Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10206 (KAR)
SRI SIDDANNA @ SIDDU S/O RAMANNA POOJARI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200078/2020 · 2025-01-07
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10206 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10206 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
# $
"
# #!! %&'()!*+',(
*- . ! " #
$%&%'(
! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" )(* ! "
" #
"
*) '+) ''
"
"
" #
,
,
# , ! -./ 011203 45 6-2 789:.762; 077</2; ./ ;.=2762; 0>0.9/66-2?<;>@2968A789:.76.89;062;')''09;
8=;2= 8A /2962972 ;062; )')'' 45 6-2 B;;.6.8903 2//.89/ 127.03<;>2060304<=0>.C-2=2.90A62==2A2==2;
68 0/ D6-2 127.03 <;>2EF .9 127.03 0/2 8*) '+G-2=2.96-2320=92;127.03<;>2789:.762;
6-2 077</2; A8= 6-2 8AA2972/ 1<9./-0432 <9;2= 276.89/ )(H ! .! 09; 9! 09; %'H 8A 9;.09
2903 8;2 &H' C-2=2.90A62==2A2==2;680/D6-2
EF276.89/) ! G! .! 09; ) ! :! 8A 6-2 7-2;<32; 0/62/ 09; 7-2;<32;
- 3 -
=.42/
=2:296.89 8A 6=87.6.2/! 76 +&+ C-2=2.90A62= =2A2==2;680/D6-2 !76EF09;276.89H8A6-2 =86276.89 8A -.3;=29 A=8@ 2I<03 AA2972/ 76 ' C-2=2.90A62==2A2==2;680/D6-2
76EF/2962972;6-2 077</2;$01123309668<9;2=>8=.>8=8</.@1=./89@296A8= 629 520=/ 09; ;.=2762; 68 105 0 A.92 8A /%'''' B .9 ;2A0<36 8A 105@296 8A A.92 68 <9;2=>8 0 A<=6-2= /.@132 .@1=./89@296 A8= ' @896-/ A8= 6-2 8AA2972/ 1<9./-0432 <9;2= 276.89/ )(H ! .! 09; 9! 8A
09; A8= 6-2 8AA2972 1<9./-0432 <9;2= 276.89 H 8A 6-2
76 77</2; ./ A<=6-2= /2962972; 68 <9;2=>8 =.>8=8</ .@1=./89@296A8=H@896-/09;./;.=2762;681050A.928A /%''' B.9;2A0<368A105@2968AA.92A<=6-2=;.=2762;
68 <9;2=>8 /.@132 .@1=./89@296 A8= 6G8 @896-/ A8= 6-2 8AA29721<9./-0432<9;2=276.89%'H8A
-2077</2; ./03/8;.=2762;68<9;2=>8=.>8=8</.@1=./89@296A8=6G8 520=/ 09; ./ .@18/2; 0 A.92 8A /'''' B .9 ;2A0<36 8A 105@296 8A A.92 A<=6-2= ;.=2762; 68 <9;2=>8 /.@132 .@1=./89@296 A8= A8<= @896-/ A8= 6-2 8AA2972 1<9./-0432 <9;2=276.89) ! G! .!8A !760/6356-2
- 4 -
077</2; ./ ;.=2762; 68 <9;2=>8 .@1=./89@296 A8= 3.A2 .2 A.=/6 629 520=/ 8A .@1=./89@296 /-033 42 =.>8=8</ .@1=./89@296 09; =2@0.9.9> 10=6 8A 6-2 3.A2 /-033 42 /.@132.@1=./89@29609;./.@18/2;0A.928A/%'''' B .9;2A0<368A105@2968AA.92A<=6-2=;.=2762;68<9;2=>8 /.@132 .@1=./89@296 8A 629 @896-/ A8= 6-2 8AA2972 1<9./-0432<9;2=276.89) ! :!8A !766 ./ 03/8 ;.=2762; 6-06 033 6-2 /2962972/ 29<@2=062; /<1=0 /-033=<97897<==29635
-204=.;>2;A076/G-.7-32;686-26=.038A6-2 011233096B077</2;0=20/A8338G/
-2 1=8/27<6=.I .9 6-./ 70/2 G0/ =2/.;.9> G.6- -2= 10=296/ .9 833<= :.330>2 -.6601<= 603<J 0304<=0>.
;./6=.76 .2 G.6-.9 6-2 ?<=./;.76.89 8A 6-2 =2/189;296 B 183.72 9 '+'*'+ /-2 38;>2; 0 78@130.96 42A8=2 #B)B6-26-29
8A=2/189;296B183.720/12= I
B 0332>.9> 6-06 6-2 077</2; ./ 6-2 =2/.;296 8A 6-2 /0@2 :.330>2 G-8 G0/ 09 07K<0.960972 8A -2= 520= 1=.8= 68 '+'*'+-22I1=2//2;-./;2/.=268@0==5-2=062=
- 5 -
/.I@896-/1=.8=68'+'*'+6-2077</2;.9/6.>062;-2= 68 A8338G -.@ 68 09 0>=.7<36<=03 A.23; 09; A8=7.435 -0;
12926=06.:2 /2I<03 .962=78<=/2 G.6- -2= -2=20A62= -2 6-=206292;-2=G.6-;.=2789/2K<2972/98668;./738/26-2 /0@2 68 09548;5 .973<;.9> -2= 10=296/ 6 ./ 6-2 A<=6-2= 70/2 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I 6-06 A8338G.9> 6-2 /0.; .97.;296 6-2077</2;89720>0.989'%'*'+.2A8<=;05/1=.8= 686-2;0628A38;>.9>6-278@130.96@0;2090662@1668 =012-2=920=-2=130728A=2/.;29728G2:2=89-20=.9> -2=-<209;7=5-2=10=296/=2/7<2;-2=09;6-2077</2;
A32;6-2 /186 6./A<=6-2=0:2==2;.96-278@130.96 6-06 6-2 077</2; 78@@.662; /<7- 09 076 G233 0G0=2 6-06 /-2 G0/ 0 @.98= 09; 03/8 6-06 /-2 42389>2; 68
78@@<9.65
) 0/2; 89 6-2 78@130.96 I
B #B) =2>./62=2; 09 " 0>0.9/6 6-2 077</2;B011233096 .9 =.@2 8) '+ ;062; '+'*'+ A8= 6-2 0A8=2@296.892;
8AA2972/0/12=I
B%<4/2K<29668=2>./6=06.898A6-2
"
#B) 011=2-29;2; 6-2 077</2; 89 6-2 /0@2 ;05
- 6 -
-2=20A62= 6-2 :.76.@
#B G0/ /296 A8= @2;.703 2I0@.906.89 .972 6-2 8AA2972 1<9./-0432 <9;2= 6-2
76 ./ 066=0762; .9 6-2 70/2 A<=6-2= .9:2/6.>06.89 G0/789;<762;45
#B.26-2?<=./;.76.8903
#B 789;<762; A<=6-2= .9:2/6.>06.89 45 =278=;.9> 6-2 /6062@296 8A 6-2 :.76.@ <9;2= 276.89 H* 8A = 42A8=26-20>./6=0620/12=I
B"<=6-2=-28460.92;
6-2 0>2 72=6.A.7062 A=8@
#B& 0/ 12= I
B A8338G.9> G-.7- 6-2 70/62 72=6.A.7062 8A 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ 8460.92; 0/ 12= I
B& A=8@ #B+ A62= ;=0G.9> 6-2 =232:096 @0-0L0=/ 09; 8460.9.9> 86-2= 9272//0=5 ;87<@296/ -2 30.; 6-2 7-0=>2 /-226 0>0.9/6 077</2; 42A8=2 6-2 127.03 8<=6A8=6-20A8=2@296.892;8AA2972/
* A62=60J.9>78>9.L09728A6-28AA2972/09;89 /27<=.9>6-21=2/29728A6-2077</2;6-2320=92;127.03 <;>2 A=0@2; 6-2 7-0=>2/ 0>0.9/6 6-2 077</2; A8= 6-2 8AA2972/ 1<9./-0432 <9;2= 276.89/ )(H ! .! 09; 9! %'H8A
276.89/) ! =! G! .!09;) !
:!8A
!7609;276.89H8A6-2
76-2/0@2G0/
- 7 -
=20;8:2=:2=406.@686-2077</2;8G2:2=6-2077</2; ;29.2;6-27-0=>2/09;730.@2;68426=.2;
% 9 8=;2= 68 1=8:2 6-2 7-0=>2/ 32:2332; 0>0.9/6 6-2 077</2; 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 7833276.:235 2I0@.92;
6-.=6229G.692//2/42A8=26-2=.038<=60/
#B68
#B )>86@0=J2;6G2965B/.I;87<@296/0/I/
B68
BH 09;.;296.A.2;A8<=@062=.0384?276/0//B68*
H A62= 78@1326.89 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 2:.;2972 6-2 320=92; 127.03 <;>2 =20; 8:2= 6-2 .97=.@.906.9> 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 @062=.03 G.692//2/ 68 6-2 077</2; 0/ /6.1<3062; <9;2= 276.89 )) 8A =
8G2:2= 6-2 077</2;;29.2;6-2/0@2-2;2A29728A6-2077</2;./ 8928A68603;29.0309;6-068AA03/2.@13.706.898G2:2= 6-2077</2;92.6-2=2I0@.92;095G.692//98=>86@0=J2; 095;87<@296/89-./42-03A
( A62= 0 @296 8A 6-2 8=03 09; ;87<@2960=5 2:.;2972 13072; 42A8=2 6-2 127.03 <;>2 6-2 320=92;
127.03 <;>2 789:.762; 6-2 077</2; A8= 6-2 7-0=>2/
- 8 -
32:232; 0>0.9/6 -.@ 09; /2962972; -.@ 0/ /6062; -2/0.;?<;>@296./7-03329>2;<9;2=6-./011203
& #2 -0:2 -20=; 6-2 320=92; 78<9/23 A8= 6-2 011233096 =. ./-03
=0601 .9>- /8 03/8 6-2 320=92;
;;.6.8903 6062
<43.7
=8/27<68= A8= 6-2 =2/189;296 B 6062
+ -2 1=.@0=5 7896296.89 8A 6-2 320=92; 78<9/23 A8= 6-2 011233096 ./ 6-06 6-2 ?<;>@296 7-03329>2; <9;2= 6-./011203/<AA2=/A=8@12=:2=/.6509;.332>03.65/.9726-2 320=92; 127.03 <;>2 >=8//35 A0.32; 68 011=27.062 6-2 2:.;2972 89 =278=; .9 =.>-6 12=/1276.:2 09; 10//2; 6-2 .@1<>92; ?<;>@296 40/2; 89 /<=@./2/ 09; 789?<976<=2 2A<=6-2=/<4@.662;6-066-2=2./09.98=;.9062;2305.9 38;>.9> 6-2 78@130.96 45 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I -2 .97.;296 0332>2;35688J13072/.I@896-/1=.8=686-2;0628A38;>.9> 6-2 78@130.96 09; 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 A0.32; 68 2I130.9 6-2 =20/89A8=/<7-.98=;.9062;2305.938;>.9>6-278@130.96 2A<=6-2=789629;2;6-066-2=20=2/2=.8</.9A.=@.6.2/.9 6-2 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I
#B 048<6 6-2 0332>2;
- 9 -
;0628A.97.;296778=;.9>68-.@6-278@130.9609;H* /6062@296 8A 6-2 :.76.@ 0=2 7896=0;.76.9> 207- 86-2= =2>0=;.9>6-2;0628A.97.;29609;6-2@0992=.9G-.7-6-2 0332>2;=012G0//0.;68-0:278@@.662;456-2077</2; ;;.6.890335 -2 789629;2; 6-06 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 -0/ 78@1=2-29/.:235A0.32;681=8:26-20>28A6-21=8/27<6=.I 066-26.@28A6-20332>2;;0628A.97.;296-2;87<@296/ 13072;456-21=8/27<6.89.2I/
B'09;
B0=2986 6-2 0<6-296.7062; ;87<@296/ 68 1=8:2 6-2 0>2 8A 6-2 :.76.@0//6.1<3062;<9;2=6-21=8:./.89/8A<328A6-2 <:29.32 </6.72 <32/ 2:2=6-232// 6-2 0<6-8= 8A I
B.2
#B&7062>8=.703350;@.662;.9-./2:.;2972 6-066-2=2./60@12=.9>.96-2=2>./62=G.6-=2/1276686-2 0>28A6-2:.76.@-2320=92;78<9/234529<97.06.9>-./ 0=><@296/ /<4@.662; 6-06 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 A<=6-2= A0.32;
68 1=8:2 6-2 @2;.703 2:.;2972 6-06 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ /<4?2762; 68 12926=06.:2 /2I<03 .962=78<=/2 0/ /6062; 45 -2= /.@135 A8= 6-2 =20/89 6-06 6-2 ;8768= G-8 2I0@.92;
6-2 :.76.@ .2
#B' -0/ >.:29 -2= A.903 81.9.89 0/ 12= I
B( 6-06 6-2=2 0=2 98 6=072/ 8A =27296 /2I<03
- 10 -
.962=78<=/2896-2:.76.@0/635-2789629;2;6-066-2 320=92;127.03<;>2A0.32;68789/.;2=6-2A0766-066-2 1=8:./.89/ 8A ! 76 ;82/ 986 066=076 .9 6-2 .9/609670/2A8=6-2=20/896-06.98=;2=68066=076276.89 ) !
:!8A !766-2077</2;8<>-668-0:2 78@@.662;6-20764542.9>G233G.6-.9-./J98G32;>26-06 6-2 :.76.@ 42389>2; 68 7-2;<32; 0/62 7-2;<32; =.42 78@@<9.65 09; .9 8=;2= 68 423.6632 -2= 70/62 -2 -0/ 78@@.662; 6-2 8AA2972 <6 89 12=</03 8A 6-2 296.=2 2:.;2972 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 -0/ 986 78@2 <1 G.6- /<7- 0 1320#.6-6-2/2/<4@.//.89/-21=05/680338G6-2011203 09; 68 /26 0/.;2 6-2 .@1<>92; ?<;>@296 10//2; 45 6-2 =.038<=6
' 2A<6.9> 6-2 048:2 /<4@.//.89/ @0;2 45 6-2 320=92; 78<9/23 A8= 6-2 011233096 6-2 320=92; ;;.6.8903 789629;2; 6-06 6-2 ?<;>@296 7-03329>2; .9 6-./ 01120392.6-2=/<AA2=/A=8@12=:2=/.6598=.332>03.6509;98 2I7216.897094260J29A=8@6-2?<;>@29610//2;456-2 =.03 8<=6 A8= 6-2 =20/89/ 0//.>92; 45 6-2 =.03 8<=6
- 11 -
<9;2= 0 G233B=20/892; ?<;>@296 2 789629;2; 6-06 6-2 320=92; 127.03 <;>2 09035/2; 6-2 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I.9>=206;260.309;8912=</038A6-2/0@26-2 1=8/27<6=.I -0/ 7062>8=.70335 ;218/2; .9 -2= 2:.;2972 =2>0=;.9> 6-2 A8=7.432 /2I<03 076 78@@.662; 45 6-2 077</2; 89 ;.AA2=296 8770/.89/ "<=6-2= -2= :2=/.89 G0/ 78==848=062;456-22:.;29728A-2=10=296/09;/<118=62;
45 6-2 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 9:2/6.>06.89 AA.72=/
#B 09;
#B) 2 A<=6-2= 789629;2; 6-06 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 -0/ 03/81=8:2;6-20>28A6-2:.76.@6-06/-2G0/0@.98=06 6-2 6.@2 8A 6-2 .97.;296 45 1307.9> =232:096 ;87<@296/ .2I/
B'09;
B.//<2;45
#B&6-220;@./6=2// 8A 6-2 /7-883 .9 G-.7- 6-2 :.76.@ /6<;.2; 9 12=</03 8A I
B 6-2 ;062 8A 4.=6- 8A 6-2 :.76.@ ./ @296.892; 0/ &'+'') / /<7- 89 6-2 ;062 8A .97.;296 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ 0>2; 048<6 H 520=/ "<=6-2= 6-2 ;8768= B
#B' G-8 2I0@.92; 6-2 :.76.@ -0/ 7062>8=.70335 ;218/2; 6-06 6-2-5@298A6-2:.76.@G0/=<16<=2;//<7-.6./7320= 6-06 6-2 077</2; 78@@.662; 09 076 8A 12926=06.:2 /2I<03 0//0<36 ;;.6.890335 6-2 9:2/6.>06.89 AA.72= B
#B
- 12 -
8460.92; 6-2 70/62 72=6.A.7062 8A 6-2 :.76.@ 0/ 12= I
B& 6-06/-242389>2;687-2;<32;0/6278@@<9.659/<7- 7.=7<@/60972/89070=2A<312=</038A6-22:.;29728A6-2 @062=.03G.692//2/6-21=8/27<6.89-0/1=8:2;6-2><.368A 6-2 077</2; 42589; 033 =20/890432 ;8<46/ #.6- 6-2/2 /<4@.//.89/ 6-2 320=92; ;;3
1=05/ 68 ;./@.// 6-2 011203 45 789A.=@.9> 6-2 ?<;>@296 10//2; 45 6-2 =.03 8<=6
0:.9> -20=; 6-2 320=92; 78<9/23 A8= 6-2 =2/1276.:210=6.2/09;8912=</038A6-2296.=22:.;297289 =278=; .973<;.9> 6-2 .@1<>92; ?<;>@296 10//2; 45 6-2 320=92; 127.03 <;>2 6-2 18.96/ 6-06 0=./2 A8= 8<= 789/.;2=06.890=2
.! #-26-2=6-2?<;>@296<9;2=6-./011203 /<AA2=/A=8@12=:2=/.6509;.332>03.65M
..! #-26-2= 6-2 320=92; 127.03 <;>2 ./ ?</6.A.2; .9 789:.76.9> 6-2 077</2;B 011233096 A8= 6-2 8AA2972/ 1<9./-0432 <9;2= 276.89/ )(H ! .! N 9! 09; %'H 8A
276.89/) ! G! .!09;) ! :!8A
- 13 -
!
76 09; 276.89 H 8A 6-2 76M 98=;2=684=.9>-8@26-2><.368A6-2077</2; 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 -0/ 1=.@0=.35 =23.2; 89 6-2 2:.;2972 8A #B B 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I #BH 6-2 /./62= 8A 6-2 :.76.@ #B& 6-2 -20;@./6=2// G-8 .//<2; 6-2 0>2 72=6.A.7062 8A 6-2:.76.@09;03/86-22:.;29728A #B'6-2;8768=G-8 -0; 2I0@.92; 6-2 :.76.@ -8<>- 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 -0/ 2I0@.92;.968603)G.692//2/.6./9869272//0=5A8=</ 68=2A2=6-22:.;29728A0336-2G.692//2/ ) 970=2A<312=</038A6-22:.;29728A #B.2 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I /-2 38;>2; 6-2 78@130.96 I B 89 '+'*'+ 42A8=2 #B) 6-2 6-29 0332>.9> 6-06 892 520=1=.8=686-2.97.;296/-2J92G6-2077</2;09;6-06 /-2A=2K<29635G0/29>0>2;.9789:2=/06.89G.6--.@8:2= @84.321-892-2=20A62=6-2.=A=.29;/-.16<=92;.96838:2 09;/.I@896-/1=.8=686-2;0628A38;>.9>6-278@130.96 6-2 077</2; 78@@.662; 09 076 8A A8=7.432 12926=06.:2 /2I<03.962=78<=/289-2=A8=6-2A.=/66.@28G2:2=/-2 - 14 - 92.6-2==2:2032;6-2/0@268-2=10=296/98=09548;523/2 .9 6-2 :.330>2 <4/2K<29635 0A62= /.I @896-/ .2 89 '%'*'+6-2077</2;89720>0.9@0;2090662@1668 =012-2=09;03/88<6=0>2;-2=@8;2/65"8338G.9>G-.7- 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ 6-=206292; G.6- ;.=2 789/2K<2972/ 9 =272.:.9>6-278@130.966-2=2/189;296$183.72=278=;2; -2= /6062@296 <9;2= 276.89 H* = 42A8=2 6-2 320=92;0>./6=0620/12=I B970=2A<312=</038A6-2 /0@2.6./2/6043./-2;6-06892520=1=.8=686-2;0628A 38;>.9> 8A 6-2 78@130.96 6-2 077</2; -0/ 78@@.662; A8=7.432/2I<03.962=78<=/289-2=062=%;05/1=.8=68 6-2;0628A.97.;296-2-0;89720>0.978@@.662;/2I<03 .962=78<=/2 89 -2= 8G2:2= 6-2 :.76.@ .9 -2= 2:.;2972 42A8=2 6-2 8<=6 ;218/2; 6-06 6-2 0332>2; .97.;296 8A /2I<030//0<36G0/78@@.662;456-2077</2;A.:2@896-/ 42A8=2 38;>.9> 8A 6-2 78@130.96 09; 68 ) @896-/ 6-2=20A62= -2 8972 0>0.9 0662@162; 68 =012 -2= 9 70=2A<3 09035/./ 8A 6-2/2 :2=/.89/ 8A #B 6-2=2 0=2 /2=.8</;./7=21097.2/A8=6-78@.9>.9-2=:2=/.89=2>0=;.9> 6-2 ;062 8A 6-2 .97.;296 -2 ;.AA2=296 ;062 09; @896-/ - 15 - /6062; 45 6-2 :.76.@ .9 -2= 78@130.96 /6062@296 <9;2= 276.89 H* 8A = /8 03/8 42A8=2 6-2 8<=6 7=2062/ ;8<46.96-2>292/./8A6-27=.@2/=.>-63518.962;8<645 6-2 320=92; 78<9/23 A8= 6-2 011233096 6-2=2 ./ .98=;.9062 ;23058A@8=26-09/.I@896-/.938;>.9>6-278@130.96 * -289E43212I8<=6.96-270/28A -23; 6-06 .9 0 70/2 G-2=2 6-2 /832 62/6.@8958A1=8/27<6=.I./0:0.30432.6./:2=5;09>2=8</ 68789:.766-2077</2;986.7.9>6-066-21=8/27<6=.I78<3; :296<=2 68 G0.6 A8= ( @896-/ A8= A.3.9> 6-2 " A8= =012 -./320:2/6-2077</2;6860335;2A297232// % 1135.9>6-2A.9;.9>/8A6-289E43212I8<=6 .9 6-2 048:2 ?<;>@296 68 6-2 .9/6096 70/2 G2 -0:2 98 86-2= 0362=906.:2 4<6 68 -83; 6-06 6-2=2 ./ 09 .98=;.9062 ;2305.938;>.9>6-278@13.09609;6-21=8/27<6.89>=8//35 A0.32;682I130.96-2/0@2"<=6-2=6-2/0.;;230509;6-2 - 16 - ;./7=21097.2/.96-2;0628A.97.;296>82/686-2=8868A6-2 1=8/27<6.8970/2 H 9 78@.9> 68 6-2 2:.;2972 13072; 45 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 89 6-2 0332>2; /2I<03 0//0<36 78@@.662; 45 6-2077</2;1=8/27<6=.I-0//6062;6-060A62=6-2.97.;296 /-292.6-2==2:2032;6-2/0@268-2=10=296/98=09548;5 23/2 A8= 0 12=.8; 8A /.I @896-/ "<=6-2= .9 -2= 7=8//B 2I0@.906.89/-2-0//6062;6-06G-.32/-2G0/G8=J.9>0/ 0 7883.2 0389>/.;2 6-2 077</2; -2= 10=296/ G2=2 :2=5 @<7- 1=2/296 .9 6-2 A.23; 778=;.9> 68 -2= 0A62= 6-2 .97.;296/-2:./.62;6-2077</2;E/-8</209;/6052;6-2=2 A8= A8<= ;05/ -2=20A62= /.972 6-2 077</2; 09; -./ 10=296/ =2A</2; 68 /832@9.L2 6-2 @0==.0>2 8A 6-2 :.76.@ G.6- 6-2 077</2; /-2 38;>2; 0 78@130.96 2972 6-2=2 0=./2/;8<46.96-22:.;29728A #B048<6-2=:2=07.65.9 =2/1276 8A 6-2 0332>2; /2I<03 0//0<36 78@@.662; 45 6-2 077</2; 9 /<7- 7.=7<@/60972/ 6-2 2:.;2972 8A 1=8/27<6=.I320:2//8@2;8<46.9=2/12768A6-2877<==2972 8A6-2.97.;296.6/23A0//6062;45-2=-2:2=/.898A # - 17 - 709986 42 789/6=<2; 0/ /62=3.9> K<03.65 0/ -23; 45 6-2 89E43212I8<=6.97062908A?<;>@296/ ( 26-060/.6@054278@.9>686-292I60/1276 .26-20>28A6-2:.76.@6-06/-2G0/0@.98=09;0>2; 048<6H520=/066-26.@28A.97.;2960/730.@2;456-2 1=8/27<6.89912=</038A6-22:.;29728A #B&.26-2 20;@./6=2// 8A 6-2 /7-883 .9 G-.7- #B /6<;.2; 09; I/
B' 09; 6-2 72=6.A.7062 09; 6-2 7-883 2>./62= =2/1276.:235 /6062/ 6-06 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ 0>2; 048<6 H 520=/ 92:2=6-232// 0/ =.>-635 18.962; 8<6 45 6-2 320=92; 78<9/23A8=6-2011233096 #B&.26-20<6-8=8AI B 7062>8=.70335 0;@.662; .9 -2= 2:.;2972 6-06 6-2=2 ./ 60@12=.9> 8A I B .9:83:.9> 6-2 ;062 8A 4.=6- 8A 6-2 :.76.@-21=8/27<6.89A0.32;68130726-28=.>.903=2>./62= 42A8=2 6-2 =.03 8<=6 9 /<7- 7.=7<@/60972/ 6-2 0;@.//.89 8A #B& 6-2 0<6-8= 8A I B =2>0=;.9> 6-2 60@12=.9> 8A I B 709986 42 .>98=2; "<=6-2= #B& 03/8 0;@.662; .9 -2= 2:.;2972 6-06 I/ B' 09; 0=2 986 40/2; 89 095 0<6-296.7062; ;87<@296/ 3.J2 4.=6- - 18 - 72=6.A.7062 .//<2; 45 6-2 78972=92; 0<6-8=.6.2/ "<=6-2= 89 12=</03 8A 6-2 2:.;2972 8A #B' $ 8768= G-8 2I0@.92;6-2:.76.@03/8/6062;.9-2=2:.;29726-066-2 0>28A6-2:.76.@G0/&520=/066-26.@28A6-20332>2; .97.;296 09; 6-2 /0@2 G0/ =2.62=062; .9 6-2 @2;.703 72=6.A.7062I BH-278B8=;.90624297-8A6-./8<=6.9 =.@.903 11203 8'''+ '* ;062; '%'* -23; =2>0=;.9> ;262=@.906.89 8A 6-2 0>2 8A 6-2 :.76.@ 06 10=0>=01-8/*'09;*0/<9;2= ! " # "$ %#"&''#$()# )# %#" $" ) # # * + # ,#" # -&#! . / )""$0
1#2" "&")"#"& #"##"$"$! $ $ & #")) ##! #"$ 3!# $!"&#&## #&##!)$#"# #" $ "$! # " $ *! # # ##! $")%#"&2"
2"! # +45!65* ## ## #""& )# + # )7" 2" + ) 8#
#! "
- 19 -
# )& # ")" ) # ) # " # 2" 9! # # # 2" ! # # + # #
"! # # # + # ):# " *
#
")" $" #""& # # 9# 2" ! "#:"#
"### 9# ! ")"! # ##)"#;#"&#)# ! 2" # ## ) # #
"#)&"9## #&)")"!) #")")#"# #"! # # " ) " # ;#"& # )# #&! 2"
" "# # ) )&# #"& #& < #! ")"!## "$ ) (# # ## ##
"##! $"#""& #" 9 #"& # )# #& ! 2" " ##
"##!#) " ##=
8# 2" ,#" , 2"!
#")" ##
""$0
6)""$# ## >
?++
9#&###"%#" # #" $ "$! ## #:& "" ) # )& @! &)! )& (##)&)##>
- 20 -
"#:"#! ")"A##)#$A
) " #"&"#A## )#$A
)#)&# #"&#&A=
& 9 12=</03 8A 6-2 048:2 ?<;>@296 10//2; 45 6-2 78B8=;.9062 4297- 8A 6-./ 8<=6 .6 ./ =2306.:235 7320= 6-060/12=<328A6-2<:29.32</6.72<32/.98=;2= 681=8:26-20>28A6-27-.3;8=?<:29.326-21=872;<=268 42 A8338G2; 09; 6-2 ;87<@296/ 68 42 =23.2; 45 6-2 1=8/27<6.890=26-2@06=.7<306.898=2K<.:0329672=6.A.7062/ .A0:0.30432O09;.96-204/29726-2;0628A4.=6-72=6.A.7062 A=8@6-2/7-883 86-2=6-090105/7-883!A.=/606629;2;O 09; .9 6-2 04/2972 6-2 4.=6- 72=6.A.7062 >.:29 45 0 8=18=06.89 8= 0 <9.7.103 <6-8=.65 8= 0
097-0506 2972 789/.;2=.9> 6-2 048:2 0/1276 G2 0=2 8A 6-2 789/.;2=2;:.2G6-066-21=8/27<6.8903/8A0.32;681=8:2 6-066-2:.76.@G0/0@.98=0/896-2;0628A.97.;296
- 21 -
+ 8@.9> 68 6-2 0/1276 8A 6-2 @2;.703 2:.;2972 13072; 45 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 68 1=8:2 6-06 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ /<4?2762;68/2I<03.962=78<=/28970=2A<312=</038A6-2 2:.;29728A
#B'09;6-272=6.A.7062/.//<2;45-2=.2 I/
B% 68
B( 98 ;8<46 .9 I
BH
#B' -0/ /6062;
6-066-2-5@298A6-2:.76.@G0/=<16<=2;8G2:2=
#B ' J216 -2= 81.9.89 129;.9> 0A62= 2I0@.906.89 8A 6-2 :.76.@.9.6.033509;0A62=8460.9.9>6-2"=218=6A=8@6-2 78972=92; 0<6-8=.65 -0/ .//<2; A.903 81.9.89 0/ 12= I
B(G-.7- 29<@2=062/6-066-2=2 986=072/8A=27296 /2I<03 .962=78<=/2 89 6-2 :.76.@ -2 " =218=6 A<=6-2= =2:2032; 6-06 6-2=2 ./ 98 /12=@068L80 A8<9; 89 6-2 7386-2/G8=92.6-2=456-2077</2;8=456-2:.76.@G-.7- G2=2 /2.L2; 45 6-2 9:2/6.>06.89 AA.72= # ;@.662;356-2=2./98/<7-1-5/.703.9?<=5A8<9;896-2 48;58A6-2:.76.@-2=<16<=28A6-2-5@29.6/23A709986 420>=8<9;6878973<;26-066-2:.76.@G0//<4?2762;68 /2I<03.962=78<=/2
- 22 -
' 9 12=</03 8A ;218/.6.89 8A
#' 2;.703 AA.72= 78<132; G.6- @2;.703 72=6.A.7062 0/ 12= I/
H 09; ( G2 0=2 8A 6-2 789/.;2=2; :.2G 6-06 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 A0.32; 68 1=8:2 @2;.703 2:.;2972 .9 6-./ 70/2 6-06 6-2 :.76.@ G0/ /<4?2762; 68 /2I<03 .962=78<=/2 / /<7-.6./-0=;68423.2:26-066-2077</2;78@@.662;09 076 8A A8=72A<3 12926=06.:2 /2I<03 .962=78<=/2 89 6-2 :.76.@
9/<7-7.=7<@/60972/6-289E43212I8<=6 .96-270/28A
-0/-23;0/<9;2=
9# # B# B C"( -&# # # # # # ! 96! )# " ### 0
D )! " #
"& ### !"&#+ # ### # ) )""& $&! #)" # " ) "# :"& @! # # #! #
2 6
- 23 -
+! $# " "#! $
"& )# % #)! $" $ # #
""#&###)"#
"""#"&#
9# " ## # # " # # #! # # 6! 392 ###*!$#&
# ) ###"&! $ & " # )& + ## 2!
@ " E! $ $ # #
"" )# * $ @ " E $# $ # + # # " # )&)"## )#$#)&""#=
! 912=</038A6-2048:2;.76<@.6./7320=6-06 6-8<>- 6-2=2 ./ 98 40= 68 =235 /83.60=5 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I 6-2 /0.; 2:.;2972 8A 1=8/27<6=.I ./ 68 42 6=</6G8=6-5 <9432@./-2; 09; .6 /-8<3; 42 8A /62=3.9> K<03.65
) 9 6-2 70/2 89 -09; 6-2 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I 7=2062/ ;8<46 .9 =2/1276 8A @0992= .9 G-.7- 6-2076G0/78@@.662;456-2077</2;09;/-2-0/A0.32;
- 24 -
68/60626-2:2=5;0628A.97.;29609;989B78==848=06.898A -2= :2=/.89 G.6- 6-2 @2;.703 2:.;2972 2972 62/6.@895 8A
#70998642789/.;2=2;0//62=3.9>K<03.65
* 6./:2-2@29635789629;2;456-2320=92;;;3 6-06 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 -0/ 7320=35 1=8:2; 6-2 8AA2972 78@@.662;456-2077</2;<9;2=6-21=8:./.89/8A276.89/ ) ! G! .!09;) ! :!8A6-2 !76
% #2 -0:2 12=</2; 6-2 2:.;2972 8A 6-2 1=8/27<6=.I /8 03/8 6-2 2:.;2972 8A # 6-2 9:2/6.>06.89 AA.72= 09;
#) 6-2 6-29
G-8 =2>./62=2; 6-2 " 09; 6-2 70/62 72=6.A.7062 8460.92; 45 #0/12=I
&-270/628A6-2:.76.@-0/9864229 ;./1<62;6-2=2./98;8<466-06/-242389>2;687-2;<32; 0/6278@@<9.65
H 276.89 ) ! :! 8A 6-2 7-2;<32; 0/62/ 09;
7-2;<32; =.42/
=2:296.89 8A 6=87.6.2/!
76 +&+ =20;/6-</
"
#$!!%
#$& #
#
!'
()
*
- 25 -
)
#
#
# )
#& # # 9## 6#"
F
#)" $ # # # & # # & (#$# # ) "
" *) & )"# )!"")#)"$ # #
"#$#A=
(
"=8@6-212=</038A048:21=8:./.89.6./7320= 6-06 .9 8=;2= 68 066=076 6-2 048:2 1=8:./.89 6-2 1=8/27<6.89-0/681=8:26-20/12766-066-2077</2;-0/ 78@@.662;09076686-2:.76.@45 J98G.9> G2336-06/-2 42389>68 09;03/868;./=2/1276-2=70/62
& 12=</03 8A 6-2 2:.;2972 8A
# 8= 6-2 2:.;2972 8A
# 09;
#) 9:2/6.>06.89 AA.72=/ 98G-2=2 6-2/2 G.692//2/ -0:2 /6062; 6-06 6-2 077</2;
G0/ 0G0=2 048<6 6-2 70/62 8A 6-2 :.76.@ 09; G.6- /<7- J98G32;>2 -2 -0/ 78@@.662; 6-2 /2I<03 .962=78<=/2 89 -2=
+ 2972 89 70=2A<3 789/.;2=06.89 8A 6-2 048:2 0/1276.6./7320=6-066-21=8/27<6.89-0/A0.32;681=8:2
- 26 -
6-28AA2972/1<9./-0432<9;2=6-21=8:./.89/8A6-2
!760>0.9/66-2077</2;
)' 9 8:2=033 12=</03 8A 6-2 296.=2 2:.;2972 89 =278=;.98<=789/.;2=2;:.2G6-2320=92;127.03<;>2 -0/ @./=20; 6-2 2:.;2972 09; -0/ G=89>35 789:.762; 6-2 077</2;A8=6-27-0=>2/32:232;0>0.9/6-.@-22:.;2972 13072; 45 6-2 1=8/27<6.89 ./ 986 78>296 =23.0432 789:.97.9> 09; 6=</6G8=6-5 9 /<7- 7.=7<@/60972/ .962=A2=2972./=2K<.=2;.96-2.@1<>92;?<;>@29610//2; 456-2320=92;127.03<;>296-06:.2G8A6-2@0662= G209/G2=6-218.968.90AA.=@06.:209;18.968.9 92>06.:209;1=8722;6810//6-2A8338G.9>
778=;.9>35=3'''(& ''./0338G2;
-2 ?<;>@296 8A 789:.76.89 09; 8=;2= 8A /2962972 10//2;456-2;;.6.8903 127.03<;>2060304<=0>..9 13
8*) '+;062;')''.//260/.;2
- 27 -
-2 011233096B077</2; ./ 07K<.662; 8A 6-2 8AA2972/ 1<9./-0432<9;2=276.89/)(H ! .!09; 9!09;276.89 %'H8A
276.89) ! G! .!09;) ! :!8A
=2:296.89 8A 6=87.6.2/! 76 +&+ 09; A8= 6-2 8AA2972 1<9./-0432<9;2=276.89H8A6-2
76' -278972=92;0.30<6-8=.6.2/0=2;.=2762;68=2320/2 6-2 011233096B077</2; A8=6-G.6- .A -2 ./ 986 =2K<.=2; .9 09586-2=70/2 -2 A.92 0@8<96 .A 095 ;218/.62; 45 6-2 077</2; /-03342=2A<9;2;68-.@891=812=.;296.A.706.89 2>./6=5 ./ ;.=2762; 68 /29; 0 7815 8A 6-./ 8=;2= 68 6-278972=92;0.30<6-8=.6.2/ /+
($*
/+
( *
# ./6838*' 6O