Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2022 DAILYLAW 2579 (PNJ)

HARBHAJAN SINGH SINCE DECEASED THROUGH HIS LRS AJAY BAWA AND OTHERS v. STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS

RFA/1024/2022 · 2026-03-30

Harkesh Manuja

body2022

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

RFA No.1024 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1024 of 2022 -)(#&"!(#)* :<%!0%%''!- -#"-#+#%8"07+ %&31&(.%$(-#-/$*    Bawa Gurm ______________ Bawa Bir Bawa Ha Singh Singh  596  %$" $*";A.$+9B %!0%-/0%#&- "$%$"-/,(00%)" 47%#%2%!&&%$" =$*"F*" %# -2#"! $- $*" %!0%+2%"#$( 56  (#. %#7.-8'"#%$(- 022 (O&M)  **1+$*"/-1!-#-/%2%1 '!-G0%#&"%.* #$*"-$*"!*% 07+%2% %#&*(!(#)**"'"&( /$*".%"(#*%#&("G$!%.$"&*"!"  S. Parduman Sing ______________________ Gurmukh Singh ___________________________ a Harbhajan Bawa Kulwant Bawa Yo Singh Singh Singh %$"!+,(&"#-$(/(.%$(-#&%$"&:C +9B %#%0%!0%-/0%#&- &-!()(#%007-2#"&47 %!&18 )"-(#&2%0+"*(0%#&($!(.$ %$"&:B<A;A'%"&47$*"%# *")!-1"-/$*"%''"00%#$2%$ $*" "G$"#$ -/ >;$* *%!" -/ $-$%0 #$($0"&/-!'!-'-!$(-#%$".-8'-#"# (#." $*" '!"&"."-!H(#H(#$"!"$ - $(-#(#$"!8-/-!()(#%0%2%!&&%$ 1!81?*(#)*(#*"!($"&:A %# *%#&+%2%%*%!%3(#)**%&-# "&()!""$%40"2*(.*(!"0",%#$/-!$ "!"1#&"!H Singh ________________ Bawa Maharaj Singh _ a Yoginder Randhir Singh ingh :CA;;(1"&1#&"!".$(-#-/$ -1$-/$*"%/-!"%(&;B< %#%0 8%#(#)*/-!8(#)'%!$-/!","# $%!#%!%#+2%%.@1(!"&/-00-2 %#&.@1(($(-#-00".$-!/-!* $*%$+%2%%!4*%3%#(#)*+4"( $%0 %.@1(!"& 0%#& -/ 9B %#%0 "#$-/$*".-8'"#%$(-#%2%!&"& $ -/ $*" %''"00%#$ 2% #","! '% &%$"&:B<A;A'%"&47$*" 2 %#%0 -#07 -!$*" -/$*" 0; "#1" -2"& *-!$ 4"(#) 0  &  '%(& + MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.09 11:25 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1024 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1024 of 2022 (88"&(%$"07 -# ".$(-# 9: .-10 !"@1(!"&$-4"%/ (#$*".0%(8'"$( ,(-0%$(,"-/'!(#. 5C6  "! 148($$*%$$*" .$ 2% 2*-007 *%!"8"%1!(#) ;%!0%%#&$* %.@1(!"&0%#& 5C6  "% $*"%''"00%#$+ /!-8 $*" 3-(#$ "/"!"#."-1!$ -!&"!.%00"&/-!# 5B6   *% '%'"!4--?%2 148((-#8%& 5;6  !-8 %!&18%#(#)* %!#%!%#( (#*"!($"&9C % #%8"07%2%( -)(#&"!(#)* 022 (O&M)  -# :<:C<:<: $*% %0-4""#. -10& #-$ *%," 4""# !"3".$"& 18 %//-!&"&-''-!$1#($7$-0"%&",(&" "$($(-#%#&+$*1$*"(8'1)#"&-!& (#.('0"-/#%$1!%031$(." "! .-#$!%+ 0"%!#"& .-1#"0 /-! $* "!"/"!"#."-1)*$47$*"%''"00% 007 8(.-#."(,"&+ % %2% %!4 #):A %#%0<%!0%-1$-/$*" $*1+*%&#-14($(#)!()*$$-.0% "%!#"&.-1#"0/1!$*"!148($$*% +($2%"$%40(*"&$*%$*"*%&% $ *-0&(#)+ $*1+ #- /1!$*"! $!(% 1!$(#$"!8-/".$(-#9:-/$*"; !#-(#$"!/"!"#."  *%," *"%!& 0"%!#"& .-1#"0 /-! 2"00%!".-!&-/$*".%"%8 %&"-#4"*%0/-/$*"%''"00%#$ !-8 $*" !".-!&+ ($ ( ",(&"#$ $* )*2%;B< %#%0;%!0%(#,(0 ($2--#+#%8"07+%2%1!81 %#%0:A%!0%-/0%#&"%.*% (!(#)*+%2%%!4*%3%#(#)* )**""/-1!-#(#*"!($"&>$* .-#$"#&"&$*%$$*"!"/"!"#."1#& 188%!(07 %#& $*" %''"00%#$ 2" &"#."(#1''-!$-/$*"(!.0%(88% -!&"!2%0(%40"$-4""$%(&"4"(  $*" '!(,%$" !"'-#&"#$>0%#&-2# 00%#$1#&"!".$(-#9:-/$*"; !4*%3%# (#)* *%& %0!"%&7 -0& $*"3-(#$0%#&8"%1!(#);B< %# .0%(8.-8'"#%$(-#(#!"'".$-/$ $*%$-#."/!-8$*"-2#'0"%&(#) &%0("#%$"&8-!"$*%#*(-2#*% $!(%0 2% 2%!!%#$"& 47 $*" 0"%!# ;A.$%#&%1.*+$*"(8'1)#  -! $*" '%!$(" %#& )-#" $*!-1)* $ %81#%40"$-/(#&14$%#."(#$   $*%$ $-$%0 0%#& (# $*" *%#& -/ ,(00%)"-(#&2%0+"*(0%#&($! 1?*(#)*%#&%2%%*%!%3(# %2%1!81?*(#)**%&/-1!- #)*+%2% 102%#$(#)*%#&% $**%!""%.*-1$-/9C %#%0 4 1#&"! 2"!" 8%&" 4"(#) #"! ;A & *( %#%0 -/$*" )-/ *%!" %!#"& )#"& * $*" #$*" -/  ($!(.$ (#)* -# %2% 0: MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.09 11:25 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1024 of 2022 %!0%-#"@1 :A %#%0:< !"0%$(#)$-$*" (#)*I%#&$*".- ,(JH%H,(J*($*! 5A6  # $ !"'!""#$(#) $*" '%"&47$*" /%,-1!-/$*"0%# !".-!&-/!()*$+ $*" 7"%! A;BH '!"&"."-!H(#H(# $*"3-(#$0%#&*- !".-!&-2"," $*%$ 4"/-!" $*" & %!4*%3%#(#)* *-0&(#) 5:6  *" '!-,(&"& 47 $*" *"!"1#&"!H  %0"&""&&%$"& -*%$%"!% %0"&""&&%$"& %4%%!%(#)* %0"&""&&%$"& -*%$%%#$ 022 (O&M)  "@1"#$07+%2%%!4*%3%#(#)* <%!0%%''!-G$8%74"#- *%!"%#&"#$($0"8"#$-/%2% .-#$!-,"!7(.-#/(#"&$-$*""#$ $*!""4!-$*"! # $*" '!""#$ .%"+ $*" '!(#.('%0 $*" %''"00%#$ ( -# $*" .-#$"#$ +%'"!2*(.*$*"'%78"#$- 0%#&-2#"!(#%..-!&%#."2($*$*" *$+%-#$*"&%$"-/%.@1(($(-#'!- H;; #&-14$"&07+ (# $*" 3%8%4 (#$"!"$-/$*"%''"00%#$2%!" *-0&(#)+(#$"!8-/81$%$(-##- ","!+/!-8$*"8%$"!(%0%,%(0%40"- " &%$" -/ '%(#) -/ $*" %2%!& 4 #)**%&%0!"%&7%0("#%$"&$*"0%#& *"&"$%(0-//(,"%0"&""&"G".1 $*" %''"00%#$ *(8"0/ (# '%!% # "&9::A;B !%%!%(#)* A>>>< <;H: BBH :KC C C C "&<:9A;; #)*%!*%0(2%0" A>>> "&:;A;A #$%!&(%0(#)* A>>C + : :>< *2%"#$($0"&$-"G.01(,"*%!" #-$(."&*"!"$*%$$*"!"(#-&('1 %%*%!%3(#)*-!*(-# %#& "#$($0"8"#$-/%2%%!4*%3%#(# %0 "8'*%( -/ $*" "#(-! .-1# #$ -/ $*" 2%!& &%$"& :B<A $-/.-8'"#%$(-#2%$-4"8%&" $*"(!!()*$%#&*%!"!".-!&"&(#$ '!-.""&(#)("%'"!3%8%4%#&( 8%4%#&( /-! $*" 7"%! A;BH;;+ $ !".-!&"&%-#"-/$*".-H*%!"! #-<<B&%$"(0+%'"!$*"!","# "-#!".-!&+($$--&&107"$%40(*  47 $*"  -# :B<A;A+ % %#&8-!"$*%#*(*%!"(#$*"3- ".1$"&47*(8(#%$%410%$"&/-!8 % #-<A -/ $*( %''"%0 %!" "G$!%.$ ><<H;+ A><H<+ : 8(# H :+ 9BH+ > H+ C>< <H + ;> <H;+ ;><H<+ A C %#%0 C %#%0 C %#%0 C %#%0 >BH<+>:HB+B>9H<+A 9 A 9 A 9 A 9 C>9HC+ ;H:+ B>:H<+ >< :>>;H:+ <:HC+ :> CH H+9B 9B 9B 9B HHHH; ; ; ; 5 !"-/ '1$" #&*(! (#)* 1#"0 A;A &"(# (#$*" &(/-! + $*" "!(# "#1" 0(*"& %2% 3-(#$ !8% %.$"& ;+ <+ A;H 9 9 9 9 ><9H C+ MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.09 11:25 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1024 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment RFA No.1024 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment