Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2019 DAILYLAW 3702 (PNJ)

NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD v. PHOOLMATI AND ORS

XOBJC/97/2022 · 2026-03-25

Harpreet Kaur Jeewan

body2019

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

FAO-7105-2019 XOBJC-97-2022 1                                                                          !"#$%"&'('#)  !"#$%"&'('#)  !"#$%"&'('#)  !"#$%"&'('#)****   ++++,,,,+- +- +- +-  ".)%' ((/0 )&" #+1!%+ ".)%' ((/0 )&" #+1!%+ ".)%' ((/0 )&" #+1!%+ ".)%' ((/0 )&" #+1!%+    +++22"33 )! +++22"33 )! +++22"33 )! +++22"33 )!  4"0(/( 4"0(/( 4"0(/( 4"0(/(  5##36 !' 5##36 !' 5##36 !' 5##36 !' )%#!5"0( )%#!5"0( )%#!5"0( )%#!5"0(     +++"(2#)%")!( +++"(2#)%")!( +++"(2#)%")!( +++"(2#)%")!(   * 71 8+ 8  9  : * 71 8+ 8  9  : * 71 8+ 8  9  : * 71 8+ 8  9  :  0"(")!* 0"(")!* 0"(")!* 0"(")!* 0+ /38+8 ')';%<#& !"$#0!5" 22"33 )!+    0+8 )=""<9#% );%<#& !";   $#0!5"&0#((#>="&!#0?&3 '6 )!(+    #)"$#00"(2#)%")!#(++    9  :;+  9  :;+  9  :;+  9  :;+  +  0"(")! 22" 35 (>"")$'3"%>@!5")(/0 )&" #62 )@; 0 '(')A &5 33")A"!#!5". 0%% !"%++2 (("%>@!5"#!#0 &&'%")! 3 '6( 0'>/) 3; 5 == 0 5"0"') $!"0 0"$"00"% !# ( !5" B0'>/) 3C+:5"0" (;&0#((#>="&!'#)( $#0"( '%5 <">"")$'3"%>@!5" 0"(2#)%")!&3 '6 )!( (""D')A ")5 )&"6")! #$ !5" &#62")( !'#) . 0%"%>@!5"0'>/) 3+ +  5"%"! '3"%$ &!( 0")#!>"')A0"20#%/&"%5"0";(')&"!5"0" '( )# &5 33")A" >@ )@ #$ !5" 2 0!'"( !# !5" $')%')A( #$ !5" 0'>/) 3 0"A 0%')A((/"#+;'+"+5#3%')A0"(2#)%")!#+0 (5 )%)"A3'A")!') %0'<')A!0/&D>" 0')A#+,8;0"(/3!')A')!#!5"%" !5#$1 !!/ ATUL SETHI 2026.04.07 17:23 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh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s.17,28,000/- (1,08,000 X 16) + /!/0"0#(2"&!(EGJ Rs.24,19,200/- (17,28,000 + 6,91,200) -+ 1#((#$&#)(#0!'/6 (+G;? + /)"0 3"H2")("( Rs.15,000/- + 1#((#$"(! !" Rs.15,000/-  #! 3* #! 3* #! 3* #! 3* (+ (+ (+ (+G;; G;; G;; G;;????  ,+  1" 0)"% &#/)("3 $#0 !5" 22"33 )!)(/0 )&" #62 )@ &#)!")%(!5 !!5"&#62")( !'#))""%(!#>"0"%/&"%+5"0'>/) 35 ( (("(("%!5"')&#6"#$!5"%"&" ("% ((+;?2"06#)!5;6"0"3@ >@#>("0<')A!5 !5". (  '3@: A"1 >#/0"0+5"( '%$')%')A( 0" 3' >3"!#>"6#%'$'"%(')&" (2"0!5")#!'$'& !'#)#+++??-,,- -G-% !"%++;'((/"%>@!5"1 >#/0 #66'(('#)"0; 0@ ) ; !5" 6')'6/6 . A"( #$ ) /)(D'33"% .#0D"0 ."0" K/ )!'$'"% ! (+G+-G2"06#)!5;.+"+$++++ ATUL SETHI 2026.04.07 17:23 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh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s.8550 HM ,+ "%/&!'#)?G!5 (+-;?L(+;;-I(+;-M G+ /!/0"20#(2"&!(EGJ (+;;,?L(+-;N(+,;M + /3!'23'"0#$O-7 Rs.17,23,680/-L(+;;,H-M -+ 1#((#$%"2")%")&@ Rs.17,23,680/- + /)"0 3"H2")("( Rs.18,000/- + 1#((#$"(! !" (+;? (+;? (+;? (+;? + 1#((#$&#)(#0!'/6 (2#/( 3; $'3' 3 )% 2 0")! 3 (+ (+ (+ (+;;;;   ; ; ; ;????L(+G;?H-M  #! 3 #62")( !'#) #! 3 #62")( !'#) #! 3 #62")( !'#) #! 3 #62")( !'#) Rs.20,47,680/-  )!"0"(! E +J 2"0 )!"0"(! E +J 2"0 )!"0"(! E +J 2"0 )!"0"(! E +J 2"0 ))/6 ))/6 ))/6 ))/6   +  )<'".#$!5"%"&'('#)>@!5"#)7>3"8/20"6" #/0!')  06')%"0 8')A5 <(+ #)"@ #@ 3  0(+;  8  ,-  06')%"0 8')A5 <(+ #)"@ #@ 3  0(+;  8  ,-  06')%"0 8')A5 <(+ #)"@ #@ 3  0(+;  8  ,-  06')%"0 8')A5 <(+ #)"@ #@ 3  0(+;  8  ,-; !5" &#62")( !'#) 6#/)! (5 33 >" !0 )($"00"% >@ !5" 22"33 )!)(/0 )&" #62 )@')!5" )D&&#/)!(#$!5"&3 '6 )!(.'!5') 2"0'#%#$- .""D($0#6!#% @+5"2 0!'&/3 0(#$!5"> )D &&#/)!( 3#)A.'!5!5" ATUL SETHI 2026.04.07 17:23 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh