- 1 - !"! #$ " "$ % &$! ' ! " #$ % & ' $$ ( $ )* $ ! *+ # $ % ' $ ,%)' $ $ *)**", (**"** $ $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % - ' """"". $ $ / & %$ / &' 01234335106078950:0;<1=2=>?05@0<1<1=2>1A07 B27050;<1=2* =><?0=70=>51C124A$5=;07B50 %?050124><05 50>05507 <= 4D E<?0 5$F >=5 D?=5<' D00G123C412<0242;0<?0@0<1<1=205.H1>0?4D>1A07<?1D @0<1<1=2 43412D< 50D@=2702<.?BD8427 ;=2<027123 <?4< <?01C@B3207=57051D2=<124;;=5742;0H1<?A4H427 A148A0<=80D0<4D170?0514A=B5<?4D50:0;<07?05 @54905 =2A9 =2 <?0 35=B27 <?4< <?0 >4<?05 => <?0 @0<1<1=205?4D@B5;?4D074D1<0>=5?05?0@0<1<1=205 1D A16123 D0@454<0A9 4D50D@=2702< ?4D751602 ?05 =B< => <?0 C4<51C=214A ?=C0 4AA03123 1AA1;1< 50A4<1=2D?1@ 8B<?0?4D>41A07<=@5=60<?0D4C0 - 3 - * 0D@=2702<.?BD8427 ?4D 4@@04507 427 ;=2<0D<07<?0;4D0;=2<027123<?4<@0<1<1=2051DA16123 12 47BA<059 ?050>=50 ?0 ?4D >1A07 =*,*", 43412D<<?0@0<1<1=205427?05@454C=B5427=2A94><05 >1A123 => <?0 D417 @0<1<1=2 @0<1<1=205.H1>0 >1A07 C412<0242;0@0<1<1=2>=5?05427?0574B3?<05 * ><05<4G12312<=;=2D17054<1=2<?0061702;0 @A4;07=250;=57<?0514A=B5< ?4D 513?<A9 50:0;<07 <?0@0<1<1=2D=>454D@0<1<1=205.H1>01D;=2;05207427 <?050 450 2= :BD<1>148A0 35=B27D <= 12<05>050 H1<? <?0 D417=5705427@549<=71DC1DD<?1D@0<1<1=24AD= 0457453BC02<D427@05BD07<?050;=57 ) ?0 50A4<1=2D?1@ 80<H002 <?0 @45<10D 1D 2=< 12 71D@B<0 ?015 C4551430 ?4D <4G02 @A4;0 =2 "+" *""(427<?5=B3?<?0H07A=;G@0<1<1=205=*1D 8=52 - 4 - 2 <?0 @0<1<1=2 <?0 @0<1<1=205 ?4D 4AA0307 <?4< H?1A0 D?0 H4D A16123 H1<? 50D@=2702< D?0 H4D >=5;07<=H=5G12<?0?=BD0=>542<=D?$4<1A427?0 <5107<=54@0?05?050>=50D?04<<0C@<07<=;=CC1< DB1;170 8B< D?0 H4D 47C1<<07 <= 4<D4A94 =D@1<4A 4A48B5431 0;4BD0 => <?1D 12;1702< 50D@=2702< @105;07 ?1D <?BC8 12<= ?05 513?< 090 4D 4 50DBA< => H?1;? D?0 A=D< D13?< 12 ?05 513?< 090 ?0 ?4D 4AD= 4AA0307 <?4< 4A=23 H1<? <?0 50D@=2702< ?1D >4C1A9 C0C805D H050 >=5;123 ?05 <= ?460 12<05;=B5D0 H1<? D<542305D 427H?02 D?050>BD07 <?09 BD07<= 48BD0 ?05?09H0504AD=>=5;123?05<=30<4?=BD0*4;50D =>A4273=A7 427C=209 >5=C ?05 @4502<D427H?02 D?07172=<43500H1<?<?0D4C0=2<?0C17213?<=> "*"! D?0 H4D 751602 =B< => <?0 C4<51C=214A ?=C0 2 "*", H?02 D?0 H4D 12 ?05 @4502<D ?=BD050D@=2702<4A=23H1<?).+@05D=2D;4C0<?050 427<5107<=G1AA@0<1<1=205=*4274AD=4DD4BA<07?05 - 5 - 045123>=5?05A1>0D?0427@0<1<1=205=*450A16123 12?05@4502<D?=BD0 2 <?0 D<4<0C02< => =8:0;<1=2D 50D@=2702< ?4D7021074AA<?04AA034<1=2DC47012<?0@0<1<1=20 ?4D4AA0307<?4<@0<1<1=2051D?461231AA1;1<50A4<1=2D?1@ H1<?=20434224<?D=434@@4=>?4274@B5H?=1D 2= =<?05 <?42 <?0 D=2 => @4<0524A 4B2< => @0<1<1=205 ?01DA161231247BA<059427A0><<?0C4<51C=214A?=C0 H1<? ?05 74B3?<05 ><05 H41<123 >=5 4AA <?0D0 9045D 7B5123 *", <?0 50D@=2702< >1A07 =*,*", 43412D<<?0@0<1<1=205427D417434224<?427D=B3?< 716=5;0 * 2A9 4><05 >1A123 => D417 @0<1<1=2 <?0 @0<1<1=205;4C0B@H1<?4@0<1<1=2B27050;<1=2* =>5$>=5C412<0242;012;0<?0@0<1<1=205A16123 1247BA<0594274AD=<4G12312<=;=2D17054<1=2<?0=54A 4277=;BC02<459061702;0=250;=57<?0514A=B5< - 6 - ?4D513?<A950:0;<07<?0@0<1<1=2D=>454D@0<1<1=2051D ;=2;05207 427 =570507 C412<0242;0 12 >46=B5 => <?0 74B3?<054<<?054<0=> """.@05C=2<?H?1;??0 1D@49123503BA45A9 + ?0@0<1<1=205?4DC470D051=BD4AA034<1=2D 43412D<50D@=2702<427?1D>4C1A9C0C805D?0?4D 4AD=C4704AA034<1=2D43412D<542<=D?$4<1A<?4<?0 ?4D<5107<=54@0?05427D?0<5107<=;=CC1<DB1;170 0D@=2702<427?1D>4C1A9C0C805DH050>=5;123?05 <=?460D0IB4A12<05;=B5D0H1<?D<542305D4274AD=<= 30<7=H59 12 <?0 >=5C => A427 ?=BD0 ;4D? 4273=A7 =524C02<D7C1<<07A9D?0?4D2=<>1A07429;=C@A412< 43412D< <?0 50D@=2702< =5 ?1D >4C1A9 C0C805D =5 542<=D?$4<1A ( ?0 @0<1<1=205 ?4D 3=20 <= <?0 0I<02< => D49123 <?4< 50D@=2702< @105;07 ?1D <?BC8 12<= ?05 513?<090427D?0A=D<D13?<12<?0D417090=H0605 - 7 - 7B5123 ?05 ;5=DD.0I4C124<1=2 <?0 @0<1<1=205 ?4D 47C1<<07<?4<>5=C;?1A7?==7D?0DB>>0507;4<454;<12 =200908B<702107<?4<D?0?47A=D<D13?<12<?0D417 090 7B0 <= ;4<454;< =H0605 D?0 ?4D 2=< @5=7B;07 429 061702;0 <= D?=H <?4< =2 4;;=B2< => 50D@=2702< @105;123 ?1D <?BC8 12<= ?05 513?< 090 D?0 80;4C0 8A12712<?0D417090 ! $0<1<1=205 ?4D 4AD= 47C1<<07 <?4< 7B5123 0;0C805*""D?03460815<?<=4D=2427?071074D D?0 H4D DB>>05123 >5=C :4B271;0 %' B5123 ?05 ;5=DD.0I4C124<1=2 <?0 @0<1<1=205 ?4D 47C1<<07 <?4< 50D@=2702< ?4D @B5;?4D07 4 D1<0 12 ?05 24C0 >5=C 4524<4G4 =BD123 =457 CC0714<0A9 4><05 <?1D 47C1DD1=2D?0?4D;?42307?05605D1=2D49123<?4<1< H4D @B5;?4D07 89 ?05 >4<?05 12 ?05 24C0 =H0605 D?0?4D2=<@5=7B;074297=;BC02<D<=061702;0<?0 D417>4;< - 8 - , ?0 @0<1<1=205 ?4D ;A41C07 <?4< 50D@=2702< 1D5B221234C071;4AD?=@4270452123 """"".@05 C=2<? =H0605 2= 061702;0 1D @5=7B;07 <= @5=60 <?0 D4C0 2 <?0 =<?05 ?427 <?0 <0D<1C=29 => 50D@=2702< 1271;4<0D <?4< ?0 1D H=5G123 12 4 C071;4A D?=@ 0 ?4D 4AD= >1A07 @0<1<1=2 D00G123 716=5;0 >5=C @0<1<1=205=2<?035=B27<?4<D?01DA161231247BA<059 H1<? 434224<? H?= 1D 2==<?05<?42 <?0 D=2=> ?05 @4<0524A 4B2< ?=B3? <?0 @0<1<1=205 ;A41CD <?4< =2 "*"! D?0 H4D 751602 =B< => <?0 C4<51C=214A ?=C0D?0?4D;?=D02<=;A41CC412<0242;0=2A94><05 50D@=2702<>1A07@0<1<1=2>=5716=5;043412D<?05 " 4G123 12<= ;=2D17054<1=2 <?0 =54A 427 7=;BC02<459 061702;0 @A4;07 =2 50;=57 427 0I4C12123 <?0 50D@0;<160 ;=2<02<1=2D => <?0 @45<10D 42712<?0A13?<=><?0061702;0A0789<?0C<?0514A =B5<?4D;=C0<=<?0;=2;ABD1=2<?4<@0<1<1=2051D2=< - 9 - 02<1<A07 >=5 C412<0242;0 8B< 3542<07 C412<0242;0 4< <?054<0=> """.@05C=2<?<=<?01574B3?<05 ><0550.4@@50;14<1=2=><?0061702;0@A4;07 =2 50;=57 <?1D =B5< >127D 2= :BD<1>148A0 35=B27D <= 12<05>050 H1<? <?0 =5705 12 JB0D<1=2 =H0605 1> <?0 50D@=2702< >41AD <= 0D<48A1D? <?4< D?0 1D A16123 12 47BA<059 @0<1<1=205 C49 ;A41C C412<0242;0 43412D< ?1C12<?0C4<51C=214A;4D01<D0A> * 2 <?0 50DBA< @0<1<1=2 >41AD 427 4;;=57123A9 <?0>=AA=H123 1' ?0@0<1<1=21D71DC1DD07 7. ("$ %) " 1D<=A=)