- 1 - !! "# # $$%& ' ( ! " # $ % & ''# % #$$ ( $ ') Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * '+'#, ! $- $- ,,&,# " $ $ #) !#" $ $ #',, $ $ ( ( #,#, #',, $ $ $ ( $ $ $ ( - 3 - .(( # ! .(( " /01234/5/016/27896:/5;8134/0<</5506306234/ 1/:<862/63:8062 , =34 786:/63 8; 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 >834 34/ <013=/:34/?033/1=:30@/6;81;=6052=:<8:05 , 4/ >1=/; ;073: 8; 34/ 70:/ 01/ 3403 86 ,,,#&030>893,,,0?A4=5/34/</3=3=86/10586B A=344/1:=:3/1A0:<187//2=6B3802A05;18?050>910B= =601>/01=6B/B8&34/21=C/18;34/01 58:378631858C/1=306234/1/A0:07855=:=86A=340811D >/01=6B/B8')1/:953=6B=6:/C/1/=6E91=/: 38 34/ </3=3=86/1 4/ A0: 02?=33/2 38 8C/16?/63 8:<=305 03 02B=1 062 34/6 38 961=:/ 8:<=305 03 050>91B= A4/1/:4/ 402 30@/6 31/03?/63;81;107391/8; 34/ 2=:305 1=B43 ;/?91 ;107391/ 8; >834 34/ >86/: 8; 34/ 1=B435/B;107391/8;6/7@8;5/;3;/?91;107391/8;:40;38; - 4 - >83434/>86/:8;34/5/;3;81/01?;107391/8;60:05>86/ ;107391/8;34/1=>:8634/5/;3:=2/0:A/550:8634/1=B43 :=2/062;107391/8;34/5/;3750C=75/4/;9134/17863/62/2 3403 :4/ A0: 0 ::=:3063 /074/1 =6 $034=?= 129 =B4/1 1=?01D 74885 062 A0: /016=6B :'#), </1 ?8634 4/1/;81/:4/402750=?/23403:4/40238:</620:9?8; :+,,,,,0::974:4/;=5/20750=?</3=3=86>/;81/34/ 1=>9605 3 A0: 05:8 7862973/2 3403 :4/ A0: 960>5/ 38 1/:9?/ 4/1 293=/: ;81 0 </1=82 8; 6/015D # ?8634: 4/1/;81/ 02/F903/ 78?</6:03=86 ?0D >/ 0A012/2 38 4/1 , 4/1/:<862/63:8#06201/34/8A6/1062 =6:91/18;34/0106234/1/:<862/63:806201/34/ 8A6/1062=6:91/18;34/5811DA=34A4=74014027855=2/2 ,' 4/ 1/:<862/63 8# 2=2 683 0<</01 062 A0: <507/2/G<013/4/1/:<862/63:80620<</01/2 >/;81/ 34/1=>96054/ 1/:<862/63 8 7863/62/23403 34/ 78?</6:03=86 750=?/2 =: 4=B45D /G81>=3063 =?0B=601D 062 963/60>5/ =6 50A 4/ 077=2/63 402 877911/2 86 - 5 - 07789638;34/6/B5=B/67/8634/<0138;34/811D8A6/2 >D1/:<862/6383A0:05:87863/62/2340334/21=C/1 8; 34/ 01 A0: 683 4852=6B 0 C05=2 21=C=6B 5=7/6:/ 4/1/;81/ 34/ 1/:<862/63 8 =: 683 5=0>5/ 38 <0D 34/ 78?</6:03=86 , 4/ 1/:<862/63 8 34/ 8A6/1 8; 34/ 811D 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 78?</6:03=86 750=?/2 =: 4=B45D /G81>=30630622/6=/234/0B/=678?/0628779<03=868; 34/</3=3=86/1 /05:82/6=/206D6/B5=B/67/340378952>/ 0331=>93/23834/21=C/18;811D$9134/1=3A0:7863/62/2 340334/811DA0:=6:91/2A=3434/1/:<862/638062 06D 5=0>=5=3D A8952 40C/ 38 >/ ;0:3/6/2 9<86 34/ 1/:<862/638 ,) 4/1/:<862/638=6:91067/78?<06D388@ 9<:=?=5017863/63=86:0:34038;1/:<862/638055/B=6B 34/6/B5=B/67/86 34/ <013 8; 34/01 21=C/163/105=0 =3 05:82/6=/234/C05=25=7/6:/8;34/5811D21=C/1062:89B43 =3:/G86/103=86 - 6 - ,+ 4/1=>9605;10?/20<<18<1=03/=::9/:06234/ </3=3=86/1 A0: /G0?=6/2 0: # 34/ 287381 A48 0::/::/2 34/ 2=:0>=5=3D A0: /G0?=6/2 062 06834/1 A=36/:: A0: /G0?=6/2 062 G# 38 #' A/1/ ?01@/2 =6 34/ /C=2/67/ 4/ 8;;=7=05 8; 34/ 1/:<862/63 8A0:/G0?=6/20:#06234/8;;=7=058;1/:<862/63 8 A0: /G0?=6/2 0: 062 G# ?01@/2 =6 34/ /C=2/67/ ,& ;3/1 4/01=6B 34/ 01B9?/63: 34/ 1=>9605 40: 0A012/2 34/ 78?</6:03=86 8; :#,&),,, 962/1 34/ ;8558A=6B4/02: 5 8 /02: 8?</6:03=86 A012/2 # 8A012:<0=6062:9;;/1=6B :)',,, 8A012:?/2=705/G</6:/: :)&') 8A012:2=/3062033/62063 7401B/: :',,, 8A012:58::8;=678?/291=6B 50=29<</1=82 :#'#&, ' 8A012:58::8;;9391//016=6B 70<07=3D 8A012:58::8;0?/6=3=/: :#,,,, 8305 :#,&) 830518962/28;; :#,&),,, - 7 - #, 4/ 1=>9605 05:8 ;0:3/6/2 34/ 5=0>=5=3D 8; )'H 86 34/ 1/:<862/63: 8# 062 062 'H 9<86 34/ 1/:<862/63:8062 ## /=6B 0BB1=/C/2 >D 34/ :0?/ 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: >/;81/ 34=: 8913 ://@=6B /64067/?/63 8; 34/ 78?</6:03=86 # 4/5/016/27896:/50<</01=6B;8134/</3=3=86/1 A8952 :9>?=3 3403 34/ 1=>9605 =6 010 #)!" 3489B4 683=7/: 3403 34/ </3=3=86/1 A0: 86 58:: 8; <0D ;18? ,#,,#& 38 ),+,, 062 34/1/ >/=6B 0 7/13=;=703/ =::9/2 0: </1 G& >D 34/ /?<58D/1 70579503/: 34/ 78?</6:03=86 03 :#',&, 4/ 1=>9605 ;0=5/2 38 683=7/ 34/ 5/0C/ A=34893 <0D 062 34=: >/=6B 0 </796=01D 78?</6:03=86/63=35/2>D34/</3=3=86/134/1/=:681/0:86 0::=B6/2 >D 34/ 1=>9605 38 1/297/ 34/ 78?</6:03=86 0?8963 - 8 - # 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0<</01=6B ;81 34/1/:<862/63:80627863/62/2340334/60391/8; 34/ =6E91=/: :9;;/1/2 >D 34/ </3=3=86/1 34/1/ A0: 68 1/F9=1/?/63 38 30@/ 5/0C/ ;18? 4/1 /?<58D?/63 ;81 0 </1=82 8; # ?8634: 3 =: :9>?=33/2 3403 34/ </3=3=86/1 7895240C/30@/634/31/03?/63;81865D0>893,?8634: 06234/1/:38;34/0>:/67/;18?293D=:6830E9:3=;=0>5/ 81 1/5030>5/ 38 34/ =6E91=/: :9:30=6/2 =6 34/ 077=2/63 4/1/;81/34/D2/;/6234/=?<9B6/2E92B?/63<0::/2>D 34/1=>9605 # 60701/;95</19:058;34/1/7812:=3=:/C=2/63 3403 34/ </3=3=86/1 0;3/1 :9:30=6=6B 34/ 077=2/63 86 ,,,#& :4/ A0: 02?=33/2 38 961=:/ 8:<=305 050>910B= 86 ,,,#& 062 :4/ A0: =6<03=/63 3=55 ,),#& A4=74 =: 0>893 '# 20D: 4/ 60391/ 8; 34/ =6E91=/::9:30=6/2>D34/</3=3=86/1=:?/63=86/2=62/30=5 3=:/C=2/63340334/ 8:<=305>=550586/196:3834/396/8; :#,#', 86:=2/1=6B 34/ 60391/ 8; 34/ =6E91=/: A4=7401/?/63=86/20>8C/A4=7401/=6786:86067/A=34 34/2=:7401B/:9??01D<18297/203G#,34/0>:/67/ - 9 - 8;34/</3=3=86/1;18?4/1293=/:;810</1=828;#?8634: 706683 >/ :0=2 38 >/ 961/5030>5/ 4/ =6E91=/: :9:30=6/2 >D 34/ </3=3=86/1 38 4/1 1=B43 58A/1 5=?> 0: A/55 0: 1=B43 9<</15=?>01/75/01/689B438:0D340334/1/:3</1=828; 34/</3=3=86/1A0:3834//G3/638;0>893#?8634:4/ </19:058;G&:48A:3403:4/A0:0>:/63;18?4/1E8> ;18? ,#,,#& 38 ),+,, 4/ 7/13=;=703/ 03 G& =::9<<813/2>D34/ /02?=:31/::8;34/:0=2:74885A48 =: /G0?=6/2 0: 834=6B =: /5=7=3/2 =6 4/1 718:: /G0?=603=86A4=74A89521/62/134/G&96>/5=/C0>5/ 4/1/;81/ =3 =: /C=2/63 3403 34/ 1=>9605 /11/2 =6 683 0A012=6B34/78?</6:03=86=6786:86067/A=3434/58::8; <0D :9;;/1/2 >D 34/ </3=3=86/1 ;81 34/ </1=82 8; 4/1 0>:/67/ ;18? 34/ :74885 =/ ;18? ,#,,#& 38 ),+,, #' 62/1 34/:/ 7=179?:3067/: 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9? 8; :'#), G # I :)+, =6:3/028;:#',&,0:0A012/2>D34/1=>96054/ </3=3=86/1 0<</55063 =: /63=35/2 ;81 :'&,&, !:)+,?=69::#',&," - 10 - # 8 834/1 7863/63=86: 01/ 10=:/2 >/;81/ 34=: 8913=634=:0<</05 /67/0<</052/:/1C/:38>/0558A/2 =6<0134/1/;81/34/;8558A=6B- 4/0<</05=:0558A/2=6<013 4/ 0<</55063 =: /63=35/2 ;810:9?8; :'&,&, =6022=3=8638A40340:>//60A012/2>D34/1=>9605 0586BA=34=63/1/:30334/103/8;H<0;18?203/ 8;</3=3=863=5534/203/8;2/<8:=3 4/ 1/:3 8; 34/ 812/1 <0::/2 >D 34/ 1=>9605 1/B012=6B0<<813=86?/6306278631=>9381D6/B5=B/67/ 8;1/:<862/63:80621/?0=696053/1/2 4/ 1=05 8913 1/7812: >/ 1/3916/2 38 34/ 1=>9605 0586BA=3478<D8;34=:E92B?/63;8134A=34 2 %# ' # (( =:38#58