Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2024 DAILYLAW 1932 (PNJ)
DEEPAK AND ORS v. IFFCO TOKIO GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. AND ORS
FAO/3041/2024 · 2026-01-23
Harkesh Manuja
body2024
[ 2024 DAILYLAW 1932 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2024 DAILYLAW 1932 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO No.3041 of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
( + *% % 2"--!" #$ ( + *% % 2"--!" #$ ( + *% % 2"--!" #$ ( 14(2 14(2 14(2 14(2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 14*2 )%* *" +$ *2 4 % * %*2 4 % * %*2 4 % * %*2 4 % * %*2 75 75 75 75 %"%( % "%4 &*+ *% ))-- % +( ") 4 &*+ *%%)* *B "% +*$ 4 4 4 4 1 1*2)% )) -4+ -- # .1 - % 5* *% ++( %(." -?@4 %.1 $*" * * ))-- B+- ($ *' -* # *2( ( " (* *2+- ($) ( (* (-- ( $* *%&(+"- % ++( 4*++" +- ($ ) ( (* + $ * .
($ .2*% -% % *" *2/;4;;4;;;BG="
,;/ ,;/ ,;/ ,;/*2 *2 *2 *2';'/ ';'/ ';'/ ';'/= H5@ = H5@ = H5@ = H5@ I)) I)) I)) I))-- -- -- -- I)* I)* I)* I)* ' ' ' '; ; ; ;';' ';' ';' ';':::: + + + + '''',,,,;';': ;';': ;';': ;';': * .( * .( * .( * .( '''',,,,;';': ;';': ;';': ;';': $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( ()%* *" + ()%* *" + ()%* *" + ()%* *" +
"--
"--
"--
"-- *22"-- *22"-- *22"-- *22"-- *))-(+.- *))-(+.- *))-(+.- *))-(+.- 5 5 5 5 *$) 1 #. -(* % +( -($ %(." -4 *< = *2 A4'/4';;BG % * # ( ( % C DE )% " (--(%-(F(* * ++*" *2 ++"%%* 'D;D';D . 2(- ( + %(." -4 )%1( # 2*% #%
")2*%1-<* -1@4* ++*" 1 =2*%
"$ *2 *2 +*" MOHMED ATIK 2026.01.23 17:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO No.3041 of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
@ $*" =( @ K4D';BG '434;/;BG 3,4K:;BG 3,4K:;@ '4:A4A;;BG * - L) 4,/4/;;BG 4,/4/;;BG # $"- ()-(% *2 # $"- ()-(% *2 # $"- ()-(% *2 # $"- ()-(% *2 4/;;L,@ 4/;;L,@ 4/;;L,@ 4/;;L,@ K4/K4';;B K4/K4';;B K4/K4';;B K4/K4';;BGGGG :43;;B :43;;B :43;;B :43;;BGGGG :43;;B :43;;B :43;;B :43;;BGGGG //4;;;B //4;;;B //4;;;B //4;;;BGGGG A4'/4';;B A4'/4';;B A4'/4';;B A4'/4';;BGGGG :;,';'/) .1 - % .1 ))-- B+- ($ (2( ( +- ($) ( (* 4 .*" # #-(# +*2 %(&%%+*% - % %(." -4 .( # * " <*2.%&( 1 2 * .1 "%% - ( # % 2*% " ( " % MOHMED ATIK 2026.01.23 17:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO No.3041 of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
".$( ($)"# 2&( + ".$( ($ *' ) ")* &( + * %+*% (+ +- ")* ( +*$*2 + * N" -14 "+ (* *2 3; (2( +* % %1 * - - " *2 +*$) (* #% " ( - - 4 %2*%4 %- +((* * ".!+ % ( # %)* *,B "% *% & #-(# + *2 2 + *2 )% + 4 -+ -- 2*% *( %2% + % ) % ( )%" ) ) & + .1- % *" -2*% %+*% ( (+ + /A1 %*2 # %+(&( %$* - % %(." - 2 3 % - %-1 3;E - " % 4 % + 2 4 )%G *% G (&( # 2 % MOHMED ATIK 2026.01.23 17:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.3041 of 2024 L$( ( #) ($*" % "-( +*$ %)* * ( +*$ * *"%4%$ .1 -% "22%2%*$ 1( 8D9 %-% ) 4 + 8D9 %*$ **/% +-($ %
" %." " %* 4 %.( + "+ "( 8D'9 +-($ ( $*%G( G- %( - %( - %( - %( - =(&(-@/A9 =(&(-@/A9 =(&(-@/A9 =(&(-@/A9 -#-%)% 24 (O&M)
) (* -())-+* %+*% $* -1( +*$*2 +*$C'434;/;BG*&( *(+%(" (+(1*2 * ( +*%%+ %2* %$( (* *2$* -1-- %(." -( . * +*# * 1( 2(%$(1*%(--#-(14%% ( # L("(+%(2*%+* % %(." - !"(2( ( 4 +* N" -1 "+( # 3;E 3;E 3;E 3;E %*$)%"-*2&( +* -#-(%*2+< %#%( # (% ) +1 ") " +-- #-% %(." %.(%%(-1 - * -1 +-($ + 2( ( # ( * .*% *" 2% -% %(." - ))-( )% + % / ( $!
* P.-")%$*"%( "% + *$) 1 ($( "% + *$) 1 ($( "% + *$) 1 ($( "% + *$) 1 ($( H H H H -$!*%$%%( % ( (&4&%(#*))-12*%+
L
*L
4%(#-1++) + 4++*%( #-14 +*+* %%1-.1 (*+"$ *%*"## 2*%4 ( "$.- *)( (* *2 - "-( +*$*2+ *+"$ %1 &( + * ( #( %2% +.1(*"% +* (%(* ( )% ))- %( # +-($ *' * *% )%* - L) *% )%* - L) *% )%* - L) *% )%* - L) *2 %+*%4((&( +-($ <" -&(($* 1-
")* + %$( (." -4(*"(# ( # 1+*# *' ) ")* 2%*$ &( + + * "+(* *2 3;E4 *"# !*% * 4 ' $!*% "#% +*2>$ (H % >$ (H % >$ (H % >$ (H % H %? H %? H %? H %? %)*% 8';'3 ='@ 8';'3 ='@ 8';'3 ='@ 8';'3 ='@ % ( #+(-% *2+4.( %+*$) (* 4(%%)+(&*2 4 ) 1 2 ( * -( *- 2 .1 ( *# * . %& %& %& %& .( # (% MOHMED ATIK 2026.01.23 17:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.3041 of 2024 ) +1 %)%*"+%" QD #% + H * +*$ *2 % ; ( &* * -1 ( + + %* &( 8D,9 +*2$ $ $ $ -*.) "+(* *2B/ O O O O 8;9
"% $ %- %$ $ %- %$ $ %- %$ $ %- %$ *%? *%? *%?
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
=))-- *'%( @4 L ) %*- )"$)4 (- * % * ,3: $)-*1$ *))*% " ( ( + "++(%+"$ + -2G"22(+( *% ( ) *2 L)*( (* ( (% %=")% @4 %( # % 2%*$ +*$) (* %2*%4 L+-" ( # ) Q 1 * P.-")%$*"% ( $ %%( "# % *"- -* *2 +- ($ / %2*% % + #$ *2 * P.-)L*"% "% + * & % 1 "% + * & % 1 "% + * & % 1 "% + * & % 1 > ( ( "% +* > ( ( "% +* > ( ( "% +* > ( ( "% +* 5 ( .- * *2 % % % ( # )-12*% + (& *% * 4 % * *2 L " ( ( +4 *2 ( * *%4 ( ( *. *%4 "% ( ( ( ( ( * * * * MOHMED ATIK 2026.01.23 17:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO No.3041 of 2024 & ( % " & ( % " & ( % " & ( % " +* & (* - ))-- B+- ($ 2" % - * " *2 $* %G( G- *2 89 & %- ( - * * * * ' , / 3 :::: KKKK AAAA DDDD ; ; ; ; ' ' ' ' " +*$) (* ( 8'9 ( >$ ") >$ ") >$ ") >$ ") %)*% =';; =';; =';; =';; 24 (O&M) "%?4 "%?4 "%?4 "%?4%)*% ====';'@K ';'@K ';'@K ';'@K % -* %N"(% ($ % "4- ( - 2*% A4;;;BG * % -**2 4D'4;;;BG= /A4;;;L/@ *2 + % -* ( - 2*%) &( *2 (+"(* $ % 2*% #% *2+*$) (* ( "% "% "% "% " - +*$*2+ "+ (* =B/ @ +*$= '434;/;M 3 " "% %*)+ ='3E@ * - +*$=4:4'A;J/;4,'; **2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( #$ **2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( #$ **2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( #$ **2 +*$ 2 % ))-1( #$ )% #*2/A1 %='4;4:;; )% #*2/A1 %='4;4:;; )% #*2/A1 %='4;4:;; )% #*2/A1 %='4;4:;; **2 **2 **2 **2 " % -L) " % -L) " % -L) " % -L) **2* *% ("$=/A4;;;L/@ **2* *% ("$=/A4;;;L/@ **2* *% ("$=/A4;;;L/@ **2* *% ("$=/A4;;;L/@ * -+*$) (* * -+*$) (* * -+*$) (* * -+*$) (* $*" % .1 %(." $*" % .1 %(." $*" % .1 %(." $*" % .1 %(." + *$) (* + *$) (* + *$) (* + *$) (* "4 ))-- B+- ($ ( N" -)%*)*% (* &( *2 *.%& (* $ ( * %& (* - "% ( * %& (* - "% ( * %& (* - "% ( * %& (*
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.3041 of 2024 >
"$$ * >
"$$ * >
"$$ * >
"$$ * //,4 //,4 //,4 //,4 #% % * %-(F(* (!" $--.) *2 % $* +*$) (* - +*$) (* 8,9 ()**2
*2 "%1 "%1 "%1 "%1'''',,,,4444';' ';' ';' ';':::: (< 0 0 24 (O&M)
*%&%1 1 *%&%1 1 *%&%1 1 *%&%1 1 *2 ( % C DE )% "$ +-($ 2%*$ *2 ( !"(2( +($*" ( )1.-%2%-* #('E 2%*$ *1 - * $ -%1)(*+-($ - &( *2 2*%( $*(2 ( #$(+-- *"))-(+(* = :::: %)<( #B%* B* %%)*%.- B*
1 *%4';/=@=(& 1 *%4';/=@=(& 1 *%4';/=@=(& 1 *%4';/=@=(& $ * $*" *2 +*$) ( ( ("(* *2 +-($ )((* (-- ( *)((( %$* 4 'E( %2%*$L)(%1*2)%( $ (* % $*" --."+2%*$ + (2(+(* 4 )% ))- =@4(2 14---* ()* =5 @ =5 @ =5 @ =5 @ 7 =(&(-@ =(&(-@ =(&(-@ =(&(-@ (* (-- ( 4 %(* *2 + )* MOHMED ATIK 2026.01.23 17:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment