Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10183 (KAR)
SHRIMANT S/O SOMANNA PUJARI AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200139/2016 · 2025-02-20
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10183 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10183 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%
"#$$ #!! &'(&)!*+(&*
,
!! ! "
" ## ! $
# #
%
&'
# #
(
) ' #
(
* "+
R Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
( # ',#
#
' (
' '
%
&' +
(
&+
( ! $- -" '
#
"-
. ' . (
((
(
! #
/' #
/'
$
#
& /' +
012 344536 71859:57 3;31<2: :05 =>7;?5<: @A 9@<B19:1@< 3<7 @8758 @A 25<:5<95 73:57 $- -" 432257 1<
@"- CD :05 6538<57 776 5221@<2 >7;5 3:
#1=3D4>8 &05851<3A:58 85A58857 :@ 32 :05 /6538<57 5221@<2 >7;5/+ E0585CD :05 6538<57 5221@<2 >7;5 9@<B19:57 :05
- 3 -
3445663<:2399>257 @2 :@ " A@8 :05 @AA5<952 4><1203C65 ><75859:1@<2 $-- -"8E59:1@< @A3<725<:5<957:05?:@><758;@81;@8@>21?4812@<?5<: A@834581@7@A21F?@<:023<7:@43D3A1<5@A2---,5390 1< 75A3>6: @A 43D?5<: @A A1<5 :05D 20366 ><758;@ 21?465 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 3 4581@7 @A 21F ?@<:02 A@8 :05 @AA5<95 4><1203C65><75859:1@<8E59:1@<@A(>8:058 25<:5<957 :05? :@ ><758;@ 81;@8@>2 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 21F ?@<:02 3<7 :@ 43D 3 A1<5 @A 2---, 5390 1< 75A3>6: @A 43D?5<:@AA1<5:05D20366><758;@21?4651?4812@<?5<:A@83 4581@7@A21F?@<:02A@8:05@AA5<954><1203C65><75859:1@< 8E 59:1@< @A (>8:058 25<:5<957 :05? :@ ><758;@ 81;@8@>2 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 21F ?@<:02 3<7 :@ 43D 3 A1<5@A2---,53901<75A3>6:@A43D?5<:@AA1<5:05D20366 ><758;@21?4651?4812@<?5<:A@834581@7@A21F?@<:02A@8:05 @AA5<954><1203C65><75859:1@<$8E59:1@<@A (>8:05825<:5<957:05?:@><758;@1?4812@<?5<:A@861A53<7 :@43D3A1<5@A2----,53901<75A3>6:@A43D?5<:@AA1<5 :05D 20366 ><758;@ 81;@8@>2 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 3 4581@7 @A @<5 D538A@8:05@AA5<954><1203C65><75859:1@<-8E59:1@< @A(>8:05825<:5<957:05?:@><758;@1?4812@<?5<:
- 4 -
A@8 61A5 3<7 :@ 43D 3 A1<5 @A 2----, 5390 1< 75A3>6: @A 43D?5<:@AA1<5:05D20366><758;@81;@8@>21?4812@<?5<:A@8 34581@7@A@<5D538A@8:05@AA5<954><1203C65><75859:1@< - 8E 59:1@< @A (>8:058 25<:5<957 :05? :@ ><758;@ 81;@8@>2 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 21F ?@<:02 3<7 :@ 43D 3 A1<5@A2---,53901<75A3>6:@A43D?5<:@AA1<5:05D20366 ><758;@ 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 3 4581@7 @A 21F ?@<:02 A@8 :05 @AA5<954><1203C65><75859:1@<-"8E59:1@<@A (>8:058 25<:5<957 :05 399>257 @2 3<7 445663<: @2 3<72036643D2------,5390151<3662------, :@:059@?4631<3<:G@?3HH3&!+:05E1A5@A:0575953257 3C>>=381329@?45<23:1@<3248@B1757><758259:1@< , @A 8 1< 75A3>6: @A 43D?5<: @A A1<5 :05D 20366 A>8:058 ><758;@ 81;@8@>2 1?4812@<?5<: A@8 3 4581@7 @A :E@ D5382 (>8:05825<:5<957399>257 @23<7 445663<: @23<7 2036643D2------,5390151<3662------,:@:05 B19:1?,3D3443 :05 2@< @A :05 75953257 3C> >=381 32 9@?45<23:1@< 32 48@B1757 ><758 259:1@< , @A 8 1< 75A3>6:@A43D?5<:@AA1<5:05D20366A>8:058><758;@81;@8@>2 1?4812@<?5<:A@834581@7@A:E@D5382:12362@71859:57:03:
366 :05 2>C2:3<:1B5 25<:5<952 20366 8>< 9@<9>885<:6D 3<7 :05
- 5 -
3445663<:2399>257 385 362@ ;1B5< 25: @AA 32 2:14>63:57 ><758 259:1@<$@A8
05 A39:>36 ?3:81F @A :05 48@259>:1@< 9325 12 32 A@66@E2
05759532571<:0129325153C>>=381399>257 @ 3<7 399>257 @ 385 C8@:0582 0585 E32 3 7124>:5C5:E55< 75953257 3<7 012 C8@:0582 399>257 @2 3<7 85;3871<;
438:1:1@< @A 3<952:836 48@458:152 3: @;3<B1 B1663;5 1:1;3:1@<2 385 45<71<; C5A@85 :05 @>8: C5:E55< :05? :05 399>257 4582@<2038C@>857;8>7;53;31<2::05759532573C>3<7012 A3?16D ?5?C582 ;31<2: :012 C39H78@4 @< --"- 3:
3C@>: $ 3?
:05 75953257,3C> >=381 :05 0>2C3<7 @A :05 9@?4631<3<:,@?3HH3A@66@E1<;012C3:0324580127316D8@>:1<5 65A:A@8'38?3443:5?4653<73A:582@?5:1?520585951B573 ?5223;5 A8@? @<5 '5583443 185H>8>C38 :03: :05 399>257 4582@<2 385 3223>6:1<; 058 0>2C3<7,3C> ??5713:56D 205 8>2057 :@ :05 24@: <538 :05 0@>25 @A 399>257 @ 3<7 23E :03:366@A:05?A@8?573<><63EA>63225?C6D38?57E1:065:036 E534@<2 61H5 3F52 2:19H2 3<7 2:@<52 ?@<; :05? 399>257
@,81?3<:3223>6:57:0575953257,3C>E1:03<3F5@<012
- 6 -
0537 3<7 @E1<; :@ :05 2317 1?439: 3C> 9@6634257 A@66@E1<; E0190399>257 @,3HH3443419H57>432:@<53<73223>6:57 3C> @< 012 81;0: 65; 3<7 399>257 @ 3<7 399>257 @ 3223>6:57E1:03F52@<01265;23<7399>257 @3<7399>257
@"3223>6:5701?E1:02:19H23<71<:5<:1@<366D?>87585701? 05853A:58366:05399>25748@955757:@E3872:05<538CDC>2, 2:3<7 3: @;3<B1 B1663;5 E1:0 3 203857 1<:5<:1@< @A ?>87581<;
3D3443 :05 2@< @A 75953257,3C> 05 9@?4631<3<:, @?3HH3A@66@E57:05399>257>4:@:05C>2,2:3<73<73::05 C>2,2:3<7 E05< 3D3443 E32 A@><7 9@6659:1B56D 366 :05 399>257 783;;57 3D3443 :@ 3 <538CD 48@458:D C56@<;1<; :@ 01B361<;3443 @<<>8 99>257 @ 3223>6:57 3D3443 E1:0 3< 3F5 399>257 @ 3<7 399>257 @" 3223>6:57 01? E1:0 2:19H2 3<7 399>257 @ 419H57 >4 3 2:@<5 E0190 E32 6D1<; :0585 3<7 3223>6:57 01? 3: :03: :1?5 9@?4631<3<: 3<7 058 73>;0:58,1<,63E CC3BB32>C21757:05399>2573<7:05853A:58 :05 1<=>857,3D3443 C51<; 399@?43<157 CD 012 E1A5, C3BB3 E3237?1::57:@312:819:@B58<?5<:@241:36#1=3D4>805 9@?4631<3<:,@?3HH3 6@7;57 3 9@?4631<: 3;31<2: :05 3445663<:2399>2573<725::05981?1<3663E1<?@:1@<
- 7 -
'3257@<:0523179@?4631<::058524@<75<:@6195 85;12:5857 :05 9325 1< 81?5 @"- 73:57 --"- 3;31<2::05399>257A@8:05@AA5<9524><1203C65><75859:1@<2 $ - - -" 8E 59:1@< @A 3<7 :0585CD 48@7>957 :05 399>257 C5A@85 :05 =>812719:1@<36 3;12:83:53<785?3<757:05?:@=>7191369>2:@7D
>81<;:059@>825@A1<B52:1;3:1@<:05<B52:1;3:1<;
AA19582 785E :05 8565B3<: ?303I382 3<7 @C:31<57 <5952238D 7@9>?5<:2A8@?:059@<958<573>:0@81:1523<73A:58859@871<;
:05 5B175<95 @A ?3:58136 E1:<52252 :05 9038;52055: E32 6317 3;31<2: :05 399>257 A@8 :05 3A@852317 @AA5<952 C5A@85 :05 9@??1::36@>8:
<9@??1::36@A:059325C5A@85:055221@<2@>8:
:05 6538<57 5221@<2 >7;5 A83?57 :05 9038;52 A@8 :05 2317 @AA5<952 3<7 8537 1: @B58 B58C3:1?
:@ :05 399>257 @E5B58 :05399>25775<157:059038;523<79631?57:@C5:8157
" < @8758 :@ 48@B5 :05 9038;52 65B56657 3;31<2: :05 399>257 C5A@85 :05 5221@<2 @>8: :05 48@259>:1@< 1< :@:36 5F3?1<57-E1:<5225232!2:@-?38H577@9>?5<:2 32F2:@3<7175<:1A157?3:58136@C=59:232
2
- 8 -
:@ 6C51::05399>257717<@:5F3?1<53<DE1:<522:@48@B5 :051875A5<950@E5B58:05D?38H577@9>?5<:232F2:@
A:58 9@?465:1@< @A :05 48@259>:1@< 5B175<95 :05 6538<575221@<2>7;58537@B58:051<981?1<3:1<;5B175<95@A ?3:58136 E1:<52252 :@ :05 399>257 32 2:14>63:57 ><758 :05 48@B121@<2@A59:1@<@A83<7:05399>25775<157:05 23?50575A5<95@A:05399>25712@A:@:3675<1363<7A3625 1?46193:1@<
$ @2:322522?5<:@A@8363<77@9>?5<:38D5B175<95 463957 C5A@85 :05 5221@<2 @>8: :05 6538<57 5221@<2 >7;5 9@<B19:57 :05 3445663<:2399>257 @2 :@ " A@8 :05 @AA5<952 4><1203C65 ><758 59:1@<2 $ - - -" 8E 59:1@<@A3<7E58525<:5<9572:3:572>483052317 =>7;?5<:@A9@<B19:1@<3<7@8758@A25<:5<9512903665<;571< :012344536CD:053445663<:2399>257 @2:@"
!503B505387:056538<579@><25681 <16>?38
3B373;1 A@8 3445663<:2 @ :@ 6538<57 9@><256 ?:
?C1H3 3:16 A@8 3445663<:2 @ 3<7 " 3<7 6538<57 776 :3:5 >C619 8@259>:@8 81 177361<; 3:16 A@8 :05
- 9 -
8524@<75<:,:3:5 362@ E5 03B5 458>257 :05 859@872 ?375 3B3163C65C5A@85>2
- 05 481?38D 9@<:5<:1@< @A :05 6538<57 9@><256 A@8 :05 3445663<:2 12 :03: :05 =>7;?5<: ><758 :012 344536 2>AA582 A8@?458B5821:D3<71665;361:D21<95:056538<575221@<2>7;5 A31657:@34485913:5:055B175<95@<859@871<81;0:4582459:1B5 0@>;0:0548@259>:1@<A31657:@48@B5:05;>16:@A:05399>257 C5D@<7 8532@<3C65 7@>C: :05 5221@<2 >7;5 9@<B19:57 :05 399>257C3257@<2>8?1253<79@<=><9:>85'D5<><913:1<;012 38;>?5<::05D9@<:5<757:03::055B175<95@A!15:05 E1A5 @A 75953257 3<7 ! :05 2@< @A 75953257,3< 1<=>857 E1:<522 385 9@<:83719:1<; 5390 @:058 0585A@85 :05 23?5 93<<@: C5 856157 :@ 48@B5 :05 9038;52 3;31<2: :05 399>257 05D A>8:058 9@<:5<757 :03: @<5 '055?3443 185H>8C>8 E1:<52257 :05 1<9175<: 3<7 1<A@8?57 :05 23?5 :@ :05 9@?4631<3<: @E5B58 :05 8524@<75<: @6195 A31657 :@ 859@87 012 2:3:5?5<: E0190 9853:52 7@>C: 32 85;3872 :05 ;5<5212 @A :05 981?5 (>8:058 :05 2:3:5?5<: @A ! 15 E1A5 @A ! 9631?57:@C53<5D5E1:<522:@:051<9175<:E32859@87573A:58 $73D2A8@?:0573:5@A1<9175<:E019048@B52:03:205E323 463<:57 5D5E1:<522 :@ :05 1<9175<: @85@B58 :05 @9:@8 E0@
- 10 -
:853:57 :05 1<=>857,! 12 <@: 5F3?1<57 CD :05 48@259>:1@< 05D A>8:058 9@<:5<757 :03: @E1<; :@ 3 7124>:5 1<B@6B1<;
3<952:836 48@458:D C5:E55< :05 75953257 A3?16D 3<7 399>257 A3?16D 3 A3625 9325 032 C55< A@12:57 3;31<2: :05 399>257 (1<366D:05D9@<:5<757:03::@1?46193:5399>257 @23<7" 15 E1B52 @A :05 399>257 @2 3<7 852459:1B56D 3 A3625 399>23:1@< E32 ?375 3;31<2: :05? :03: :05D 3223>6:57 :05 75953257 3<7 ! E1:0 C3?C@@ 2:19H2 99@871<; :@ :05 6538<579@><2563:3<D2:85:90@A1?3;1<3:1@<1:93<<@:C52317 :03:36@<;E1:0399>257 @2:@&366?5<+:05399>257 @2 3<7 " &E@?5<+ 3223>6:57 :05 75953257 3<7 ! 5B58:056522!$:055D5E1:<522:@:051<9175<:93:5;@819366D 2:3:57:03::0585E5853C@>:399>2574582@<23::05:1?5@A 1<9175<: < 2>90 9189>?2:3<95 1: 12 ?3<1A52:6D 96538 :03: 399>257 @2 3<7 " E585 <51:058 48525<: 3: :05 295<5 @A @99>885<95 <@8 3223>6:57 !
99@871<;6D 6538<57 9@><256 A@8:053445663<:2483D2:@366@E:05344536CD25::1<;32175:05 1?4>;<57=>7;?5<:
5A>:1<; :05 3C@B5 2>C?1221@<2 :05 776 A@8 :058524@<75<:,:3:52>C?1::57:03::058512<@458B5821:D@8 1665;361:D1<:051?4>;<57=>7;?5<:21<95:056538<575221@<2
- 11 -
>7;5 @< 7>6D 34485913:1<; :05 5B175<95 3: 65<;:0 432257 3 E566,8532@<57=>7;?5<: 22>901<:58A585<9512<@:936657A@8 1<:051?4>;<57=>7;?5<:CD:0129@>8:5A>8:0589@<:5<757 :03: !,E1A5 @A :05 75953257,3C> 3< 5D5E1:<522 :@ :05 1<9175<: 6@7;57 3 9@?4631<: 2@@< 3A:58 :05 1<9175<: 32 458 F05851:583:57:053B58?5<:2@AFB58C3:1?C5A@85 :05 @>8: (>8:058 !,1<=>857 :05 2@< @A 75953257 3<7 ! 362@ 2:3:57 :03: :05 399>257 1<712981?1<3:56D 3223>6:57 01? E1:0
2 $ $ 3<7 3<7 93>257 ;815B@>21<=>81525175<:1A157:05E534@<2>2573::05:1?5@A 9@??1221@< @A 981?5 (>8:058 :05 5B175<95 @A !2 3<7 9@88@C@83:52 E1:0 :05 5B175<95 @A ! 15 :05 E1A5 @A ! 3<7!$,5D5E1:<522:@:051<9175<:5<9539@<=@1<:85371<;
@A :05 5B175<95 @A !2 3<7 $ 36@<; E1:0 :05 ?571936 5B175<95:0548@259>:1@<0322>99522A>66D48@B57:059038;52 65B566573;31<2::05399>257 99@871<;6D:056538<575221@<2 >7;503281;0:6D9@<B19:57:05399>257A@8:059038;5265B56657 3;31<2::05?3<705483D2:@712?122:05344536
!5 03B5 ;1B5< @>8 3<F1@>2 9@<217583:1@< @< :05 38;>?5<:237B3<957CD:059@><256A@8:05852459:1B5438:152 2@ 362@ 03B5 9385A>66D 458>257 :05 5B175<95 3<7 7@9>?5<:2
- 12 -
463957 C5A@85 >2 05 4@1<:2 :03: 38125 A@8 @>8 9@<217583:1@< 385
<:051<2:3<:932536C51::0548@259>:1@<5F3?1<57 -E1:<52252:@48@B5:059038;5265B566573;31<2::05399>257 1: 12 857><73<: :@ 756B5 1<:@ :05 <1::D ;81::D @A 1<71B17>36 5B175<95 @A 366 E1:<52252 1: 12 2>AA1915<: :@ 34485913:5 :05 5B175<95@A?3:58136E1:<52252
@ 48@B5 :05 0@?191736 753:0 @A 75953257,3C> @@=381 :05 48@259>:1@< 4857@?1<3<:6D 856157 @< :05 5B175<95 @A!",?571936@AA1958E0@9@<7>9:573>:@42D@<:059@8425 @A :05 75953257 3<7 122>57 3 4@2:,?@8:5? 854@8: 32 458 F 99@871<; :@ 01? :05 93>25 @A 753:0 E32 7>5 :@ J035?@8803;19 20@9H 32 852>6: @A 1<=>8152 2>2:31<57K (>8:058 05362@2:3:57:03:366:051<=>81523853<:1,?@8:5?1< <3:>85 771:1@<366D :05 48@259>:1@< 362@ 463957 :05 1<L>52:
43<903<3?3 9@<7>9:57 @< :05 9@8425 @A :05 7595325732 458
- 13 -
F783E<CD!-!2"3<7 385:0543<90E1:<52252 A@8F05DC@:0175<:1A157:051<=>8152@<:059@8425@A:05 75953257<2>909189>?2:3<9539@<=@1<:85371<;@AF2 3<736@<;E1:0:055B175<95@A!2"-"3<7 E5385 @A :05 B15E :03: :05 48@259>:1@< 032 48@B57 :05 0@?191736 753:0 @A 75953257,3C> C5D@<7 366 8532@<3C65 7@>C: B5< @:058E125:0575A5<95032<@:2581@>26D7124>:57:050@?191736 753:0@A:0575953257
@ 9@<<59: :05 399>257 1< :05 0@?191736 753:0 @A :05 75953257 3<7 :@ :05 1<=>8152 2>2:31<57 CD ! :05 48@259>:1@< 21;<1A193<:6D 856157 @< :05 5B175<95 @A !,:05 9@?4631<3<: !,1<=>857 !,E1A5 @A !
3<7 !$ 3< 1<7545<75<: 5D5E1:<522 :@ :05 1<9175<:
< 9385A>6 458>236 @A :055B175<95@A:0525E1:<52252!E0@25::05981?1<3663E 1<:@ ?@:1@< CD 6@7;1<; F,9@?4631<: 032 2:3:57 :03: :0585 E32 3 91B16 7124>:5 012:@8D 1<B@6B1<; 3<952:836 48@458:152 C5:E55< :05 75953257M2 A3?16D 3<7 399>257M2 A3?16D ;31<2: 2317C39H78@4@<:05?@8<1<;@A--"-E05<75953257, 3C>65A:0120@>25:@B121:'383?5?4653<73A:582@?5:1?5 @<5 '055?3443 185H>8C>8 1<A@8?57 058 :03: :05 399>257 E585 3223>6:1<; 058 0>2C3<7 <538 3H3443M2 0@>25
- 14 -
??5713:56D 205 ?375 032:5 :@ :05 24@: 3<7 E1:<52257 399>257 @2 :@ " 3223>6:1<; 058 0>2C3<7 E1:0 3F5 2:@<52 3<7 C3?C@@ 2:19H2 15
2 $ $ 3<7 6C51: 205 3::5?4:57 :@ 4391AD :05 29>AA65 0@E5B58 :05D :0853:5<57 058 E1:0 7185 9@<25L>5<952
E1<; :@ :05 3223>6:
058 0>2C3<7 2>99>?C57 A@8:0E1:0 >C25L>5<:6D :05 399>257 48@955757:@C>2,2:@41<253890@A0582@<!)205A@66@E57 :05? 4@< A1<71<; 058 2@<G! 3: C>2 2:@4 :05D 783;;57 01?:@01B3<1<;3443M2A15673<73223>6:5701?E1:0:0523?5 E534@<2@E5B582053<7!8529>570582@<3:5805 E32 37?1::57 :@ @241:36 3: #1=34>8 A@8 :853:?5<:
>C25L>5<:6D 205 6@7;57 :05 9@?4631<: 32 458 F 012 B5821@< @A ! 1< F E32 93:5;@819366D 754@257 CD 058 1< 0585B175<950@>;0:0575A5<9598@22,5F3?1<57:012E1:<522 3: 65<;:0 32175 A8@? :05 37?1221@< CD 058 45<75<9D @A 91B16 7124>:5 C5:E55< :05 75953257 A3?16D 3<7 :05 399>257 A3?16D <@:01<; E@8:0E0165 E32 56191:57 :@ 712C5615B5 058 :52:1?@<D (>8:058!:051<=>857362@754@2571<0125B175<95:03::05 399>257 @2 3<7 93>;0: 0@67 @A 01? 3<7 3223>6:57 E1:0 3F505399>257 @456:572:@<5@<0129052:3<720@>67582 :05 399>257 @2 3<7 " 3223>6:57 01? E1:0 C3?C@@ 2:19H2
- 15 -
A8@? 0537 :@ :@5 12 2:3:5?5<: E32 859@8757 3A:58 73D2 A8@? :05 73:5 @A 1<9175<:
@ 7@>C: :0585 12 3 7563D 1< 859@871<; :05 2:3:5?5<: @A ! @E5B58 05 96381A157 :05 23?5CD754@21<;:03:1??5713:56D3A:58:051<9175<:05E32 37?1::57:@@B58<?5<:@241:36#1=3D34>833<7:05853A:5805 E32 201A:57 :@ 183= @241:36 A@8 01;058 :853:?5<: A@66@E1<;
E0190 :05 @6195 859@8757 012 2:3:5?5<: 5<95 1: 9@>67 C5 ;3:05857 :03: :05 7563D 1< 859@871<; 012 2:3:5?5<: 7@52 <@: :3H53E3D012:52:1?@<D
" @ 2:85<;:05< :05 5B175<95 @A !2 3<7 :05 48@259>:1@< 362@ 856157 @< :05 5B175<95 @A ! :05 E1A5 @A ! 3<7 !$G:05 1<7545<75<: 5D5E1:<522 0518 :52:1?@<D 965386D 9@88@C@83:52 :@ :05 :52:1?@<D @A !2 3<7 05D C@:0 93:5;@819366D 2:3:57 :05 3223>6: ?375 CD 399>257 :@ 759532573<7!05D362@175<:1A157:05E534@<2>257CD :05399>2570@>;0:05851237563D1<859@871<;:052:3:5?5<: @A:0525E1:<522520@E5B58:05D5F4631<57:058532@<A@82>90 7563D5<95:055B175<95@A:0525?3:58136E1:<52252,!2 3<7$3859@<212:5<:1<852459:@A:053223>6:45845:83:57 CD 399>257 @2 :@ @< :05 75953257 3<7 !
: 12 B505?5<:6D9@<:5<757CD:056538<579@><256A@8:05399>257
- 16 -
:03: ?>90 98575<95 93<<@: C5 3::39057 :@ :05 :52:1?@<152 @A !23<721<95:05D385:05A3?16D?5?C5823<7?@2: 1<:5852:57E1:<52252E0@255H:@9@<B19::05399>257@E1<;:@ 345<71<;91B167124>:5C5:E55<:05:E@A3?16152@E5B58@< ?5:19>6@>25F3?1<3:1@<@A:0525E1:<52252:05185B175<95385 9@<212:5<: 85;3871<; :05 3223>6: CD :05 399>257 @2 :@ (>8:058@<458>236@A:054@2:,?@8:5?854@8:@A:0575953257 32458F :058538532?3<D321<=>8152@C258B571<:05 9@8425 @< :05 75953257 CD :05 @9:@8 !",@9:@8 032 @41<57 :03: ?@2: @A :05 1<=>8152 A@><7 @< :05 9@8425 @A :05 75953257E3293>257CD
$3<715 F523<7
$15 :05 C8@H5< 03<765 @A :05 F5 (>8:058 32 458 :05 E@><7 958:1A193:5 @A ! :0585 E585 1<=>8152 1<A619:57 @< 01? 99@871<; :@ :05 5D5E1:<522 :05 399>257 362@ 93>257 1<=>8152 CD 456:1<; 2:@<52 @ 7@>C: :05 859@B58D ?303I38 E1:<52252 !2 3<7 :><57 0@2:165 :@ :05 48@259>:1@< 9325
5B58:056522 !-,<B52:1;3:1<;
AA1958 032 965386D 2:3:57 :03: :05 E534@<2
2 :@ $ E585 251I57 7>81<; :05 24@:
43<903<3?3,F" (>8:058 :05 <B52:1;3:1<;
AA1958,!- 032 251I57 :05 96@:052 E@8< CD :05 399>257 3: :05 :1?5 @A 9@??1221@<@A981?5C3257@<:0518B@6><:38D2:3:5?5<:153:
- 17 -
:05 C5052: @A 399>257 @
2" 3<7 C3257 @< 012 B@6><:38D2:3:5?5<:32458F
$:@-E585251I57 3: :05 0@>25 @A 399>257 @ C3257 @< 012 B@6><:38D 2:3:5?5<:,F"
:@ E585 251I57 A8@? 399>257
@C3257@<012 B@6><:38D 2:3:5?5<:GF
:@" E585 251I57 A8@? 399>257 @ C3257 @< 058 B@6><:38D 2:3:5?5<:GF$
:@E585251I57A8@?399>257 @ C3257 @< 012 B@6><:38D 2:3:5?5<:GF 3<7
251I57 A8@? 399>257 @" C3257 @< 058 B@6><:38D 2:3:5?5<:,F- 66 :0525 859@B58152 E585 5AA59:57 ><758 FG303I38 5<95:0@>;0!23<7:>8<570@2:165:055D5E1:<52252 :@:051<9175<:!23<7175<:1A157:05E534@<2>257CD :05399>257E0165 45845:83:1<;:05981?5CD:05?!":05 571936
AA1958E0@9@<7>9:57:053>:@42D032@41<57:03::05 1<=>8152 A@><7 @< :05 9@8425 9@>67 C5 4@221C65 :@ 2>2:31< CD >21<;
$3<7153F523<7
$15:05C8@H5<03<765 @A:053F55<95E5385@A:05B15E@A:03::0548@259>:1@< 362@ 48@B57 :05 859@B58D @A E534@<2 >257 CD :05? A@8 9@??1221@<@A:05981?5
@7@>C::0585127563D1<859@871<;:052:3:5?5<: @A !
3<7 !G:05 1<=>857 3<7 :05 5D5E1:<522
- 18 -
5B58:056522 32 7129>2257 2>483 C@:0 :0525 E1:<52252 03B5 7>6D 5F4631<57 :05 8532@< A@8 :05 2317 7563D (>8:058 :05 5B175<95 @A :0525 E1:<52252 93<<@: C5 712C5615B57 ?5856D A@8 :058532@<:03::05D385:058563:1B52438:123<E1:<5225205 @<MC65 45F @>8: 1< :05 9325 @A
!" 0567 :03: :05 5B175<95 @A 2@65 8563:57 5D5E1:<52293<C5C3212A@89@<B19:1@<438:19>6386DE05<:0585 12 <@ B3;>5<522 1< 012058 :52:1?@<D E1:0 852459: :@ :05 39:
9@??1::57 CD :05 399>257 05 @<MC65 45F @>8: 1< 383;8340 @ @A:052317=>7;?5<:0567:03:
#!$ !"
" #
$
%&' ( #
) * *#
+
(
* *
$ 2458:0563E63177@E<CD:05@<MC65 45F@>8: 1<:053C@B593251:125B175<::03::058512<@2>90C38:@856D :05 5B175<95 @A 8563:1B5 E1:<52252 3<7 :05 23?5 93<<@: C5 7129387572@656DA@8:058532@<:03::05D385:058563:1B52@A:05
- 19 -
75953257 < :05 9325 @< 03<7 :05 5B175<95 @A 8563:1B5 E1:<52252 362@ 9@88@C@83:52 E1:0 :05 5B175<95 @A @:058 E1:<52252322>90E5385@A:05B15E:03::059@<:5<:1@<@A :05 6538<57 9@><256 A@8 :05 3445663<:2 7@52 <@: 0@67 ?>90 E3:58
: 12 362@ 38;>57 CD :05 6538<57 9@><256 A@8 :05 3445663<:2 :03: :0585 385 9@<:83719:1@<2 1< :05 5B175<95 @A !2 3<7 @< 9385A>6 458>236 1< @>8 B15E :0@25 ?1<@8 9@<:83719:1@<27@52<@:;@:@:058@@:@A:0548@259>:1@<9325 05 @<MC65 45F @>8: 1< :05 9325 @A %&
' ! ( 03205671<4383;8340 @E019012L>@:57B58C3:1?32 ><758
)! #(
# # #
,
(
( #
!#
#(
#
(
##-
- 20 -
- 6C51::0129325852:2@<:055B175<95@A5D5E1:<522 :@:051<9175<:3<7?@:1B5A@8:051<9175<:7@52<@:463D?>90 B1:368@65<5B58:056522:0548@259>:1@<0322>99522A>66D48@B57 :05 ?@:1B5 A@8 9@??1221@< @A 981?5 CD :05 399>257 : 12 24591A19366D 2:3:57 CD !2 3<7 3<7 !-,2@< @A 75953257:03::0575953257032;1B5<>4&:E@+39852@A63<7 :@399>257 @23<7@>:@A"39852@A63<73<7:0585E323 91B167124>:545<71<;C5:E55<:05? 22>90:05399>257E32 9@?456657:@45845:>3:5:05981?5
2A3832:05B505?5<:2>C?1221@<@A:056538<57 9@><256 A@8 :05 3445663<:2 85;3871<; <@<,438:19143:1@< @A 399>257 2@ 3<7 " 1< :05 1<9175<: 12 9@<958<57 @< 9385A>6 458>236@A:055B175<953B3163C65@<859@87:0@>;0!23<7 2:3:57 :03: 399>257 @2 :@ " 438:19143:57 1< :05 1<9175<: 3<7 3223>6:57 :05 75953257 3<7 !
<5B58:056522 !$ 3< 1<7545<75<: 5D5E1:<522 032 2:3:57 :03: 399>257 4582@<2 3223>6:57 :05 75953257 E1:0 E534@<2 0@>;0 05 2:3:57 :05 438:19143:1@< @A 399>257 @2 3<7 " 2>C25L>5<:6D 1< 012 5B175<95:0585@99>828532@<3C657@>C:3C@>::05438:19143:1@< @A 399>257 @2 3<7 " E0@ 385 E@?5< !$ E32 B58D 24591A19 1< 9015A 5F3?1<3:1@< E0585 05 754@257 399>257
- 21 -
4582@<2 438:19143:57 1< :05 1<9175<: 5 C51<; 3< 1<7545<75<: 5D5E1:<522:@:051<9175<:98571C161:D032:@C53::39057:@012 :52:1?@<D21<95:05@:0581<7545<75<:5D5E1:<522!2 3<7 9@6659:1B56D :>8<57 0@2:165 :@ :05 48@259>:1@< 9325 0@>;0 !2 3<7 2:3:57 3C@>: :05 438:19143:1@< @A 399>257 @2 3<7 " 1< :05 1<9175<: CD 9@<217581<; :05 5B175<95@A!$E5A1<72>C2:3<:136A@8951<:052>C?1221@<@A :056538<579@><256A@8:053445663<:2 :03: :05399>257 @2 3<7"E585A36256D1?46193:571<:05981?5A@8:058532@<:03:
:05D 385 :05 E1B52 @A 399>257 @2 3<7 852459:1B56D !5 9@<9>8 E1:0 :05 9@<:5<:1@< @A :05 6538<57 9@><256 A@8 :05 3445663<:2:03:1:120387:@C5615B5:03::05399>257 @23<7
" 3223>6:57 :05 75953257 E1:0 C3?C@@ 2:19H2 E0165 399>257
@2 :@ 3223>6:57 01? E1:0 75376D E534@<2 61H5 F5 3<7 2:@<52:12362@0387:@C5615B5:05D:05399>257 @23<7" :05853A:58 E5<: 2538901<; A@8 ! 0@671<; C3?C@@ 2:19H2 :@ :05C>22:@43<7:05D3;31<3223>6:57!36@<;E1:0399>257
@2:@ 27129>22572>483:05?5719365B175<95@A!" 75419:2 :03: :05 ?3=@8 1<=>8152 A@><7 @< :05 9@8425 @A :05 75953257 E32 93>257 CD 3F52 2:@<52 3<7 :05 03<765 @A :05 3F5 < 2>90 9189>?2:3<952 :05 C3?C@@ 2:19H2 >257 CD :05
- 22 -
399>257 @2 3<7 " 3445382 :@ C5 7@>C:A>6 (>8:058 399@871<; :@ !-,<B52:1;3:1<; @AA1958 :05 399>257 @2 3<7 " 48@7>957 C3?C@@ 2:19H2 15
3<7 A8@? :0518 0@>25 : 12 A>8:058 0387 :@ C5615B5 3A:58 3223>6:1<; :05 75953257 3<7 !
:05 399>257 @2 3<7 " 9388157 :05 C3?C@@ 2:19H2 :@ :0518 0@>25 3<7 017 1: 3: 0@?5 5<95 :05 5B175<95 @A !$ 3445382 :@ C5 :8>:0A>6 3C@>: :05 <@<, 438:19143:1@< @A 399>257 @2 3<7 " : 12 E@8:0 :@ ?5<:1@< 0585:03: 1:12E56625::657481<91465@A63E :03:E0585@<:05 5B175<95:E@4@221C161:1523853B3163C65@8@45<@<5E0190;@52 1< A3B@>8 @A :05 48@259>:1@< 3<7 :05 @:058 E0190 C5<5A1:2 3< 399>257:05399>25712><7@>C:576D 5<:1:657:@:05C5<5A1:@A 7@>C: <@:058 ;@675< :08537 E0190 8><2 :08@>;0 :05 E5C @A :05 37?1<12:83:1@< @A =>2:195 1< 981?1<36 93252 12 :03: 1A :E@ B15E2 385 4@221C65 @< :05 5B175<95 377>957 1< :05 9325 @<5 4@1<:1<; :@ :05 ;>16: @A :05 399>257 3<7 :05 @:058 :@ 012 1<<@95<95:05B15EE019012A3B@>83C65:@:05399>257E@>67 C537@4:57<:059325@<03<7:055B175<95@A!$965386D ;@52:@48@B5:03::0585E585399>2574582@<21<:051<9175<: 3<7438:19143:1@<@A399>257 @23<7"123<3A:58:0@>;0:
- 23 -
0@>;0 399>257 @2 :@ " 385 9@<B19:57 A@8 :05 @AA5<952 4><1203C65 ><758 59:1@< $ - - -"8E59:1@<@A21<95:05438:19143:1@<@A399>257
@2 3<7 " 85?31<2 ><48@B57 CD :05 48@259>:1@< C5D@<7 8532@<3C657@>C::051<B@6B5?5<:@A399>257 @2:@1<:05 ?>8758 @A :05 75953257 3<7 1< 1<A619:1<; ;815B@>2 1<=>8152 :@ !CD20381<;9@??@<1<:5<:1@<1248@B57CD:055B175<95@A 5D5E1:<522527129>22572>4831<2>909189>?2:3<952:05D385 613C65 :@ C5 9@<B19:57 ><758 59:1@< @A 1<2:537 @A 59:1@<@A36@<;E1:0@AA5<952><75859:1@< $-- 3<7-"@A05@<MC65 45F@>8:1<:05 9325@A *+854@8:571<!! ,-05671<383;83402 @:@32><758
#! #
# ./!%0 #1.!%0
( # 2
#
#
# #
3( #
#4 #
- 24 -
./ 0 1
!-+
2
50
" #( #
+
.6./!%0 7
#
*
( (
.# ./!%0
! (2 (#
8( #
"
(
#! (
.6 ./!%0#
!$+ ( #(
2 1.!%0 9
:( #
&&&.0%0## (4
+ # ###
(#2
#
;<3%(9&=&=: &00.>?9&=&=:.0090:&(8&@ +
0AB!!0%0
- 25 -
(
160%0 #
# #
2
#
$ (
(8
"
..0%0! #
(# ;C 0 ) )(9//:100?/>=0090:/@
!(+
8 ! 4
C;
C(9//1:1001&? //1 00 90: '61@
D
"
7 #
; C(9//1:100>&&?//1 00 90: /6/@ +
2
"
; C( 9//1: 1 00 1& ? //1 00 90: '61@ #
! (
# #
!(
0 # #
./!%0
! ! 3
% ;3 % ( 9/6>: 00 >/ ? /6> 00 90: &1&@ ( 0
?
1 E3
.6 ./!%0(
%'*
- 26 -
&5?4032122>446157+
+#" #
" ./!%0(
#
! (
#
0 38 7 0 C % ;C % ( 9/'.: 00 =. ? 3!< /'.0&=.@(? >E! ##
F 7 C GC H
;7 C GC H
( /&. 00 ,F %0 ./ ? 9/&.8&': '& !3 .= ? !F< 9/&': '& 0 />@ ( 4 "
# ./
1. ! # 8
./
(
1../
7
#
./ # #
1.(
1. 1. ./
*
- 27 -
&5?4032122>446157+
!+ 84 # #
9
: )%;9
:)%(/'' 00,F01.?3!</'0(./@
0
< ;0
< ( 9&==1: & 00 &( . ? &==1 00 90: '.@ +
# ./!%0 ( #
4 3 I
);3 I
)(9//>:>00.?//>0090://=@ (#0 ? . + 4 "
#(
" (5 0
1=&!%0 9
: +
9" :
(
J (
9 :J
# 0"
"
# ./!%0( ( #
# ###
"
' +
# # # 1.!%0 !C G % );C G %
- 28 -
)(/100,F0 &/? 9/.:0<>6?3!</10.1@(
8 7 0
# #
" (
#1.!%0 # # # # #
#
! 1=&!%0 9
:
+
( # # ! (
K #
#
8 4
# #
+((#
1&!%0
#
9 8
:*
&5?4032122>446157+
+ #
B2
3%;
B23%(9&==&:>00>?&==& 0090:'@?900&6(&.:
- 29 -
&. , 0 ( # # ?9:
1=&
# ./
#
K 9: #
"
5 0 ( (
#
1=& # ./!%0K 9:
1=& # ./
1=& # 1. *
&5?4032122>446157+
3 1../!%0
( 4 # ##
1. "
( ./!%0
# !
(
*
*
446D1<; :05 481<914652 6317 7@E< CD :05 @<MC65 45F @>8: 1< :05 3C@B5 9325 1: 9@>67 C5 255< :03: C@:0 :05
- 30 -
9@??@< @C=59: 3<7 9@??@< 1<:5<:1@< 385 :83957 C39H :@ :05 23?5 5B175<95 :05 438:19143:1@< @A 399>257 @2 3<7 " 3445382 :@ C5 7@>C:A>6 1< :05 1<9175<: 3<7 :05 48@259>:1@< A31657 :@ 52:3C6120 :05 ;>16: @A 399>257 @2 3<7 " C5D@<7 8532@<3C65 7@>C: 3<7 1: 12 52:3C612057 CD :05 5B175<95 @A ?3:58136E1:<52252:03:399>257 @2:@38545845:83:@8@A :05981?53<7:05A39:248@B573<7:055B175<95377>957E1:0 85A585<95:@:059038;5><75859:1@<E@>67C5:0523?51A :059038;5E585><75859:1@<@A:0@>;0:05399>257
@2 :@ 385 <@: 9038;57 ><758 59:1@< @A 2>C2:1:>:1@< @A 59:1@< @A A@8 59:1@< @A 12 458?1221C65 99@871<;6D E5 0@67 :03: :05 9@<B19:1@< 3<7 25<:5<951?4@257CD:055221@<2@>8::@399>257 @2:@ A@8:05@AA5<9524><1203C65><75859:1@<2 $- - 3<7-"@A20366C58537E1:059:1@<@A1<2:537 @A59:1@<@A
(@8:05A@8;@1<;8532@<2E5385@A:059@<2175857 B15E :03: :05 48@259>:1@< 032 A31657 :@ 48@B5 :05 9038;52 65B56657 3;31<2: :05 399>257 @2 3<7 " C5D@<7 8532@<3C65 7@>C: @E5B58 :05 48@259>:1@< 032 2>99522A>66D 52:3C612057 :05;>16:@A:05399>257 @2:@A@8:05@AA5<9524><1203C65
- 31 -
><758 59:1@<2 $ - - 3<7 -" 8E59:1@< @A<:03: B15E@A:05?3::58E53<2E58@1<:2 @ 3<7 831257 3C@B5 1< 438:6D 3AA18?3:1B5 3<7 48@9557 :@ 4322 :05A@66@E1<;
1 81?1<36 44536 @---"12 2
11 05 >7;?5<: @A 9@<B19:1@< 3<7 @8758 @A 25<:5<95 432257 1< @"- 73:57 $- -" CD :05 2: 776 5221@<2 >7;5 #1=3D34>81225:,321751<852459:@A399>257 @2 3<7"153445663<: @23<7"
111 05 399>257 @2 3<7 " 15 :05 3445663<:
@2 3<7 " 385 39L>1::57 A@8 :05 @AA5<952 4><1203C65 ><758 59:1@< $ - - 3<7-"8E59:1@<@A
1B 05'316C@<72@A3445663<: @23<7"2:3<72 93<95665705A1<53?@><:1A3<D4317CD:05?
20366C585A><757:@:05?@<7>5175<:1A193:1@<
B 05 344536 3;31<2: 3445663<:2 @ :@ 15 399>257 @2:@12/
B1 05 9@<B19:1@< 3<7 @8758 @A 25<:5<95 3;31<2: :05 399>257
@2 :@
432257 1<
- 32 -
@"- 73:57 $- -" CD :05 776 5221@<2 >7;5 #1=3D34>8 1< 852459: @A @AA5<954><1203C65 ><75859:1@<@A12 ?@71A157 A@8 :05 @AA5<95 4><1203C65 ><758 59:1@< @A 05 399>257 @2 :@ 385 9@<B19:57 A@8 :05 @AA5<952 4><1203C65 ><758 59:1@<28E59:1@<@A59:1@< 8E59:1@<@A59:1@<$8E59:1@< @A 59:1@< - 8E 59:1@< @A 59:1@<- 8E59:1@<@A59:1@<-" 8E59:1@<@A
B11 05 25<:5<95 1?4@257 CD :05 6538<57 5221@<2 >7;5 A@8 399>257 @2 :@ A@8 :05 @AA5<952 4><1203C65><75859:1@<2 $- - 3<7-"@A3859@<A18?57
B111 5;12:8D 12 71859:57 :@ 85:>8< :05 :8136 @>8:
859@872 36@<; E1:0 958:1A157 9@4D @A :012 =>7;?5<: :@ :05 6538<57 5221@<2 >7;5 A@8:0E1:0
-+
&
%* $
-+
&$ * $ ## 12: @6 @