RFA No.553 of 2023



         
 
 
 
                !"  !"  !"  !" #  #  #  #  %&&'(" !%   )*%(      !%    !%   )*%%     $! $! $! $! !* !* !* !*5 5 5 5   



  8 (+&4&.,8*)7  
'3 %&3.8+,0&&')1  
 +, :*'(&'(*)(+&,   *' ,2& ,:=-11(1*' ,2*-'( *) :*2 ;1..,<&,'13-% *.,(1-2,'4*(+ 08 (+& (+1 *-% 3 (O&M) 
    
    
    
    
 
 
 
    * * * *    ,(&*)& ,(&*)& ,(&*)& ,(&*)& 
 
 
 
   

 
  

 
  

 
  

 
             #!  
$ #!  
$ #!  
$ #!  
$ %$,+.*'4;*:,(& *%(+&,33&..,'( %$,%-'&+$,-+,. (( %+1+&%2,4;*:,(& *%%&3*'4&'(* >>>>   %,.   %,.   %,.   %,. 
*)676 
*)676 
*)676 
*)676 89,8*)3%&&'(,33.1:,(1*'3%, 74,81')1.1'<(+&3%&&'(,33&, '3-%-,':&*)'*(1:&*)(+&,33.1: )1.&4*'0&+,.)*)%&3*'4&'(*  +,;& +&,%4 .&,%'&4 :*-'&. )*% &,33.1:,(1*' *':&4&4.8(+&*(+&%121.,%.81(- 1*' 3%*:&&41'< +,;& ,.%&,48 0&& 23&',(1*' 3&%(,1'1'< (* (+& .,' &+1. ,(+,'?*(1(%1:(-%4 *(+&%(,(-(*%80&'&)1(1';1&9*) *-%( 1'  *666 *) 67  *666 *) 67  *666 *) 67  *666 *) 677777                   *) *) *) *)676 676 676 676 @!  @!  @!  @! &:11*'" &:11*'" &:11*'" &:11*'"B B B B7777676 676 676 676 CC CC CC CC33&..,'( 33&..,'( 33&..,'( 33&..,'(  
 !  
 !  
 !  
 ! &3*'4&'( &3*'4&'( &3*'4&'( &3*'4&'( !  !  !  !   -'/,0 3%,8&%+,0&&'2,4&)*%:*'4*'1 3&,. 3.1:,(1*'1-&4*'7676+ *(+&,2&1(,?&'*'%&:*%4 *% (+& 3,%(1& ,'4 <*'& (+%*-<+ ( 1(-,(&4.,'4*9'&%3&%(,1'1'<(* 0&&' +&.4 &'(1(.&4 )*% (+& &'+,': .,'4 1(-,(&4 1' %&;&'-& &(,(& -%4,3-%'*9 ,(+,'?*(,.*'<9 *)/-4<2&'(4,(&467D67B3,   @! 91(+ A  *6   @! 91(+ A  *6   @! 91(+ A  *6   @! 91(+ A  *6
 
 
 
 1   *'1'< +*%( + (+& (+& ,':&4 & 1& 91(+ ,&4 
 *) 
 *) 
 *) 
 *) MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.23 17:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.553 of 2023 67E 67E 67E 67E(1(.&4FFFF -' -' -' -' %H %H %H %H   , /-(,'4),1%:*2 ,%& &'(1(.&4 )*% 3,82&'( *) 1'(& %&<,%4%&.1,':&: *)I1'<,33,+ I1'<,33,+ I1'<,33,+ I1'<,33,+ ))1:&%,'4'*( ))1:&%,'4'*( ))1:&%,'4'*( ))1:&%,'4'*( .,9 .,14 4*9' 1 %,4&+ *..&:(* %,4&+ *..&:(* %,4&+ *..&:(* %,4&+ *..&:(* 8&,% ,'4  .,'4*9'&%,.0&1 (+&%&*)1&G(%,:( I6 *) (+ &'(1( )*% 4&:1 3&% 9&.. 4&., )1.1' ,33& 3&%1* %&,* (1.. *-<+ 1'(&% 3&%1* 3 (O&M) -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( ,&4(+&%&-3*','4,33.81'<(+&3 :*23&',(1*'(+&.,'4*9'&%L,3 % <%,'( *) 121.,% ,2*-'( *) :*2 '(&%&( )*% (+& 3&%1*4 *) 4&.,8 1' &:,'0&3.,:&4-3*'(+&4&:11*' +*(,33, +*(,33, +*(,33, +*(,33,'<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '*(+&%J '*(+&%J '*(+&%J '*(+&%J%&3*%(&4,IIII6767B 6767B 6767B 6767B ' 1' !*+,% 1'<+ !*+,% 1'<+ !*+,% 1'<+ !*+,% 1'<+ &,4 +%*-< &,4 +%*-< &,4 +%*-< &,4 +%*-< .&:(*% @ % &:(*% @ % .&:(*% @ % &:(*% @ % %&3*%(&4 , I676
 676
 676
 676
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
' ( *'*)*'H0.&-3%&2&*-%(1':, <+ <+ <+ <+3&:1,.,'4:=-11(1 3&:1,.,'4:=-11(1 3&:1,.,'4:=-11(1 3&:1,.,'4:=-11(1 BB BB BB BBJ,'4(+&.,(&(&G3*1(1*' *-<+ % @ %  *-<+ % @ %  *-<+ % @ %  *-<+ % @ %  (,(& *) ( (,(& *) ( (,(& *) ( (,(& *) ( 
 7BJ 
 7BJ 
 7BJ 
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.553 of 2023 )1.1'   
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
*)67E 
*)67E 
*)67E 
*)67E %,(1*'+-+,%1'<+@ %H %,(1*'+-+,%1'<+@ %H %,(1*'+-+,%1'<+@ %H %,(1*'+-+,%1'<+@ %H ::*%41'<.8(+&3%&&'(,33&,.14 -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( -'/,02,..
'4-(%1&@G3*%( %& +&.4 &'(1(.&4 )*% 121.,% ,2*- (+&% 121.,%.8 1(-,(&4.,'4*9'&% &%&1',0*;&,9&..,:*'(&'(*) 74,81')1.1'<(+&3%&&'(,33 '<&+,0&&'.,14(*(+&9,%44,( 1:(-4<&-%4,3-%:-2&)&%&' (1*'5*)(+&,'4:=-11(1*' L.,'4*9'&% 9, 3,%(.8 ,..*9 67L 3&% ,:%& )*% ,%,'1 *2  3&% ,:%& )*% ,'/,% ,412 , .,'4 ,.*'< 91(+ *(+&% (,(-(*  ,%& ,4 14&2 (+,( -'4&% 121 %21'< 3,%( *) (+& ,2& ,:=-11(1 &+1. ,(+,'?*(1(%1:(-%4,3 :%&,&4 (* 7777L 3&% ,:%& ,(&467D67B1'  *666  *666  *666  *666 E E E E(1(.&4FFFF -'/,02,..
'4-(%1& -'/,02,..
'4-(%1& -'/,02,..
'4-(%1& -'/,02,..
'4-(%1& 413*&4*)1'(&%2*)(+&4&:11 %(*%3*%, %(*%3*%, %(*%3*%, %(*%3*%,(1*' (1*' (1*' (1*'HHHH:,&-3%,,'4 *-'( *) :*23&',(1*' , +, 0& &% ,.*'< 91(+,..(,(-(*%8 0&'&) 3   (+& 33&,. 4,(&4 %&':& :( *9&4 *2& ,'4 -(*%8 21.,% 1(1*' ,3-% :%& ,( 66*) 66*) 66*) 66*) %1& %1& %1& %1&@ @ @ @ 11*' (+&  0&&' '&)1( MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.23 17:50 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.553 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment