Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2018 DAILYLAW 5279 (PNJ)

UNION OF INDIA v. JABARA SINGH AND OTHERS

RA-RF/16/2018 · 2026-03-25

Harkesh Manuja

body2018

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected                                                    !   !   !   ! "  "  "  "  %&'! %   ()%'        ()%'      %   $   $   $   $  89  .2 ; )<;  )>)( )>;)(=> )(==1 ; =>.&  ;  )?;  )?< )(  );)(= )(==1 ; 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases                         )  )  )  )> > > >       ;;;; ) ) ) )    ) ) ) )    5.'*)'*% 5.'*)'*% 5.'*)'*% 5.'*)'*%    ')( ')( ')( ')(                 "#   $ "#   $ "#   $ "#   $ %%-&).&1% &,)-&, )%'*++,,&' -+%./%0123)' )%'*%+)&2&'4,&2)5&% %$%-&*$-*,1''1 BBBB  1 %,  1 %,  1 %,  1 %, .2 '*. )::)& )%2%1 '* +% )(=>.& )?)( (==1  ;  )?;)( => >.& )>)(==1 ; )@;)(=>.& ) )?@)(==1 ; )=; )( =>.&  )??)(= ( ==1 ;  )@; )( => =>.& )?)(==1 ; )A;)(=>.& ) n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected =>.&  ;  ); )<>)( );)(= )< )( ==1 +%&' %3.5  %)2-%)21 7.&02.221 2'2@= D &.)&)(&2. )( ,5 % .&3) 7%3.'/1('% )(== 89  / %,,.&04%3.5. ++,1)&'*,. '*E-..'.)&. '* D#F )& &'.',2()%0%& '1>@()%* 8A9  %. ()%:.&0+%')( *.,&2.'%. <=@?@ .- 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases )?)(==1 ; )<; )( =>.&  )<@)(= (==1 ; );)(=> =>.& )<)(==&2 1 ,)&0 5.'* ++,.'.)& ()% )  ++,.'.)&  5,,  ++,. 21@=>()%+%:..)&'):G0) 1,,'*%3.5;++,.'.)& <+27/'*.)-%'.&:.& 2.-%2.&0*&2)'*%F 3),32 .& ,, '* %3.5 ++,. %7.&0-,,2)-'(%): ;  / 5/ )( %3.5 ++,.'.)& 5.&0'*2..)&2'2@= ,.:.'20%)-&2'*'.&'*5 &.&*&25+27/'*#& & A==A@>1  -* '* %+ %&')(7&(.'.&'%:)('.)& *)%'D'*>@'F %.(,/ ''.&01 '* ,&2 )5&2 )('*%3&-'')(3.,,0 '%.''*.&25E-.%23.2 -2 -&2% '.)&  C < )( n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected E-..'.)&5 5%2-&2% 89  .& -&2%'.)&> 2'2 =<@> 7&(.')('.) 89  * 7/'*,&2)5& 5%2.+)2) '.',2DI)%.&0 A==@>@+ # ))( ''*.&'&)( 8<9  * ')'*)&F7,  '.',2 DDDD &. &. &. &. %'.&&',/'* '*.-)(0%& *,2'*'.&%,' 7&(.')('*+% '*2..)&%&2  & '*3 5*. 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases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n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected .' A 6-20  8?9  & ' 2'2=<@> >;)('*>@ =@@> & &*&2):+ '.&'%:)('* 8>9  '.,, -&2%'.)&> )():+&'.)& .&0* .&0* .&0* .&0*FFFF- 22.'.)&, .'% ==1 0%& '%:)(2..)& -+*),2.&0'*0% %,3&'+%&) (%&)-%' H< 7- 2' .2 -&2 .0*  1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases '5%2('%+':7%1@>'* A; 5 ,%,/ 3.,7, ') '* -20:&'L & '* :&5*.,1 72 )& '* , @>1'*%+)&2&'4,&2)5&%1+ @'15*.*5%2.+)2)( & '* .2 2..)&1 '* %+) +&'.)&5,,'*7&(.'- ('* (%&)-%'F5%22' '.,, 00%.321 '* %+)&2&'4, >;A)('*>@'5.'*+ .)&.&'%:)(2..)&%&2%27 -+%*.2 (%& '.'.) .'%.' -201 '*.&2;-:; ( %&'.&0 &*&2 :%G' 3,- .)&%&2%2.&'*()%.'2 0%&')(7&(.'-&2%'.)&A &)<')>)('*2..)&2'2 -%'.J'%'2*%-&2%!; < &3.5)(:/7)32.-.) 7- :&2)'*%'')( '2=@@>1+27/'*),,' .2&2'*:%G'3,-)('*E- &2%'.)&)('*'1. .0*)-%'.&#''% '&'++,  &.)&)(&2.1J!; n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected . .. ... .3   ,.:  ? *,2 '*(  . .. ... .3  > 7& 5 A '1 %' &* )%'* &* ): '&2  1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases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n RFA No.127 of 2004 . &2 7-''.&0 %.2-+')'* @=1===4;+%% %.#&2 =1===4;+%% A>1===4;+%% :G.&,&2 A=1===4;+%% &0,/1 2.22 .& (3)-% )( '  - ) '* ,.:&'4+'.'.)&%  %):+&'.)&()%'*.%E-.%2,&2 . &2 7-''.&0 %.2-+')'* @=1===4;+%% %.#&2 =1===4;+%% A>1===4;+%% :G.&,&2 A=1===4;+%% ,2)'*%''-')%/7&(.'.22.'.)& -:(%):'*2')()'.(.'.)&'.,,' & 5*.* 3% . %,.%1 -&2% '. A=M -&2%'.)&A)(' )(@M  )%'*(.%'/%&2'' %.)2 '.,, '-, %,.N'.)&1 7-' )& ' 5.'*(('(%):'*2')(+) %*.&'%'*,,7+.2)&,/)&' &2&))&'*),'.-:)('*:)-&' : )%2.&0,/ ,, '* ,.:;+'.'.) 'L 5 % % % % ( '* % % ,&2' % % % % .'.)&, '.,,'* '.)& )('* ''* )& '* .)& )&'* -&')( '.'.)& MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 12:34 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected 8@9  00 .&'&)(++ 6-20:&'2'2 %,3&'+)%'.)&  ?@1?   E- .& )'* )('* ')'* '* .3. ++  &.  +% *,,     )5 00%.32)('* %+)&2&'4,& 8=9   * ++%7))G5 89  & ' ,&2)5&%+%' '*7&(.')('* 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases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n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected 2..)& %&2% :%.'&7()- ++,.&'4 &.)& :7&(.' 89  -%' E-.%2-&2%' '*>@'1 ()%:)(2.%.:. )'*% ''-')%/ )7%3'.)&: 5 %)%22 '* ):.&0.&'))+ &2'*-1'*, 7&(.'.&'%: )(%+'.'.)&1+% *%-&2%!; H> -20 2 )& 5% -&2 3& .&') *2 %(% 'G .2 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases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n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected ')  .%% 7() %(% ' ,&0 5 +% '* 7() -&2) % ,&2 7& ++ )-, A=1 3. ,% &)- )('* &2 ,&0 '. .&'% && 7%.&0 ),,  8A9  & 3 ++,.'.)&()% )-%'.&'*:.& 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases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n RFA No.127 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment CM Nos.1889-CI & 18 with other connected 89  .& '*%()%1'*%. )(2,/.&(.,.&0 2(..&/.&) 2.+)2)( 89  +     %* %* %* %*1111= = = =< < < < '.G K*' K*' 1890-CI in/& RA-RF No.16-CI of 2018 in RF cted cases .& ,, '* %3.5 ++,.'.)& .&)&2')26-2.'-+)&'* ,.&0'*+%&'%3.5++,.'.)& )-%'(&/)'*%1+&2.&0++ +*)'))+/)('*.)%2%7+,2               *'*%+G.&04%)&2 4) *'*%%+)%'7,  4) n RFA No.127 of 2004 & *3 7& 2.:.2 )& : '*++,.'.)&(.,2()%)&2)&'. .)&5,,()%:G.&00))2' ++,.'.)&1.(&/*,,,)' 2)&'*(.,)()&&'2  $    $    $    $           9 :%.'1 '.)& 2'* '&2  MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.02 12:34 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment