- 1 - ! ! "# $ $# % & & ' ( ) ! " # $ " !%%& ' ( ) " * " # Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !%#++%& & % &$&, " !%%& ' ( &) ($) " $$% % ++&+&, " -&+& " -&+& . - 3 - . / (./ ) 01234561313708396:;0:6<5<7=347176>1370($)78 126 ?@8 >1 $$% (A >1 $$%B 87< 427<1) <6?: C312 6>1370 % 78 7:6 78 3=39 <7>6:;<6 (A126 B 87< 427<1) 561313706< C27 34 59?301388 D687<6 126 ?<0?1?E? ?@8 <3D;0?9 (A<3D;0?9B 87< 427<1) 2?4 >2?9960F6: 126 7<:6< :?16: ++&+&, 70 7 8396: ;0:6< <:6< - ;96 (?) ?0: (:) <6?: C312 46>1370 % 78 DG :6860:?01 7& DG C23>2 126 <3D;0?9 ?997C6: 126 4?3: ?5593>?1370 ?0: :34H3446: 126 4;31 87< C?01 78 >?;46 78 ?>1370 ?0: ?947 70 126 F<7;0: 12?1 4;31 34 D?<<6: DG 6>1370#?0:78126 >1$$% & 7< 126 4?E6 78 >70=60360>6 126 5?<1364 ?<6 <686<<6:17DG1263<<?0E4D687<6126<3D;0?9 - 4 - 0 4;557<1 78 126 56131370 126 561313706< 2?4 >70160:6: 12?1 126 3H5;F06: 7<:6< 34 3996F?9 6<<7067;4 ?0:0714;41?30?D9663126<309?C7<708?>14?0:93?D9617 D6 461 ?43:6 0 126 93F21 78 59?301 ?=6<H6014 ?0: 126 >701601370 78 126 59?301388 126 <3D;0?9 2?4 6<<6: 30 :34D6936=30F 126 59?301388B4 >?46 ?0: :34H34430F 126 4;31 C3127;1 5<756< ?5593>?1370 78 I;:3>3?9 H30: 1 2?4 ?947 8?396:176J?H30612?159?3013882?4596?:6:?0:H?:67;1 126>?;4678?>137087<83930F1264;31 , 26 <3D;0?9 2?4 8?396: 17 1?E6 3017 >7043:6<?1370 126 7<:6< :?16: ++&+&& 5?446: DG 126 70BD96 56J 7;<1 30 7&+&+ ?0: 30 8?3930F 17 6J>9;:612656<37:8<7H%+&+&+17&+&&+&&7;178 126 93H31?1370 816< :6:;>130F 126 4?3: 56<37: 4;31 >2?9960F30F 126 7<:6< :?16: &-+%&+$ 34 C31230 13H6 5593>?1370 7-&+&+ 8396: 126 59?301388 C?4 :34H3446: 6=60 127;F2 234 >7;0469 47;F21 13H6 ?0: 126<687<6 59?301388 >?0071 D6 5<6>9;:6: 8<7H >2?9960F30F 126 8<642 ?557301H601 78 :6860:?01 7& 5593>?1370 7-&+&+ - 5 - ?0: 7-&+& ?<6 071 D?46: 70 4?H6 >?;46 78 ?>1370 % 26<3D;0?92?4?9476<<6:30?55<6>3?130F126 8?>1 12?1 126 >?;46 78 ?>1370 87< 83930F 126 4;31 ?<746 70 &$+&+&C2607<:6<C?45?446:?55730130F:6860:?01 7& ?4 ;1?C?993 3996F?99G 30>6 93H31?1370 34 ? H3J6: @;641370789?C?0:8?>14126<3D;0?97;F21071172?=6 :34H3446: 126 ?556?9 70 126 F<7;0: 78 93H31?1370 C3127;1 279:30F 60@;3<G 26 <3D;0?9 2?4 ?947 6<<6: 30 279:30F 12?14;3134231DG6>137078 >1$$%134<696=?0117 071612?1127;F26>1370D?<4I;<34:3>1370783=397;<1 126<63407D?<87<83930F1264;31D687<6126<3D;0?930>6 59?301388C?4071?5?<1G171265<7>66:30F430C23>27<:6< :?16: &$+&+& C?4 5?446: ?0: 126<687<6 93H31?1370 34 <6@;3<6:17D6>?9>;9?16:8<7H126:?1678E07C96:F6 # 2396 :6>3:30F ?0 ?5593>?1370 ;0:6< <:6< - ;96781267;<134<6@;3<6:17977E3017709G126 59?301 ?=6<H6014 ?0: 126 C<31160 41?16H601 >?0071 D6 977E6: 3017 26 ?=6<H6014 78 126 6013<6 59?301 34 17 D6 - 6 - 1?E603017>7043:6<?137017?4>6<1?30C26126<126<634?0G >?;46 78 ?>1370 87< 126 4;31 36C6: 8<7H ?0G ?0F96 126 3H5;F06: 7<:6< 34 071 4;41?30?D96 ?0: 5<?G 17 ?997C 126 56131370 461 ?43:6 126 4?H6 ?0: :3<6>1 126 <3D;0?9 17 :6>3:61264;3130?>>7<:?0>6C3129?C - 04;557<178234?<F;H601496?<06:>7;046987< 12659?3013882?4<6936:;57012687997C30F:6>343704. ! "# " " $ ! % & ' " '"( %)) * +&, - ./0 * 1 %* 2&& ") 3 4* !& 5 1 &++#& &&+% &$&& &+%%- ,7#$&+ - 7 - 6?<06:>7;046987<<64570:6017&4;DH3116: 12?1430>612659?301:764071:34>9746>?;4678?>1370?0: 31 34 D?<<6: DG 93H31?1370 126<687<6 <64570:601 7& 8396: 7 ;0:6< <:6< - <;96 (?) 78 17 <6I6>1 126 59?301 816<>7043:6<30F1267DI6>13708396:DG12659?301388 126<3D;0?92?45?446:1263H5;F06:7<:6<?0:126<6?<6 07I;41383?D96F<7;0:4173016<86<6C3121264?H6?0:5<?G 17<6I6>112656131370 $ 04;557<178234?<F;H601496?<06:>7;046987< 126<64570:6017&2?4<6936:;570126:6>343704. %6 "#!7 ") 4 4) "& 4)8$"9 8$ %$ :!# )"; < %-$% =&; > & - 4 = 0 +% ? %$#;55% #(&+&+)##+ -(&+&+)-## (&+&),% - 8 - 2* 0 2 2 $ 3 ; * 2 $ 4* @ &&* 3 A " "# = 4 ";% "& - ; % '&1&4$; ( 4 2- 3) 4 -; , + 6?<:?<F;H6014?0:56<;46:126<6>7<:4 9?301388 8396: 4;31 30 @;641370 C312 ? 5<?G6< 17 :6>9?<6 12?1 26 34 126 :3<6>1 :64>60:601 78 ?K<?1 ;83 ?<H?41 4?: 9 ;93G?()?0:2?4?<3F21?0:3016<641 17?:H303416<?0:H?0?F6126?<F??44;>>6447<?II?:? ?4230 ?0: ;1?C?993 78 126 0713836: ?@8 304131;1370 ?0: 461?43:61267<:6<:?16:&$+&+&5?446:DG:6860:?01 7?43996F?9?0:=73:$B ?0:7126<<69368462?4 ?947 47;F21 87< <641<?3030F :6860:?01 7& 8<7H $(&++#)#&+- +(&+&)-+# (&+#),&-% &&+&3=6?C()-& 3=39 556?97,#&$&+&, - 9 - ?:H303416<30F ?0: H?0?F30F 126 ?<F? 78 ?K<?12 ;83 ?<H?41 4?: 9 ;93G?(A?<F?B87<427<1) & 134126>?467812659?30138812?12634126:3<6>1 :64>60:601 78 ?K<?12 ;83 ?<H?41 4?: 9 ;93G? 26 0713836: ;1?C?993 78?K<?12 ;83 ?<H?41 4?: 9 ;93G? (0713836:A ;1?C?993B87<427<1)C?4H?0?F30F126?88?3<478 126 ?<F? 816< 234 :6H346 30 $+ 234 69:6< 470 G6: ?G?4;::30 ?<H?41 C?4 H?0?F30F 126 ?88?3<4 78 126 ?<F?6:36:30126G6?<$$ 816<234:6?1223469:6< 470G6: 1?;99??<H?41C?4H?0?F30F126?88?3<478126 ?<F? ?4 56< 7<:6< :?16: +&++# 0 126 4?3: 7<:6< :6860:?01 77?<: 2?4 <686<<6: 17 =?<37;4 9313F?1370 D61C66023H?0:706?H66:?42??<H?41?0:5?446: 7<:6<4308?=7;<78G6: 1?;99??<H?41 G6: 1?;99? ?<H?41 C?4 344;69644 0 +-+,&++$ 26 4696>16: ?0: :6>9?<6: 59?301388 ?4 234 4;>>6447< ?II?:? ?4230 30 126 5<6460>6 78 8?H39G H6HD6<478 ;83?<H?41 ?42?3E KK?H ?0:;E2<? ?1 126 5<6H3464 78 ?:?< 27;E2?0:3 78 2<306 78 ?K?<?1 - 10 - ;83 ?<H?41 () >>7<:30F9G 70 &+$&+# ?816< 126 :6?1278G6: 1?;99??<H?41C31212656<H34437078234 H7126<?0:301265<6460>678?991268?H39GH6HD6<478 ?K<?1 ;83 ?<H?41 () 30 126 5<6460>6 78 ?42?3E KK?H ?0: ;E2?<??:?< 27;E2?0:3 ?1 42<306 78 ?K<?1;83?<H?41()59?301388C?4:6>9?<6:?4?II?:? ?0:4;>>6447<78?<F??K?<?1;83?<H?41 4?: ;93G? () ?0: 314 5<756<1364 :7>;H601 >?H6 3017 6J34160>6 C23>2 2?4 D660 C3106446: ?0: ?>E07C96:F6: DG ?99 126 56<4704C27C6<65<646016860:?017&?0:2348?126< C6<6 ?947 5<64601 ?0: C3106446: 126 4?3: :7>;H601 26<687<6 126G ?<6 6417556: 8<7H >9?3H30F 7126<C346 9?301388 ?0: 234 H7126< >70130;6: 126 46<=3>64 ?:H303416<6: ?0: H?0?F6: 126 ?88?3<4 78 126 ?@8 04131;13704 , 0 +-+&&+ 59?301388 3013H?16: 126 ?@8 883>6< ?:F3< 260 1230F4 4177: 12;4 70 &#+$&+$ 126 ?:F3< 2?4 & 4601 ? 5<7574?987<?557301H60178:6860:?017&?4 ;1?C?993 - 11 - 01234<6F?<::6860:?017&2?4F3=60?5593>?1370:?16: &$+$&+$ C23>2 34 ?816< 126 5<7574?9 78 126 ?:F3< 4 56< 126 4?3: 5<7574?9 :6860:?01 7& C?4 ?5573016:?4 ;1?C?9934;DI6>117?>70:3137012?12642?99 <6417<6 ?@8 5<756<1G H6?4;<30F &# F;01?4 30 ;<=6G 7$ 78 ?:?4?F?< 2?2?5;< ?9;E C23>2 C?4 41?0:30F301260?H6782348?126< % 7C6=6<12660@;3<G7883>6<?0:2?=6071 6J5<6446:?0G753037070126?5593>?13707859?301388;0:6< 6>1370 ,&() 78 ?@8 >1 $%% 87< >7083<H?1370 78 4;>>6443700234<657<11262?441?16:12?159?301388 3430=79=6:307,#,$$87<12678860>65;0342?D96 ;0:6< 6>1370 $& 78 ?0: 126<687<6 234 ?557301H601 >?0071 D6 >7043:6<6: ?4 56< 46>1370 #,(D) 78 ?@8 >1 264?3:5<7=343703487<<6H7=?978 ;1?C?993?0:07187< ?557301H601 26<687<6 126 7530370 78 126 34 3996F?9 ?0: ?F?3041 9?C 26 4?3: >?46 C?4 <6F3416<6: 70 126 30413F?1370 78 :6860:?01 7& ?0: 234 8?126< :;<30F 126 H307<31G7859?301388?0:3160:6:30?>@;311?9 - 12 - # 3:6 7<:6< :?16: -+&+&+ :6860:?01 & C?4 ?5573016: ?4 ;1?C?993 87< ? 56<37: 78 G6?<4 1 34 =73: $B 0:6< 6>1370 # 78 ?@8 >1 59?301388 >2?9960F6: 126 4?H6 30 5593>?1370 7-&+&+ D687<6 126 ?@8 <3D;0?9 ?9?D;<?F3 ;<30F 56<37: 31 C?4 :34H3446: 87< 0705<746>;1370 816< 6J53<G 78 G6?<4 ?F?30:6860:?017&H?:6?5593>?137070&++&&+&87< >7083<H?1370 78 ;1?C?9934235 630F ? 41<?0F6< 17 126 59?301388B48?H39G;0:6<6>1370,&()78?@8 >1?0:;96 %%78?@8;964:6860:?017&>?0071>9?3H26<6:31?<G ;1?C?9934235 0 4;557<1 78 126 ?5593>?1370 :6860:?01 7& 2?4 4C7<0 17 8?946 ?883:?=31 26 ?557301H601 78 :6860:?01 7& 34 ?F?3041 126 16<H4 78 :66: 78 ?@8 6>1370,&()?0:;96%%78126?@8;964 - 4 56< 6>1370 &(&)(F) 78 126 ?@8 >1 ?0: ;96%#126?@87?<:340712?=30F?;127<31G17?557301 26<6:31?<G ;1?C?993 ?0: 126<687<6 7<:6< :?16: &$+&+&34071160?D96?0:93?D9617D6461?43:626 ?557301H601 78 :6860:?01 7& ?4 26<6:31?<G ;1?C?993 - 13 - ?H7;014 17 :603?9 78 =6416: <3F214 78 59?301388 26<687<6 3016<86<60>6 DG 126 <3D;0?9 34 06>644?<G 1 34 ?947 <6@;3<6: 17 30I;0>1 :6860:?01 7& 8<7H 3016<86<30F C312 :?G 17 :?G ?:H30341<?1370 ?0: H?0?F6H601 78 126 ?@8 04131;1370 26 8?>14 0?<<?16: 30 126 59?301 >704131;16 >?;4678?>1370?0:260>64;3187<46=6<?9<693684 2;4 D687<6 126 <3D;0?9 :6860:?01 7& 8396: 7 ;0:6< <:6< - ;96 (?) 78 17 <6I6>1 126 59?30170126F<7;0:12?11264;3134D?<<6:DG93H31?1370 ?0:126<63407>?;4678?>1370 $ 13407130:345;1612?1126?<F?30@;64137034 ? 0713836: ?@8 04131;1370 ?0: 59?301388 34 126 9306?9 :64>60:601 78 126 0713836: ;1?C?993 0 126 4;31 30 234 5<?G6<30?::31370177126<<69368412659?3013882?447;F21 87< >7<<6>130F 601<364 30 126 071383>?1370 DG 30>7<57<?130F 234 0?H6 ?4 26<6:31?<G ;1?C?993 ?1 9-% ?0: -# 78 F?K6116 071383>?1370 :?16: #+,$-, 1 34 56<130601 17 071612?112659?30138834>9?3H30F26<6:31?<G ;1?C?9934235 78 126 ?<F? 30 @;641370 30 234 >?5?>31G ?4 126 9306?9 - 14 - :64>60:601780713836: ;1?C?9931344;883>360187<23H17 5<7=6 12?1 26 34 ? 9306?9 :64>60:601 78 126 0713836: ;1?C?993 26<6 34 07 066: 87< 4;D4131;130F 234 0?H6 30 126 F?K6116 071383>?1370 26<687<6 126 4?3: 5<?G6< 34 ?D4;<: 9?301388 34 071 >9?3H30F <3F21 78 ;1?C?9934235 ?4 ?F?3041 126 0713836: ;1?C?993 ?0: 126<687<6 126<6 34 07 066: 87< 23H 17 >2?9960F6 126 601<G 30 126 F?K6116 071383>?1370C31230?56<37:78706G6?<?4<6@;3<6:;0:6< 5<7=347786>1370#()78126 >147?417279:12?1126 4;3134D?<<6:DG93H31?1370 &+ 134?94707130:345;1612?112669:6<D<7126<78 59?301388G6: 1?;99? ?<H?41 C?4 :34>2?<F30F 126 :;1364 7826<6:31?<G ;1?C?993?456<7<:6<:?16:+&++#?0: 26:36:70&+$&+#6C?4344;69644 816<234:6?12 59?301388>9?3H30F17D61269306?9:64>60:601781260713836: ;1?C?993 <6@;6416: :6860:?01 7 17 ?557301 23H ?4 26<6:31?<G ;1?C?993 :H3116:9G ?1 12?1 13H6 7,#,$$ C?4 560:30F ?F?3041 126 59?301388 87< 126 78860>65;0342?D96;0:6<6>1370$&7827;F2126 - 15 - :6860:?01 7& 2?4 071 5?446: ? 456>383> 7<:6< <6I6>130F 234 ?5593>?1370 87< ?557301H601 78 ;1?C?993 ?4 56< 126 96116< :?16: &-+%&+$ ?0 3013H?1370 C?4 4601 17 126 341<3>1 ?@8 883>6< ?:3F3< 41?130F 12?1 430>6 ? ><3H30?9 >?46 34 560:30F ?F?3041 126 59?301388 26 >?0071 D6 ?5573016: ?4 ;1?C?993 3:6 7<:6< :?16: -+&+&+ :6860:?01 7 2?4 ?5573016: :6860:?01 7& ?4 1?C?993C312?>70:3137012?12348?H39G42?99<6417<6126 5<756<1GD6970F30F17126?@8304131;137030@;641370 & 9?301388 >2?9960F6: 126 4?H6 30 5593>?1370 7-&+&+ 456<1267<:6<42661H?301?306:301264?3: >?46 126 4?3: ?5593>?1370 >?H6 17 D6 :34H3446: 70 &,&+& 87< :68?;91 0>6 ?F?30 =3:6 7<:6< :?16: &$+&+& :6860:?01 7& C?4 ?5573016: ?4 ;1?C?993 7C 126 59?301388 34 >9?3H30F 12?1 126 ><3H30?9 >?46 C23>2 C?4 8396: ?F?3041 23H 30 7,#,$$ C?4 ?1 126 3041?0>6 78 :6860:?01 7& ?0: 234 8?126< ?0: 26 34 ?>@;3116: 30 126 4?3: >?46 >>7<:30F9G 26 2?4 8396: -&+& 87< ? :6>9?<?1370 12?1 26 34 126 :3<6>1 - 16 - :64>60:?01 78 126 0713836: ;1?C?993 ?0: 2?4 ? <3F21 17 ?:H303416<126?@804131;137030@;641370 && 6<;4?97812659?301?=6<H6014>96?<9G30:3>?164 12?1126>?;4678?>1370>9?3H6:DG12659?30138834<6>;<<30F >?;46 78 ?>1370 4 ?0: C260 234 <3F21 17 >9?3H ;1?C?9934235 34 :6036: DG ?55730130F 47H6 7126< 56<470 ?4 ;1?C?993301234>?46:6860:?017&>?;4678?>1370 ?<346 87< 23H 17 >9?3H 126 <69368 26 6013<6 59?301 ?=6<H6014?<6<6@;3<6:17D61?E603017>7043:6<?137017 ?4>6<1?30C26126< 126<6 34 ?0G >?;46 78 ?>137017 8396 126 4;31 0 126 59?301 31 066: 071 D6 456>3836: 30 ? 5?<13>;9?< 5?<? ?4 17 C2?1 6J?>19G 34 126 >?;46 78 ?>1370 12?1 2?4 ?<346087<12659?3013881783961264;3126<687<6126<3?9 7;<12?46<<6:30279:30F12?1126<63407>?;4678?>1370 87< 126 4;31 30>6 126 <3F21 78 59?301388 17 >9?3H ;1?C?9934235 34 <6>;<<30F >?;46 78?>1370126<3?9 7;<1 2?4 ?947 6<<6: 30 279:30F 12?1 126 4;31 34 D?<<6: DG 93H31?1370 - 17 - & 7< 126 ?D7=6 <6?4704 126 7;<1 34 78 126 >7043:6<6:753037012?11263H5;F06:7<:6<3493?D9617D6 461?43:6?0:?>>7<:30F9G12687997C30F. (3) 26 56131370 8396: DG 126 59?301388 ;0:6< 5<7=347 17 6>1370 ($) 78 126 ?@8 >1 $$%3426<6DG?997C6: (33) 26 3H5;F06: 7<:6< :?16: ++&+&, 30 7-&+& DG 126 ?<0?1?E? ?@8 <3D;0?9 ?9?D;<?F334461?43:6 (333) 26 4;31 34 <6417<6: 17 8396 26 ?@8 <3D;0?9 5<7>66: C312 126 H?116< 30 ?>>7<:?0>6C3129?C : '$# %( $ ..,$