5,0975 6-.:39:;, 2;-.8,5;,,:-:E @;72;
5;3@5 :;-: 7: @-5 5:-1/718 71 :;, 1-<, 39 !-D:4<6-:,0 =,1:;,,0,-5,,::,.7554,/>A:;,.7<71-034.:5;3@5 :;-:7:755:-1/71871:;,1-<,39!-D:4<6-:,0;,.,93., 7: 75,=7/,1::;-::;,.,7523157/,.->0,93.2,71:;,-.84<,1:39 :;,0,-.1,/23415,093.:;,-66,00-1::;-::;,/,2,-5,/@-5 -1,<603A,,39!-D:4<6-:,0 >4:13::;,-66,00-1:;,.,71 ' : 75 :.7:, 0-@ :;-: @;,1 20-7< 6,:7:731 75 970,/ 41/,. :;, 6.3=757315 39 :;, <603A,,5 3<6,15-:731 2:
:;, .,0-:7315;76 39 ,<603A,, -1/ ,<603A,. 75 -
;,1 :;,., 75 13 60,-/7185 3. :;, 6.339 :;-: :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 @-5 :;, ,<603A,. 39 :;, /,2,-5,/ -78-<>-. !400- :;, 9-5:,1718 39 :;, 07->707:A 31 :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 >A :;, 3<<755731,. 75 13: 6,.<7557>0,
- 10 -
10,55:;,3<<755731,.23<,5:3:;,2312045731:;-::;,., ,E75:5 :;, .,0-:7315;76 39 :;, ,<603A,. -1/ ,<603A,, ;, 2-113: 8.-1: -1A23<6,15-:731 41/,. :;, 6.3=75731539:;, <603A,,53<6,15-:7312: * ;, C4,5:731 @;,:;,. :;, =,;720, 75 3@1,/ >A .,5631/,1:
3 3. .,5631/,1:
3% @-5 5,231/-.A @;70, 8.-1:718 :;, 23<6,15-:731 ;, ,<603A,. <-A 13: >, :;, 3@1,. 39 :;, =,;720, -1/ ,=,1 :;,1 79 :;, ,<603A,, @-5 -2:71841/,.:;,715:.42:731539:;,,<603A,.31:;,=,;720, >,0318718:353<,>3/A,05, :;,17:75:;,,<603A,. @;375 07->0,:36-A:;,23<6,15-:731;,.,93., :;75-.84<,1:39 :;, 0,-.1,/ 23415,0 -66,-.718 93. :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 ;-5 23157/,.->0,93.2,-1/;-5:3>,-22,6:,/
>=73450A :;, 3<<755731,. /7/ 13: >,5:3@ ;75 -::,1:73131:;,9-2::;-::;,.,@-513542;.,0-:7315;7639 ,<603A,. -1/ ,<603A,, >,:@,,1 :;, -66,00-1: -1/ :;, /,2,-5,/1:;,->5,12,39-1A542;.,0-:7315;76 07->707:A 2340/ 13: ;-=, >,,1 9-5:,1,/ 4631 :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 ;,.,0-:7315;7639,<603A,.-1/,<603A,,;-=71813:>,,1 /,17,/ 71 :;, 2.355,E-<71-:731 39 :;, >A .,5631/,1:
- 11 -
3 7: -66,-.5 :;-: :;, /,17-0 39 542; .,0-:7315;76 71 :;, 60,-/7185 >A .,5631/,1:
3 @700 310A .,<-715 -5 - 60,-/718 >4:@7:;34:-1A6.339
1:;,3:;,.;-1/ :;,:,5:7<31A39:;,:;-:
:;, /,2,-5,/ @-5 :;, ,<603A,, 41/,.
.,5631/,1:
3 !-D:4<6-:,0;30/5833/;,.,93., :;,.,>,71813/,17-039 542; .,0-:7315;76 71 :;, 2.355,E-<71-:731 39 >A .,5631/,1:
3G!-D:4<6-:,0 :;,7<6481,/?4/8<,1:75 13: 545:-71->0, 41/,. 0-@ 1 :;, .,540: :;, 54>5:-1:7-0 C4,5:731 39 0-@ .-75,/ >A :;75 34.: 75 -15@,.,/ 71 :;, 1,8-:7=, F ;, .,540:-1: ,99,2: 39 542; 971/718 @700 >, :;-:
:;, 07->707:A ;-5 :3 >, 9-5:,1,/ 4631 .,5631/,1:
3 ,12, :;,93003@718$
7" ;,-66,-075-003@,/ 77" ;, 7<6481,/ ?4/8<,1: -1/ 3./,. 6-55,/ >A:;,3<<755731,.71
3*#%*75 ;,.,>A 5,: -57/, :3 :;, ,E:,1: :;-: 7:
- 12 -
9-5:,1,/ :;, 07->707:A 4631 :;, -66,00-1: ;,.,71 777" ;, 07->707:A :3 6-A :;, 23<6,15-:731 75 9-5:,1,/ 4631 .,5631/,1: 3 G !-D:4<6-:,0 7=" ;, .,5: 39 :;, 3./,. 6-55,/ >A :;, 3<<755731,.@340/.,<-7141-0:,.,/ =" ;,-<341:71/,6357:>,93.,:;7534.:>, .,941/,/:3:;,-66,00-1:
/# '
$ ( $
75:
3$0
3$F $