Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2018 DAILYLAW 5307 (PNJ)

GENERAL MANAGER NTPC APCPL JHARLI v. SURAJBHAN AND ORS

CR/5487/2018 · 2026-04-07

Harkesh Manuja

body2018

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

CR No.5487 of 2018                                                           "##$% "   &'"%    "   &'"%    "      !  !  !  ! '34 '34 '34 '345555      "+2 4333)+#   '% '$333   +. 9#$%*'$#-*$%(# 02%(*'6"%*(  ':;4'&  ':;4'&  ':;4'&  ':;4'& =>  2 3? 3;3;)+# '6"%,7(#"#02 )"+2#"9+-#02 (O&M)                           ':;  ':;  ':;  ':;    +%#'&# +%#'&# +%#'&# +%#'&#                                      !     !     !     ! "*A+ *$8(,-.'/+%# '"%(#)#%*%*'$#" " (+(+",-.'/+%# '"%(#"#)'$-#$% "0(*$+.!+1*+,,+"2+$ BBBB  , "+1  , "+1  , "+1  , "+1 '&33 '&33 '&33 '&33 "+2#" 9+-# *$ %(* +))1*/+%*'$ * #-02%(*'6"% '%*/#'&%(#+))1*/+%*'$7+*6#  +.*$8 (#+"- 1#+"$#- /'6$#1 &'" %(#+))1*/+%*'$,%(#+9#*+11'7# *(#"#02"#/+11#- &3; < &3; < &3; < &3; <  27+2'&)"##$%)#%*%*'$,/(+11#$8 #-02%(#1#+"$#---*%*'$+1* 2%(#'0@#/%*'$)"#&#""#-+%%(#*$ 02%(#"#)'$-#$%51+$-'7$#"+0'                 :;4'&3; < :;4'&3; < :;4'&3; < :;4'&3; < #/**'$ #/**'$ #/**'$ #/**'$34 34 34 3433333 3 3 3CCCC    #%*%*'$#" #%*%*'$#" #%*%*'$#" #%*%*'$#"          #)'$-#$% #)'$-#$% #)'$-#$% #)'$-#$%         +$+  * &'" "#/+11*$8 '& %(# '"-#" -+% 6#-%'%(#$'$5+))1*/+$%D"#)'$-# &'" %(# )+"%*# +$- &'" %(# "#+' 7#- "-#"-+%#-4333)+ #$8#(+0##$1+*-%'%(#'"-#"-+% *%"*/%6-8#,(+@@+"5/695E#/6%* #*$%+$/#'&)#%*%*'$#",'))'*$8% +0'6%"#1#+#'&#$(+$/#-+9'6$% 1 -+%#- -#$% +'$ +#- -+%#- 6%*$8 8%(# $%'& MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.10 10:22 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.5487 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.5487 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.5487 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CR No.5487 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment