Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2024 DAILYLAW 2324 (PNJ)

PARAMJIT KAUR AND ANOTHER v. ASHA GAKHAR AND OTHERS

FAO/2754/2024 · 2026-01-13

Vikram Aggarwal

body2024

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

                                   ! "# $%     &&''         ()    %*+% $%      ,- & $           .        - !"# $%      &&''         ()    %*+% $%      ,- & $                    '"# */0$10%&&''      2%&&'     ( $*#&0$10    & $ 3 #  & 4 2%&&'     555     This judgment shall dispose of the afore titled appeals, both seeking enhancement in compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Mansa (hereinafter referred to as “the MACT”).   %''   ''42$ 1$  FAO-2754-2024 6%         / 1   % %  &&' 1 7 . %'' '  2 $ 6% 1  8# $   96 & ' &   6   #$2 % :9   6   '$ 24 % '/' &    1   ; $  ' < /% # $  <   %  (% ' 0 =..  % >% (?  %/   &   - .'+%  # $%% $%  VIKAS CHANDER 2026.01.21 15.00 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document  $.   .    :9  - =0. 0)  E  %    @  -  $ $0 % '  &   0     - 0 0=)  $$# /  #   - .0 0.. =.)     $ 24 % :90 % 2'   &      - 0=0) .  9%  $ % $ # 6#'$2&42' $$    %  #    $ 24 % ' $ :9 ' / 6 %   G H  #''4 9%$ 2# ' $' 2 ' 4&4%  6#'$2 &% 6$ =  9%&  &&' $ /'4$ & $    $ /&&'    0  40 %'''   $$ & $                  !&:!34+0,-,2 1// L%% &+ /)  $    B )3   L%%&2'     B )3  VIKAS CHANDER 2026.01.21 15.00 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document