- 1 - ! "# " $% #!!&! '# ! " % &! ()*(+,-)(!!,, ' !! ! "#$#%&# ! '( &%! )&)&%'! * +)&%+ ! ! )+%))&%# ! * ! +'&)&%% ! !! )('& !%$( ! ! , ! ! Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! - - % ./0 1/2/345 67/0/83 69/9/83 :3;61 6<9/83 '( 164; =/9.6<9/83&%8>1/0>/56;?@9.64<<:06;4004/5/3A9.6 B:;A2639 43; 81;61 8> <837/<9/83 43; 063963<6 ;496; )'%))&%# C4006; ?@ 9.6 8:19 8> ;;5 /7/5 :;A6 43; ! 454?:1A/ /3 8+'&)&%% 43; 9.6 B:;A2639 43; 81;61;496;)&)&%'C4006;/3158+)&%+?@9.68:19 8>;;5/091/<943;600/830:;A6454?:14A/ ) <<:06;=40<.41A60.6696;?@;;/9/834514>>/<85/<6 454?:14A/ >81 9.6 8>>63<60 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/830 )(' & 8> 43; 6<9/83 %$( 8> 3;/43 8981 6./<560 <9 %'$$.64556A49/834A4/3099.64<<:06;/09.4983)&&#)&%& 494?8:9&#&&C2/39.66763/3A9.64<<:06;=.8=409.6 ;1/7618>9.6184;185561?641/3A16A/09149/838")'"%'#' =40;1/7/3A9.604/;76./<56/31676106;/16<9/83/34140.43; 36A5/A639 243361 43; 40 4 160:59 2/381 <./5;163 8> ;6>4<98 <82C54/3439 4260.=.8=6161/;/3A9.6/1C54@?/<@<56839.6 - 3 - 184; =./<. =40 :3;61 16C4/1 <426 :3;61 9.6 =.6650 8> 9.6 8>>63;/3A 76./<56 43; ;/6; <<:06; .4; C564;6; 389 A:/59@ ?6>8169.61/458:1943;<5426;98?691/6;:1/3A9.6<8:106 8> 91/45 C1806<:9/83 .4; 6D42/36; 3/36 =/9360060 40 % 98 ' 43; A89 241E6; 3/36 ;8<:26390 40 D% 98 ' 8 ;6>63<6 67/;63<6 =40 564; 83 ?6.45> 8> 9.6 4<<:06; 381 =40 43@;8<:2639A89241E6;/30:CC8198>9.6;6>63<6.61/45 8:19 4>961 .641/3A ?89. 0/;60 7/;6 /2C:A36; B:;A2639 43; 81;61 8> <837/<9/83 43; 063963<6 ;496; )'%))&%# <837/<96; 9.6 4<<:06; >81 9.6 8>>63<60 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/830 )(' & 8> 43; >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 %$(8>9.63;/43 89816./<560<9%'$$43;063963<6;./2 98 C4@ >/36 8> 0%&&&" >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 )(' 8> 43; /3 ;6>4:59 98 :3;61A8 0/2C56 /2C1/0832639 >81 4 C61/8; 8> 836 2839. >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 & 8> 063963<6; ./2 98 :3;61A80/2C56/2C1/0832639>814C61/8;8>9=8@641043;98 C4@ >/3; 8> 0#&&&" 43; /3 ;6>4:59 98 :3;61A8 0/2C56 /2C1/0832639 >81 4 C61/8; 8> 9.166 2839.0 43; >:19.61 063963<6; ./2 98 C4@ >/36 8> 0%&&&" >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56:3;616<9/83%$(8>9.6 <943;/3;6>4:5998 - 4 - :3;61A8 0/2C56 /2C1/0832639 >81 4 C61/8; 8> 836 2839. .6 04/; B:;A2639 43; 81;61 8> <837/<9/83 43; 063963<6 =40 :30:<<600>:55@<.45563A6;?@9.6C69/9/83614<<:06;?6>8169.6 ;;5 /091/<9 43; 600/830 :;A6 454?:14A/ /3 158+)&%+ =./<. =40 ;/02/006; ?@ B:;A2639 43; 81;61 ;496;)&)&%'.616>8164<<:06;/0?6>8169./08:19 64136; <8:3065 >81 9.6 4<<:06;C69/9/8361 0:?2/90 9.49 9.61/458:1943;9.6CC6554968:19.4766116;/3<837/<9/3A 9.6 4<<:06; >81 9.6 <.41A6 0.6696; 8>>63<60 .624961/45 83 16<81; ;8 389 0.8= 9.49 4<<:06; =40 ;1/7/3A 9.6 8>>63;/3A 76./<56/34140.43;36A5/A639243361 3;/0C:96;5@184;/3 =./<. 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 .4; 94E63 C54<6 =40 :3;61 16C4/1 43; 9.6 <./5;163 .4; 0914@6; 98 9.6 04/; 184; =./56 C54@/3A43;404160:599.616=40434<</;639.61/458:19 43;9.6CC6554968:19.476>4/56;984CC16</4969.494<</;639 /3 F:609/83 .4; 94E63 C54<6 40 4 160:59 8> 36A5/A63<6 ?@ 9.6 <./5;16343;9.6/1C416390=.8.4;4558=6;9.6<./5;16398C54@ /3 9.6 :3;61 16C4/1 184; .6 0:?2/90 9.49 9.6 063963<6 /2C806; 83 9.6 4<<:06; ?@ 9.6 1/45 8:19 43; 9.6 CC655496 8:19/0.410.43;;/0C18C819/83496<<81;/3A5@0.6C14@098 4558=9.6C69/9/83 - 5 - 61<83914564136;.408CC806;9.6C14@6124;6 /39.6C69/9/8343;0:?2/909.499=82/381<./5;163.476;/6;/3 9.6 184; 914>>/< 4<</;639 =./<. =40 <4:06; 40 4 160:59 8> 9.6 140. 43; 36A5/A639 ;1/7/3A 8> 9.6 8>>63;/3A 76./<56 ?@ 9.6 C69/9/8361 /3<6 9.6 ;6<6406; 416 <./5;163 /9 <43389 ?6 04/; 9.49 9.616 =40 <8391/?:981@ 36A5/A63<6 830/;61/3A 9.6 >4<9 9.499=82/381<./5;163.476;/6;/39.6184;914>>/<4<</;639 9.6 1/45 8:19 =40 B:09/>/6; /3 063963</3A 9.6 C69/9/8361 >81 4 C61/8; 8> 9=8 @6410 >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 & 8><<81;/3A5@.6C14@098;/02/009.6C69/9/83 # .6C1806<:9/83/381;6198C1876/90<406.406D42/36; 3/36=/936006043;A89241E6;3/36;8<:26390/39.6C160639 <406%G 4260./09.6>49.618>9.67/<9/2<./5;163=.8 .476;/6;/39.64<</;639)43;4169.6C43<.40989.6 /3F:609C43<.43424D)43;?89.9.606=/9360060.476389 0:CC8196;9.6<4068>9.6C1806<:9/8343;9.616>8169.6@=616 916496;40.809/56=/9360060 + #43;+41604/;98?69.66@6=/936006098 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 43; ( /0 9.6 434A61 8> 9.6 82C43@ 98 =./<. 9.6 <83914<9 8> 184; 16C4/1 =40 4=41;6; - 6 - $ /0 9.6 85/<6 :?"30C6<981 =.8 .4; 16<6/76; 9.6 <82C54/39 43; 16A/09616; 9.6 ! /3 9.6 C160639 <406 ' /1<56 30C6<981 8> 85/<6 /0 9.6 37609/A49/83 >>/<61 /3 9.6 C160639 <406 =.8 .40 >/56; 9.6 <.41A6 0.669 4A4/309 4<<:06; 4>961<82C569/3A9.6/37609/A49/83 D%/09.681/A/3458>9.6 <82C54/3943;D)43;4169.6/3F:609C43<.434248>9.6 ;6<6406; <./5;163 D /0 9.6 0C89 C43<.43424 43; D# 43; + 416 9.6 809 81962 6C819 8> 9.6 ;6<6406; <./5;163 D( /0 9.6 6C819 43; D$ /0 9.6 3;623/9@ 83; D'/09.6<8C@8>9.6! 16A/09616;/39.6C160639<406 ( %=.8/09.6>49.618>9.67/<9/2<./5;163.4009496; 9.49839.6;4968>/3</;639=.63.6=40/39.69640.8C8=36; ?@ ./0 =/>6 ./0 2/381 <./5;163 4249.4 43; E0.4@ =616 C54@/3A 8:90/;6 .6 184; /3 >1839 8> 9.6 964 0.8C =40 :3;61 16C4/143;9.6184;185561=./<.=40;1/763?@4<<:06;;40.6; 4A4/309 9.6 <./5;163 =.8 =616 C54@/3A 83 9.6 184; 43; 40 4 160:59./0;4:A.961 4249.4;/6;499.60C8943;083E0.4@ =.8 0:>>616; A1/678:0 /3B:1/60 98 ./0 56A0 =40 /226;/4965@ 0./>96;/3434:989880C/945?:9.60:<<:2?6;989.6/3B:1/60 /39.680C/9456.40/;639/>/6;9.64<<:06;409.6;1/7618> 9.68>>63;/3A76./<5643;./0<82C54/390:?2/996;989.6C85/<6 - 7 - =40 241E6; 40 D% 164;/3A 8> 9.6 ;6C80/9/83 8> 9./0 =/93600 1676450 9.49 .6 =40 /30/;6 9.6 964 0.8C =.63 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 .4; 94E63 C54<6 43; .6 .4; 389 4<9:455@ 0663 9.6 4<</;639 43; + 416 9.6 ?189.610 8> =/>6 8> % .606 =/9360060 .476 09496; 9.49 =.63 9.6@ =616 3641 9.69640.8C8>%9.62/381<./5;1638>%=616C54@/3A 83 9.6 184; :3;61 16C4/1 43; 9.6@ =616 1/;/3A 9.6/1 C54@ ?/<@<56 9 9.49 9/26 8>>63;/3A 76./<56 184; 185561 =./<. =40 ;1/763 /3 9.6 1676106 ;/16<9/83 ?@ 4<<:06; /3 4 140. 43; 36A5/A639 243361 ;40.6; 4A4/309 9.6 C54@ ?/<@<56 8> 9.6 <./5;16343;404160:59<./5;163>655;8=3839.6184;43;9.6@ <426:3;619.6=.66508>9.68>>63;/3A76./<56 $ # /0 4389.61 /3;6C63;639 6@6 =/93600 =.8 4508 .40 0C8E634?8:99.6243361/3=./<.9.64<</;639/3F:609/83.40 94E63 C54<6 .6 ;6C80/9/83 8> 98 + <8118?814960 =/9. 64<.89.6143;/0<830/09639=/9.16A41;989.6243361/3=./<. 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 .4; 94E63 C54<6 55 9.606 =/9360060 .476 09496; 9.49 =.63 9.6@ =616 /3 >1839 8> 9.6 964 0.8C 8> % 9.6@ 04= 9.6 <./5;163 C54@/3A 83 9.6 184; 1/;/3A 9.6/1 C54@ ?/<@<56 43; 9.6@ 4508 04= 9.6 4<<:06; ;1/7/3A 9.6 8>>63;/3A76./<56/341676106;/16<9/83/34140.43;36A5/A639 - 8 - 243361 43; 9.8:A. 9.6@ 14/06; 4 <1@ 4<<:06; ;/; 389 .641 9.62 43; 4>961 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 988E C54<6 4<<:06; /226;/4965@ 098CC6; ./0 76./<56 43; 143 4=4@ >182 9.6 0C89 .6 1/45 8:19 40 =655 40 9.6 CC655496 8:19 .47/3A 4CC16</496; 9.6 8145 43; ;8<:263941@ 67/;63<6 474/54?56 83 16<81;9.616>816.4761/A.95@<837/<96;9.6C69/9/83614<<:06; >81 9.6 4556A6; 8>>63<60 43; ;8 389 066 43@ /116A:541/9@ 81 /556A45/9@<822/996;?@9.61/458:1943;9.6CC6554968:19 =./56<837/<9/3A9.6C69/9/83614<<:06;>819.6<.41A60.6696; 8>>63<60 ' 308>4140063963<6C4006;?@9.61/458:19404A4/309 9.6 C69/9/83614<<:06; >81 9.6 <.41A6 0.6696; 8>>63<60 /0 <83<6136; 9.6 24961/45 83 16<81; =8:5; A8 98 0.8= 9.49 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 .4; 94E63 C54<6 83 9.6 184; =./<. =40 :3;6116C4/1.69640.8C8>%43;./0=/>6/0494;/0943<6 8>4?8:9%&&269610>1829.60C898>4<</;639.6;6<6406; <./5;1638>%=616C54@/3A839.6184;:3;6116C4/143;9.6@ .4; <826 :3;61 9.6 =.6650 8> 9.6 184; 185561 =./<. =40 :3;/0C:96;5@;1/763?@9.64<<:06;/341676106;/16<9/83 416 =.6658>9.6184;185561/02:<.?/AA61/30/H643;9.6;1/7618> 9.6 184; 185561 /3 381245 </1<:20943<60 =/55 389 ?6 /3 4 - 9 - C80/9/83 98 066 9.6 89.61 0/;6 8> 9.6 1416 =.665 =.63 .6 /0 06496;839.606498>9.6184;185561.8:A.%=.8/09.6 >49.618>9.6;6<6406;<./5;16343;43;+=.84169.6 24961345 :3<560 8> 9.6 ;6<6406; <./5;163 =616 761@ 2:<. C16063936419.69640.8C43;9.604/;=/9360060.4;06639.6 <./5;163C54@/3A839.6184;=./<.=40:3;6116C4/19.6@.4; 389?89.616;98<455?4<E9.6<./5;163=.8=616C54@/3A839.6 184;=./<.=40:3;6116C4/143;839.689.61.43;9.6@.4; 4558=6;9.6<./5;16398C54@839.6184;:3;6116C4/143; +.47609496;9.499.6@.4;06639.6<./5;163C54@/3A839.6 184;:3;6116C4/143;9.6@4508.4;06639.64<<:06;;1/7/3A 9.68>>63;/3A76./<56/341676106;/16<9/83=./<.=40<82/3A 98=41;0 9.6 C54@/3A <./5;163 43; 9.8:A. 9.6@ 14/06; 4 <1@ 4<<:06; ;/; 389 .641 9.62 43; 40 4 160:59 9.6 4<</;639 /3 F:609/83 .4; 94E63C54<6 !182 9.6 4>81604/; /9 4CC64109.49 4<<:06; =40 389 /3 4 C80/9/83 98 066 9.6 <./5;163 =.8 =616 C54@/3A 83 9.6 184; :3;61 16C4/1 =.63 .6 =40 ;1/7/3A 9.6 8>>63;/3A76./<56/341676106;/16<9/83 3;/0C:96;5@8>>63;/3A 76./<56=40?6/3A:06;>819.6C:1C8068>184;16C4/143;=./56 9.6 184; 16C4/1 =81E /0 :3;61 C18A1600 /3 381245 </1<:20943<60 184; 185561 /0 389 ;1/763 /3 4 ./A. 0C66; - 10 - .616>816/9<43389?604/;9.499.6 4<</;639/3F:609/83.4; 94E63C54<608565@?6<4:068>9.636A5/A63<68>9.64<<:06;43; 83 9.6 89.61 .43; /9 4CC6410 9.49 9.616 =40 <8391/?:981@ 36A5/A63<6 83 9.6 C419 8> 9.6 C416390 43; 16549/760 8> 9.6 ;6<6406; 2/381 <./5;163 =.8 .4; 389 94E63 0:>>/</639 <416 /30C/96 8> 066/3A 9.49 9.6 2/381 <./5;163 =616 C54@/3A /3 C54@ ?/<@<56 83 4 184; =./<. =40 :3;61 16C4/1 .6 24961/45 83 16<81; =8:5; 4508 A8 98 0.8= 9.49 C69/9/83614<<:06; /0 4 2411/6;243.47/3A>42/5@43;<./5;163.64<</;639/08>9.6 @641 )&%% 43; 452809 % @6410 .47654C06; >182 9.6;496 8> 4<</;639 3;61 9.6 </1<:20943<60 42 8> 9.6 C/3/83 9.49 /> 9.6 063963<6 /2C806; ?@ 9.6 1/45 8:19 83 9.6 4<<:06;C69/9/8361/028;/>/6;9.60426=8:5;061769.663;0 8>B:09/<6<<81;/3A5@9.6>8558=/3A" / 1/2/345 67/0/8369/9/83/0C4195@4558=6; // .6 B:;A2639 43; 81;61 8> <837/<9/83 ;496; )'%))&%#C4006;?@9.68:198>;;5/7/5 :;A6 43; ! 454?:1A/ /3 8+'&)&%% <83>/126; ?@ 9.6 8:19 8> ;;5/091/<943;600/830:;A6454?:14A//3 - 11 - 158+)&%+ ?@ B:;A2639 43; 81;61 ;496; )&)&%'/0.616?@<83>/126; /// 8=6761 9.6 81;61 83 063963<6 ;496; )'%))&%# C4006; ?@ 9.6 1/45 8:19 43; <83>/126; ?@ 9.6 CC655496 8:19 4A4/309 9.6 C69/9/83614<<:06; >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;616<9/83& 8>/028;/>/6;=./56 9.6 04/; 81;61 8> 063963<6 C4006; 4A4/309 9.6 C69/9/83614<<:06; >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 )(' 8> 43; >81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 %$( 8> <9 /0 .616?@<83>/126; /7 !81 9.6 8>>63<6 C:3/0.4?56 :3;61 6<9/83 & 8>4<<:06;C69/9/8361/0063963<6; 98:3;61A80/2C56/2C1/0832639>814C61/8;8> 0/D2839.043;98C4@>/368> 0#&&&"43;/3 ;6>4:5998 :3;61A80/2C56/2C1/0832639>814 C61/8;8>9=82839.0 !.- (!&! '# ! ", # /098%58)