RFA No.540 of 2023



                             !   !   !   ! "  "  "  "  #$$%&! #   '(#&      #    #   '(##              (  (  (  (34 34 34 3433335555



  #*8 ,$:*,)$/#('*   (# +.-$9&&(*,,-+ (' &)$ *11,/9*&/( %*0$,8*%*= 9*$  (  (  (  (3 3 3 3   5555



  8 &)$2$,*8('>?7   (& 3 (O&M) 
    
    
    
    
 
 
 
    ( ( ( (????    *&$('$ *&$('$ *&$('$ *&$('$ 
 
 
 
  

 
  

 
  

 
  

 
             "  
 "  
 "  
 "  
 #*),(%2@(9*&$ (#&)$*11$,,*%& #*#+%$)*+)*,&& #)/)$#0*2@(9*&$ (##$1(%2$%&( AAAA   #*,   #*,   #*,   #*, 
('676 
('676 
('676 
('676 #*8$# 0*2$/%&)$*11,/9*&/(%/ '*11$,,*%&%*0$,8*%*=)*%2 (# &)$ #$*(% 0$%&/(%$2 /% &)$ -+&$<9$1&/(%*%2&)$*11,/9*%& *&/(% *#$ (#2$#$2 &( .$ /01,$*2$ =)*%2*%2*%:**02$9$* 
('676 
('676 
('676 
('676 8;*8('1#$$%&*11,/9*&/(%1#* 7>2*8/%'/,/%:&)$1#$$%&*11$* (&/9$('&)$*11,/9*&/(%         ????47 47 47 47(' (' (' ('676 676 676 676 B   B   B   B  $9//(%! $9//(%! $9//(%! $9//(%!3C 3C 3C 3C7777676 676 676 676>>>>    D D D D11$,,*%& 11$,,*%& 11$,,*%& 11$,,*%&  
    
    
    
   $1(%2$%& $1(%2$%& $1(%2$%& $1(%2$%&              +%-*. /'(#/01,$*2/%:&)$*11,/9*%& *%2*%2*%:**0;)()*@$2/$ )$ *11,/9*&/(% &)$ *0$ / *,,(; &*0$%&/(%$2/%1*#*:#*1)( 2$2 * ,$:*, )$/# (' *11$,,*%& *$2/%(#2$#&(1+#+$&)$1#$$ 1#*8$#)*.$$%0*2$'(#9(%2(%/ 1$*, 1   * 2/$2 ;$2 (6 *%& #$$%& (%/%: MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.24 10:41 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.540 of 2023   % *%2 # )/ ) *%2#$ 1$9&/@$,  
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
%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& 0*,,
%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& 0*,,
%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& 0*,,
%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& * $2&)$#$+1(%*%2*11,8/%:&)$1 9(01$% *&/(% &)$,*%2(;%$# K*1 # :#*%& (' /0/,*# *0(+%& (' 9(0 %&$#$ & '(# &)$ 1$#/(2 (' 2$,*8 /% $9*%.$1,*9$2+1(%&)$2$9/ /(% )(& )(& )(& )(&*11* *11* *11* *11*%:*2/$*2&)#(+:) %:*2/$*2&)#(+:) %:*2/$*2&)#(+:) %:*2/$*2&)#(+:) %(&)$#I %(&)$#I %(&)$#I %(&)$#I#$1(#&$2* HHHH67673C 67673C 67673C 67673C % /% ()*# /%:) $*2 )#(+: ()*# /%:) $*2 )#(+: ()*# /%:) $*2 )#(+: ()*# /%:) $*2 )#(+: ,$9&(# B # $9&(# B # ,$9&(# B # $9&(# B #  #$1(#&$2 *  H676
 676
 676
 676
  2*8  ;*  9(%2(%$2 &( *99(#2 .$/&%(/%&$#$ &;* *;*#2$2'(#2$ *9&$2)$#$+%2$#!5 #+%$ )*+ )*,  &&  +%- 9$(%.$)*,'('#$ 1(%2$%&( 3B $/%&)$*11,/9*&/(% (# &)$ 1*#&/$  *%2 :(%$ &)#(+:) & /&+*&$2,*%2(;%$# 1$#&*/%/%:&( .$$% )$,2 $%&/&,$2 '(# &)$ $%)*%9 ,*%2 /&+*&$2 /% #$@$%+$ $ &*&$ +#2* 1+#%(; *&)*%=(&*,(%:; ('-+2:0$%&2*&$26?74673C1*   B  ;/&) J   (36>   B  ;/&) J   (36>   B  ;/&) J   (36>   B  ;/&) J   (36>5555
 
 
 
 (#&(#1(#*&/(% )+)*#/%:) (#&(#1(#*&/(% )+)*#/%:) (#&(#1(#*&/(% )+)*#/%:) (#&(#1(#*&/(% )+)*#/%:) $1#/%9/1,$('1*#/&8 .$ /2$ :#*%& K*11,/9*%& .$/%: /0/,*#,8 /&+*& (01$% *&/(%  )(;$@$#  ;/&)(+& * /% '/,/%: &)$ 1#$ $%& *11$*,
% & (%('(%G.,$+1#$0$(+#&/%9* :)   :)   :)   :)  1$9/*,*%29E+/ /&/ 1$9/*,*%29E+/ /&/ 1$9/*,*%29E+/ /&/ 1$9/*,*%29E+/ /&/ ?CC ?CC ?CC ?CCI*%2&)$,*&$ &$<1( /&/(% (+:) #  B #   (+:) #  B #   (+:) #  B #   (+:) #  B #   &*&$ (' & &*&$ (' & &*&$ (' & &*&$ (' & 
 373CI 
 373CI 
 373CI 
 373CI ;)$#$.8  2$,*8 (' #2 1*#/&8 .$&;$$% /0/,*#,8 1,*9 2$,*8$21$#/(2)$#$,$@*%&1(#&/ 2   +%-*. 3B6 ) &)$ &)$ *%9$2 $ /$ ;/&) * $2 
 (' 
 (' 
 (' 
 (' %:)B %:)B %:)B %:)B *%&(' +*&$2 & *%8 % &)/  9* $ / /&/(% / /&/(% / /&/(% / /&/(% /(%('  &&*#  &&*#  &&*#  &&*# (' 36 ,*9$2 #&/(% MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.24 10:41 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.540 of 2023 H36 (' &) $%&/& '(# 2$9/ 1$# ;$,, 2$,* '/,/% *11$ 1$#/( #$*( &/,, (+:) /%&$# 1$#/( '/,/%   
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.540 of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
('673 
('673 
('673 
('673 #*&/(%)+)*#/%:)B #G #*&/(%)+)*#/%:)B #G #*&/(%)+)*#/%:)B #G #*&/(%)+)*#/%:)B #G 99(#2/%:,8&)$1#$$%&*11$*,/2 +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$B<1(#& +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$B<1(#& +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$B<1(#& +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$B<1(#& #$ )$,2 $%&/&,$2 '(# /0/,*# *0(+ &)$# /0/,*#,8 /&+*&$2,*%2(;%$# */,*.,$+%2$#&)$*0$%2$21#(@//  &( &)$ 1#$$%& *9E+//&/(% /%9,  *11$,,*%& )*,, %(& .$ $%&/& '(#&)$1$#/(2('2$,*8/%'/,/%:&)$ $%2/%:*11,/9*&/(%/'*%8)*,,*                  )$&)$#1$*=/%:K#$*(%$2 $K )$&)$##$1(#&*.,$  $K  *#$ *2 /2$0 &)*& +%2$# /0/ #0/%: 1*#& (' &)$ *0$ *9E+//&/ $)/, *&)*%=(&/&#/9&+#2*1 9#$*$2 &( 337777K5 1$# *9#$ *&$26?74673C/%  (6366  (6366  (6366  (6366 3 3 3 3&/&,$2FFFF +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$ +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$ +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$ +%-*.0*,,
%2+&#/$ 2/1($2('/%&$#0('&)$2$9// #&(#1(#* #&(#1(#* #&(#1(#* #&(#1(#*&/(% &/(% &/(% &/(%GGGG9*$+1#**%2 (+%& (' 9(01$%*&/(% * )* .$ $# *,(%: ;/&)*,,&*&+&(#8 .$%$' //(%('*%29E+//&/(%9&3 %9,+2/%: &)$ /%&$#$& (% (,*&/+ &/&,$2 &( /%&$#$& (% &)$ $%)*%9 &)$*11$*,/$>?7>2*8 ,,*,(&*%22/1($2('                     $K( $K(     4   0/,*# /&/(% *1+# 9#$ *& 66(' 66(' 66(' 66(' #/$B #/$B #/$B #/$B //(% &)$  .$$% %$'/& C4 &/+0 *%9$2 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.24 10:41 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment