- 1 - ! "!# $"" %%&'( ) * ! " "" " #$# % "&"! ' (& ( ( )( (&' Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! (& (! * ! " '# ( )( (&' % "& " ! + ' ! '$' ! & * ','$ "& ! ! ',' & * & * ! ( ( -" " ( -" ' ./01 2./03.1 45637.2 850 9:. /;;.22/39 3760/34. 5<;/3= ".>3? /??0>.@.1 A= 9:. B61?<.39 /31 /C/01 1/9.1','$;/77.1>3! 5','539:.8>2. 589:. 5609589:..3>50 >@>261?./31 :50/;60 - 3 - 850 7:509 D0>A63/2E 3760/34. 5<;/3= >7 A.850. 9:>7 5609 F6.79>53>3? 9:. 2>/A>2>9= /31 F6/396< 58 45<;.37/9>53501.0.1A=9:.0>A63/2>39:.42/><;.9>9>53 8>2.1A=0.7;531.39 5':.0.>3:.3760/34. 5<;/3= C/7/00/=.1/70.7;531.39 5>39:.42/><;.9>9>53 :. 8/496/2 </90>G 58 9:. 4/7. >7 9:/9 9:. ;.9>9>53.042/></39 /31 :>7 C>8. 53 $'' /9 /A569 ' ;< /9 6<A/0;.9 0577 A5/01.1 / ..; A./0>3? 5' # 10>@.3 A= >97 5C3.0 C:5 C/7 /00/=.1 /7 0.7;531.39 5' >3 9:. 42/>< ;.9>9>53 95 ?5 95 9:.>0 @>22/?.A6916.95:>73.?2>?.3910>@>3?9:.7/>1B..;<.9 C>9: /3 /44>1.39 7 / 0.7629 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 /31 :>7 C>8. 7688.0.1 >3B60>.7 /31 9:.= C.0. /1<>99.1 95 9:. :57;>9/2 85090./9<.39:.0./89.0;.9>9>53.0/;;05/4:.10>A63/2 7..H>3?45<;.37/9>5353/445639589:.>3B60>.77679/>3.1 A=:>< ".850. 0>A63/2 9:. ;.9>9>53 C/7 5;;57.1 A= 0.7;531.39 53760/34. 5<;/3= 4539.31>3? 9:/9 9:. @.:>42. C/7 67.1 850 :>0. ;60;57. /31 ;.9>9>53.0 :/1 - 4 - A5/01.1 9:. 7/<. /9 9:. A67795; /7 / 8/0. ;/=>3? ;/77.3?.0C:>4:>7 359 ;.0<>99.1 >3 9:. 7/>1 @.:>42. 9 C/7/2754539.31.19:/99:.45<;.37/9>5342/><.1A=9:. ;.9>9>53.0 C/7 :>?:2= .G50A>9/39 63></?>3/0= /31 639.3/A2. >3 2/C :67 4539.31>3? 9:/9 9:. 9.0<7 /31 4531>9>537 58 9:. ;52>4= :/7 A..3 @>52/9.1 9:. 3760/34. 5<;/3=0.7>79.19:.;.9>9>53 89.0 80/<>3? /;;05;0>/9. >776.7 9:. 0>A63/2 A=>97B61?<.39:/7:.219:/99:.0.>7359:>3?530.450195 7:5C9:/99:.@.:>42.C/7A.>3?67.1850:>0./319:/99:. ;.9>9>53.0 C/7 / ?0/96>9567 ;/77.3?.0 44.;9>3? 9:. 1>7/A>2>9=79/9.1A=*/9'I9:.0>A63/2:/7/C/01.1 45<;.37/9>53 58 7$ C>9: >39.0.79 /9 #I ;.0 /336<805<9:.1/9.58;.9>9>539>220./2>J/9>53631.09:. 85225C>3?:./17( - 5 - 2 5 ./17 <5639 ' 577 58 86960. >345<. 16. 951>7/A>2>9= 7$ 57758/<.3>9>.7 7 />3/31688.0>3?7 7 551 560>7:<.39 /31 53@.=/34. 7' .1>4/2 G;.37.7 7'$' # 577 >345<. 160>3? 90./9<.39 7 $ 99.31/39 :/0?.7 7 59/2 7$',' 5631.1588 7$ # *:>2. 45<>3? 95 764: 4534267>53 9:. 0>A63/2 955H>3954537>1.0/9>539:..@>1.34.758*'K;.9>9>53.0 /31 9:. 54950 .G/<>3.1 /7 * C:5 /77.77.1 9:. 1>7/A>2>9= G7'95'/319:.9.79><53=589:.5C3.0 46<10>@.0 58 9:. B..; /7 C.22 /7 /3 588>4>/2 58 9:. 3760/34. 5<;/3= - 6 - $ ./03.1 45637.2 0> 6A:/7: /22/;60 /;;./0>3? 850 9:. /;;.22/393760/34. 5<;/3= 76A<>97 9:/99:.40577.G/<>3/9>5358*'/319:.45<;2/>398>2.1 A=9:.;.9>9>53.0A.850.9:.4534.03.152>4.1>74257.9:/9 C:>2.;.9>9>53.0/31:>7C>8.C.0.0.9603>3?/89.0/99.31>3? </00>/?. 58 9:.>0 0.2/9>@. 9:.= C.0. C/>9>3? /9 9:. A67 795; 0.7;531.39 5' ;.9>9>53.0 A5/01.1 9:. 7/>1 B..; /78/0.;/=>3?;/77.3?.0C:>4:>7/?/>3799:.9.0<7/31 4531>9>537589:.;52>4=9>776A<>99.19:/9850@>52/9>53 58764:9.0<7/314531>9>537589:.;52>4=9:.3760/34. 5<;/3= >7 359 2>/A2. 95 ;/= 9:. 45<;.37/9>53 >7 7.4531 ;053? 58 9:. /0?6<.39 >7 9:/9 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 >7 79/9.1 95 :/@. 7688.0.1 / 1>7/A>2>9= 58 'I /7 5;>3.1 A= */319:.3/960.589:.>3B60>.715.735976??.799:/9 9:. 7/<. >7 95 A. /44.;9.1 850 86349>53/2 1>7/A>2>9= /275 :.0.850. 9:.F6/396< 58 9:. 45<;.37/9>53 /C/01.1A= 9:. 0>A63/2 >7 1>7;69.1 A= 9:. 3760/34. 5<;/3= /31 9:.7/<.A.0./77.77.1A=9:>7 5609 - 7 - :. ;.067/2 58 9:. 40577.G/<>3/9>53 58 9:. *'7:5C79:/9:.C/7359/8/0.;/=>3?;/77.3?.09>7 79/9.1 A= *' 9:/9 C:.3 :. C/7 79/31>3? /96<A/0;.9 0577 /3 .<;9= B..; 4/<. 9:.0. /31 5C3.0 58 9:. 7/>1 B..; C/7 H35C3 95 :>< 850 # =./07 /31 :>7 3/<. C/7 /9>2.79/9.79:/9:.:/1/4F6/>39/34.C>9:9:.5C3.0 589:.B..;/319:.0.850.9:.B..;10>@.0795;;.19:.B..; /31 :. A5/01.1 9:. 7/>1 B..; :. 40577.G/<>3/9>53 8/>2.1 95 .2>4>9 9:/9 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 C/7 / 8/0. ;/=>3? ;/77.3?.0 :. 76??.79>53 </1. 95 *' 9:/9 :. C/7 / 8/0. ;/=>3? ;/77.3?.0 :/1 A..3 1.3>.1 A= :>< :.0.850.9:.40577.G/<>3/9>53589:.*'>735958/3= /77>79/34.959:.3760/34. 5<;/3=954539.319:/99:. ;.9>9>53.0C/7/8/0.;/=>3?;/77.3?.0/31/7764::.>7/ ?0/96>9567;/77.3?.0 , ;.067/2 58 9:. 45<;2/>39 A= *' C5621 /275 7:5C9:/99:.;.9>9>53.0:/142./02=79/9.1>3:>745<;2/>39 9:/9 C:.3 :. C/7 /9 6<A/0;.9 0577 9:. B..; 4/<. 9:.0./31:.A5/01.19:.7/<.:.45<;2/>39/27515.7 - 8 - 359 7:5C /3=9:>3? C:>4: C5621 0.31.0 :>< / ?0/96>9567 ;/77.3?.0589:.B..;:.0.850.35>39.08.0.34.4/3A. </1.>39:.4534267>53589:.0>A63/29:/99:.;.9>9>53.0 C/7 359 / ?0/96>9567 ;/77.3?.0 /31 /7 764: 9:. 3760/34. 5<;/3= >7 2>/A2. 95 ;/= 9:. 45<;.37/9>53 95 :>< ' /7 9:. F6/396< 58 45<;.37/9>53 >7 4534.03.1 9:. 2./03.1 45637.2 850 9:. /;;.22/39 C5621 76A<>9 9:/9 9:. 3/960. 58 9:. >3B60>.7 7679/>3.1 A= *' /31 9:. .@>1.34. 58 9:. * C5621 7:5C 9:/9 /3 .G50A>9/391>7/A>2>9=>779/9.1A=*:.;.067/2589:. *5631 .09>8>4/9./9 GC56217:5C9:/99:.;.9>9>53.0 C/7 /1<>99.1 95 .1>4/0. 57;>9/2 /31 :. C/7 5;.0/9.1 850 #>77.495<= C>9: >37>96 8>G/9>53 9 C/7 5;>3.1 9:/9>9C/7/?0>.@567>3B60=:.>74:/0?.6<<.0=/9 G#/2757:5C79:.7/<. '' :. 9.79><53= 58 9:. * 456;2.1 C>9: 9:. >7/A>2>9= .09>8>4/9./9 G$C56217:5C9:/9:.C/7359 9:.54950C:590./9.19:.;.9>9>53.0/9/3=;5>39589><. - 9 - . 532= /77.77.1 9:. 1>7/A>2>9= 58 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 /31 :. 5;>3.1/7A.25C( ! " " # " $%& " $ # " # # " $%& ' " # " " ( & " ) - 10 - ' :. 0>A63/2 >3 9:. ><;6?3.1 B61?<.39 :/7 :.21 9:/9 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 :/7 7679/>3.1 9:. 86349>53/2 1>7/A>2>9= 58 'I A= /44.;9>3? 9:. 5;>3>53 58 * 9 >7 .@>1.39 9:/9 9:. >74:/0?. 6<</0= /9 G# /31 9:. 59:.00.45017153597:5C9:/99:.0.C/7/3=>3B60=959:. 7;>3/245015C.@.0/89.01>77.495<=58 #@.09.A0/ * 79/9.7 9:/9 :. /77.77.1 9:. 1>7/A>2>9= /31 :. :/7 85631 C./H3.77 /7 79/9.1 /A5@. :. ;.9>9>53.0 79/9.7 9:/9 :. C/7 / 552>. 9:.0.850. 9:. /A5@. >3B60>.7 7679/>3.1A=:><:/@./88.49.1:>7./03>3?7/7 552>. ' :. ;.9>9>53.0 C/7 /?.1 /A569 =./07 /7 53 9:.1/9.589:./44>1.39 537>1.0>3?9:./?./@54/9>53 /319:.3/960.589:.>3B60>.77679/>3.1A=9:.;.9>9>53.0 /7 C.22 /7 9:. 9.79><53= 58 * >9 /;;./07 9:/9 9:. 0>A63/245621359:/@.B679/11.19:.1>7/A>2>9=58I95 9:. 2><A /31 I 95C/017 9:. 2><>9/9>53 58 9:. 0/3?. 58 <5@.<.397 /31 79>883.77 58 9:. 3.4H 9 >7 ;.09>3.39 95 359.9:/9.G4.;99:.5;>3>5358*9:.0.>7359:>3?.27. 530.4501957:5C9:/99:.1>7/A>2>9=959:.6;;.02><AC/7 - 11 - I/313.4H<5@.<.39:/7/27545390>A69.1I:. 4/2462/9>53/795:5C*/00>@.1/9/1>7/A>2>9=58'I>7 359 H35C3 .34. A= 4537>1.0>3? 9:. 3/960. 58 9:. >3B60= 9:. 1>7/A>2>9= 79/9.1 A= * /31 9:. /@54/9>53 58 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 9:. 86349>53/2 1>7/A>2>9= >7 0./77.77.1 A= 9:>7 5609/9I ' 9 >7 7..3 9:/9 9:. 0>A63/2 :/7 /77.77.1 9:. 359>53/2>345<./97#;.0<539::.?6>1.2>3.7 >776.1A=9:./03/9/H/9/9..?/2.0@>4.769:50>9=850 7.992.<.39589:.1>7;69.7A.850.9:.5H1/2/9;0.740>A. 9:.359>53/2 >345<. 58 7 850 9:. =./0 ' 3 6<;9..336<A.0581.4>7>5379:>7 5609:/7:.219:/99:. ?6>1.2>3.7 >776.1A= /0. :.21 95 A. /44.;9/A2. 53 9:. ?05631 9:/9 9:.= /0. >3 ?.3.0/2 453850<>9= C>9: 9:. <>3><6< C/?.7 8>G.1 631.0 9:. >3><6< */?.7 49 :.0.850. 9:. 359>53/2 >345<. 58 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 >7 95 A. 9/H.3/77$;.0<539: ' :.0.850. /44.;9>3? 9:. 359>53/2 >345<. 58 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 /9 G$ ;.0 <539: 9/H>3? 9:. - 12 - 1>7/A>2>9= /9 I /31 A= /15;9>3? 9:. <629>;2>.0 58 D'#E 9:.45<;.37/9>53631.09:.:./15825775886960.>345<. >70.4/2462/9.1/7631.0( 7$G'G'#GIL7$# '# :. 45<;.37/9>53 /C/01.1 A= 9:. 0>A63/2 631.0 59:.0 :./17 15.7 359 0.F6>0. /3= >39.08.0.34. .34. 9:. ;.9>9>53.0 >7 .39>92.1 850 45<;.37/9>53 /7 631.0( 2 5 ./17 C/01 A= 9:. 0>A63/2 C/01A=9:>7 5609 ' 5775886960.>345<. 16.951>7/A>2>9= 7$ 7$# 57758/<.3>9>.7 7 7 />3/31688.0>3?7 7 7 551 560>7:<.39 /31 53@.=/34. 7' 7' .1>4/2 G;.37.7 7'$' 7'$' # 577 >345<. 160>3? 90./9<.39 7 7 $ 99.31/39 :/0?.7 7 7 7$ 7#' - 13 - '$ 509:./850.7/>10./75379:./;;./21.7.0@.1 95A./225C.1>3;/09.34.9:.85225C>3?( > :. >3;/09 >> :.42/></390.7;531.39 5':.0.>3>7.39>92.1 85045<;.37/9>53587#'C>9:>39.0.79 /99:.0/9.58#I;.0/336<805<9:.1/9.58 ;.9>9>539>220./2>J/9>53>379./1587$ /C/01.1A=9:.0>A63/2 >>> :.0.79589:.9.0<7/314531>9>5370.?/01>3? 1.;57>9 /31 .94 501.0.1 A= 9:. 0>A63/2 0.</>363/29.0.1 >@ :. /<5639 >3 1.;57>9 A.850. 9:>7 5609 >7 501.0.1 95 A. 7.39 A/4H 95 9:. 0>A63/2 8509:C>9: 1 '" ) " " >79 5('2 5( (