Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2023 DAILYLAW 4942 (PNJ)

M/S A.M. AUTO DIESEL AND ANR. v. VARINDER NATH MAYOR ANDA NR.

CR/3990/2023 · 2026-04-20

Harkesh Manuja

body2023

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

CR No.3990 of 2023 (                                             !"    '("    (!  +  +  +  + /0  1 (' !*%#, 4$#&& ! & #! *%8%&3* "$  ) "%"%(! 9 -&#!*&(*.2#" /0  % '%& *%!"$ 1 # $() !(; #!* #6#%! " "$  ) "%" 7(!#'%* ! 4 (#)) # *#! #""$  <3 "(' "$  =#""  2# 23 (O&M)                          (  (  (  (A; A; A; A; #" (' #" (' #" (' #" ('                                            +  +  +  + #$%&(%,*8(4#"  ("$ ) "%"%(!  (! '("$  )(!* !" BBBB  ,- #&.  ,- #&.  ,- #&.  ,- #&. 12#1(')  !") "%"%(!'%& *3!* && !6  $# 7 ! &#%* "( #! (* 3*6 -3!%(%8!.#&#!*$#,2 9" !#!" ( # "( 4(9 C#=% " #" *#!%& % '&1 "#"%!6, %! "$  )  !" 4# #:5#""$ %! "#!4 ('"$  ) !* : %"3#" * #" #1( 3%&*%!6 "%"%(! 9" !#!", 2$  %! "$  %"1<3#"$ * =% *) =%  #!*" !*  *$%#''%*#8%"(!:>: ('& #! *4(3! &'("$ ) "%"%(! # #*@(3! * "( :D:5: '(                 A;;: A;;: A;;: A;;:(' (' (' (': : : :AAAA- E. - E. - E. - E.  4%%(!   4%%(!   4%%(!   4%%(! : : : :::::DDDD: : : :>>>>     "%"%(! "%"%(! "%"%(! "%"%(! -. -. -. -.   )(!* !"  )(!* !"  )(!* !"  )(!* !"----....         3!* "%4& 5('"$ (! "%"3"%  *#" * :F:F: )# * 71 " 2$  71"$ ())("3!%"16#!" * =%!  ?9 #%!*  #"$ # # , #! 8%4"%(! ) "%"%(! 4#=  "( )(!* !"9&#!*&(*<3#"$ * =% %!6  $3 #* ! (#*, #&#!*$ )(!* !"9&#!*&(* 4&#%= * "$ )(!'#=%!6('%3 , )(!* >::# ?9 !"$ #%**# %(! 7 '( "$ & #! *%#&(3 ( 4(9 C#=%!#"%(! (' ?9 1 "3"%(! 1 "$  *"( #1( "( 7  =% * !*$#  "$ % !* !" *#" , (3",  ! MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 14:45 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.3990 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.3990 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.3990 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.3990 of 2023 ( ())("3!%"1 "( 37"#!"%#&) @3 )#6=#"%4#))(# (* *#" *:F: ) "%"%(! 9" !#! %! "$  8%4"%(! $(2 8 "$ #= 71"$ ) "%"%(! 7 '( "$ & #! />0   # ('$ #%!67 '( "$  =#"" , "$  )  !"(* #!* 4(9 C#=%!#"%( ,::,:::92% # #('#!* %& /50  $ #))&%4#"%(!-.,%'     )%& )%& )%& )%&: : : :,: ,: ,: ,:>>>> "%G ?$ ?$ 23 (O&M)     ( 4(9 C#=%!  ?9 2# " # @3*%4 "("$ %6$"('"$ ) "%"%(! (#4$#"$ "$#!* ' #"%!6"$ %6$ F:F:)# *71"$ & #! * #!"# #''(* *(!  '' 4"%8 () ! ) "%"%(! ) '  * #" "$  %! "#! #= $#&&7 37@ 4""()#1= !"(' ! 9" !#!""("$  )(!* !"9&#! ! * !"(!"(&&  #! *4(3! &'("$ ) "%"%(! '( "$ & #! *%#&(3"%'%C  & #! * %#& (3" %  <3 " #!*'%C#*#" '(#)) ##!4 (' "%(! ! 4#  "$ , ) "%"%(!  2%"$%!"%= 7 '( "$ & #! *% * 8 !3 #!*"$ ())("3!%"1#'' $  )  !" ) "%"%(! % #&&(2 * ,%'#!1,$#&&#&("#!**%)( *(     - - - -       $ "$ ) #G%!6 #(! *   $ "$  )("#7&     " #" * # , % &%G &1 "( 4#3 %(! 9" !#!"$  '( ,#*()"%!6 %6$"(!$1) 9" 4$!%4#&6(3!*," %#&(3"%$  71 "#%*  ())("3!%"1"(4(9 C#=%!  ? "#!4  (' "$   )(!* !"9&#!*&( ('4("-.(' ,::,:::9"(7 )# &#!*&(*(!(7 '( "$ *#" '%C $#)(%!" *(3""$#""$ ! C"* %C *'(:>::>!34$8% 2 " * "( !("%'1 "$  )#"%  #7(3" "  )(!* !"(7 %!6 ?9'(  '#%& "( * )(%" "$  4("-. %#&(3","$ #= 7  4(8  * #''(* *8%* "$%(* 7 " #" * * %! "$  #7(8  " = !*% ('  + .  + .  + .  + .         ( ( 5 4#3  "%!6# ,"$  $  ?9 &(*, )#%* '%C * *#"  2(' " "$  ($% . (' *# " *# !*%!6 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 14:45 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment