Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2019 DAILYLAW 3431 (PNJ)

NACHHATAR KAUR AND ANOTHER v. PAL KHAN AND OTHERS

FAO/3843/2019 · 2026-04-01

Harpreet Kaur Jeewan

body2019

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

FAO-3843-2019 1                                                                !"#$!%&'&"(  !"#$!%&'&"(  !"#$!%&'&"(  !"#$!%&'&"())))* * * **+ *+ *+ *+  %,, -. /- %,, -. /- %,, -. /- %,, -. /-($ ($ ($ ($( ( ( (" ,!- " ,!- " ,!- " ,!-    ***00!11( ***00!11( ***00!11( ***00!11( ''''  2!-'/' 2!-'/' 2!-'/' 2!-'/'  1.,(($" ,!-' 1.,(($" ,!-' 1.,(($" ,!-' 1.,(($" ,!-'     *** !'0"($!( ' *** !'0"($!( ' *** !'0"($!( ' *** !'0"($!( '   ) 345* 5   . 6 ) 345* 5   . 6 ) 345* 5   . 6 ) 345* 5   . 6  -!'!( ) -!'!( ) -!'!( ) -!'!( ) -* /-78$7"% !8   #"--*5(9!!7 ":18$7"% !8   #"- ,!00!11( '*      -*7$!!0&(8$7"% !8   #"--*5/((:.*5&(;18$7"% !8   #"--!'0"($!( "**    "(!#"--!'0"($!( "'**    -*-$!!0./<-8$7"% !8   #"--!'0"($!( "*('/-(%! "<0(:*     . 68*   . 68*   . 68*   . 68*  *  00!11( '%1&<( ' -! '!!=&(; !(,(%!<!(  "# ,! %"<0!(' &"(<"/( >-$!$?: ,!" "-%%&$!(  1&<'-&?/(18 5(;-/-,!-!&(# !--!#!--!$ "' ,!@-&?/(1A8-!;-$&(; ,!$! , "#17&-5&(;,8&(-"$'&$!%%&$!( 8>,&%, ""=01%!"(*** *  ,! -&?/(1 7&$! >-$ $ !$ **8 >-$!$ %"<0!(' &"("# '*8B8BC " ,!%1&<( '00!11( '&( ,!- &" "#)8>,!-! '8("%"<0!(' &"(<"/( >';-( !$ "%1&<(  0-"#"-<-!'0"($!( "*?-" ,!-"# ,!$!%! '!$* >',!1$ ,  17&-5&(;,$&!$$/! " ,!-"$'&$!%%&$!( >,&%,>'-!'/1 "#-', ATUL SETHI 2026.04.10 15:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh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s.7,68,000/- (48,000 X 16) B* / /-!0-"'0!% 'GH '*8I8CH"#I8+8 +* 4"''"#%"('"- &/< '*8C I* /(!-1!F0!('!' Rs.15,000/- * 4"''"#!'  ! Rs.15,000/- * !$&%1?&11' '*88BC  " 1) " 1) " 1) " 1) '* '* '* '*8B8B 8B8B 8B8B 8B8BCCCC  *  ,! 0-!'!(  00! 18 #&1!$ ?: ,! %1&<( ' '!!=&(; !(,(%!<!( 8,'?!!(%"( !' !$?: ,!-!'0"($!( '* *  4! -(!$ %"/('!1 #"- ,! 00!11( ' %"( !($' ,  ,! -&?/(1,'%"('&$!-!$ ,!&(%"<!"# ,!$!%! '!$"(1">!-'&$!' ,! >'  '=&11!$ >"-=!-*    &' 1'" %"( !($!$ ,  %"<0!(' &"( "( %%"/(  "# 1"'' "# %"('"- &/< ,' ?!!( >-$!$ "(1: " "(! "# ,! %1&<( ' %,, - . /-<" ,!-8 >,!-! '8 &  "/;,  " ,7! ?!!( ATUL SETHI 2026.04.10 15:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh FAO-3843-2019 3 ;-( !$ "%1&<( C00!11( "* ""05&(;,# ,!-'>!11* & !' 5-12!-< -'*7 5-12!-< -'*7 5-12!-< -'*7 5-12!-< -'*7''''*!1,&-('0"-  "-0"- &"( -'*8+ *!1,&-('0"-  "-0"- &"( -'*8+ *!1,&-('0"-  "-0"- &"( -'*8+ *!1,&-('0"-  "-0"- &"( -'*8+ 5  5  5  5 8 &"(1('/-(%! "<0(:4 $*7'*-(:5! ,& -'*8  &"(1('/-(%! "<0(:4 $*7'*-(:5! ,& -'*8  &"(1('/-(%! "<0(:4 $*7'*-(:5! ,& -'*8  &"(1('/-(%! "<0(:4 $*7'*-(:5! ,& -'*8 I+ I+ I+ I+5 + 5 + 5 + 5 +($;< !(!-1('/-(%! "<0(:4&<& !$ ;< !(!-1('/-(%! "<0(:4&<& !$ ;< !(!-1('/-(%! "<0(:4&<& !$ ;< !(!-1('/-(%! "<0(:4&<& !$ 7'*(/ <1&' ,/,-/ < -'*85  7'*(/ <1&' ,/,-/ < -'*85  7'*(/ <1&' ,/,-/ < -'*85  7'*(/ <1&' ,/,-/ < -'*85 * *  !- %"( -8 1! -(!$ %"/('!1 -!0-!'!( &(; ,! -!'0"($!(  ('/-(%! "<0(:,'(" $&'0/ !$ , ?" ,0-!( '-!!( & 1!$#"- %"('"- &/<8?/ %"( !($' ,  ,!&(%"<!,'?!!(-&;, 1:%"('&$!-!$' '*8C0!-<"( ,* B*  ,7!%"('&$!-!$ ,!#"-!'&$'/?<&''&"('($0!-/'!$ ,! 00!-?""=* +*  ,!-&?/(1,'''!''!$ ,!&(%"<!"# ,!$!%! '!$' '*8C0!-<"( ,8>,&1!-!1:&(;"( ,!(" &#&% &"("*II$ !$ B**I8&''/!$?: ,!4?"/- "<<&''&"(!-8/(9?8'0!->,&%, &( ,!:! -I>*!*#***I8 ,!<&(&</<>;!'"#/('=&11!$ >"-=!->!-! '*IB+*B0!-<"( ,*,!%%&$!( &(J/!' &"( ""=01%! "( ** ($ ' "( ,  $ !8 (" &#&% &"( "*5C $ !$ **I!##!% &7!>*!*#***I>'001&%?1!*'0!- ,!'&$ (" &#&% &"(8 ( /('=&11!$ >"-=!- >' " ?! 0&$  <&(&</< "# '**B -"/($!$ "## " '*C 0!- <"( , ($ ' '/%,8 ,! %"<0!(' &"((!!$' "?!%1%/1 !$?: -! &(; ,!<"( ,1:&(%"<!"# ,!$!%! '!$' '*C* I*  5&<&1-1:8 ?" , 0-!( ' -! !( & 1!$ " %"<0!(' &"( "( %%"/( "#1"''"#%"('"- &/<&(7&!> ,!1>1&$$">(?: ,!"(3?1! ATUL SETHI 2026.04.10 15:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh FAO-3843-2019 4 0!F "/- &(;<3'%'!'/0-*,!%"<0!(' &"(/($!- ,!" ,!- %"(7!( &"(1,! $'&'1'""( ,!1">!-'&$!($(!!$' "?!!(,(%!$* *  (7&!>"# ,!#% '($%&-%/<' (%!'"# ,&'%'!($ ,! $!%&'&"(' -!#!--!$ " ,!-!&(?"7!8 ,! %"<0!(' &"( &' -!>"-=!$ ' /($!-) 5-*"* 5-*"* 5-*"* 5-*"* ! $' ! $' ! $' ! $' "<0!(' &"(>-$!$ "<0!(' &"(>-$!$ "<0!(' &"(>-$!$ "<0!(' &"(>-$!$ * "( ,1:&(%"<! '*C * ((/1&(%"<! '*88CKRs.8404 FL * !$/% &"(GBH '*B8CK '*88M '*B8L * / /-!0-"'0!% 'GH '*I8BCK '*B8N '*8IL B* /1 &01&!-"#O+3 Rs. 11,29,504/-K '*I8BF+L +* 4"''"#$!0!($!(%: Rs.11,29,504/- I* /(!-1!F0!('!' Rs.18,000/- * 4"''"#!'  ! '*8C '*8C '*8C '*8C * 4"''"#%"('"- &/< '* '* '* '*+ + + +8 8 8 8CCCCK '*8CFL * !$&%1?&11' 88B 88B 88B 88B  " 1 "<0!(' &"( " 1 "<0!(' &"( " 1 "<0!(' &"( " 1 "<0!(' &"( Rs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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh FAO-3843-2019 5 >& ,/0 "$ !&( !-!' *,!%"<01&(%!',11?!-!0"- !$?: ,!(= " ,!-&?/(1%"(%!-(!$* *  (7&!>"# ,!?"7!$&'%/''&"(8 ,!0-!'!( 00! 1&'0- 1: 11">!$($ ,!>-$"# ,!-&?/(1&'<"$&#&!$%%"-$&(;1:* *  !($&(; &'%!11(!"/' 001&% &"('8 &# (:8 ',11 1'" ' ($$&'0"'!$"#* * * * **+ *+ *+ *+    K  . 6L K  . 6L K  . 6L K  . 6L /1'! ,&                   6,! ,!-'0! =&(;C-! '"(!$) !' "  6,! ,!- !0"- ?1!) !' "    ATUL SETHI 2026.04.10 15:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document Chandigarh