Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2018 DAILYLAW 5319 (PNJ)
NEETU BALA AND OTHERS v. ANAND AND OTHERS
FAO/6270/2018 · 2026-05-22
Harkesh Manuja
body2018
[ 2018 DAILYLAW 5319 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2018 DAILYLAW 5319 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO No.6270 of 2018 '''' )))) .... / %, / %, / %, / %, *%, ," 2 *%, ," 2 *%, ," 2 *%, ," 2 3333 + 04 + 04 + 04 + 04 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 !" #$ 4 5 5 5 5 6 6 6 6 % 5 % 1,% % 1,%% 7 7 7 7 0 898'9: * -%&( 04 < % 2,$* (, , 1%,$ ,1 ; # .0 %>( '''' Since to the quantum narration of the fa
018 (O&M)
,? ,? ,? ,?
,? ,? ,? !" #$ %%& !" #$ %%& !" #$ %%& !" #$ %%& !" #$ ( !" #$ ( !" #$ ( !" #$ (*%, ," 2 *%, ," 2 *%, ," 2 *%, ," 2 !" #$ ("*+, , !" #$ ("*+, , !" #$ ("*+, , !" #$ ("*+, , %, +0,*% (&* % ,1 !" #$ %, +0,*% (&* % ,1 !" #$ %, +0,*% (&* % ,1 !" #$ %, +0,*% (&* % ,1 !" #$ 2 ,% % 1"++!" #$ ( 2 ,% % 1"++!" #$ ( 2 ,% % 1"++!" #$ ( 2 ,% % 1"++!" #$ ( 04(1 04,1 *%, ," 2$ ,1 04(1 04,1 *%, ," 2$ ,1 04(1 04,1 *%, ," 2$ ,1 04(1 04,1 *%, ," 2$ ,1 4 % , %,1 4 % , %,1 4 % , %,1 4 % , %,1 6 7 6 7 6 7 6 7 % 7( ,(4 &,2 ,% **++ %(# $ % !4 &,2 ,%%*, ,)A "% 2,$ BBBB 4 4 4 4 0 0,1*% ** +42 ++ # -0 + % , ,% 22( %(-" +C>4 %-0 $," , **++ A2+ ($ +, # ,11(+( #,1* ( (, (++( % +(= >( $, ,%&(2"+ % 22( 4,2 Since the sole issue for determination ntum of compensation awarded by f the facts of the case is omitted herein ,?':9,1'98; @> ,?':9,1'98; @> ,?':9,1'98; @> ,?':9,1'98; @> F** F** F** F**++ ++ ++ ++ F *, F *, F *, F *, ')9) ')9) ')9) ')9)'9' '9' '9' '9'???? 2 2 2 2 ''''''''99993333'9'?
'9'? '9'? '9'? , -( , -( , -( , -( ''''''''99993333'9'? '9'? '9'? '9'? $ ( $ ( $ ( $ ( (*%, ," 2 (*%, ," 2 (*%, ," 2 (*%, ," 2
"++
"++
"++
"++ ,11"++ ,11"++ ,11"++ ,11"++ , **+(2 -+ , **+(2 -+ , **+(2 -+ , **+(2 -+ ,$* 0 # - + ( , % 2( + ($ %(-" +4
+ + ;
,1 .4.94999AG % # ( ( % D:3E*% " (= (, , 22," ,1 ,1, ,22"%% , '99.'9? ination in the present appeal is confine d by the learned Tribunal, a detaile herein for the sake of brevity. 1
+ ;1,%
"$ ,( onfined detailed MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.6270 of 2018
) % -02, # -," .0 ( #(( 2 $," ,1 2, , 2 ( % +, ,)A ,)A ,)A ,)A . % ,$* 0 ( ,11 ( # &(2+ 2,$* (,
DISCUSSION A 3 -,,H,1 2 **++ ? * 22( 4 # 2,,+4 + + ( 2,$4 *% + ,"% 4( ( ( ( ( 018 (O&M) % 2," + 1,% **++ ( # 2 4 .0 % $%( ,%(," " 4 ( 2,$D )94999*% "$ ,1 2,$* (, #% " % ( + + $"+ (*+(% +, (+ -( #, +, %( %2, % 4+ % 2," +%*% % %1" 1 2 "$ ,1 22( (2+4 , &% "-$( ( -0 + % %(-" +2 AND REASONING & % + % 2," +1,% 1( 1,%2( %#"$ *%" +,1 %2,% %& + # -," .0 % " + + % %(-" +4 (+ ( 2,$,1 2 J*,( (, ,1 + 4 (&((, #!(- ( +& - - ( # #!(- ( +& - - ( # #!(- ( +& - - ( # #!(- ( +& - - ( # G2+ ($ (+ ($*"# ($,1 22( 4 $( 4 + %(-" +%% 2," +1"% %2, % 2, & (, + , +(% **+( ++ % ,1( % ( ( #%*, ,)A "% ,% &
#+(# 2 ,1 1 2 ,1 *% 2 4 +2 ++ 1,% ,( %1% 2 % * % ( *%" * * & 2 -0+ % ," +1,% 2 4 ($,1 " 0( #( I % **+0( # *%( 2(*+ ,1 , (, )94999AG*% "$, & (, 2 ,1 , K-+ "*%$ #!(- ( - %( % #!(- ( - %( % #!(- ( - %( % #!(- ( - %( %4%*,% 2 # ( ,% ( , ( % % 2 1 4 *%G ,% 1 (, + &%4 %$ MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.6270 of 2018 '9'3 9: '9'3 9: '9'3 9: '9'3 9: ( &,+&( # $( ,% **+(2 -+ ,H( ( !" #$
“9. incli In th take deter and suffe cann the p child accid head the m relev arise Jagd Greo 3692 ? In vi Court deems it ap the skilled ones, a per month. Acco Rs.9,263.71, whic compensation. 018 (O&M)
9:9 9:9 9:9 9:94 ,-%& 2,$* (, ,% ,"# , - %$( , H(++ ,%H%( %+& (%*%, "2 %( " %5
“9. On the aspect of monthly incom inclined to interfere with the judgme In the present case, it is evident tha take into account the monthly i determining the quantum of compens and consistently reiterated principle suffers death or permanent disabil cannot be placed in the same catego the purposes of assessing the amou child was not engaged in gainful accident. In such a case, the compu head of loss of income ought to be m the minimum wages payable to a sk relevant period in the respective S arises. The said observation was re Jagdish Chand and Ors., (2020) Greola v. Manzoor Ahmad Simon 3692.” In view of the factual and legal pos s it appropriate to advert to the preva ones, as in the year of accident, i.e., 20 . Accordingly, the monthly income , which is rounded off to Rs.9,265/- (, ( $, ,% 22( 2+ ($ 2 - ( ,1 $( ($"$ # ($ +& * % #% * ncome of the minor appellant, we a gment and order of the Courts below t that the Courts below have failed ly income of the appellant whi pensation.
It is now a well-entrenche ciple of law that a minor child wh sability in a motor vehicle acciden tegory as a non-earning individual fo amount of compensation because th nful employment at the time of th mputation of compensation under th be made by adopting, at the very leas a skilled workman as notified for th ive State where the cause of actio s rendered by this Court, in Kajal 020) 4 SCC 413, and Baby Saksh on and Anr., 2024 SCC Online S al position discussed hereinabove, th prevailing minimum wages, which fo i.e., 2016, in Haryana were Rs.9,263.7 come of the deceased is assessed - for the purpose of computation o 3
2 # *,1 e are below. iled to while nched d who cident, l for se the of the er the least, or the action ajal v. akshi ne SC ve, this hich for ,263.71 ssed at tation of MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO No.6270 of 2018 QUESTION O MULTIPLIER A : # -," .0 ,"+ ,% ( %(+0 *%, + $( ($ +4 J*2 ,-2 0," #, ,1 ,( 2% ( Verma’s case an 2009(3) RCR(Ci "2 (, ,139E **+( 4 !" # %"+ +& J <<<<) $%+ $%+ $%+ $%+ ,1&( ,1&( ,1&( ,1&( * * * * $," $," $," $," "$- ,1* ,* 1 $(+0 ++, ( 2,$ , , 1, 018 (O&M) N OF DEDUCTION TOWARD IER AND FUTURE PROSPECTS 2 ( 4 2 0 % , 0 ( (+02, ( " $ !,%*,% (, ,1( 1( 2( + ( * 2 ,1 "- ( + * % ,1 ( % ( 2, %(-" , % "**,% 2+ ($ 4(1( 2( +2, %(- ( # % % ($( ( + e and others v. Delhi Transport C R(Civil) 77, *%2%(- 39E,1 ( 2,$ , % #$ ( +12+ %(1( "2 J % 2 (%*%, "2 %" %5G " 4"2*%2 #,1 "2 (, " 4"2*%2 #,1 "2 (, " 4"2*%2 #,1 "2 (, " 4"2*%2 #,1 "2 (, %+0 #"( +( " $$ ,$ %+0 #"( +( " $$ ,$ %+0 #"( +( " $$ ,$ %+0 #"( +( " $$ ,$ &( 24( ( , " "" + , "2 , &( 24( ( , " "" + , "2 , &( 24( ( , " "" + , "2 , &( 24( ( , " "" + , "2 , *%, + +(&( # J* ,1 *%, + +(&( # J* ,1 *%, + +(&( # J* ,1 *%, + +(&( # J* ,1 ," +(H+0 , &- * , ," +(H+0 , &- * , ," +(H+0 , &- * , ," +(H+0 , &- * , &%(+,H % LII?;.> $-%,1 *
( 1 $(+0,1 *2(1(2&( 2( %# % ,2, %( ,* " ( $ , 1,% %%(&( # $(+00 ( $ , 4 ," ( ( + +, , 2$( ,%4 , + "$- 2,$( (&( -0 , + "$-%, , , %%(& *%, ++(&( #J* 1,++, ( #(++" % (, 5 ARDS PERSONAL EXPENSES CTS ($ ,1 $( # %*%, +J* ( " (( 2,$ "2 % #4 ,1 2 ,"+ & - ( # ,"+ % , -+0 & - % ,1 1 $(+0,%,&%4-( # %(-" (, , ,",+ +(H + ,"# + + ( , ( Sar rt Corporation and anr reported a % 2 ( - 2+,% (*%, +J* (,% ( % "2 (, ( , ( 1+J(-+,%%(# (, ( , ( 1+J(-+%"+ ,11 (, ( , ( 1+J(-+%"+ ,11 (, ( , ( 1+J(-+%"+ ,11 (, ( , ( 1+J(-+%"+ ,11 $ 4( ,-%& ( - $ 4( ,-%& ( - $ 4( ,-%& ( - $ 4( ,-%& ( - 2 , 2 , 2 , 2 , GGGG (% (% (% (% ,1 #%,( 2,$ , ,1 #%,( 2,$ , % ,1 #%,( 2,$ , ,1 #%,( 2,$ , % 2 % - + 2 2 % - + 2 2 % - + 2 2 % - + 2 $$-%,1 1 $(+0A *
$$-%,1 1 $(+0A * $$-%,1 1 $(+0A * $$-%,1 1 $(+0A * ?;.>)?'M4 (,"% + (1 ,1 2 + %#4( - %(-" (, , 1 $(+04 ,"% $ 2, %(-" (, ,1 2 , ( ++, , 2 "+ , " ( $-%,1" ( % %$( %,1" ( N", ( ($"+ (*+( J* ,1 2 (,"% # 4 NSES, ( ,% ( "% 4 - - # +(H+0 Sarla orted as +,%4 %(+0 %(#( ,11% ,11% ,11% ,11% - 2 - 2 - 2 - 2 % % % % (1 - 2 % $ 0 ,( " ( ( +( -0 % # & MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment FAO No.6270 of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
- *%2 # ,1 - *%2 # ,1 2 , -#,&% -0 0%(#( %"+, , -#,&% -0 0%(#( %"+, 2 , -#,&% -0 0%(#( %"+, , -#,&% -0 0%(#( %"+, ,"+ * "*, 2(%2"$ 2,1 ,"+ * "*, 2(%2"$ 2,1 ,"+ * "*, 2(%2"$ 2,1 ,"+ * "*, 2(%2"$ 2,1 - 2+,% ,1 ( "%%( - 2+,% ,1 ( "%%( - 2+,% ,1 ( "%%( - 2+,% ,1 ( "%%( , * % ,"+ &- +% , * % ,"+ &- +% , * % ,"+ &- +% , * % ,"+ &- +% %(-" + (#,"% % %(-" + (#,"% % %(-" + (#,"% % %(-" + (#,"% % &( ,1 *2( +1 "%,1 2 ( ,1 *2( +1 "%,1 2 &( ,1 *2( +1 "%,1 2 ( ,1 *2( +1 "%,1 2 "2 (, , % *%, + +(& "2 (, , % *%, + +(& "2 (, , % *%, + +(& "2 (, , % *%, + +(& ( 2,$C 2,$C ( 2,$C 2,$C &( ,1 1,% ( (2"(, *% 2 , J .9E4 .9E4 .9E4 .9E4( ,1 % 39E 39E 39E 39E 2 ,"+ -!" 4% , !" 4% , !" 4% , !" 4% , $ 2,1 2 (( 22( + &-( $, +0 ( 2,$ )399 (% %0$, %,"# % 0$ ( &( 2 1,% 2,$( #4 ( # ," ( 1,% "+ , " $
H'Q'R." ( 2$( ,%, ( " %*%" ( ,%H," 2 "- "$ 999 ,%H( # $$-% ,$ *%,&((, 1,% ,- ($ *% J* '39" $," ," , '39 *% $, *% $, 9R ''39*%$, ( $," 2 * O (* 2 ,%04'99.;'> ;(&(+>?
(* 2 ,%04'99.;'> ;(&(+>?
(* 2 ,%04'99.;'> ;(&(+>?
(* 2 ,%04'99.;'> ;(&(+>?
( %( # **%,*%( ,1 39 ( %( # **%,*%( ,1 39 ( %( # **%,*%( ,1 39 ( %( # **%,*%( ,1 39 &( #J* ,1 2 $ &( #J* ,1 2 $ &( #J* ,1 2 $ &( #J* ,1 2 $ ,1 "2 (, 1,% *%, + J* ( " ,1 "2 (, 1,% *%, + J* ( " ,1 "2 (, 1,% *%, + J* ( " ,1 "2 (, 1,% *%, + J* ( " +,%1,%$"+ ,1" (&% + **+(2 (, +,%1,%$"+ ,1" (&% + **+(2 (, +,%1,%$"+ ,1" (&% + **+(2 (, +,%1,%$"+ ,1" (&% + **+(2 (, ,1 22 2 " (*" ,1 22 2 " (*" ,1 22 2 " (*" ,1 22 2 " (*" %( 1 %( 1 %( 1 %( 1 %$ %%( #4 2, %(-" ( %$ %%( #4 2, %(-" ( %$ %%( #4 2, %(-" ( %$ %%( #4 2, %(-" ( % 4 %1,%4 H( # ,&% ++&( % 4 %1,%4 H( # ,&% ++&( % 4 %1,%4 H( # ,&% ++&( % 4 %1,%4 H( # ,&% ++&( %!" (1( ( 1(J( # "2 (, O %!" (1( ( 1(J( # "2 (, O %!" (1( ( 1(J( # "2 (, O %!" (1( ( 1(J( # "2 (, O 2 4 (,"% , &%% %(2 2 4 (,"% , &%% %(2 2 4 (,"% , &%% %(2 2 4 (,"% , &%% %(2 +(&( # J* , , +(&( # J* , , +(&( # J* , , +(&( # J* , , GGGG (% ,1 (% ,1 (% ,1 (% ,1 ;$* ("**+( ;$* ("**+( ;$* ("**+( ;$* ("**+( (, 4 ( ,"% ( ,1 2, ( % J2* (, + 1,, ( # 22,% ( #+0 9E4 9E4 9E4 9E4 , % *%, + +(&( -+ **%,*%(
-+ **%,*%( -+ **%,*%( -+ **%,*%( ( *2"+ 5 ( ( (% 4 , , " ( ,%, ," , 9 ,% ( % $," $, 2 (+>?I (+>?I (+>?I (+>?I 39E 39E 39E 39E -0 -0 -0 -0 ( "% ( "% ( "% ( "% (, (, (, (, " +0 " +0 " +0 " +0 (-" (, -" (, (-" (, -" (, ++&( ++&( ++&( ++&( , O , O , O , O ,1 ,1 ,1 ,1 *+( > *+( > *+( > *+( > % +04 +(&( # 2"+( % MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.6270 of 2018 8
"% 1" "% *%,*2 7"$ %%(* ( 7"$ %%(* ( 7"$ %%(* ( 7"$ %%(* ( %( (&( !" #$ $ $ $ $ '9);I> '9);I> '9);I> '9);I>
“? *% * % 1(+ -( : 2 ," ( 2% ( 2% ( 2% ( 2% + + + + J*
Thus (supra), this Cour
judgment and re reported as 2017( the income of the QUESTION OF
9. Furthermor Sarla Verma’s ca
“United India In 780, compensatio assessed accordin 018 (O&M)
"% %$,%4 %# % N" 2 4 %+( 2 ( ( %# % ( *+ 2 ( ( ( (& %( + "% 2,$* 0 & %( + "% 2,$* 0 & %( + "% 2,$* 0 & %( + "% 2,$* 0 &((, - 2 ,1 , K-+ * $ 7"$ %( , %%" $ 7"$ %( , %%" $ 7"$ %( , %%" $ 7"$ %( , %%" ?3 ?3 ?3 ?3,-%& " %5G ? 1 2 ( -0 H( %,+ -0 H( %,+ -0 H( %,+ -0 H( %,+ % 2 % 2(+ ( % ,"+ 1( ( +0 , (+ -0 ( -+ 2(+ 4 ( , -(+( ( #2, ( (, ,1$ +% % ( $ 04 %,1 ,*( %,1 ,*( %,1 ,*( %,1 ,*( - ,* *% ( ($"$/
" + #%4 1,% + 2( 0 ( ( 2% ,- ,* 1,%1" "% 2% ,- ,* 1,%1" "% ( 2% ,- ,* 1,%1" "% 2% ,- ,* 1,%1" "% + ( + ( + ( + ( $ 7"$ %( $ 7"$ %( $ 7"$ %( $ 7"$ %(;"*% > ;"*% > ;"*% > ;"*% > J* FC Thus in view of the law laid dow s Court deems it fit to apply multiplier and relying upon National Insuran 017(4) RCR (Civil), this Court deem of the deceased towards future prospe N OF COMPENSATION UNDER C ermore, in view of the judgment of ’s case and others’s case (supra); ia Insurance Co.Ltd. vs. Satinder K ensation awarded under conventiona cordingly. Appellants/claimants are th (, ,1 **%,*%( $"+ (*+(% + 2 , !" #$ ,1 & & & & 0 0 0 0 %*,% '9'3. '9'3. '9'3. '9'3.
*J ,"% (+ %+0( # "*, , , % , , % , , % , , %%*,% ,+ ,+ ,+ ,+ ;"*% > % N"( ( ( 2 1%,$ 2+ ($ ,1 2,$* (, -0 (11% 1,, ( #1%,$ ,1 2+ , +(& % ,1 (A% +(1 ( % (, &%( 2, ( 2 ,*( (, ,*( (, ,*( (, ,*( (, $, +0 , (, +( 2,$ $/ #2 4I.84 (2-, + % 0 ( 3.99AG *% $, .9 .9 .9 .9
"%*%,*2 $"+ (*+(%(3
"%*%,*2 $"+ (*+(%(3
"%*%,*2 $"+ (*+(%(3
"%*%,*2 $"+ (*+(%(3 , G +1 "2 (, 1,% *%, d down in Devendra Kumar Tripath ltiplier of 15. Further in light of the sa surance Company v. Pranay Seth rt deems it appropriate to grant 40% o rospects. ER CONVENTIONAL HEADS nt of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Sm ; Pranay Sethi’s case (supra) an er Kaur”, reported as (2021) 11 SC entional heads is also required to b are thus, held entitled for Rs.18,000 6
% & % % & % % .'I .'I .'I .'I ,% $ -0 2+ ($ ( 2,$ % .9E .9E .9E .9E 3 3 3 3 %, + ipathi the said Sethi 40% of Smt. pra) and 1 SCC d to be 18,000/- MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.6270 of 2018 as compensation u Consortium is appellants/claima consortium. CONCLUSION
10.
In vi are held entitled f S.No. Nat
1. Ann Rs.
2. Ded
3. Net
4. Futu
5. Tota
6. Los 18
7. Los
8. Fun
9. Los
10. Tot
11. Am
12. Enh
QUESTION OF ( " ,%0 - 1 * A $, %,1 - **,% (, , S S S S ' &( ,1 ,- 018 (O&M)
tion under funeral head and Rs.18,00 is assessed to the tune of R laimants being the parents of the ION In view of the discussion made herei titled for the grant of compensation in t Nature Annual Income of Deceased (mont Rs. 9,265/-) Deduction (40%) Net Income (Rs.1,11,180-44,472) Future Prospects (40%) Total Income (Rs.66,708 + 26,683.2 Loss of Income after applying mu 18 as per the age of 15 (93,391.2 x Loss of estate Funeral Expenses Loss of Consortium (48,000 x 2) Total compensation Amount Awarded by the Tribuna Enhanced Compensation N OF APPORTIONMENT (,% % 2 2,$ 1( 22%" %"*, 4 ++ ( % (,,1?95.94 %-0 2 4-( # + G+# + , 1 %4( 22,% 2 ( + #% ,1( % D:3E*% -%& (, $ -0 , K-+ 18,000/- towards loss of estate. Loss o of Rs. 96,000/- (48,000 x 2) a f the deceased are entitled to fili e herein above, the appellants/claiman ion in the following manner:- Amount (in Rs.) (monthly income Rs. 1,11,180/- Rs. 44,472/-
Rs. 66,708/- Rs.26,683.2/- ,683.2) Rs. 93,391.2/- ing multiplier of 91.2 x 15) Rs. 14,00,868/- Rs. 18,000/- Rs. 18,000/-
Rs. 96,000/- Rs.15,32,868 /- ibunal Rs. 4,40,000/- Rs. 10,92,868/- ,$* (, $," 4 +, # ( ++ - **,% (, $, # 0?9E % ++ &,+&"*, # +(%4 %$ ( ( #.9E + % "$( , N"( -+ !" +"*%$,"% ( <$ "* <$ "* <$ "* <$ "* 7
Loss of 2) as filial laimants
++ ++
" ( *( ( *( ( MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
FAO No.6270 of 2018 , %& , %& , %& , %& ;.> 3) ;.> 3) ;.> 3) ;.> 3) , % , % , % , %&7 &7 &7 &7 ( % ( 2+ ($ 1%, 2 ( $ % 1 % +, # , 0 + 2+ ($ + ) & ( 2 ,1
**+(2 (, ;>4(1 0 0 0 0''''''''4444'9' '9' '9' '9'???? (H / / 018 (O&M)
(, + "% 2,$* 0($ (, + "% 2,$* 0($ (, + "% 2,$* 0($ (, + "% 2,$* 0($ **%,& ( "-N" !
% 0 0 , %4'9 % 0 0 , %4'9 % 0 0 , %4'9 % 0 0 , %4'9 2 ,IE*% "$, $ 1%,$ ,1( ( " (, ,12+ $," ( , * ( ( ( %$ # ( 'E( % 1%,$ J*( ,$ (, % $," ++- "2 1%,$ 2 &( ,1 1,%#,( # (2"(, 4 **++ A2+ ($ + 4(1 04 ++ +, (*, , %* H( #A% , A, %%*,% -+ A, ($( , %4 ($( , %4 ($( , %4 ($( , %4%*,% ;'99 ;'99 ;'99 ;'99 !" #$ ( + <
" $$ <
" $$ <
" $$ <
" $$ %4'9.;> ;(&(+>..) %4'9.;> ;(&(+>..) %4'9.;> ;(&(+>..) %4'9.;> ;(&(+>..)4 "4 $," ,12,$* (, % 2+ ($* ( (, (++( % +(= (, $, 4 $ ++-* 0 - J*(%0,1*%(, ,1 %$, 1%,
" ,12,$* (, +% 0* ( 2 2,$* (, , 4 *% ** +*%1%% ++, ( # $(2++ , ,1 ; 7 > ; 7 > ; 7 > ; 7 > 8
;'99I> ;'99I> ;'99I> ;'99I> 4 , 0 -+ 1%,$ ( , ," MOHMED ATIK 2026.05.22 14:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment