Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 10140 (KAR)

BASAWARAJ @ BASAPPA v. SAYYAD AND ORS

MFA/201760/2019 · 2025-01-23

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#"$ %# # & !" ! #$% "#! & " ' ' " ( " ') !" ! ) " (& ') !*+*, - % ) !) " %% )" ! # "#) " '" " ') !*+*," '$,+ . ) " ! # "#) " +") " ( " ') !*+*," '$,+ LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.28 18:03:37 - 0800 - 2 - $ ! " '! ) " )! ! " " %/ ! ." " ') !*+*, - % )) " " $0 & ) ) $ " %! % ) ! + ** % ) ! ') ! ! "" 1 ,"" 1 " ! " %") ! ) # # 2 ) # #2 ) 345673458369:;8<374==345>8?@:5AB34==37748A 486 7345836 9:;8<37 4==345>8? @:5 53<=:8638A :$ C 8<;54893:D=48E486=35;<36AB3D4A35>47:8539:56 - 3 - E 9:8<38A :@ F:AB AB3 =45A>3<" AB3 D4AA35 >< A4G38;=@:5@>8476><=:<47"AB:;?B>A><<74A36@:56D><<>:8 $ B><4==347FEAB3=3A>A>:835974>D48A><6>539A36 4?4>8<AAB3H;6?D38A4864I45664A36+=4<<36>8 :** FE AB3 66>A>:847 >J>7 ;6?3 486 3DF35" " '474F;54?>" @:5 <B:5A K 5>F;847/" IB353FE"4<;D:@ <""I4<4I45636:8499:;8A:@ AB3>8H;5>3<<;<A4>836FEB>D>8AB35:46A54@@>9499>638A , B3@49A<7346>8?A:AB><4==3474534<F37:I# 4 B3 =3A>A>:835 IB>73 =5:9336>8? FE I47G 8345 DF47?45:<<":83?::6<J3B>973F345>8?:'$,+ 94D3>883?7>?38AD4883548664<B364?4>8<AAB3=3A>A>:835" IB353FE" B3 <;<A4>836 @549A;53 :@ B>< 73@A @3D;5 486 :AB35 D>8:5 >8H;5>3< 3 I4< 46D>AA36 A: AB3 B:<=>A47 486 A::G A534AD38A 4< >8=4A>38A @:5 <>L 64E< 486 ;8635?:83 B353@:53" B3 <:;?BA @:5 9:D=38<4A>:8 F3@:53 AB3 5>F;847 @5:DAB3:I835486>8<;535:@AB3:@@386>8?J3B>973 F B3 =3A>A>:8 I4< :==:<36 FE AB3 8<;54893 :D=48E :@ AB3 J3B>973 :8 AB3 ?5:;86 AB4A AB353 I4< 8: - 4 - <;9B83?7>?3893:8AB3=45A:@AB365>J35:@AB3J3B>973486 AB4AAB3A35D<4869:86>A>:8<:@AB3=:7>9EI353J>:74A36486 4< <;9B" AB3 =3A>A>:8 A: F3 <A5>9A =5::@ :@ AB3 9:8A38A>:8< A4G38;=FEB>D 9 B3 5>F;847@54D364==5:=5>4A3><<;3<4864@A35 4==539>4A>8? 3J>63893 :@ AB3 =3A>A>:835 4< 486 AB3 :9A:5 4< " IB: 4<<3<<36 B>< 6><4F>7>AE 486 4@A35 =35;<>8?AB36:9;D38A<"94D3A:AB39:897;<>:8AB4AAB353>< 1 6><4F>7>AE 486 AB353@:53" 4I45636 9:D=38<4A>:8 4< F37:I# 7 : 45A>9;745< D:;8A :I456<>8H;5E=4>8486 <;@@35>8? <*" :I456<D36>9473L=38<3< <," :I456<@::64863LA54 8:;5><BD38A486D36>947 4AA38648A <"+ :I456<9:8J3E4893 <" :I456<7:<<:@>89:D36;5>8? A534AD38A <"* :I456<35D4838A6><4F>7>AE <" ! :I456<63=5>J4A>:8:@@;A;53 4D38>A>3< <" :A47:D=38<4A>:8 :;8636:@@ <"" <"" - 5 - * 3>8?4??5>3J36FEAB3<4>64I456"AB3=3A>A>:835 ><F3@:53AB><:;5A B3 7345836 9:;8<37 4==345>8? @:5 AB3 4==37748A I:;76<;FD>AAB4AAB39:D=38<4A>:84I45636FEAB3 5>F;847 ;8635AB3B346:@7:<<:@@;A;53>89:D36;3A:6><4F>7>AE><:8 AB3 7:I35 <>63 486 AB3 5>F;847 @4>736 A: 9:8<>635 AB3 6><4F>7>AE >8 4 =5:=35 D48835 A >< <;FD>AA36 AB4A AB:;?B AB3 :9A:5 B46 <A4A36 AB4A AB3 6><4F>7>AE I4< A: AB3 3LA38A :@ 1" AB3 5>F;847 B4< 4<<3<<36 AB3 @;89A>:847 6><4F>7>AE4A1"AB353@:53"AB353><8336A:534<<3<<D38A:@ AB39:D=38<4A>:8 " 7345836 9:;8<37 @:5 AB3 53<=:8638A 8<;54893:D=48E63@386>8?AB3>D=;?836H;6?D38AA>< <;FD>AA36 AB4A AB3 6><4F>7>AE >< =5:=357E 4==539>4A36 FE AB3 5>F;8474869:D=38<4A>:8><47<:H;<A486534<:84F73 + 8 =35;<47 :@ AB3 3J>63893 4J4>74F73 :8 539:56" =45A>9;7457E" AB3 :;86 35A>@>94A3 4< I377 4< AB3A3<A>D:8E :@ :9A:5">A><97345AB4AAB353><=BE<>9476><4F>7>AE4A 1 B3@549A;53:@@3D;5@:548?5>9;7A;5><A"IB:><4?36 - 6 - E345<"><63@>8>A37E94;<>8?>D=36>D38A>8B><64EA:64E 7>@3 B3 @549A;53 >< ?:>8? A: B4;8A B>D @:5 AB3 53<A :@ B>< 7>@3 B353@:53" AB3 4<<3<<D38A :@ AB3 6><4F>7>AE FE AB3 5>F;847 4A 1 4==345< A: F3 :8 AB3 7:I35 <>63 8 AB3 9:8<>63536 :=>8>:8 :@ AB>< :;5A" B4J>8? 53?456 A: AB3 4J:94A>:8 :@ AB3 =3A>A>:835" AB3 @;89A>:847 6><4F>7>AE >< 534<<3<<364A1 B3 ?;>637>83< ><<;36 FE AB3 '4584A4G4 A4A3 3?47 35J>93< ;AB:5>AE ' @:5 <3AA73D38A :@ AB3 6><=;A3<F3@:53AB3:G6474A=53<95>F3AB38:A>:847>89:D3 :@ <+* @:5 AB3 E345 8 ;D=A338 8;DF35 :@ 639><>:8<" AB>< :;5A B4< B376 AB4A AB3 ?;>637>83< ><<;36 FE '453A:F34993=A4F73:8AB3?5:;86AB4AAB3E453>8 ?3835479:8@:5D>AEI>ABAB3D>8>D;DI4?3<@>L36;8635AB3 >8>D;D4?3<9A B353@:53"AB38:A>:847>89:D3:@AB3 =3A>A>:835><4993=A364< <+"*=35D:8AB B;<" AB3 =3A>A>:835 >< 38A>A736 @:5 4 A:A47 9:D=38<4A>:8 :@ <+"* L L + L 1 AB4A 3M;47< A: <"+" :8<3M;38A7E" AB3 9:D=38<4A>:8 ;8635 AB3 - 7 - B3467:<<:@>89:D36;5>8?AB374>6;==35>:6><9479;74A364< <+"*L$AB4A3M;47< <"* B39:D=38<4A>:84I45636FEAB3 5>F;847;8635 :AB35B346<53D4>8<;847A3536"B3893"6:3<8:A53M;>5348E >8A35@353893 FE AB>< :;5A 99:56>8?7E" AB3 =3A>A>:835 >< 38A>A736@:5D:6>@>369:D=38<4A>:84<F37:I# :5AB34@:53<4>6534<:8<"AB34==34763<35J36A: F3477:I36>8=45A3893"AB3@:77:I>8?# 7 : 45A>9;745< D:;8A 4>8486<;@@35>8? <*" 36>9473L=38<3< <," $ ::6"3LA548:;5><BD38A486 D36>9474AA38648A <"+ , :8J3E48939B45?3< <" * :<<:@>89:D36;5>8?74>6;= =35>:6 <"* :<<:@>89:D36;3A: =35D4838A6><4F>7>AE <"+" :I456<63=5>J4A>:8:@@;A;53 4D38>A>3< <" :A47:D=38<4A>:8 <$""* 3<<#I45636FEAB3 5>F;847 "" 66>A>:8479:D=38<4A>:8 <*"** - 8 - > B34==347><477:I36>8=45A >> B3>D=;?836H;6?D38A4864I456=4<<36FE AB3 5>F;847 >< D:6>@>36 B3 4==37748A >< 38A>A736 @:5 48:AB35 <;D :@ <*"** I>AB >8A353<A 4A 1 =35 488;D" @5:D AB3 64A3 :@ =3A>A>:8A>775347>N4A>:8">8466>A>:8A:IB4AB4< F3384I45636FEAB3 5>F;847 >>> 3<=:8638A :$ C 8<;54893 :D=48E A: 63=:<>A AB3 9:D=38<4A>:8 4D:;8A I>AB>8 + I33G< @5:D AB3 64A3 :@ 5393>=A :@ 4 9:=E :@ AB><H;6?D38A >J B353<A:@AB3A35D<4869:86>A>:8<53?456>8? 63=:<>A 486 3A9" :563536 FE AB3 5>F;847 53D4>8;847A3536 6 '# ( # ><A:#7:#, #'