Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2023 DAILYLAW 5278 (PNJ)

EXECUTIVE ENGINEER v. SANDEEP AND OTHERS

CR/317/2023 · 2026-03-18

Harkesh Manuja

body2023

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

CR No.317 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.317 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.317 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment