Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 10022 (KAR)
SWAPNA v. MALLIKARJUN
MFA/201128/2024 · 2025-02-14
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10022 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 10022 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! " #$
! %
#$ $
""&' (
!"# $
%
&
'
(
! ) !"*# $
%
'
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+ + !,%!' + +
# #+
## #**"*" !"#"#*"* -
# # +
+
+ +
+#
+ +
. ##
. #
$ %
. ## '
/0 1203045 611067 /63 8004 9:70; 8< 5/0 =:90 =/> =63 5/0 2031>4;045 809>20 5/0 ;;7# 2:4?:167 @;A0 +6B:7< >@25 6768@26A: %9>2 3/>25- 5/0 +6B:7< >@25-' ;0904;:4A5/0105:5:>49:70;8<5/0/@3864;@4;020?5:>4 !%!'%:6'>95/0:4;@ 622:6A0?5!,%9>23/>25C5/0 ?5-'300D:4A;:33>7@5:>4>95/0B652:B>4:6720765:>43/:1>4 5/0 A2>@4; >9 ?2@075<# /0 ;0?200 >9 ;:33>7@5:>4 >9 B622:6A0/6E:4A800416330;36B0:3:4?/67704A08<5/0 611077645 =/> =63 5/0 2031>4;045 809>20 5/0 +6B:7< >@25#
- 3 -
*# /0 1625:03 620 2090220; 5> 63 102 5/0:2 264D 809>205/052:67>@25>95/01@21>30>9?>4E04:04?0#
# /0 B652:B>4:67 ?630 ?6B0 5> 80 9:70; @4;02 0?5:>4 !%!'%:6' >9 5/0 ?5 300D:4A ;:33>7@5:>4 >9 5/0 =0;7>?D 3>70B4:F0; >4 *#"(#*"! 805=004 5/0 1625:03# 5 :3 5/0 ?630 >9 5/0 105:5:>402 5/65 5/0 2031>4;045 =63 920G@0457<1:?D:4A@1G@622073=:5/5/0105:5:>4024>5?> >10265:4A =:5/ 1029>2B64?0 >9 />@30/>7; >87:A65:>43 64; ;@5:03920G@0457<A>:4A5>/021620453/>@3064;356<:4A 5/0209>2B>45/35>A05/02:4502902:4A=:5/5/02031>4;045 :4/:31029>2B64?0>9>99:?:67;@5:038<920G@0451/>40?6773 =:5/ 7>4A ?>4E02365:>4 ;@2:4A >99:?0 />@23 B:380/6E:4A =:5/5/0105:5:>4025/206504:4A9:7:4A>9?>B176:4536A6:435 5/0 105:5:>402 64; >5/02 :43564?03 6B>@45:4A 5> 6?53 >9 ?2@075<=020A2>@4;326:30;:45/0105:5:>4# # 5 :3 4>5:?0; 5/65 5/0 2031>4;045 =63 176?0;
>45/0863:3>94>5:?030455/2>@A/
/6E:4A 8004 209@30; 64; 5/0 +6B:7< >@25 /63 12>?00;0; 5>
- 4 -
20?>2; 6 9:4;:4A >4 1>:453 9>2 ?>43:;0265:>4 26:30; :4 5/0 99:2B65:E064;/63;:33>7E0;5/0B652:B>4:6720765:>43/:1#
# >:459>2?>43:;0265:>4926B0;809>205/0+6B:7< >@25:3639>77>=3
(# 9502/>7;:4A:45/0699:2B65:E06320A62;33@?/ ?>45045:>45/0+6B:7<>@25/6312>?00;0;5>;:31>30>9 5/0105:5:>4# H# 11067 :3 9:70; 8< 5/0 2031>4;045 ) =:90 64;
E62:>@3 ?>45045:>43 /6E0 8004 26:30; 64; 310?:9:?677< 633025:4A 5/65 4> 4>5:?0 =63 302E0;# +@25/02 3@8B:550; 5/655/>@A/4>5:?0=6335650;5>/6E08004302E0;:45/0 304305/651>35674>5:?030458<
=6335650;5>/6E0 8004 C 5/0 36:; 4>5:?0 =63 :33@0; 5> 5/0 2031>4;045 65 5/0 6;;2033 B045:>40; :4 5/0 105:5:>4 65 C> 3/>D 6A62 7>?D 062
6B465/ 64A/ 6B@;6<6/6E646B6761@2G#&:35#6768@26A:3
- 5 -
>45/0;650>96770A0;302E:?0>9
4>5:?0:45/0B>45/ >90150B802*"**5/02031>4;045/6;67206;<3/:950;5> 5/0/67D:#5:3310?:9:?677<6330250;5/655/02031>4;045 /6;70955/0/>@30>4*#"*#*"*"64;3@?/96?5:30E:;045 92>B5/0102@367>95/0105:5:>49:70;@4;020?5:>4!*>9 5/0 2>50?5:>4 >9 >B04 92>B >B035:?
:>704?0 ?5 *"" >4 *(#"H#*"** =/020:4 5/0 6;;2033 >9 5/0 2031>4;045=633/>=463I
>6B6761@2G#6B6761@2 :35#6768@26A: 4>=203:;:4A65676J:6A62 /67D:G# /67D: :35# :;62K =/:?/ :3 5/0 6;;2033 65 /67D:# /0 611077645 /63 9:70; ?025:9:0; ?>1< >9 ;>?@B0453 :4?7@;:4A 5/0105:5:>4?>1<9:70;@4;025/012>E:3:>43>92>50?5:>4>9 >B0492>B>B035:?:>704?0?5=/:?/=6312030450;
>4 *(#"H#*"** =/020:4 5/0 6;;2033 >9 5/0 2031>4;045 :3 3/>=463/67D:#??>2;:4A7<:5:33@8B:550;5/655/096?5 5/65 5/0 2031>4;045 =63 302E0; 65 5/0 6;;2033 65 6B6761@2 =63 5/0 =2>4A 6;;2033 5> =/:?/ 4>5:?0 =63 3045 64; 5/0 1>3567 C209@30;- ?644>5 80 56D04 5> /6E080043@99:?:0454>5:?0#
- 6 -
#
06240; ?>@4307 9>2 5/0 2031>4;045 =>@7; 3@8B:55/655/0;>?@B0453>95/02031>4;045:4?7@;:4A5/0 6;/66262;3/>=35/046B063B045:>40;:45/0?6@30 5:570 >9 5/0 105:5:>4 :#0# 105:5:>4 9:70; @4;02 0?5:>4 !%!' %:6'>95/0?5=/:?/=>@7;:496?55/653/0:335:77203:;:4A 653/>D6A627>?D)64;6??>2;:4A7<4>5:?030455> 5/07635D4>=46;;2033=633@99:?:045#
,# 5 :3 5> 80 4>5:?0; 5/65 3:4?0 5/0 >2;02 16330; 8<5/0+6B:7<>@25=63640L16250>2;0264;5/0B6:4 ?>45045:>48<5/0?>@43079>25/02031>4;045:35/65:95/0 >@25=0205>/>7;5/654>5:?0=634>53@99:?:0455/045/0 B65502=>@7;/6E05>8030455>5/0+6B:7<>@259>29203/ 04G@:2< 63 :4 5/0 B652:B>4:67 12>?00;:4A3 @47033 5/0 633025:>43 >9 5/0 105:5:>402 620 208@550; 8< 5/0 0E:;04?0 705 :4 =:5/ 3@11>25 >9 =:5403303 5/0 B65502 ?644>5 80 6;J@;:?650;8<5/:3>@25# !"# 062;8>5/3:;0364;102@30;5/020?>2;3# !!# /01>:4539>2?>43:;0265:>4620639>77>=3
- 7 -
!' /05/025/02031>4;045/63B6;0>@5 6?6305>/>7;5/65302E:?0>94>5:?063 3@99:?:04520G@:2035>8030563:;0M
*' >430G@0457< =/05/02 ?630 :3 B6;0 >@5 9>2 20B:55:4A 5/0 B65502 9>2 203@B15:>4 >9 52:67 92>B 5/0 356A0 >9 61106264?0>92031>4;045M
!*# 5B@35804>5:?0;5/655/0105:5:>49:70;8<5/0 611077645/@3864; 809>20 5/0 +6B:7< >@25 =63 @4;02 0?5:>4!%!'%:6'>95/0?5#/036:;105:5:>4=639:70; 3/>=:4A5/06;;2033>95/02031>4;045)=:90639>77>=3
! " #$$$ ! %
&
&%
"
'%()*+',
!# 102@367>95/0>2;023/005>95/0+6B:7<>@25 12>?00;:4A3 =>@7; :4;:?650 5/65 35013 =020 56D04 65 5/0 9:235:43564?064;B65502=636;J>@240;>4E62:>@3;6503# 4!*#"#*"**5/052:67>@25 /63B6;0640452<:45/0 >2;023/005639>77>=3
,%
( % %-. )
/ %
- 8 -
0 12345355
!# @830G@0457< >4 !!#"H#*"** 5/0 ?>@4307 9>2 5/0 105:5:>402 /6; 6A6:4 20G@0350; 5:B0 5> 9@24:3/ 5/0 ?>220?5 6;;2033# /0 0452< :4 5/0 >2;02 3/005 >4 !!#"H#*"**:3639>77>=3
,% , /+
6
/+
/0
7 /0 /+
83395355
!# 70627< 5/0 105:5:>402 =63 6=620 5/65 2031>4;045/6;70955/0/>B0=6<86?D>4!*#"#*"**64; /6; 20G@0350; 5:B0 5> 9@24:3/ ?>220?5 6;;2033# @830G@0457<:5:34>5:?0;5/65+64;
=639@24:3/0; 63 20?>2;0; :4 5/0 >2;02 3/005 ;650; * #",#*"** 64; >4 5/0 40L5 ;650 5/0 >99:?0 4>50 20?>2;3
209@30; 8< 2031>4;045 />7;:4A 5/0 302E:?0 3@99:?:045 5/0 B65502 :3
- 9 -
12>?00;0;=:5/ 8<4>5:4A5/068304?0>95/02031>4;045# /0>2;02>9*,#",#*"**206;3639>77>=3
! " #
$ %&# ' ( )$*+ $ %&# ' ,-. /01
+2 2345'46'74789'
!(# /0+6B:7<>@25/63/07;4>5:?05>803@99:?:045 64; 12>?00;0;# /0 12>?00;:4A3 5/02069502 /63 A>40 9@25/02 :4 5/0 68304?0 >9 5/0 2031>4;045 64; 69502 20?>2;:4A5/00E:;04?0>95/0105:5:>4025/0+6B:7<>@25 /6316330;64>2;02>4B02:536950220?>2;:4A5/09:4;:4A >4 5/0 1>:45 9>2 ?>43:;0265:>4 :4 5/0 699:2B65:E0 64; :4 0990?5/>7;:4A5/655/06?53>9?2@075<=020035687:3/0;#
!H# 02@367>95/0
?>E0267>4A=:5/52:67>@25 20?>2;364;36B0=>@7;:4;:?6505/654>5:?0=63:33@0;8< 655/06;;2033>95/02031>4;045639>77>=3 &6
: ; <
!" #$$$!6%
&
&%
"
/= '%()*+',
- 10 -
!
# /:3=>@7;:4;:?6505/654>5:?0=63:33@0;5>5/0 6;;2033 B045:>40; :4 5/0 ?6@305:570 >9 ## 05:5:>4 5/>@A/ ?>@4307 9>2 5/0 105:5:>402 /6; @4;0256D04 5> 9@24:3/5/0?>220?56;;2033>4!*#"#*"**#561106235/65 4> ?>220?5 6;;2033 =63 9@24:3/0; ;031:50 310?:9:?677< ?>@4307 9>2 5/0 105:5:>402 @4;0256D:4A 5> 9:70 ;056:73 >9 ?>220?5 6;;2033 63 5/0 2031>4;045 /63 7095 5/0 />B0 63 >8302E0;:45/0>2;023/005#5:39@25/024>5:?0;5/655/0 =63 3045 :4 5/0 B>45/ >9 ?5>802 *"**# 9 5/0 105:5:>402 /6; @4;0256D04 809>20 5/0 >@25 5> 9@24:3/ ?>220?5 6;;2033 63 5/0 2031>4;045 /6; 7095 />B0 63 :3 0E:;045 92>B 5/0 12>?00;:4A3 :4 5/0 >2;02 3/005 ;650;
!*#"#*"**?70627<6;;20339@24:3/0;:45/0
>@A/55> /6E0 8004 ;:9902045 92>B 5/65 :4 5/0 ?6@305:570 >9 5/0 105:5:>4636;B:550;7<5/02031>4;045/6;70955/0/>B0#
!,# 02@30; 5/0 6;;:5:>467 ;>?@B0453 12>;@?0; 8< ?>@43079>25/02031>4;045#/036<>95/02031>4;04563 4>5:?0;68>E05/653/0/6;70955/0/>@3063>4 6<*"*" :53079 64; =63 203:;:4A 65 676J: 6A62 G#/67D: :;62
- 11 -
:352:?5?>B03>@592>B5/0102@367>95/0105:5:>49:70;8< 5/0 2031>4;045 @4;02 0?5:>4 !* >9 2>50?5:>4 >9 >B04 92>B >B035:? :>704?0 ?5# 02@367 >9 5/0 >2;02 3/005 =>@7; :4;:?650 5/65 5/0 105:5:>4 @4;02 5/0 >B035:?
:>704?0 ?5 =63 9:70; >4 *(#"H#*"** 64; 5/0 6;;2033 3/>=4 :4 5/0 ?6@305:570 =63 /67D:# /0 6E02B0453 65 1626 ># >9 5/0 105:5:>4 673> =>@7; :4;:?650 5/65 5/0 2031>4;045 /6; 7095 5/0 />@30 >9 5/0 105:5:>402 :#0# B652:B>4:67/>B063>4*#"*#*"*"#/0?025:9:0;?>1<>9 5/0105:5:>4:39:70;#
*"# 4 7:A/5 >9 5/0 68>E0 96?53 :5 :3 ?7062 5/65 5/0 4>5:?0 =:5/ 04;>230B045 209@30; ?644>5 80 207:0; @1>45>/>7;5/655/04>5:?0=633@99:?:04564;5/01>3567 3/626>9C209@30;-?70627<:3;>@859@7635/02031>4;045=63 :496?5203:;:4A65/67D:64;6??>2;:4A7<5/04>5:?05>5/0 3/>D 6A62 7>?D B6761@2 6;;2033 ?>@7; 4>5 80 56D044>50>9#>707<>43@?/A2>@4;5/09:4;:4A>9+6B:7< >@25>4302E:?0/07;3@99:?:04520G@:2035>8030563:;063 5/01203@B15:>4>94>5:?0:33@0;5>5/0?>220?56;;203363
- 12 -
?>@7;80;26=48<176?:4A207:64?0>912>E:3:>43>9040267 76@303 ?5 ?644>5 80 ;26=4 63 5/0 2031>4;045 /63 ;0B>4352650;5/655/02031>4;045=63356<:4A65/67D:63 >45/0;650>9:33@64?0>94>5:?05>5/02031>4;045:45/0 >45/ >9 ?5>802 *"**# ??>2;:4A7< >4?0 5/0 >2;02 />7;:4A 4>5:?0 /07; 3@99:?:045 :3 305 63:;0 5/0 B65502 20G@:203 2052:67 92>B 5/0 356A0 >9 61106264?0 >9 5/0 2031>4;045#
*!# /0 G@035:>4 >9 ;0?:;:4A >4 5/0 105:5:>4 64;
0E:;04?0>420?>2;8<5/:3>@25 B6<4>5 806112>12:650 63:4B652:B>4:67;:31@503033045:677<B65502:3;0?:;0;>4 5/0 863:3 >9 6E02B0453 >9 ?2@075< =/:?/ 400;3 5> 80 035687:3/0; 673> 8630; >4 208@5567 0E:;04?0 8< 5/0 2031>4;0455>;:312>E05/0633025:>4>95/0105:5:>402#4 7:A/5>95/0;:3?@33:>46368>E05/01>:4539>2?>43:;0265:>4 620/07;:45/0699:2B65:E0#??>2;:4A7<B6550220G@:2035> 80 20B:550; 86?D 9>2 20?>43:;0265:>4 92>B 5/0 356A0 >9 61106264?0>95/02031>4;045#??>2;:4A7<5/0J@;AB045 64;;0?200>95/052:67>@25:330563:;064;5/0B65502:3
- 13 -
20B:550; 5> 5/0 356A0 >9 61106264?0 >9 5/0 2031>4;045# /0 1625:03 5> 611062 =:5/>@5 9203/ 4>5:?0 809>20 5/0 +6B:7<>@25>4!H#"#*"*# **# 0 B6D0 :5 ?7062 5/65 5/0 0E:;04?0 >9 5/0 105:5:>402 >4 20?>2; ?64 80 6;>150; 8< 5/0 105:5:>402 8< 9:7:4A 6112>12:650 1706;:4A 64; :9 5/0 105:5:>402 =020 5> 6;>155/00E:;04?0705:436B0B6<8056D045>8061625 >90E:;04?0@1>4?>45:4@65:>4>95/052:67;031:50>2;02>9 20B64;# 9502 5/0 61106264?0 >9 5/0 2031>4;045 40?03362<1706;:4A38<=6<>9=2:550435650B045:35>80 9:70;=:5/:46102:>;>9>40B>45/>9;650>961106264?0>9 61106264?064;B65502:35>8012>?00;0;5/020>463102 12>?0;@20#00;70335>356505/65677?>45045:>43620D015 >104#??>2;:4A7<611067:3;:31>30;>99# )*
&
! %' $
)*
&$ ' $
:35>#!7>#!