Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2020 DAILYLAW 2380 (PNJ)
IFFCO TOKIO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD v. SHIVANI THAKUR AND ORS
XOBJC/56/2024 · 2026-03-24
Sudeepti Sharma
Public Interest Litigationbody2020
[ 2020 DAILYLAW 2380 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2020 DAILYLAW 2380 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
""
# '('()'#(
, $ / # 2020 (O&M) & 2024
FAO-866 XOBJC
+
*1 /
!"# &'$(
,-$&#
2
3
"
+ 3
4
"$2 5 67$2 8#9+")'):.
!
" .
/0
$
$*
$
-.
#(00 %
$
-1- 866-2020 (O&M) & BJC-56-2024
;
"#$%1 !$%$)%*+%'21 ##$%31
*
#: .
%
&
+
$
; &
# *
*
$
$
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
&%* <
$ 4 5 ) $2 5
'('()'#(
/ # %
=
8 $2
'('()' 4 5 > 7n Balabhgarh from which was being was pillion rider AM, when they bearing registrat negligent manne Due to the impac General Hospita 2020 (O&M) & 2024
"
$ %% 2 "$2
# :
#(00 $*
$
"$2 5
$* $*
5"$2 )'#(
$*
$ 2
n 27.9.2015, Deepak Thakur h from Bawal on motor cycle bearing s being driven by the deceased and hi n rider.
While driving the motor cycle they reached near Assam Petrol pum gistration no. HR61B-1778 being driv manner and at a very high speed and impact deceased sustained serious and ospital, Rewari, where, he was dec
-2- +
*
&
?
$
$*
.
%
&
#
;#8 '(0>'5"
)!'()'
+
*
%
& $
2% akur (since deceased) was going bearing registration no. HR-51AR-37 and his colleague Gaurav son of Sure cycle at a moderate speed at about 7. l pump Nikhri in the mean time a cant g driven by respondent no.1 in rash a ed and hit the motor cycle of decease us and fatal injuries and he was taken as declared dead. FIR No. 410 dat
" )'#: " &
oing to 3751 f Suresh out 7.50 a canter rash and ased. taken to 0 dated GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
27.09.2015 unde Dharuhera.
: @ A $* ' " 0 1 ) ! 1 & $ % & % 2020 (O&M) & 2024 5 under Sections 279/337/304-A of IP @ A % $ " ( ' .. " / 3( ( 0 ( ' .) 1 ) 2 1 $ * " $ ? * * A; A; & -3- of IPC was registered at Police Stati & % & ! "# $% "$ & '# &$ ' )* +), -4 # .. ( 9 + * " %& B % * & % $* 2 * e Station $ ##5 4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this
document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 0 B % % # % % % ( 1 % #' 5 ? % $ $ ## 2020 (O&M) & 2024 B $ % % * $ # #+ + )!'()'#: *& % * $ 1 & & ? $* * $2 . $ %% B & $ $* + *$ & -4- % % 3 & % $ C& &
& & $* $ * & $ $ $ & # $ % * " $* * & & " " * * 7 : %* " " " & GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 #) D 6/ % 8 ' ! ( "# % = 2020 (O&M) & 2024 D % & & " / 7 / 8 . 9 ( ( 8 ./:; ; . "# % "$ &( ( ( ' ' . . +45 ' +) !
( ( 8 ' ( ' '' ( . ( 8 . 8.":;' #%"$& !
=/)3 8 .1%
-5- & $
(
+
'
< (
9
(-( '
+) &;) &#" (
'
(
;
;.
(
!
! !*3)(
(
!
."
!
8.
8.15
3 8 .&$
4 <4 -( ;4
4 (
( / 4 !
4 4
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
> ' @ ' $ '
.
' ( + 4 2020 (O&M) & 2024
8.&
'
=/)
"#%:00#:0$1; /.* . '
(
?3"$,A0B)*)3* '
?/A"$B;**%
'
'
$
' =/)
'
> '' (
=/)! (
8
'
.
(
! ' :
(
, -. ./ 56 -76 ( 40 48
!
<
)(
=/)E 8 .15 /
-6- (
> =/)1$"#$%"$&
/
( '
? 3*
%5$9C? %$#A*B
" ''
<
>3(
4 8
! >
(
8.
.
8
=3.
' DC) ! ( ' - . /0 1 !"#$%!&'()* /0 1 $%!2 3 '* 2 48 - ' < ( ' / ' =/)8 .15 ( @ 4 8 .15 . ( + 2 # 4 ' GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 > ( 9- - * ' 9 " 2020 (O&M) & 2024 > ( - =/) ' -( + ' =/) - - 1 ( + 6 < ' 8 . 9 < < ' +), -4 ##53 8 / 8 ) 9 8 .1% ( ' / " "$ & ' -7- ' '
/ ( '-/ * ' < = 6 ( '-/ * +E' ; < ' ; ' ' 9 ( ( ' ' ' ( ' . ( ( ! 9 ' < ; .
(
(
'
3(
'
; 3
'
' 4 4 '
;8 '3
4 4 ' 4 . (
4 4 4 3 ' GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
-/
- (
61
+ %
&
*
*
"&
<
C
#>
2020 (O&M) & 2024
(
-./01 -/
'
'
'
'
-./0'-/*
+E' ;8*
+E' +
(
/
(
('
*
$*
*
$ ? *$
*
*
%
%
&
* C
%$
?
% $ +
-8-
+
'
+, '
'
+
*(
; 3
((' ' '
(
;
2 $*
"
"
*
&
%
A
C
%
& & ?
$
$$
:
4 :
4 3
9
A; % &
%
" GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
#: $
$
$ %
* % #
* + - !" 2%&;*
* &
$ E#
#! F?
% % % % $ ? 2020 (O&M) & 2024 % & % < & % * * % B * % % 2 E#" 3 & * & $ - 37 3 " < %% F? * $ % % & $ % & * % $ % % -9- E#3 & % * "& & % & $ %% % * * $ %% & % " < % * B -$ / / ' . & $* A;F<>0.& $ ? *
$ A; * $ # " & % " . : * " * .& " ; " # # GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 + + % #0 & + ? % #( & < $* % 7 % )' -9 //$;; 2020 (O&M) & 2024 % " & % % " < $ & * , - .1 % * * ? $ $ $ * $ * * % " %
E# $ $* % ? * 9- ( $;; #$%$" -10- $ & $ $ $* < & % / $ 1 '$%$!*!<& B - $ * $ $ ? $* % % %7 * %$ E# & ? B -$ + - ./01 ? $* / " $ -$ " ? * " " GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 % $ % + $ $ )# % $ )) 9 4 5 )8 $2 %
)> B & 8 9&:;)+ " = 2020 (O&M) & 2024 $ % * ? $ $ $ & $ %% % $ %* % %% $* + * 2 2 % & "$2 % & 7 B -$ + $* +&!&%#%$'< !. 6606),! =/./8.
-11-
%
* $
+
%*
%
? % $
* %
* *
$*
$
2 $*
5
& %
%%
<+
&9;)+ ,!
+$)!'& 121
/7-0.
"
" " * "
$* " " )+&!
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
&
A AB , A
B A
B A
2020 (O&M) & 2024
& !
D @
(
38
'
3
!
'
8
(
<3
' ;
3'
!
'
3
(
( '
A *9 '
/ ! *0#,3)+ AB**&&-
,!(
(
F .-08'/. A
B8
3
3 A
BC
A '
3 ABC
A'BC
A
B =
8 B
-12- @
;3 %55 AE;E '3(
' 3 <
!'( (
3' <
' '
'
;
' (
' 3
'
'
3 !
9 3 ;/) %#$ .* A/ BC 3 % ' 3 %#$;*1,#B ( 4 8 * 3 G 3 3 8 B( ( F H ' 4 A> B 4 4 '4 3 4 $ 4 3 %%& 4 4 ' GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 A AB A / ( !; A B A B ( A A 2020 (O&M) & 2024 A B 3 ABC A : A BC8 A / 3 A B3A BA B A B / ( 3 A BA'B3A B3AB A B ' 3 A : 888888888888 !;>0, - / A B ; A A B ! ( ' 3 ' ! ' A8 ( 3( 3 A B ! ( '< 8 ! ' ( A B ! ' -13- < B B 3 ( ' ( B /
' ( ' 3 8 3 B 8 / ./ .- 6? ' B3 ' ( ' ' 3 3(! ' ' ' B 4 ( 8 8 ' 8 ' !
( ' ' 3 3 4 B3 ! ' 4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 $% , - * - 0$ ! #& 2020 (O&M) & 2024 3 $% # # #- , # .#,8 - 55 F ! 3 ) 0$$$:4 3 ' ( ,$I < ( < 0$I ! ' ! ' * ( ' B; ' 'BC A &I BD ' ( BC FA - 55F! ( 0$$$:4 + ,$I +( + '3 ! ' #&I * B; 'BC A#&I BD ' ( -14- '3 3 #-- 8 @/ 6 ( 3 ( 0$ ; ' < < ' ! &I' 3 3' ( ' (F F) 0,3$$$:4 BF) &1$$:4 F # FA&1$$8 #BF) % 35$$:4 0$ 3 ' ( ' (
' !
(
' (F
F)0,3$$$:4
BF)"#$$$:4 F#
6, E (4 3'4 ) '
4 ' ! GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
-
(
B 'B A#$ B B J
): B 1+ # # " D + = F. % 2020 (O&M) & 2024
BC
FA
-55F!
(" ; 3
(
' (
( #$I (
' (F BD
(
'
F),$3$$$:4 'BC
A#$I8
BD
' A"& B BC
FA1"$$$ JF!
!
/
A*
;
9 B-$ +
0(=.
6306 # 8"
# 0 / .=
C D. +.% $
=.;
$ %
< F. A
% % & 2$C "
2%
-15- FA"#$$$8#BF)13&%3$$$:4 "&
3 (
(!
#$I;
( <
3
$I !
( BF)1"$$$:4 BF5 $$$85BF)#3&,3$$$:4
A;BA-B A*B ( ' 9D
ABK -./ >
& / #(00 & % < %
% C
*% C
* < &
C %
* <
*
"
4 ( !
4
4 4
4 /0 &% "
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
) B @/
“ # '* /
"# '6* 6 2020 (O&M) & 2024
“!3(
'
3 ')&3$$$3)1$3$$$
'
( ' <
' (
'
B-$ + /1$%$%B$!
;
#!(
'*//.#-/# !
"0 /* C
.
"#$$A*B/1,
'
@ *
;3 " &4"& 3
8
'
!
*
' 'E5EE#E '6*1#8./.0# 60#"!!A /
3
(
'
-16-
8' /
3
8 )&3$$$
!
'
4
<4
( '
'
'
2
-0 0 +
" <
'8
' #5!&5#5!25H
'
.
3"$#; 3*
- '
AB
! 3 "$$% ;*L "%5 A*B / 'E5E (
'
33( '
#//,/ 3
L
3
4 - $I ' F
#;*L -
!4 4 4 4 : 4
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
i. . 3 ii. C
iii. !
' iv. D
v. C <
i. ii. ' iii. iv.
0 v. ' 2020 (O&M) & 2024
D?3"$5; ; ?;3"$
L
M5 /
''
'
( 3
H '
8
H 8
M !
3
9
(
<
/
'
3
(
' L "$0!
M-#7-0F '' ''
031?&
-17- 5;*L$A*B9
"$#;*L%#%A*B8' AB
5F
'
;
(
'
!( 3 (
F
H H
(
'<
J
K '
G
AB
( '
3
(8
:
G
5 N ;"$
'F
94 ' (
4 4
4
H 4
'
4 54 "$ F GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
vi. vii.
vii. ' 2020 (O&M) & 2024 '' ( ' * ( - 3 ' 0 ( 3 3 < ( 0 I ! < / , A B3 ( '&$I '.* !$A / ( ( A B ' ( %I ' * -18- 8 ( ( 8 =3 9 A B 3 ' < ( ' ' ' * C A B3 /. . 3 ( %I L 3 3( %I ( 3 B 4 4 4 3 %I O 4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 1 4 C A) 13,1 = B D
3 C C .
! ! 1 )! & $ # )0 * + ; & 2020 (O&M) & 2024 1 5 ! 3 & (F , ( 3,158 "80 : $$ ) %35 3% A&$ B ) 13%$3% 8 3 4 ) 531,3 ) &3$$3$ 3 4 ) 3&$3$ ) "3$$3$ ) 1 3,%3 ! ( 3 3 ' 1 3,%350 :4 ( % & $ 8)* % %* # & % & = * % & 3 & $ % -19- ' 3 3( ' 3%#5:4 $3%5%:4 1,35,1:4 $3$$$:4 $3$$$:4 $3$$$:4 ,%350 :4 = % 8) * & & @ *% 1 B=+ & * *₹# '' '''5 4 4 ) %I & & GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 $ & * % * $ & % B& $ )(
& 8' & & * 2020 (O&M) & 2024 ? * + $ & < $ & ' & * & & + $* % * ? %* & % < <$ * G % -20- *F<"#:F<" $ & & * * * ₹ !
# )5" $ *2 < % * '#'>)'#: % $* * % ? * ₹&2 $C: $ * % * % D B -$ ">:. & & * * / GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 + +70 / $ & $ 2020 (O&M) & 2024 70 9- 3 8 + 3$%!2-/ - 2!; % * * " & ? &" 6/ ' 3 ) ##315$:A B ( ) 1 8 ' ! 3 3 * ! *( ' 3( ' * C @ L ' 0/ ' ' 3 -21- 3,0 / % *
/ *$ < $ < 2 % + *3 8 8 ' 8 ) 131%,:3 ! ' 113& : / ( ' + ( 8 ' / * C @ / ' ( / "3 9 @ 6 2 ( 3( / " " % 4 4 + 4 4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 8# " 3 8) % B& 88 % & 8> $ #? +?
+? #$ $2 5 %* 2020 (O&M) & 2024 83 ' 8 ' 8 2 & $ % * 3 222&C:'&2 $:;& * & %>'H & & % & & % + & & & $* 2 % % * & &--$@ # & "$2 5 " " -22- 8 $ < % $ 5 A$ & * & & ? * B -$ + $* + * "$2 $* 09.09.2019 8 4 $ " & ? * " " GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202 # * ) A 8 = < > : ! 1 0 A ( 1 A $'&- +$)% !?B)%& %<&%* 8: +
3+ -/ - C* $B9 *'?$%0 2020 (O&M) & 2024 4 * ; 0 I:'H ;8> & #5> ;): ;!! # =
* ;# F
;#: F< ;#: +
;>''''<# ;>''''<)
;;>''''<) ;) -$+,% &'?$% 6 )%'@&!##B:'< )%&- 6 %*#&+$)%' 62 .
8D 7+ +- -!%&
C*-)#?%D '< ,!?$# $( #-&:
%
-23- /, 000!5" 8>>>85":'H 000!. :08)5"#'888'6#5>. !!>(05"#'888'9):08). #>0!( # 5"!!>(0#6#)6# . #:'''5" #:'''5" )'''''5" 656E6F 61E2F 62EE33F 656E661E20
$*B-$ 08+$%!;B"! //'$%$$
*
I : $( 61 #&: ?% (?-?%D '< *!
J
. B"!& %$$* I(H *!$ GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-866-2020 XOBJC-56-202
8
$ $2 09.09.2019 8!
24.03.2026
E E 2020 (O&M) & 2024
"
+
*
% &
&
*2 $
$2 "
%
.
*
.
%5" %4 5
$ 4
-24- *
$
&
2%
$
%&
&
0 5
&
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document