Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2024 DAILYLAW 1622 (PNJ)
JOGENDER SINGH v. BHAG SINGH SINDHU AND OTHERS
FAO/967/2024 · 2026-02-03
Harkesh Manuja
body2024
[ 2024 DAILYLAW 1622 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2024 DAILYLAW 1622 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 %%%% &&&& ,,,, - #* - #* - #* - #* (#* * 0 (#* * 0 (#* * 0 (#* * 0 1111 ).2 ).2 ).2 ).2 !" 2 !" 2 !" 2 !" 2 34 34 34 34 5 5 5 5 # 4 3# /*# 3# /*## 3# /*## 73 73 73 73 89 . 1%:%&2( +#$' .2 < # 0*"( '* * */ ' ' ' #' //# 8%9 #'+ )(#.' !
024 (O&M)
* * * *BBBB !" ##$ !" ##$ !" ##$ !" ##$ !" !" !" !" '(#* * 0 '(#* * 0 '(#* * 0 '(#* * 0 !" ' ()** !" ' ()** !" ' ()** !" ' ()** #* ).*(# '$(# */ !" #* ).*(# '$(# */ !" #* ).*(# '$(# */ !" #* ).*(# '$(# */ !" 0*# # / )) !" ' 0*# # / )) !" ' 0*# # / )) !" ' 0*# # / )) !" ' .2'/ .2*/ (#* * 0" */ .2'/ .2*/ (#* * 0" */ .2'/ .2*/ (#* * 0" */ .2'/ .2*/ (#* * 0" */ 2 #* #*/ 2 #* #*/ 2 #* #*/ 2 #* #*/ 563 7 563 7 563 7 563 7 # '# *2$*0 *# (()) #'))2$*0 *##(* * % #+' $' !)2$*0 *##(* *&= # 0*" 2 2 2 2 . .*/(# (()20)) !
+. )# 3* *#00' #'+ )DE2 #+. "* * (()) =0)'" )* ! ' '* */ 0)'" ( ' '* ')) ' +.'"' $'0 )#00' 2 (()) 2+' !' #/') ' !/*#!# */0*"( '* * B?C B?C B?C B?C*/ */ */ */%:%, %:%, %:%, %:%,; F3E ; F3E ; F3E ; F3E G(( G(( G(( G(()) )) )) )) G (* G (* G (* G (* %: %: %: %:: : : :%:% %:% %:% %:%???? 0 0 0 0 ::::&&&&::::%%%%%:%? %:%? %:%? %:%? * +' * +' * +' * +' ::::&&&&::::%%%%%:%? %:%? %:%? %:%?
" '
" '
" '
" ' '(#* * 0 '(#* * 0 '(#* * 0 '(#* * 0 )) )) )) )) *// )) *// )) *// )) *// )) * (()'0+) * (()'0+) * (()'0+) * (()'0+) 3 3 3 3 *"( . !+ )' * # 0' )'"#'+ )2 #';
*/ 2??2:B%=H # ' ' # >?@(# "/#* ' 0 ) #)'A '* 2 * 00* 2 '0*00 ##* ::1%:%: 0)'"( ' '* +/*# )# 00* */' #' //#+. 1
';/*# /#*" */ # .'" MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 ' "* *#$'0 !)'! #'$ +.#(* 8&9 / +. +* (# 0* 0) '* #(* * 8,9 ' (# (() 0*"( '* !)'! 0*/ )# #'+ ) * +' !#( 3 3 3 3
66
66
66
66= = = = 819 6 /*#" '* #'+ ) !# ' #' ' /') * ((#0' !*$# ' ! #! C@2 #+.# #'+ )* ! +.(().' !((# ' 0(0' ' ! 024 (O&M)
'0 )#00' '0 **I()0 #'$' ! */ $'0) +#' ! #!' * *=#'$# / #!*' ! #* ! 0)'"( ' ' # '2 )# #'+ ) $' 00' *00 ##* 00* # 2??2:B%=H0 ' ! !!#'$ !' /*# ) + (#/## +. (( 0 (0'/' ' 0)'" #'$#+ #0*#' /$* )+' ! * ' '( 2 #/*# # 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 =63 =63 =63 =63 # 0* ) /*# # ') +"' ' ! !#*). "!# '(#*(*# '* ' +. (()) =0)'" 0' )(#' 0'())' " */ /'#0*"( (()) =0)'" //# (# # #' !'"' 0(+)*/(#/*#" ! *$!# M 0*" ((#*(#' " ) '()'# I' !' # */ '+')' . 0 0* ::1%:%: ')))!' !# !' # '* * H,1HH&CB: +' ' '* $) ' ! $' 0) # 1%:%&2 ##'$ * */# !)'! #'$' !
0*"( '* #' # 1%:%&J ()) =0)'" /*# 0" '" ( ' '* ' #!#' * #*/ (()) =0)'" +. #2/*# I*/+#$' .2 * 6 6 6 6 (()) =0)'" ')
"* #+. )# # '* * # K +"' #'+ * +. * L+) (K* ( '* ' ' #.0/ # #" '+')' . * K *#"' !'').0 '$' 'J #/* 0*"( '* * #)**/' 0*" ' *0* '# '* (#" 00*#' !).2 (#. 2
# +' ! ) !*/ J */ #' ! . # # */ + ) * # # # */ /*#2 0*" MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 0*"( '* *" 3 3 3 3 * * * *&&&&==== 8?9 # $" ).0* M ).0 8C9 +**I*/ 0 (()) 8N9 / # ! ' 0/# * # < 7 < 7 < 7 < 7 * # )'* ' #' <? ' 0 0 0 0 ;'E ;''E $ ;E ;+E 024 (O&M)
#+ ' +). 0' */ '0 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 3
3
3
3
#0* #2)# 0* )/*## ' /0 0'#0 .0*"( 2 2 (# ( $ # )# 0* ) /*# /' /*#0' #!
" /*# #"' ' ! M " * /#*" (#' 0'())'* ' 7 "#$ .7 "# #D 7 "#$ .7 "# #D 7 "#$ .7 "# #D 7 "#$ .7 "# #D # '00*"( <? # '0 0*" ' #.0# /*))* ' !4 0 '#."!;(0')"! 0 '#."!;(0')"! 0 '#."!;(0')"! 0 '#."!;(0')"! K( #) ' ! * # " # (*# '* 2 * #'' !/** ;''E 6* */ # ' ! ; * # $ " * + ' # 6**/# ' ! #' ! ( 6**// ## ' !* 0 ' 00*# 0 ' )) 6 6 6 6
#(* *&= # 0*"( #0 " 0*/ 02 (()) (() )'+) *+'"' # (# ' (# (( $ 0+.)# * )/*# */ 0*"( '* 2 ' ' ') ' '"')#0+. * L+)( #D #D #D #D#(*# ;%:E&,& ;%:E&,& ;%:E&,& ;%:E&,& '* ' *+ #/*#(#* 0*"( '* ' # ' (#* !E !E !E !E " 2 *(' )'A '* 2 "'0' /**2 "'0)) * K( ' # # !' E '0 ' # * #20*"(#'' !4 (#'**/ # " J 00* */(#" '+')' . 3
* ( . )) (#H *# ') * (K ,& ,& ,& ,& * ) #* ) '0' 2 ' # * ) MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 ;'''E * * * * ;'$E ' ;$E ;$'E #* 0 ;+E2 (#" ;
<6
<6
<6
<6 8B9 ( .# *) *#I' ! 3 *"( .2 # ! (()) =0) */ '$ 7 "# #)'+)$' 0 ' * # /' ' 0*"#0*# 8B9 * 2#"' ' #' ! ' 024 (O&M)
;'''E #"'0)K( * * * * HHHH(0 '#."!; #) (0 '#."!; #) (0 '#."!; #) (0 '#."!; #) ;'$E "!/*#(' 2 //#' ! ' #' 6**/" ' '; =*#)* ;$'E 6**/K(0 '* */)'/; #* ' (#* )' #.020* #;'E2;''E;E ;'$E # #'(0'/'0"'0)$' 0)'" 2 0*"( '* ')) ;+E2;'''E2;$E ;$'E#) ' ! *)* (#" '+')' .2 / # "' ; =*#)**/(#*(0 */"##'! 3 3 3 3 3D 3D 3D 3D (# ) */ #0*# #$) '" */ 00' # 3 !# > *$ '* #'!!# # !#")# #'+ )#'! 0)'" > %%2:::=H(#"* # 3 !#
-H1 ' 0 * * //#/#*" . * !#* * ' #/# ' *#+. )# #'+ ) * 2(# " */(()) ' *(' )/*#%. 0 ' (#'* ' 2,??
)"!E )"!E )"!E )"!E ! # "0* M 0*/ )**/(#*(0 */"##'!E ;*# ' !*/ *#"))* !$' .E 20*"( '* '))+ #* '* ).' #'* 0*/' $' 00*##*+*# ' ! $' 0 '))!# # .*/ ; )**// ## ' !* 00* '0) K( 2 )* */ " ' ' '!E )**/K(0 '* */)'/D 3
3 3
3 3
3 3
3 (()) =0)'" # ' ! %%2:::=H (# "* !# 3 !"
#'$ 6'"' ! ). "* ).' 0*" 2' 0* * 0 ' " " ' + * 0*! .' /'#"' .*#(#$#' .#/* #"' '* */ "* )) =0)'" *((#
- 0)**/' 0*" //#+. ,???? ;C&&&& K %E #* *// 4
*/ * ). ' #.2 0*/ ;''E */ ' ' )'/D 1N +.
"'
"*/
" /*#2 ).
-H .'" // * MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO NO.967 OF 2024 2,C:=H # ()0* ::1% "* * #'! )+* ' * )+/ * &"* * 0'#0 " 0 * 0* #$ '$). # #"*#2 * +' !0*/< #'! )+* ' / #)**/ # */ # #'0 '* * ' / 0 '* ) '+ $*0 '* */ < (( * < (( * < (( * < (( * 0 # 0*"( '* " * #/ #(# 8B%9 ( '"*/00' (# ) )' < '* ) # < '* ) # < '* ) # < '* ) # 1B&2 '0#0* 024 (O&M) # #2$' ). "* *#$'0 ) 1%:%: (()) =0)'" 0 *' +) K '* *)0 ' 0#"#I* #'! ' K * " (()) * ) *# 0 *#I' !0(0' . */ (# 02 )* */ > ?12BBBC=H;C&&&& * !2 (()) =0)'" /<0 *' +) K '* *)0 ' 0#"#I*$##'! ' K */' 0*"=/ 0 '* )'+')' .' / *#I +' ! (#/*#" +. ' "*+')' . # ' ! 0(0' +')' . ". '//# /#*" "' ' #' '* )).2 * L $ $ # 7 "#D $ $ # 7 "#D $ $ # 7 "#D $ $ # 7 "#D #(*# 0)'" //# '+')' . ". + # * * ). /*# (#*(0 (# ) */ #0*# * 1N.#0*"( '* '* +.* ' '* 0 # 0*6 $ # . 'D # 0*6 $ # . 'D # 0*6 $ # . 'D # 0*6 $ # . 'D# 0*# 0* 0) '* ' '#!# )#00' ' (# 0 * " $+ +H#' /* 0( )/#0 # "') '// K/' !#2/ # 00' * )$ //#)**/' 0*" #/*#2/ #0* '#' !/0 */ ' 0*" /*# ' (#'* &&KB:E#* *// * ??2::: //# C@ '+')' .2 . 0( )/#0 # "') '// K/' !#D' * )+ /' '>1@2I(' !'
$' (()) J # ) $ 0' .2 ) (#' 0'() '0) '+')' . ( ' ! (* * L+) (#"* # 2' 0 # %:%: 11& %:%: 11& %:%: 11& %:%: 11& ) * "* *# $'0) 00' / # )* */ ' 0*" + ! */ (()) =0)'" * *// #(#*(0 ' *+* 0*/ * L+) (#"* # #(*# ;%:CE??N: ;%:CE??N: ;%:CE??N: ;%:CE??N:( #2# #4H 5 **I /*#& */ 2' /*# * ' :::=H . ' */ /'#'/ $' $# */ ' ' 2 )* # ' (# MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 <1B ' 0* (#" ' .# ' 8B&9 $ )**// # (#*(0 > :@ / # (#*(0 ( #(* */ 0)0 0*"( '* ( > &2B%2:,:=H 3 3 3 3 8:9 K */C@2 #0*#K
? (()) =0)'" ((#*K'" ). * (#$)
"'0' #' ! +#
" )!* .* * ! *0*))0 (#*$#/*# # '' 024 (O&M)
1B&-') #"' ' !' 0*"2 0*"*/ 0 * #/ # #" *+ +)* !
' '* * )+&:@2'/ !*/ # 0 0 + ' '* * )+1@0 ))#. $' */ +*$'0 '* 2 ## ' !2)))*+ ' ) :@ #/*#2 ' 0*" */ 0 + I %,2%::=H ;%%2 )0 ) '* */ 0*"( '* 00* (.+)/*# / 0 '* )'+')' H;%,2%::K%KBK1=::E <36O <36O <36O <36O
(# 02 (()) =0 2 '0+ +)'/#*" ?+.# .' !23 22
" )* * ' # " #/*#2 I '"*/"* *#$'0 )#00' ' !#+')' '* (#'*2 0*"( /*#'$' /' /*#0/# * 00* */00' 2(#* )0 )) +'))/*#0)'"=#'"+ # N12?B%=H. ' "+)*( ' 21:2:::=H ' '* */1:@*/0 ))#. * #(#*(0 2 # 0 ! */ ,: .# * ) + " */ 0 + ,: * + ! */ 1: * ?: .#2 #.* )#0 ))#.) K (()) =0)'" ' ' '* *0*"( '* /*#)**// / (()) =0)'" / # ' %2::: P %2%::E (# "* /*# 0*#' !).2 ' * # /' ')' . * K */1@' =
6Q =
6Q =
6Q =
6Q =0)'" //# '+')' . *
" '+')' .0# '/'0 (#*$ 2 #' *((#
-H& ( " */ 1 )I 2 I(' ! ' "' 0* /0 # " +'
"( '* # ' /#*" /0 **0I 0 * +(# " *+$'!') #" ( #(*2 * !2 * )+' *(' '* */ '* # 20*"( ' 6
* *1: #2 KD '* * # ' ! # * * )I /0 *# */ * I !') )+')) '* MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment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
'+')' .J (.'0) !* . # +. * 0 #4H #/## !" 2 ' #' //# )'/H)* ! # */ '+') 2 " */ *0 *# M */ 0)'" H(()) * 12::2:::=H # R(' /0 (#.# */ 0)'" '* +. "*/ :2::2:: 2/'# #* +) "* *' '* 0' +. * L+ $' ! #!# * (0 ) ' ' $' /#*" *0 " (()) =0)'" ' !#'$* )0( )/#0 # "') '// ' K/' !#D3*# 2 # -H& (#*$ * #0*# 2 (()) =0)'" /* ' */ *(' '* "* ' //#' ! 7 #' !2 ' 7 7 7 7 J . //#2 +')' . *# * + ' '" H 2:::=H * L+) 0 )'# #. $* // 2# * */ MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 3 3 3 3 8%9 " //#' !/#*"( '// */ #'! /' ' ). !* !# M 0 0 #> 6 6 6 6 8&9 (()) =0)'"
" #4H * * * * 6* &2B % 3 & * , * * * * * " " " " 8,9 $' */ *+ * #$ * #$ * #$ * #$ ;,E1& ;,E1& ;,E1& ;,E1&(( 76#. 76#. 76#. 76#. 024 (O&M)
R
R
R
R
"' ).2 ' # + (* # " '0"') *"*# ! )+* ' 0# "#I #'! /*# ' (* H*(# '$ 0# * 0*"( '* # */ 0#! #/*#2 0*"( '* 2::2:::= $' */ +
" ))+ ' )/*# !# # # # # 6**/ 0*"; 2,C:P ??
&2B%2:,:E 3'0)K( =*(' )'A '* *"( '* #* #(0 ' *"( '* #(' // * )*"( '* * )*"( '* * )*"( '* * )*"( '* "* #+. #'+ ) "* #+. #'+ ) "* #+. #'+ ) "* #+. #'+ ) 0"* 0"* 0"* 0"* !# */ ' # > ?@ (# +#$ '* "+. * L+) '* ) # 0*"( .6'" '* ) # 0*"( .6'" '* ) # 0*"( .6'" '* ) # 0*"( .6'" ((#*$' +M !" . * #2%:,;E . * #2%:,;E . * #2%:,;E . * #2%:,;E L L L L #' /*# & "* '// */#'! * )# " ' K /' !# * ) * $#2 )# #'+ ) /') */(0')' 20* $. 00#! '* !# # '0 #' +*$2
*/0*"( '* ' /*))* ' "* ;' E "* ;' E "* ;' E "* ;' E ??2:::P ,21B21:=H 21:2:::=H '#. 2::2:::=H //#' ! %2::2:::=H B2:B21:= B2:B21:= B2:B21:= B2:B21:=HHHH 2??2:B%= 2??2:B%= 2??2:B%= 2??2:B%=HHHH C2,&2,N= C2,&2,N= C2,&2,N= C2,&2,N=HHHH " ' * M ' +) ) (#"* # ' <" ( <" ( <" ( <" ( 6'"' * #2 6'"' * #2 6'"' * #2 6'"' * #2#(*# ;%:: ;%:: ;%:: ;%:: ' )<
"" * #$ <
"" * #$ <
"" * #$ <
"" * #$ ;'$')E,,&2 ;'$')E,,&2 ;'$')E,,&2 ;'$')E,,&2 2 ' # 8
"') $ * #! ' ' ! ' ' ' ' ' ;%::BE ;%::BE ;%::BE ;%::BE #$ #$ #$ #$ ' MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO NO.967 OF 2024 0 * B@ 0)'" /#*" ' "* #/ #)* ! *.) 0)'" ) 819 00 '(* */ ' #'+ )
' */ +# #. +# #. +# #. +# #.::::&&&&2222%:% %:% %:% %:% 'I - - 024 (O&M)
B@ (# " * "* */' ' '* */0)'" ' * (' ' ' # "* ! ' %@' # /#*" K(' *" '* # "* ))+ 0 /#*" 0 00*#' !).2 (() /') ' ' /*#' "*'/'0 '* */ ' !"'0)) * (()'0 '* ;E %:% :% %:% :%???? #(I' !=#* =* ##(*# +) =* */ 0*"( '* # *
"( ' '* '))' #)'A '* 0
"* 2 " )) + (.+ K('#.*/(#'**/ #"* /#* */0*"( '* )#.(' 00*"( '* ' 0 */ (()) =0)'" */ # ( +. )# ;E'/ .2)))* '(* ; 73 E ; 73 E ; 73 E ; 73 E 9
* 0 .+) /#*" ' * ' # (* MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.03 18:19 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment