PR COMMISSIONER v. M/S SWISS RE GLOBAL BUSINESS SOLUTIONS INDIA
ITA/884/2017 · 2026-08-28
K V Aravind, S G Pandit
body2018
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2018 DAILYLAW 1318 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
DailyLaw.ai
[ 2018 DAILYLAW 1318 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
1/35
!"#
$
%&
' ! %"#"# ! "#
()*
"
**
"## * & *
%&+
,
"
(* #
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
2/35
% ! - ./+ .&(( %. 0 $ *( $ *
1
./+
! 11
.&(( %. *0
2345 667889:;)%737:<7 !! "# $ %&&' #! 23) 45 7)65:27:;%))7))77
=>) 66798 >) 4>872 ?' ;=7 737:<7 6< 65 ;728' 9>)>:@ )<?);9:;>98 A<7);>5:) 54 89B 9 >)>:@ 4 5C ;=7 27 54;=7:D5C79E667889;7 >?<:98F7:D= 9:@985 7 >: ()* +
, - . 29;72 +
789;>:@;5;=7))7))C7:;79
/
+
=7 6 565)72 )<?);9:;>98 A<7);>5: 54 89B 4 9C72?';=7737:<7>:;=77C5 9:2<C5466798>) 9)<:27 0
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
3/35
! " # $
$ #$ %!&#
"
# '" ()" # %*+ #
" , ," ' ! #
-. ! # /
!&01
. =7 879 :72 >?<:98 94;7 2>)D<))>:@ ;=7 >398 D5:;7:;>5:) 54 ?5;= ;=7 667889:;%737:<7 9:2 7)65:27:;%))7))77=9) 7;< :7294>:2>:@9)<:27 0 2 3
3 %3'
-
! $ ! #
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
4/35
4
5
6 7 6 & &
89:68:;<
=
>? 3'# ' "
@ " #=)
A+
87:;B
A +
;;
. A
+
;;
+
87: 89
A /
C A A&
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
5/35
>?$ %!&#=) $
' +
7<D67
A
+
;; 76
A
'$4A5 '
A
'$4A5
>?#=) A
'$4A5
#
+
D9D2B
A +
;;
A
'$4A5
=
" $ 4!5 # -
E'$ ;;<$E<<BE
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
6/35
(), ' 8::B $B8$A4! 5 E '
$ ! # - E'$ $A *;:B838:;: ,
$ "
4$ 5 4!5#-
E'$69";6D4% 50
7
'
$
'$ A
A ) '
A0
B 3 3 '
89
A . 3 ! F 3 3 '
A
4$ 5 ! # -
A'$4
5$
.
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
7/35
. $ +
2;92 A
2; +
2;9
$
A&!&
0
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
8/35
/ =7 D5:; 537 )' >:358372 =7 7>: >) :5 C5 7 >:3>7B54;=727D>)>5:54;=>)5< ;>: 0,+. , % ,+ , 29;72 ,. B=7 7>:>;=9)?77:5?)7 372;=9;<:87));=74>:2>:@54 ;=7 >?<:98>)45<:27E49D>767 37 )7;=766798<() % 54 ;=7 D; >) :5; C9>:;9>:9?87 =7 78739:;
65 ;>5: 54 ;=7 <2@C7:; >) A<5;72 ?785B 45 792' 747 7:D70 98#
"
! $
99
! G "
C '
'
(
87H
(
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
9/35
! A
9<
G# $
!% & A
96
! A
G ' & G
! A G(
( )
A
A =
$' = ' ! I
$'*++
!,
$'='
! $')=! "
$' =
* -((I
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
10/35
$' &= %
97$
--(( )
G $
& ! '
A
A . ! AF
,'$./! ./!% ./!% ./! 0./! # 1,'$ .2
. G
92 ! A A
A
! '
&
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
11/35
3&& 3
E A . G +
! &
A A
4 5
A A F
E A
&
A
A +
! &
A
' 9: E &
F E
+
! 6, A
&
.55! A
E +
! '
! '
' $ % .55!
.7
A
F
A A
A
E
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
12/35
+
! 4E+!5 $ 78.) A 75 A A 9&
9B J
"
. (
$ E & 3&& 3
'
'
6
' , $' $ 6, /
C A
9D
G . Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
13/35
' ( E %
. ! ' # E %
- '*$ :' & ;
+
<:
! A
A
<;
+ J J / J
(
(
E
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
14/35
+ E
! F
. . F
! A
<8$
. A
! AF
A
<9
. %
2/! A '
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
15/35
,
J A
$
/ *
&
A
<<
' . *
E
' . " 87:)A
A
' /
. A C "
;<9 ;<2
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
16/35
'
2/! A
2/! A )
)
<6 & 3 ' . . / J
3'
E
2/! A
. . F 3 ' 2/! A
/
. )
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
17/35
. )
.
/
G
-) & < = *'$ &&&)+
<7 $
A$
( 4K
E
K
A A
'A '$ E 5 /
) F
K
&
&
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
18/35
/
+ A . & ' 2/! 2. A
<2$ . )
&
A E 3'
<B
&
$
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
19/35
<D J J )/
. "
, #& =
>
C ' "
? *$@ , ( ,
. "
F
2/! A
) &
' $)$A;+ 6:3. F
3' 3 '
" 87:)A
A
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
20/35
AE
% ()
'
& # 1 A 6'B! C#))D/.EF7818 () /7G.G/.H
" '
" 87:)A
A " ;:: ' ! '
" 87:)A A
/
3'
6; '
(G ( )
(G ( ) +
A
" 87:)A A
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
21/35
. ' / D
* 4*5 A#! )&) &<
*$ F
A#! ;:
3 & ') (G ( ) )) * $')) *$3 !&
3 #
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
22/35
;;L ;8L
;9
!&
3#
A#! 3 =
29
3 #
&' $= & (G ( ) ) $ $ # A+
3 #
-" 3 I) (G ( )
*$ $= *' & ' < 3 # AM8::6):7
,5E//
=
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr.
Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
23/35
' < &,./// #
*$
&) ' *$ ; $$ $ $'< & ' < ( -"
!& +
;9::: ' ' < &$ ; ' < 8!7
*$ & $
*$ ) &
*'$
$
A
!&
3 #
A
!& 3 #
% !& * C
!& 3 #
). 0
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
24/35
;<
!& 3 #
). ;689LL
8< $ K + K'$>8::6? 829 $+ 6:;<8 288 4"'5 3
" '
$
$) ') .// & ) & <$ )'; '$) $= 2/! &#
86 + +
' &$) &
$ ) $= ; < $< '*$ J' & $;
'
$ < &'$ &) A
87 $
3 # *
*$ &'$ '
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
25/35
3 #
) ; & &
' ') 2/! & # 1 .2.@
% " E
%
6$ ' $
& # 1! A >
'$ #) ) F /8G..G/.H D/.HF 78 1 7E 6$F $ A
F
A
. # !F
"
# N # ' ( "
# ' F
/
' A.
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
26/35
D;;
F
/
=
D '
A
. # F
. N#
'
@ ( " #
26H
;: A
/
'
. A#! Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs.
M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
27/35
;; $
'
/
0
'E
% % *=
'
& # 1!## 'A &;# ) D/.HF 87 #, .H2 % *=
(G K #& $' )
F
/
F
/
+)O
45
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
28/35
45 NA#" $
"
# 4NA#" #5
3 @
$
# 43 @ #5 !&
NA#" # 3
@
#
45
AM 8::7):2 !&
K ) ) $ 0 ( ) ; &' $$=
*$ ;
) $ F
A +
NA#"
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
29/35
. J
+
NA#" # 3
@ #
F . $
NA#" # 3
@
#
(
F
A
&
NA#"# 3
@
#
F
$
J' ) ) < =
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
30/35
'*$ J' & $; 0 68
F
3 '
F
. C
3 '
/
" 87:)A A -) <$=J'') &) & & *= *'$ $ &# $1 69 /
$
J (
$ '
E
+
A
E K
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
31/35
6<
A
E A
! A
. ' (
A + E % . G $ / A E
& 3&& 3 6
' , $' $ 6, *'$ . A
! AF
/ A
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
32/35
+ A
. !
AF ) J A
. $
)
E
+
$
2/! A
3 '
/ . )
. 3'
" '
F
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
33/35
$' + 66
A
/
/.F 3
/
E A 4EAA5
$ A& (
E
# /
." %
( ! " 4%(!"5
" 3
4. -
5
/
3 ' 2/! A ' . /
&
. J
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
34/35
/
67
+ /
/
/ 2/! A
+
62 . . A
'
Date of Judgment 26-06-2018, ITA No.884/2017 Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) & another Vs. M/s Swiss Re Global Business Solutions India Private Limited
35/35
. 2/! A ' 6B +
0
& : ;=7 D> D<C);9:D7) =93>:@ =79 2 ;=7 879 :725<:)7896679 >:@45 ?5;=;=7)>27)*79 754 ;=7 D5:)>27 72 56>:>5: ;=9; :5 )<?);9:;>98 A<7);>5: 54 89B9 >)7)45 D5:)>27 9;>5:>:;=76 7)7:;D9)7
7:D7;=7667984>872?';=7667889:;%737:<7 >) 8>9?87 ;5 ?7 2>)C>))72 9:2 >) 9DD5 2>:@8' 2>)C>))72 5D5);)
% /
% /
(%