THE MANAGER CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA AND ANR v. VED PARKASH CHAWLA AND ORS
CWP/151/2021 · 2026-05-13
Deepak Manchanda, Harsimran Singh Sethi
body2019
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2019 DAILYLAW 3893 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2019 DAILYLAW 3893 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
09.10.201 (hereinaft whereby t sought to from his p
2. responden prescribin
"#$
) )
"#$%& (((
*+", The present petition has bee 19 (Annexure P-3) passed by th ter referred to as the “Tribu the impugned order of recovery be effected from respondent N pension in installments has been
Learned counsel for the p nt No.4 had passed a Pension ng the pension of respondent N
!*.- $%&'&(/!!0
$#&#&($+'
$'1(2$(#'
! &' )
,- en filed challenging the order da he Central Administrative Tribu unal”) in OA No.060/1506/20 y dated 22.11.2018 (Annexure A No.1 on account of excess paym set aside. petitioner-Bank submits that Payment Order dated 02.06.20 No.1 as Rs.8608/- per month to
ated unal 018, A-7) ment the 015 be SAPNA GOYAL 2026.05.19 09:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!*.-
33 paid to him, but while feeding the said data into the computer, the same was wrongly entered as Rs.12913/-.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that from day one, respondent No.1 knew that he was receiving pension in excess of his entitlement, keeping in view the fact that the correct entitlement was mentioned in the Pension Payment Order, yet respondent No.1 continued to accept the pension beyond his entitlement.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that once payment in excess of entitlement was accepted by the respondent No.1 with due knowledge, the same is liable to be recovered.
5.
*
+ , ,-
. -
$/
.
, , ,. +.0 1
+ 23,
! '
! " #!., !''''4)
5!6567
. .
.- -. . 8 .,
. - + 0
.
0 . ,--- 9
+
" +
6.
8 ,
,. + 23,
! ' SAPNA GOYAL 2026.05.19 09:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!*.-
3/3 $% &''% () ! % " * +% $
, % ! - .- -+0
. -+
., .,
.-+.
.:- .-
.
;
*
+ , - + ,
, . + ,
<
=
+ +
-,
>
'
? -0
.
---+- , 0
@
'
$ . & . "@@< -
- 0 9 <A@<:$
-
@ @
"@@A 2--+ --+.9
"> B:$ 9 -. -,+
SAPNA GOYAL 2026.05.19 09:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!*.-
343
C ,+
-
.
D . +
0 :,+
,.
"
C
. ,. . & - + -
- 9 <A@<:$
. ,- 2
0 -- -+ + , +
.
:/ - +
B
2 , , 0
#
8
+ + - + ,.
0 ' + 26,
! '! BE@@"@@A - . / . 0$ 1
"> @;
"@ A - , - + , + 0 ,
-
9
+ > + $
SAPNA GOYAL 2026.05.19 09:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!*.-
33
!
"
# E
2
+- +-
,+ 0 2- , ++ + + ,
+ ,
A
8
+
.,.
+ 0+ :B -
;
C + ,.
,,-0 ,
<
' , . +
.
. ,,,.
,.+ .
-+- 0 ,
>
C
+,
-
2 34
. . ' . . 0
.. . , ,.
+
+ SAPNA GOYAL 2026.05.19 09:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
!*.-
303 + ,. 0
"@
+
"
F
+-,@> @
"@ > ,.C, ,+ , +.-,. 0
,,
""
+
)7.
* -
B$@E$"@"A .
*
-
&C1 =
+:G1
=
,G1
SAPNA GOYAL 2026.05.19 09:15 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document