- 1 - ! " #!$ %! # &'()*+'(*, % ! " !! # $ ! % $ ! " !! # # % & ' ( ! " !! # ) & ! ) ! " Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !! # % *& ' !( + &+& %& $ & && + $ , % $ ! " !! # * & ' &+ ! %!+$( & + )$ + & & - + & & % & . $$ ' $$ + ++ & ).'( $ ) % ). + & + + ! ##+ - 3 - & + % / # ! %# '&/ # ! %# ( 001234 52$ 65 783 93:583 6;<2 5186 1=438 306<5= )$ 5: 8& ><6; 7 ?87@38 65 A172; 6;3 3=6<83 ?850334<=B2 <= 5. $$ ?3=4<=B 93:583 6;3 5186 5: <C<D #14B3 7=4 #+ ;7DE< <478 4<268<06 78<2<=B 516 5: 8<F3 5 $$ 83B<263834 9@ ;7DE< 5>= &5D<03 676<5= <478 :58 6;3 5::3=032 ?1=<2;79D3 1=438 306<5=2).$)7=48374><6; 306<5= ).5: & $ 3784D378=34051=23D:586;3?786<32 378=34051=23D:586;3?36<6<5=382219F<626;76 832?5=43=6 5$ <2 267@<=B 23?78763D@ 7D5=B ><6; ;38 ?783=62 2<=03 6;3 @378 $$ 001234 5 >;5 <2 6;3 ;1297=45:832?5=43=65$;74:<D3474<C5803?36<6<5=<= - 4 - 6;3 @378 $$ 93:583 6;3 G18<24<06<5=7D 5186 76 7=B7 344@ 4<268<06 3D7=B7=7 6763 7=4 <= 6;3 27<4 ?850334<=B2832?5=43=65$;72?786<0<?7634<=6;3@378 $$<623D:&8323=608<F<=7D 0723;72933=83B<263834<= 6;3 @378 $$ 9@ F7E<=B :7D23 7=4 5F=<912 7DD3B76<5=2 7B7<=26 7DD 6;3 83D76<C32 5: 7001234 5 ;383 <2 =5 ?85?383H?D7=76<5=:586;3<=584<=76343D7@5:6;833@3782 <=7??8570;<=B6;3?5D<0300584<=BD@;3?87@2657DD5> 6;3?36<6<5= ) &38 05=687 D378=34 <B; 5186 5C38=F3=6 &D37438 7??378<=B :58 832?5=43=6 5 7=4 D378=34 051=23D7??378<=B:58832?5=43=65$;7C35??52346;3 ?36<6<5= ;3 D378=34 051=23D 7??378<=B :58 832?5=43=6 5$ 219F<62 6;76 7:638 6;3 4<C5803 ?36<6<5= >72 :<D34 9@ 6;3 ;1297=4 7001234 5832?5=43=6 5$;72 <=<6<7634 ?850334<=B2 7B7<=26 7DD 6;3 7001234 ?3825=2 1=438 6;3 ?85C<2<5=2 5: 6;3 &856306<5= 5: %5F3= :85F 5F326<0 !<5D3=03 06 $ 7=4 6;3837:638 ?8323=6 08<F<=7D ?850334<=B2 ;72 933= <=<6<7634 3 219F<62 6;76 - 5 - <=C326<B76<5=5:6;30723<27D8374@05F?D36347=40;78B3 2;336;72933=:<D34>;<0;>51D4?8<F7:70<3B5652;5> 6;766;383<2F7638<7D65?852301636;37001234?3825=2:58 6;37DD3B345::3=03200584<=BD@;3?87@2654<2F<226;3 ?36<6<5= &38127D 5: 6;3 F7638<7D 7C7<D79D3 5= 830584 >51D4 B5 65 2;5> 6;76F788<7B3 5:7001234 5 >;5<2 6;325=5:700123452$7=4><6;832?5=43=65$>72 ?38:58F34 5= .$$ ;3 05?@ 5: 6;3 4<C5803 ?36<6<5= F743 7C7<D79D3 65 6;<2 5186 9@ D378=34 051=23D :58832?5=43=65$>51D4B5652;5>6;765=D@:5872;586 ?38<54 6;3 ;1297=4 7=4 ><:3 D<C34 65B36;38 = 6;3 4<C5803 ?36<6<5= >;<0; >72 :<D34 93:583 6;3 G18<24<06<5=7D +7F<D@5186767=B7344@4<268<063D7=B7=7 67639@ 70012345727B7<=26832?5=43=65$<6<22676346;76 2;3;74D3:66;3F768<F5=<7D;5123<=6;3@378$$<623D: 7=4 D3B7D =56<03 >72 <22134 5= 93;7D: 5: 6;3 ;1297=4 65 832?5=43=65$5=).$$<623D:;3837:6384<C5803 ?36<6<5= <= +&5. $$ >72 :<D34 93:583 6;3 - 6 - G18<24<06<5=7D +7F<D@ 5186 76 7=B7 8344@ 4<268<06 9@ 7001234 5 ;1297=4 5= )$$ ;3 832?5=43=6 5$>;5>72238C34<=6;327<4?850334<=B2;743=63834 7??3787=0393:5836;3+7F<D@5186<=6;3@378$$<623D: 7=4 ;74 :<D34 =3032278@ 7??D<076<5= 93:583 6;3 +7F<D@ 5186233E<=B687C3DD<=B3H?3=232:85F;38;1297=4;3 27<47??D<076<5=>72:<D349@;38<=6;3F5=6;5:065938 $$ ;3837:638 832?5=43=6 5$ ;72 :<D34 7 051=638 7::<47C<693:5836;3+7F<D@51867=4<=6;327<47::<47C<6 2;3 ;72 ?87@34 6;76 4<C5803 ?36<6<5= F7@ 93 7DD5>34 ?85C<4342;3>72?7<4?38F7=3=67D<F5=@5:2D7E;2 7=4 7DD B<:62 7=4 97BB7B3 B<C3= 418<=B 6;3 >344<=B 93 83618=34 65 ;38 ;<2 051=638 7::<47C<6 >72 :<D34 5= $$$$$ 93:583 6;3 G18<24<06<5=7D +7F<D@ 5186 9@ 832?5=43=6 5$ ;3 ?8323=6 08<F<=7D ?850334<=B2 ;72 933= <=<6<7634 9@ ;38 5= )$$ 3:583 6;3 +7F<D@ 5186<=6;3051=6387::<47C<6:<D349@832?5=43=65$6;3 7DD3B76<5=2 =5> F743 <= 6;3 :<826 <=:58F76<5= 783 =56 :51=4 &8<58 65 :<D<=B 6;3 :<826 <=:58F76<5= <= 6;3 ?8323=6 0723 832?5=43=6 5$ ;72 <=<6<7634 ?850334<=B2 7B7<=26 - 7 - ;38 ;1297=4 93:583 6;3 G18<24<06<5=7D 5186 1=438 6;3 ?85C<2<5=2 5: 6;3 &856306<5= 5: %5F3= :85F 5F326<0 !<5D3=03 06 $ 6 <2 5=D@ 6;3837:638 6;3 ?8323=6 08<F<=7D0723;72933=83B<263834>;<0;<2;<B;D@93D7634 ;35=I9D3 1?83F35186<=6;307235: 6763 5: 76 ?787B87?;5;7259238C3472:5DD5>2 ! " # # # '$( $ - 8 - $ = 6;3 ?8323=6 0723 6;3 43D7@ 5: 79516 6;833 @3782 <= 7??8570;<=B 6;3 ?5D<03 ;72 =56 76 7DD 933= 3H?D7<=34 9@ 832?5=43=6 5$ 7=4 6;3 7DD3B76<5=2 F743 7B7<=266;3?36<6<5=382;383<=>;57836;30D52383D76<C32 5: 7001234 5 783 5F=<912 <= =76183 =438 6;3 0<801F267=032 7F 5: 6;3 5?<=<5= 6;76 6;3 <F?1B=34 08<F<=7D?850334<=B2<2D<79D36593A172;3400584<=BD@ :5DD5><=B58438<2?72234 <( ;308<F<=7D?36<6<5=<27DD5>34 <<( ;3 3=6<83 ?850334<=B2 <= 5. $$ ?3=4<=B 93:583 6;3 5186 5: <C<D #14B3 7=4 #+ ;7DE< <478 4<268<06 78<2<=B 516 5: 8<F3 5 $$ 83B<263834 9@ ;7DE< 5>= &5D<03 676<5= <478 :58 6;3 5::3=032 ?1=<2;79D3 1=438 306<5=2 ). $ ) 7=4 8374 ><6; 306<5= ). 5: & 72 - 9 - 7B7<=26 6;3 ?36<6<5=382 7001234 52$ 65 267=42A172;34 -+ ($ %! * ! <265 D5 &