Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10187 (KAR)

SURESH S/O BHIMASHI YATNAL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200115/2022 · 2025-01-13

Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$! % #$!! $"" & '&(")*'&)) + !!" # $ ""% & & ' !!" """" & !(" # $ " """"% Digitally signed by SWETA KULKARNI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & )( $*% & """ & & )!"!*"**! """ +*!( " , , & &&& )*) ) ) $%*!& """ & " & - " " - " !$ $- " % ./ 011/22034 .05 672/8 4.75 011/02 0907354 4./ :;89</34 =6 >=3?7>47=3 038 =@8/@ =6 5/34/3>/ 804/8 )!"!*"**! 1055/8 73 /557=35 05/ =" +*!( AB 4./ 882" /557=35 ;89/ $./@/73064/@ @/6/@@/8 4= 05 C2/0@3/8 /557=35 ;89/D 6=@ 5.=@4% 7:0B01;@0 E./@/73 4./ 2/0@3/8 /557=3 ;89/ >=3?7>4/8 4./ 0>>;5/8 6=@ 4./ - 3 - =66/3>/51;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=35) )) F)**! =6 038 5/34/3>/8 .7< 4= ;38/@9= @79=@=;5 7<1@75=3</34 6=@ 276/ 038 87@/>4/8 4= 10B 0 673/ =6 5"*F 73 8/60;24 =6 10B</34 =6 673/ 4= 6;@4./@ ;38/@9= 57<12/ 7<1@75=3</34 6=@ 0 1/@7=8 =6 57G <=34.5 6=@ 4./ =66/3>/ 1;375.0A2/ ;38/@ />47=3 )* =6 " >>;5/8 75 6;@4./@ 5/34/3>/8 4= ;38/@9= @79=@=;5 7<1@75=3</34 6=@ 0 1/@7=8 =6 4.@// <=34.5 038 ./ 75 87@/>4/8 4= 10B 0 673/ =6 5"!F 73 8/60;24 =6 10B</34 =6 673/ 6;@4./@ 87@/>4/8 4= ;38/@9= 57<12/ 7<1@75=3</346=@01/@7=8=64.@//<=34.56=@4./=66/3>/ 1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=3) )=6 "./0>>;5/875025= 87@/>4/8 4= ;38/@9= @79=@=;5 7<1@75=3</34 6=@ 276/ 038 7<1=5/8 0 673/ =6 5"*F 73 8/60;24 =6 10B</34 =6 673/87@/>4/84=;38/@9=57<12/7<1@75=3</346=@01/@7=8 57G<=34.56=@4./=66/3>/1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=3) F =6 " ./ 0>>;5/8 75 025= 87@/>4/8 4= ;38/@9= @79=@=;5 7<1@75=3</346=@01/@7=8=64.@//B/0@50387<1=5/8673/ =6 5"!F 73 8/60;24 =6 10B</34 =6 673/ 87@/>4/8 4= ;38/@9=57<12/7<1@75=3</346=@01/@7=8=64.@//<=34.5 - 4 - 6=@4./=66/3>/1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=3*!=6 " 475 025=87@/>4/84.040224./5/34/3>/55.022@;3>=3>;@@/342B" *" ./ A@7/6 60>45 E.7>. 2/8 4= 4./ 4@702 =6 4./ 011/22034F0>>;5/80@/056=22=E5 ""! 75 4./ 604./@ =6 8/>/05/8 H5.0B 2=89/8 0 >=<120734A/6=@/4./@/51=38/34=27>/=3*!"+"*!05 1/@ G""! 022/9739 4.04 ./ E05 @/578739 73 4./ .=;5/ =6 =3/.03H0@ 04302""(=3@/3402A057502=39E74. .7560<72B" B0?=>047=3./E0503;4=F7>H5.0E8@7?/@" 755=3H5.0B$3=E8/>/05/8734.75>05/%E0554;8B739 73 )@8 540380@8 73 0@04.7 >.==2 3/0@ .7?0:7 7@>2/" 3 *"+"*!040A=;4"1"<"8/>/05/8H5.0BE/34=;4 4= 120B 6=22=E739 E.7>. ./ 3/?/@ @/4;@3/8" ./ >=<12073034D5E76/736=@</8.7<0A=;44./7@<755739>.728 =?/@0>022"./@/064/@""!02=39E74..75E76/5/0@>./8 6=@4./7@5=30386=;383=4@0>/5=6.7<"1=3/3I;7@739 E74. 4./ @/2047?/5 04 HH02H=4 ;<A07 038 033;@ 73 6J021;@02;H038029.034./B673022B@/5=@4/84=2=89/ 0<755739>=<120734A/6=@/4./ =6=27>/4047=3 - 5 - 051/@G""!040A=;4)1"<"./5078>=<120734>0</ 4=A/@/9754/@/873@7</="**!AB4./=27>/ 6=@4./=66/3>/1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=3) )=6 051/@ G""! 0907354 ;3H3=E3 1/@5=35" ;A5/I;/342B =3 4./ 6=22=E73980B7"/"**"+"*!""!@/>/7?/804/2/1.=3/ >022 6@=< 4./ H783011/@ 8/<038739 0 @035=< =6 5"*F4=@/2/05/.755=3"""!87?;29/84./5078 8/?/2=1</34 4= 4./ @/51=38/34=27>/" ""!!F4./ 4./3 @/51=38/34=27>/ >=38;>4/8 03 73?/5479047=3 AB 0302BJ739 4./ >022 @/9754/@ =6 4./ <=A72/ 3;<A/@ A/0@739 +()!*)+)=64./>=<12073034""!038025=0302BJ/8 4./ >0225 ./ @/>/7?/8 6@=< 4./ H783011/@" 3 0302BJ739 ""!! >0</ 4= H3=E 4.04 4./ ""! .05 @/>/7?/8 @035=< >022 6@=< 4./ <=A72/ 3;<A/@ 7"/" +()**()" >>=@87392B""!!>=38;>4/873?/5479047=3AB6738739=;4 4./;5/@=64./5078<=A72/03874E05 @/?/02/84.04=3/ .03H0@ 04302 7"/" 4./ ;3>2/ =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 7"/" ""( E05;57394./5078<=A72/3;<A/@"3/3I;7@739.03H0@ ./ 73 4;@3 @/?/02/8 4.04 4./ 0>>;5/8 E05 @/578739 02=39 E74..7<=34./67@5462==@=64./.=;5/E./@/""!E05 - 6 - @/578739038./6;@4./@5404/84.044./0>>;5/8E05;5739 4./ 5078 <=A72/ 038 4.04 ./ E05 0A5>=38739 6=@ 4./ 2054 4E= 80B5 7"/" 6@=< **"+"*!" &=22=E739 E.7>. 4./ @/51=38/34=27>/ 011@/./38/8 4./ 0>>;5/8 =3 *"+"*!"3/3I;7@B4./=27>/@/>=@8/84./?=2;340@B 5404/</34 =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 05 1/@ G""! E./@/73 4./ 0>>;5/8@/?/02/84.04=3*"+"*!040A=;41"<" ./ H783011/8 4./ 5=3 =6 ""! <054/@ H5.0B 6@=< 0<A0209057038./4==H.7<4=B=4771/&0>4=@B038 <;@8/@/8 .7< AB 0550;24739" ./@/064/@ ./ 8751=5/8 4./ >=@15/ AB 4.@=E739 74 3/0@ 4./ .722 54047=3 >2=5/@ 4= 4./ 60>4=@B" / 6;@4./@ @/?/02/8 4.04 ./ >=?/@/8 4./ >=@15/ E74.57J/54=3/5038025=08<744/84.04./E=;285.=E4./ 120>/=6A;@702" )" ./@/064/@ 4./ 0>>;5/8 2/8 4./ 3?/5479047=3 667>/@"5"!4=)0384./55754034=<<7557=3/@4=4./ 120>/ =6 A;@702" B @/<=?739 4./ 57J/ 54=3/5 ./ 5.=E/8 4./ >=@15/ =6 4./ 5=3 =6 ""!" >>=@87392B 4./ @/51=38/34=27>/>=38;>4/84./73?/5479047=3AB8@0E739 - 7 - @/2/?034 <0.0J0@5" "5"! 038 ) 4./ 10@/345 =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 78/34767/8 4./ >=@15/ =6 4./7@ 5=3 A05/8 =3 4./ >2=4./5 ./ E=@3 04 4./ 47</ =6 <755739" ;A5/I;/342B ""!)E74.4./1/@<7557=3=64./:;@7587>47=30209754@04/ 73?=H/8 />47=35 ) F 038 )* =6 73 4./ >@7</038 >=38;>4/8 6;@4./@ 73?/5479047=3" 64/@ @/>=@8739 4./ 5404/</34 =6 4./ E743/55/5 038 =A4073739 3/>/550@B 8=>;</3456@=<4./>=3>/@3/80;4.=@747/5""!)20784./ >.0@9/F5.//4 0907354 4./ 0>>;5/8 6=@ 4./ =66/3>/5 1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=35) )) F)*038*!=6 A/6=@/4./>=<<74402>=;@4" " 3 >=<<74402 =6 4./ >05/ A/6=@/ 4./ 2/0@3/8 /557=35;89/4./2/0@3/8/557=35;89/.0?7396=;38 1@7<060>7/>05/09073544./0>>;5/86@0</84./>.0@9/5 6=@4./06=@/</347=3/8=66/3>/5"./0>>;5/812/08/83=4 9;724B4=4./>.0@9/5038>207</84=A/4@7/8" " 3 =@8/@ 4= 1@=?/ 4./ >.0@9/5 2/?/2/8 0907354 4./ 0>>;5/8 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 73 4=402 /G0<73/8 !) E743/55/5 A/6=@/ 4./ /557=35 =;@4 05 F! 4= F!) - 8 - <0@H/8)8=>;</34505G5"F!4=F)03878/34767/8( <04/@702=A:/>4505"5F!4=(" " 64/@ >=<12/47=3 =6 1@=5/>;47=3 /?78/3>/ 4./ 2/0@3/8 /557=35 ;89/ @/08 =?/@ 4./ 73>@7<7304739 /?78/3>/ =6 4./ <04/@702 E743/55/5 4= 4./ 0>>;5/8 05 5471;204/8 ;38/@ />47=3 )!) =6 @""" =E/?/@ 4./ 0>>;5/88/37/84./50</"./8/6/3>/=64./0>>;5/875 =3/=64=4028/37020384.04=66025/7<127>047=3"=E/?/@ 4./0>>;5/83/74./@/G0<73/803BE743/553=@9=4<0@H/8 03B8=>;</345=3.75A/.026" (" 64/@ 055/55</34 =6 4./ =@02 038 8=>;</340@B /?78/3>/ 120>/8 A/6=@/ 4./ /557=35 ;89/ 4./ 2/0@3/8 /557=35 ;89/ >=3?7>4/8 4./ 0>>;5/8 6=@ 4./ >.0@9/5 2/?/2/8 0907354 .7< 038 5/34/3>/8 .7< 05 5404/8 " ./5078:;89</3475>.022/39/8;38/@4.75011/02" " / .0?/ ./0@8 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./ 011/22034@7 ""0H00382/0@3/888747=302404/;A27> @=5/>;4=@6=@4./@/51=38/34F404/" - 9 - +" ./ 1@7<0@B >=34/347=3 =6 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./ 011/22034 75 4.04 4./ :;89</34 >.022/39/8 ;38/@ 4.75011/025;66/@56@=<1/@?/@574B038722/90274B573>/4./ 2/0@3/8 /557=35 ;89/ 6072/8 4= 011@/>704/ 4./ /?78/3>/ =3 @/>=@8 73 0 @79.4 1/@51/>47?/" / 6;@4./@ >=34/38/8 4.044./1@=5/>;47=3.05;44/@2B6072/84=1@=?/4./9;724=6 4./ 0>>;5/8 A/B=38 @/05=30A2/ 8=;A4 05 4./ /347@/ >05/ @/545=3>7@>;<54034702/?78/3>/0384./@/753=4037=40=6 /?78/3>/273H7394=4./>@7</05@/27/8AB4./1@=5/>;47=3" ./ 2/0@3/8 /557=35 ;89/ >=3?7>4/8 4./ 0>>;5/8 A05/8 =3 5;@<75/5 038 >=3:/>4;@/ E74.=;4 011@/>704739 4./ /?78/3>/ 73 @79.4 1/@51/>47?/" >>=@8739 4= .7< 4./ 2/0@3/8/557=35;89/>=3?7>4/84./0>>;5/85=2/2BA05/8 =3/?78/3>/=6"5"!038)7"/"4./604./@038<=4./@=6 4./8/>/05/8E.=0@/4././0@50BE743/554=4./73>78/34" ""*4./03>.E743/554.=;9.5;11=@4/84./>05/=64./ 1@=5/>;47=3 =3 1/@;502 =6 .75 /?78/3>/ 4./ 8@0E739 =6 @/2/?034 <0.0J0@5 04 4./ 120>/ =6 73>78/34 038 025= 4./ 120>/ E./@/ 4./ >=@15/ E05 @/>=?/@/8 04 4./ 735403>/ =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 0@/ 3=4 8@0E3 05 1/@ 20E 038 4./@/ 75 0 - 10 - >=34@087>47=3734.//?78/3>/=6""*0384./>=34/345=6 4./<0.0J0@5" !" ./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 5;A<744/8 4.04 4./ 2054 5//3 E743/55 "" .05 3=4 >=<1@/./357?/2B 5;11=@4/8 4./ >05/ =6 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 038 4./@/ 75 03 73=@87304/ 8/20B73@/>=@8739.755404/</34"55;>.4./1@=5/>;47=3 >=22/>47?/2B 6072/8 4= 1@=?/ 4./ >7@>;<5403>/ =6 2054 5//3 4./=@B" &;@4./@ 4./@/ 0@/ <04/@702 >=34@087>47=35 038 =<7557=35734.//?78/3>/=6"5"!038)@/90@87394./7@ <755739>.7285=025=4./10@47>71047=3=64./0>>;5/8734./ >@7</ AB 8/<038739 @035=<" ./ <=A72/ 3;<A/@ 1@=8;>/8AB""!038=4./@736=@<047=3=6.75@/>/7?7390 @035=< >022 AB 4./ 0>>;5/8 75 >=22/>47?/2B 3=4 1@=?/8 05 4./ >022 @/9754/@ 1@=8;>/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 75 572/34 =3 >0228/40725" 35;>.>7@>;<5403>/54./2/0@3/8/557=35 ;89//@@/8E.72/>=3?7>47394./0>>;5/86=@4./=66/3>/5 1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=35) F038)*=6 "&;@4./@ ./>=34/38/84.044./1@=5/>;47=3025=6072/84=1@=?/4./ >7@>;<5403>/ =6 78/3476B739 4./ >=@15/ AB "5"! 038 ) - 11 - 7"/" 10@/345 =6 4./ 8/>/05/8" 73>/ 4./B 78/34767/8 4./ >=@15/=32BA05/8=34./>2=4./57"/"4./5.7@40384@=;5/@ E=@3AB4./8/>/05/8=34./804/=6<755739"=E/?/@74 754./51/>767>>05/=6 3?/547904739667>/@0384./=>4=@ 4.04 4./ >=@15/ E05 4=4022B 8/>=<1=5/8" 3 5;>. >7@>;<5403>/4./1@=5/>;47=3.050A:/>42B6072/84=1@=?/ 4./ 9;724 =6 4./ 0>>;5/8" >>=@87392B ./ 1@0B5 4= 022=E 4./ 011/02 AB 5/44739 0578/ 4./ 7<1;93/8 :;89</34 =6 >=3?7>47=3038=@8/@=65/34/3>/" !!" /6;4739 4./ 0A=?/ 5;A<7557=35 <08/ AB 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./ 011/22034 4./ 2/0@3/8 88747=302 >=34/3854.044./:;89</34>.022/39/8734.75011/02 3/74./@ 5;66/@5 6@=< 1/@?/@574B 3=@ 722/90274B 038 3= /G>/147=3>03A/40H/36@=<4./:;89</341055/8AB4./ /557=35 =;@4 6=@ 4./ @/05=35 7387>04/8 AB 4./ /557=35 =;@4 ;38/@ 4./ E/22 @/05=3/8 :;89</34" ./ /?78/3>/ .05 025= A//3 0302BJ/8 73 0 9@/04 8/4072 AB 4./ /557=35 =;@4"./@/6=@/3=I;/547=3=603B734/@6/@/3>/75>022/8 6=@ E74. 4./ >=3?7>47=3 =@8/@ @/>=@8/8 73 4./ 7<1;93/8 - 12 - :;89</34" B /3;3>704739 .75 5;A<7557=3 4./ 2/0@3/8 882"0@9;/84.044.//?78/3>/=6"5"!038)7"/" 10@/345=64./8/>/05/8>04/9=@7>022B/540A275./84./60>4 4.04 4./ 0>>;5/8 75 5=2/2B @/51=357A2/ 6=@ 4./ H78301 038 <;@8/@ =6 4./7@ 5=3 H5.0B" &;@4./@ 4./ 0>>;5/8 025= 8/<038/8 @035=< 6@=< ""!" ./ 5078 051/>4 75 0667@<047?/2B 1@=?/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 AB 120>739 4./ /?78/3>/=64./>022@/9754/@8/40725038025=AB120>7394./ >/@4767>04/ ;38/@ />47=3 =6 4./ 36=@<047=3 />.3=2=9B >4 6@=< 4./ >=3>/@3/8 =667>/@ =6 4./ 7@4/2 =<103B"&;@4./@4./0>>;5/8.7<5/262/84./=27>/038 "5"!4=)0384./55754034=<<7557=3/@F""!*4=4./ 120>/=6A;@702=64./>=@15/03804.75735403>/4./>=@15/ =64./8/>/05/8E05@/>=?/@/8".7517?=402>7@>;<5403>/ .05;30<A79;=;52B1@=?/84./>.0@9/52/?/2/809073544./ 0>>;5/8" / 6;@4./@ >=34/38/8 4.04 4./ 2054 5//3 4./=@B ;38/@ 4./ >7@>;<54034702 /?78/3>/ 75 025= 1@=?/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3AB/G0<73739""E.=>04/9=@7>022B5404/8 4.04 ./ .08 5//3 4./ 0>>;5/8 038 4./ 8/>/05/8 =3 *"!"*! 3/0@ 4./ 120>/ 6@=< E./@/ 4./ >=@15/ E05 - 13 - @/>=?/@/8"2A/744./@/758/20B73@/>=@8739.755404/</34 4./ 5078 8/20B E05 08/I;04/2B /G12073/8 AB """ &;@4./@ 4./ <=47?/ 6=@ 4./ 73>78/34 7"/" 0<=;34 8/<038/8 AB 4./ 0>>;5/8 75 1@=?/8 AB 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 ""! 038 4./ >022 8/40725 7"/" G""*(" 3 5;>. >7@>;<5403>/ 4./ 2/0@3/8 882" 5;A<744/8 4.04 4./ <73=@>=34@087>47=35734.//?78/3>/=6<04/@702/?78/3>/ 8=/5 3=4 9= 4= 4./ @==4 =6 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 >05/ 038 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3>2/0@2B1@=?/84./9;724=64./0>>;5/8A/B=38 022 @/05=30A2/ 8=;A4 038 4./ 011/02 8/5/@?/5 4= A/ 875<755/8" !*" 0?739 ./0@8 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./ 011/22034 5= 025= 4./ 2/0@3/8 882" 038 025= 064/@ 1/@;502 =6 4./ /347@/ /?78/3>/ =3 @/>=@8 4./ 1=7345 4.04 0@75/6=@=;@>=3578/@047=30@/ - 14 - ! "#$ $#%&'( !)" /.0?/738/1/38/342B0302BJ/84.//347@/=@02 038 8=>;</340@B /?78/3>/ =3 @/>=@8 73 =@8/@ 4= 011@/>704/ 4./ @/51/>47?/ >=34/347=3 =6 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./ 10@47/5" /6=@/ 8/2?739 734= 0302BJ739 4./ /?78/3>/=3@/>=@8055404/85;1@04.75>05/4=4022B@/545 ;1=3 >7@>;<54034702 /?78/3>/" 5 1/@ 4./ 5/442/8 1=5747=3 =6 20E 2078 8=E3 AB 4./ =3DA2/ 1/G =;@4 E0B A0>H 73 4./B/0@!++)7"/"734./>05/=6 @/1=@4/8 73 4./ =3DA2/1/G=;@47310@09@01.=" ./2805;38/@ K& ) * * * & * ) - 15 - + * ( * * , * - , , * !" ./ 1@73>712/5 /3;3>704/8 73 4./ 0A=?/ >05/ 75 025=@/74/@04/8734./>05/=6 @/1=@4/8 73 ! 038=3DA2/1/G=;@420784./9=28/31@73>712/54= 1@=?/4./>05/A05/8=3>7@>;<54034702/?78/3>/"./5078 1@73>712/5 025= @/74/@04/8 73 4./ @/>/34 :;89</34 =6 4./ =3DA2/1/G=;@4734./>05/=6 " @/1=@4/8 73 #$# %& #! E./@/73 4./ =3DA2/ 1/G =;@4 .05 5;<<0@7J/8 4./ 9;78/273/5 4= >=3?7>4 4./ 0>>;5/8 73 4./ >05/ E.7>. 0@/ A05/8=3>7@>;<54034702/?78/3>/" - 16 - !" //173973<7384./0A=?/1@73>712/5E./3E/ 0302BJ/4.//?78/3>/=3@/>=@8038025=4./>7@>;<54034702 /?78/3>/ @/27/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 4./ 6=22=E739 051/>45 0@/8@0E=;@>=3578/@047=3 $7%,- ,./0/123 1-24, 1-0-25-1 65,27 3 =@8/@ 4= 1@=?/ 4./ .=<7>7802 8/04. =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 .05 @/27/8 =3 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 "+F8=>4=@ E.= >=38;>4/8 4./ 0;4=15B =3 4./ >=@15/ =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 038 755;/8 4./ 1=54F<=@4/< @/1=@4 05 1/@ G"!" 3 1/@;502 =6 G"! 4./ =>4=@ .05 </347=3/8 4.04 4./ 8/>/05/8 5;54073/8 /G4/@30273:;@7/505;38/@ $0% =<<;374/8 6@0>4;@/ 5//3 =?/@ 4./ =>>717402 @/97=3 /G4/38739 6@=< @79.4 <054=78 1@=>/55 4= 2/64 <054=78 1@=>/55"36;@4./@/G0<73047=3A@073 E05 27I;/67/8 038 20@9/ 3;<A/@ =6 20@?0/5//3" $A% =34;57=35//3=?/@4./03H2/@/97=3 A=4.@79.40382/64" - 17 - ! " 64/@/G0<73739""+F=>4=@.05=173/84.04 4./8/04.758;/4=C.0/<=@@.09/0385.=>H050@/5;24=6 A2;34 73:;@B 4= ?7402 =@9035 $A@073%D" "+ 8/1=5/8 73 5;11=@4=6>=34/345=6G"!".=;9.4./2/0@3/8>=;35/2 6=@4./0>>;5/8>@=55F/G0<73/8"+I;/547=37394.044./ 5>7/34767>/G0<73047=3E053=4>=38;>4/8AB03/G1/@44./ =>4=@5404/84.044./@/753=3//8=65;>.03/G0<73047=3 4= 5404/ 4./ >0;5/ =6 8/04." 5 5;>. 4./@/ 75 0 >2/0@ >=@@=A=@047=3A/4E//34./4/547<=3B=6"+038>=34/345 =6 G"!" &;@4./@ 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 025= @/27/8 =3 4./ 73I;/54103>.030<08@0E3=34./>=@15/=64./8/>/05/8 051/@G"(AB"!*F4./4./355754034=<<7557=3/@=6 7:0B01;@0"31/@;502=6G"(4./50</@/?/0254.044./ >=@15/E058/>=<1=5/8"./10@/345=64./8/>/05/87"/" 5"! 038 ) 78/34767/8 4./ >=@15/ =6 4./7@ 5=3 A05/8 =3 4./ >2=4./5 6=;38 =3 4./ >=@15/" "* 75 4./ 103>.0 E743/55 6=@ G"(" / 8/1=5/8 4.04 4./ 0>>;5/8 5.=E/8 4./120>/0384./<0.0J0@E058@0E34=4.04/66/>4051/@ G"! 038 025= G"( 4./ 73I;/54 <0.0J0@" &;@4./@ 5"!038)025=8/1=5/80A=;44./73:;@7/56=;38=34./ - 18 - >=@15/=64./8/>/05/8"/3>/0>=3:=734@/08739=64./ /?78/3>/ =6 "+F=>4=@ "!*F4./ 4./3 55754034 =<<7557=3/@ "*F103>.0 E743/55 6=@ G"( 038 025= 4.//?78/3>/=65"!038)>=;12/8E74.G5"!(038 !E/0@/=64./>=3578/@/8?7/E4.044./1@=5/>;47=3.05 1@=?/8 4./ .=<7>7802 8/04. =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 H5.0B A/B=38@/05=30A2/8=;A4" !(" = >=33/>4 4./ 0>>;5/8 E74. 4./ .=<7>7802 8/04. =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 @/27/8 =3 4./ 6=22=E739>7@>;<5403>/5 &2) $/55/89 4,- 1-0-25-1 319/89 0.:32/84 ;7"+2812((-544,-200<5-1" !" 5 1/@ 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 "! .75 5=3 H5.0B E05 <755739 6@=< *"+"*! 04 0A=;4 +" 0"<" 038 204/@./02=39E74..75E76/F"")5/0@>./86=@4./7@5=3 038E/@/;30A2/4=6738.7<"/3>/=34./50</379.404 0A=;41"<"./?7574/84./=27>/4047=30382=89/8 4./ <755739 >=<120734 05 1/@ G"!" 05/8 =3 4.75 4./ - 19 - @/51=38/34F=27>/ @/9754/@/8 03 & 05 1/@ G") 6=@ 4./ =66/3>/1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=3) )=6 ">>=@87394= "!=34./6=22=E73980B7"/"*!"+"*!./@/>/7?/80 >022 6@=< 03 ;3H3=E3 1/@5=3 8/<038739 0 @035=< =6 5"*F" / 5404/8 4.04 4./ H78301/@ 4.@/04/3/8 "!54047394.045.=;28./60724=.038=?/@4./@035=< 0<=;34./E722H722.755=3"&=22=E739E.7>."!736=@</8 4./50</4=4./=27>/038.038/8=?/@.75<=A72/1.=3/ 4= 4./<" >>=@87392B "!!F//30 =.03 4./ 4./3 >=38;>4/873?/5479047=3AB=A40737394./>0228/4072@/>=@85 $% =6 4./ <=A72/ 1.=3/ =6 4./ >=<12073034 7"/" +()!*)+)" &;@4./@ "!! 8/1=5/8 A/6=@/ 4./ =;@4 4.04 =3 0302BJ739 4./ =6 4./ 5078 <=A72/ 1.=3/ 3;<A/@5./2/0@344.04"!@/>/7?/80@035=<>0226@=< 4./ <=A72/ A/0@739 3;<A/@ +()**()" 5 5;>. 03 73?/5479047=3E05>=38;>4/8038"(F.03H0@ 04302E05 0@@/54/8E.=753=3/=4./@4.034./;3>2/=64./0>>;5/8" 1=3/3I;7@B"(@/?/02/84.044.=;9.4./5078<=A72/ 3;<A/@ A/2=39/8 4= .7< 4./ 50</ E05 40H/3 AB 4./ 0>>;5/8038./E05<755739573>/**"+"*!"./@/064/@ - 20 - 4.//347@/E05=A4073/8AB"!!051/@G"*(038 "!! 0@@/54/8 4./ 0>>;5/8 =3 *"+"*!" 3 6;@4./@ 73?/5479047=37475@/?/02/84.0405<03B05 >0225E/@/ @/>/7?/8 AB "! 6@=< 4./ 0A=?/F</347=3/8 <=A72/ 3;<A/@E74.7305103=6)4=80B58/<038739@035=<" 64/@0@@/54=64./0>>;5/8"!!@/>=@8/8.75?=2;340@B 5404/</34 05 1/@ G"! E./@/73 4./ 0>>;5/8 >=36/55/8 4=4./>@7</0381@=8;>/84E=<=A72/5051/@5")038 "3*!"!"*!"!90?/.756;@4./@5404/</34A/6=@/ 4./1=27>/051/@G"*E./@/73./@/74/@04/84./>=34/345 =6G"!038025=8/1=5/80A=;44./>=36/557=3<08/AB 4./0>>;5/8A/6=@/4./1=27>/04.751@/5/3>/"55;>.=3 1/@;502=64./0A=?//?78/3>/=65"!!!0384./ 1@=5/>;47=31@=?/84./>7@>;<54034702/?78/3>/=6<755739 =64./>.7282=89739=6>=<120734AB"!8/<038739=6 @035=<AB0>>;5/80380@@/54=64./0>>;5/8" - 21 - &;) -0=-(7 0(:5- 4,- 1-0-25-1 24 4,- ;-,-544,-200<5-1" !+" >>=@87394=!*4./55754034=<<7557=3/@ =6 7:0B01;@0 038 !)F4./ 3?/547904739 667>/@ 064/@ 0@@/54 =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 =3 *"+"*! .75 ?=2;340@B 5404/</34@/>=@8/8051/@G"!0384./0>>;5/8@/?/2/8 4.04 ./ E=;28 5.=E 4./ 120>/ =6 H78301 A;@702 =6 4./ >=@15/ =6 4./ 8/>/05/8" >>=@87392B ""** 5;<<=3/8 ""*4./103>.04=4./=27>/4047=35=025="5"!038 )7"/"4./10@/345=64./8/>/05/8038734./7@1@/5/3>/ 4./0>>;5/8>=36/55/8038025=2/80224./5/E743/55/54= 4./ 120>/ =6 A;@702 7"/" 3/0@ B=47 71/ &0>4=@B 038 =3 @/<=?02=64./57J/854=3/54./1=27>/6=;384./>=@15/=6 4./ 8/>/05/8 73 0 8/>=<1=5/8 5404/" 5"! 038 ) 78/34767/84./>=@15/A05/8=34./>2=4./5E=@3AB.7<04 4./47</=6.75H78301" *" &;@4./@ "!* 4./ 55754034 =<<7557=3/@ 8@/E4./73I;/54103>.030<0=34./>=@15/051/@G"(" ""* 038 =4./@ 103>.05 E/@/ 1@/5/34" !)F4./ - 22 - 3?/547904739 667>/@ 025= 8@/E 4./ <0.0J0@ 73 4./ 5078 120>/051/@G"!"""*E05?/@B<;>.1@/5/34044./ 47</=68@0E739G"!"/?/@4./2/555"!038)E/@/ 025=1@/5/3402=39E74.4./55754034=<<7557=3/@" *!" 4 75 4./ >=34/347=3 =6 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./011/220344.044./>=@15/E058/>=<1=5/8051/@4./ /?78/3>/ =6 +F=>4=@" 5 5;>. 4./@/ 75 3= 5;>. 1=557A7274B =6 78/3476B739 4./ >=@15/ AB 5"! 038 ) 7"/" 4./ 10@/345 =6 4./ 8/>/05/8" &;@4./@ ./ 5;A<744/8 4.04 4.=;9.4./A2==850<12/5E/@/8@0E36@=<5"!038) 4./@/ E05 3= 5;>. /G0<73047=3 >=38;>4/8 AB 4./ >=3>/@3/80;4.=@747/5"55;>.4./1@=5/>;47=3.056072/8 4=1@=?/4.044./>=@15/@/>=?/@/8044./735403>/=64./ 0>>;5/8A/2=3954=4./5=3=65"!038)" **" 5 875>;55/8 5;1@0 =3 1/@;502 =6 G"! 4./ <755739 >=<120734 2=89/8 AB ! E./@/73 ./ .05 >04/9=@7>022B</347=3/84./>=2=@=64./5.7@40384@=;5/@ E=@3 AB 4./ 8/>/05/8 04 4./ 47</ =6 <755739" 04/@ 5"!038)A=4.E/@/78/34767/84./>=@15/A05/8=34./ - 23 - 5078>2=4./57"/"5"!038*"3>0@/6;21/@;502=64./ >2=4./5</347=3/873G"!0384./>=2=@=65"!038* 5/7J/8;38/@G"!*4./@/750>2/0@57<720@74B"=@/=?/@ 5"!038)A/7394./10@/345=64./8/>/05/874>033=4 A/1@/5;</84.044./10@/345E/@/;30A2/4=78/3476B4./ >=@15/=64./7@5=3064/@6=;@4=67?/80B56@=<4./804/=6 8/04. 4.=;9. 4./ A=8B E05 73 0 10@47022B 8/>=<1=5/8 5404/"/?/@4./2/55=31/@;502=64./73I;/54103>.030<0 G"( =3 I;/547=3 3;<A/@ 74 .05 A//3 035E/@/8 4.04 4././79.4=64./>=@15/E05"*73>./5"./50</6;@4./@ >20@767/5 4.04 4./ >=@15/ 75 =6 0 <02/ >.728" 5 5;>. 4./ >=34/347=3 =6 4./ 2/0@3/8 >=;35/2 6=@ 4./ 011/22034 4.04 5"! 038 ) 6072/8 4= 78/3476B 4./ >=@15/ 8=/5 3=4 .=28 <;>.E04/@"&;@4./@=31/@;502=64.//?78/3>/=6""** 038 ""* 4./B >04/9=@7>022B 5404/8 4.04 4./ 0>>;5/8 ?=2;34//@/8 A/6=@/ 4./ 3?/547904739 667>/@ 73 4./ =27>/ 4047=30384./@/064/@./2/84./<4=4./120>/=6A;@702" 55;>.7475/540A275./84.044./507860>4E05/G>2;57?/2B E74.734./H3=E2/89/=64./0>>;5/8"./1@=5/>;47=3.05 025=120>/84./1.=4=9@01.5=64./>=@15/0384./120>/=6 - 24 - A;@702 05 1/@ G5" 038 +" 5 5;>. 73 =;@ >=3578/@/8 =1737=3 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 025= 1@=?/8 4./ >7@>;<5403>/ =6 @/>=?/@B =6 4./ >=@15/ 04 4./ 735403>/ =6 0>>;5/8 ;38/@ G"!"&;@4./@./0>>;5/8025=5.=E/84./120>/E./@/ ./ <;@8/@/8 8/>/05/8 AB 8@=11739 57J/8 54=3/5 =3 .7<" ./=27>/8@/E<0.0J0@=64./5078120>/051/@G"!!" "* 6;@4./@ 5404/8 4.04 4./ =27>/ 5/7J/8 4./ >2=4./5 6@=< 4./ >=@15/ ;38/@ G"!* 05 1/@ 5"! 038 *" 22 4./5/ <0.0J0@5 E/@/ 8@0E3 AB ""!)F4./ 3?/547904739 667>/@ 73 4./ 1@/5/3>/ =6 ""* 038 4./ 10@/345 =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 5"! 038 )" .=;9. 4./ 8/6/3>/ >@=55F /G0<73/8 4./5/ E743/55/5 04 2/394. 3=4.739 E=@4.E.72/ .05 A//3 /27>74/8 6@=< 4./< 4= 875>0@8 4./7@ 4/547<=3B" ./<73=@>=34@087>47=3573@/51/>4=64./47</=68@0E739 <0.0J0@5 <0B 3=4 745/26 A/ >=354@;/8 05 0 9@=;38 4= 875A/27/?/ 038 875>0@8 4./ ?/@57=3 =6 4./5/ E743/55/5" /3>/E/0@/=64./>=3578/@/8?7/E4.044./1@=5/>;47=3 .05025=1@=?/84./0A=?/>7@>;<5403>/" - 25 - &0)254--8,-(7 *)" 578/ 6@=< 4./ 0A=?/ >7@>;<5403>/ 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 .05 025= @/27/8 =3 4./ 2054 5>/3/ 4./=@B 7"/" 4./0>>;5/80388/>/05/8E/@/6=;38044./120>/E./@/ 4./ >=@15/ E05 @/>=?/@/8 =3 *"+"*! AB " 3 1/@;502 =6 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 ./ 5404/8 4.04 =3 *"+"*!040A=;41"<"E./3./E054@0?/27394= 7::0@07.=E==<3/0@ 387=08./6=;384./0>>;5/8 0388/>/05/8011@=0>.7394./.722F4=17"/"3/0@4./B=4.7 71/&0>4=@B"=E/?/@4./@/064/@./E/344=;<A07038 @/4;@3/8=3*"+"*!"1=3.75@/4;@3./2/0@340A=;4 4./ <;@8/@ =6 4./ 8/>/05/8" >>=@87392B ./ 5404/8 4./ 50</A/6=@/4./=27>/".=;9.4./@/7508/20B=680B5 73 @/>=@8739 4./ 5404/</34 =6 " 4./ 5078 8/20B .05 A//3 1@=1/@2B /G12073/8 AB " 5404739 4.04 064/@ *"+"*!./E/344=;<A076=@6=;@80B5038;1=3.75 @/4;@3 =3 *"+"*! ./ 90?/ .75 5404/</34 A/6=@/ 4./ =27>/" 8<744/82B 4./ >=@15/ E05 @/>=?/@/8 4./ 120>/ E./@/ "" .08 5//3 4./ 0>>;5/8 038 8/>/05/8 =3 - 26 - *"+"*!" /3>/ 4./@/ 75 3= @/05=3 4= 875A/27/?/ 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 """ 5 5;>. 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 025= 1@=?/8 4./20545>/3/4./=@B" &1) $4/=- *" ./3/G4>7@>;<5403>/=64./1@=5/>;47=3@/27/8 75 4./ <=47?/ 6=@ 4./ >=<<7557=3 =6 >@7</" 5 875>;55/8 5;1@0 "! 73 .75 /?78/3>/ 038 025= 73 .75 >=<120734F G"! 2=89/8 =3 4./ 6=22=E739 804/ =6 73>78/34 7"/" =3 *!"+"*! .05 >2/0@2B 5404/8 4.04 .75 5=3 E05 <755739 6@=< *"+"*! 038 4./@/064/@ ./ .7<5/26 038 .75 E76/ 5/0@>./8 022 4./ 120>/5 038 2=89/8 4./ >=<120734" 3 .75 /?78/3>/./.055404/84.04=34./3/G480B7"/"=34./ *!"+"*!./.05@/>/7?/80>0224=.75<=A72/1.=3/6=@ 0 @035=< =6 5"*F" ./@/AB ./ 736=@</8 4./ 50</4=4./=27>/038.038/8=?/@4./<=A72/1.=3/4= 4./<"31/@;502=64.//?78/3>/=6"!!5./0302BJ/8 4./>0228/40725=64./5078<=A72/1.=3/038>0</4=H3=E 4.04 4./ ;3>2/ =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 E05 ;5739 4./ 5078 <=A72/ 1.=3/ 038 =3 73I;7@B =6 4./ ;3>2/ =6 4./ 0>>;5/8F( - 27 - >0</4=H3=E4.044./0>>;5/8E054./1/@1/4@04=@=64./ >@7</" >>=@87392B ./ .05 A//3 0@@/54/8 AB 4./ =27>/" &;@4./@4./>0228/40725=64./<=A72/1.=3/=6""!038 4./8/>/05/8E05=A4073/8AB4./ 3?/547904739667>/@05 1/@G"*("31/@;502=6G"*(4./50</8/17>454.04 4./@/ 0@/ <;24712/ >0225 /G>.039/8 73 4.=5/ 3;<A/@5" /3>/4./8/<038739=6@035=<AB4./0>>;5/875>2/0@2B 1@=?/8 038 74 9=/5 E74.=;4 50B739 4.04 4./ 0>>;5/8 H783011/84./8/>/05/86=@9073"55;>.4./<=47?/6=@ 4./ >=<<7557=3 =6 4./ >@7</ 75 025= 1@=?/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3" *" /3>/=3>0@/6;2/G0<73047=3=60224./0A=?/ >7@>;<5403>/ >=;12/8 E74. 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 <04/@702 E743/55/8875>;55/85;1@0>2/0@2B/540A275./54./=66/3>/5 >.0@9/8 0907354 4./ 0>>;5/8 7"/" 6=@ 4./ =66/3>/5 1;375.0A2/ ;38/@ />47=35 ) ) ) $% )* 038 *! =6 " * " 3=@8/@4=>=3?7>44./0>>;5/86=@4./=66/3>/ 1;375.0A2/;38/@/>47=3) FE.7>.0@/@/I;7@/84=A/ - 28 - 1@=?/8AB4./1@=5/>;47=30@/5;<<0@7J/8AB4./=3DA2/ 1/G =;@4 73 4./ >05/ =6 4./ '( ) * +,@/1=@4/873#$#%&05 ;38/@ . / / , , 0 0 $8% + *1 2+ ( * !3" 2 *(" 112B739 4./ 20E 5;<<0@7J/8 AB 4./ =3DA2/ 1/G =;@4 73 4./ 0A=?/ >05/ 4= 4./ 60>45 038 >7@>;<5403>/5 =6 4.75 >05/ ""! 4./ 604./@ =6 4./ - 29 - 8/>/05/8.055404/873.75/?78/3>/4.044./0>>;5/83=4 =32B H783011/8 .75 5=3 A;4 025= 8/<038/8 0 @035=< =6 5"*F 6@=< .7< 4.@=;9. <=A72/ 1.=3/" &;@4./@ 4./ 0>>;5/8 4.@/04/3/8 .7< 4.04 76 ./ 6072/8 4= 0@@039/ 4./ 5078 0<=;34 ./ E=;28 H722 .75 5=3" ./ /?78/3>/ =6 ""!!4./4./3 E.=73747022B=A4073/84./6@=< 4./ <=A72/ 1.=3/ A/2=395 4= ""! >2/0@2B @/?/025 4.04 "! .08 @/>/7?/8 <=@/ 4.03 >0225 6@=< 4./ <=A72/ 3;<A/@ +()**() A/2=39739 4= ""(" &;@4./@ 4./ /?78/3>/ =6 ""( @/?/025 4.04 4./ <=A72/ 3;<A/@ +()**() A/2=39/8 4= .7< 038 4./ 5078 <=A72/ E05 ;5/8AB4./0>>;5/8=34./804/=673>78/340380>>;5/8 E/34 0A5>=38739 /?/@ 573>/" 3 5;>. >7@>;<5403>/5 4./ 1@=?757=35 =6 />47=3 ) $% =6 >2/0@2B >=<127/8 E74. 734./7354034>05/"=@/=?/@4./1@=5/>;47=35;>>/556;22B 1@=?/8 4./ @/>=?/@B =6 5"! 038 * 7"/" 4./ <=A72/ 1.=3/5 04 4./ A/./54 =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 A05/8 =3 .75 ?=2;340@B 5404/</34 G""!" *F103>. E743/55 025= 8/1=5/8038?027804/84=4.04/66/>4" - 30 - *" =6;@4./@A;44@/554.//?78/3470@B?02;/=64./ 50</E/@/2B=34./8/>757=3=64./=3DA2/1/G=;@473 4./ >05/ =6 -- . / . 0 1* )& @/1=@4/873#$#E./@/734./ =3DA2/1/G=;@47310@09@01.=" .05./2805;38/@ 1$ & * &4 5 6 6 1&45& 2 &4 * 3 &4 * /* + * * / 6 &45& + * 3 * * + * /* 7+ 7+ 6 &8 " - * - 31 - 7+(+ &8 - 2 *+" &;@4./@7303=4./@8/>757=3=64./=3DA2/1/G =;@4 73 4./ >05/ =6 2 1* )& @/1=@4/8 73 #$ $ 34 73 10@09@01. ="! =6 4./:;89</347475./2805;38/@L 1 + - &45& 9 * &45& " / * &45& + / * - 2 )" B4./0A=?/67387395=64./=3DA2/1/G=;@4 73 4./ :;89</345 74 75 >2/0@ 4.04 4./ /2/>4@=37> /?78/3>/ 120>/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 @/2B739 =3 4./ >=3?/@5047=3 A/4E//3 4./ <=A72/ 1.=3/5 >03 A/ @/27/8 573>/ /?/@B <=A72/ .0385/4 .05 03 /G>2;57?/ 3;<A/@" = 4E= <=A72/ .0385/45 .0?/ 4./ 50</ 3;<A/@ 038 /0>. - 32 - 47</4./<=A72/.0385/475;5/86=@<0H7390>022A/578/5 @/>=@87394./3;<A/@=64./>022/@4./1/@5=3>022/8038 4./ 3;<A/@5=6/?/@B .0385/40@/025=@/>=@8/8AB 4./ 5/@?7>/ 1@=?78/@" /3>/ 4./ 0A=?/ /?78/3>/ =6 4./ >03A/@/27/84=>=33/>44./0>>;5/8E74.4./022/9/8 >@7</573>/4./5078/?78/3>/>=</5E/22E74.734./0<A74 =6 />47=3 =6 4./ ?78/3>/ >4" 5 ./28 AB 4./ =3DA2/ 1/G =;@4 73 4./ >05/ =6 1* )& 1( 5@/1=@4/873 #$$4$$/3>/ =3 >0@/6;2 1/@;502 =6 4./ 20E 2078 8=E3 AB 4./ =3DA2/ 1/G =;@4 73 4./ 0A=?/ :;89</345 5= 025= 4./ /?78/3>/ 120>/8AB4./1@=5/>;47=3E/0@/=64./>=3578/@/8?7/E 4.04 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 .05 5;>>/556;22B 2078 .038 =6 4./ 0>>;5/8 038 1@=?/8 4.04 ./ 75 4./ 1/@1/4@04=@ =6 4./ >@7</" )!" 31/@;502=64./=?/@022/?78/3>/120>/8AB4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 038 025= 4./ 0A=?/ >7@>;<5403>/5 @/27/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 038 >=3578/@739 4./ 304;@/ =6 4./ >@7</ 038 4./ <033/@ 73 E.7>. 74 E05 12033/8 038 >=<<744/8 - 33 - 4./<=47?/6=@4./>=<<7557=3=64./>@7</4./>=38;>4=6 4./ 0>>;5/8 7"/" A/6=@/ 8/<038739 @035=< >=<<744739 4./<;@8/@=68/>/05/8/540A275./5.75>@;/20>4" 35;>. >7@>;<5403>/54./A@;4020>4=64./0>>;5/8751@=?/8AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 AB @/2B739 =3 @/2/?034 >7@>;<5403>/5 =6 4.//?78/3>/=6>=3>2;57?/304;@/"./>7@>;<5403>/@/27/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3 875>;55/8 5;1@0 0@/ >=35754/34 E74. 4./.B1=4./575=64./9;724=64./0>>;5/8"578/6@=<4./ 0>>;5/8 3=3/F/25/ .0?/ >=<<744/8 4./ <;@8/@ =6 4./ 8/>/05/8 6=@ 03B @/05=35" ?/3 =4./@E75/ 4./ 0>>;5/8 6072/8 /74./@ 4= 1;4 6=@E0@8 =@ 1@=?/ 5;>. 8/6/3>/ E.7>. E=;28 A@/0H 4./ >.073 038 E=;28 97?/ 0 8766/@/34 734/@1@/4047=3 4.03 4.04 =6 E.04 75 12/08/8 AB 4./ 1@=5/>;47=3" 3 5;>. >7@>;<5403>/5 E/ 0@/ =6 4./ ?7/E 4.04 4./ 9=28/3 1@73>712/5 2078 8=E3 AB 4./ =3DA2/ 1/G =;@4734./>05/=6 5404/85;1@00385;A5/I;/34 :;89</3450@/1@=?/80384./2/0@3/8/557=35;89/.05 @79.42B >=3?7>4/8 4./ 0>>;5/8 6=@ 4./ >.0@9/5 2/?/2/8 0907354 .7<" ./@/6=@/ E/ 6738 3= 9==8 9@=;385 4= 734/@6/@/ E74. 4./ :;89</34 =6 >=3?7>47=3 038 =@8/@ =6 - 34 - 5/34/3>/ 1055/8 4./ /557=35 =;@4" >>=@87392B E/ 035E/@ 1=734 ="! 73 4./ 3/9047?/ 038 1=734 ="* 73 4./ 0667@<047?/0381@=>//84=10554./6=22=E739 $0% ./011/0275./@/AB-" $A% ./ :;89</34 =6 >=3?7>47=3 038 =@8/@ =6 5/34/3>/ 804/8 )!"!*"**! 1055/8 73 /557=35 05/ =" +*!( AB 4./ 2/0@3/8 882" /557=35 ;89/ 7:0B10;@0 75 0667@</8" 1* & %) ! 1* &! ) ! 754="!2="*+