Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2017 DAILYLAW 3353 (PNJ)

ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD v. RAMANJIT KAUR AND ORS.

FAO/4764/2017 · 2026-03-23

Sudeepti Sharma

body2017

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-                                        ' ()& #" *   /   2017 (O&M) & 2019            FAO-47 XOBJC    ,   "    ! "#     '( %     *+%'$                #0 &$1 & +" 2    #3&$1  +  2! 4 5 67! 5..8-) 22    ,- ./ %"  " !  !" #$ "  6+ "& :" %!  ;)  +"#,"  $ &-.  +    !  -1-     4764-2017 (O&M) & OBJC-88- 2019      $       "# $%&  %) "%&%0&1 2 &(33 %'$ $%&3            5 +( "9   %!  &6<     "   +   -..&"( +( (   "(" &   "  4       4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-     4  4 55   ! 4  06.04.2017 pa Judge), Mohal Section 166 o "   + = " + >  = ?  !  + 9  ,    *("& (9    ! >" %"   "  ( 2017 (O&M) & 2019  9  "  !   5 ,6 %"    2!  "  6  5  " passed by the learned Motor Accid Mohali (for short, 'the Tribunal’) in 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 +  &(" =&? &42 (9" @ " *("   # ,  * " + !"  + !"  4  2!      ! "  4 55,6       >+ +   + "    " (9" 9 ((  !( (   >=2$ *("9  (     9 1!  ( (  $ !  .? -2-   "     "  ! + !  2 ) (  " 9  r Accident Claims Tribunal, (District l’) in the claim petition filed under t, 1988 !" %!  &+ "  2! 4  " @A   + ,"  $ &      "  2   ( +"   %!  & "+&   1"   ( "   =& >" (#" +" " & $2 ?& 1 !   "    &"("  ?  & 9" "  "   2  strict nder  " +  2         GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2  2  2      & "  =&? &42 >" "  + "     .  " "   !  %!  "  ( (1 "D 9 <<9   !" 2017 (O&M) & 2019 203      '4! 253 !        '4! 2$34 !6 $+3(    "  %!   "  9 2 (9" @A *("" 2      1              +"   ( 9   ! " !  ! !  B  " (""  1(+"++(1"  9 ( 9"  "  &9" "& (" "   -4-     &    ! 1           * * " ( "1      "   +    +"+  9 "  !  B &"        8      "  %!     (  + "(  ""    " "     + " !  " (    &  ! "     *  + +            GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-    1 2017 (O&M) & 2019 >+ (+ "&9 +"92 7)8!   #! 9  &        *    "*     +!'":.!   +!'":.*         ! "!"  1        !'(-$,./, -0  (       ! ;       &      !   *<  <  *      *        *   (            *    &      &        *  -6-  !  "           +  4   ', :.!9       ,     &     , "!"#$!;    ,     &   -0*         *           ,            &   , * ! 1        &            ! '   !     *    ,  *   =! "!"#$!;                 ! * "  , , , ,    ,  ,     ! ,    * GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019         &  -0!>*'    *   (      !(  *                  &    1   *   ! 9  *        &      * ! 1    &    & &           *     ! "! *     &       &    !)   !%*  *      -7-        ! '(-$,./,   *  !"*       &          !" , +!':(!*    ??4 +!':>*       &    !    &  !     ,    *&*    * !)  *    &,    !'("0,%, -0*     *   &+           &      & &  ,  * * , !) *>)4 &  * ! *   ??4*      & ,    ,    !  ,  ) ,      , ,    GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019 &              ! !)        *    & ! 0 ;*    &       *  >)4        *     & ! 1    ,@    !)  >)4  !            ! 9  & & *    &      ??4       !)    &  !    @ *  !)  * -8-  *     &           )  *  &,  &        !* *     & ,    !&*    & * & *          &    >)4                 &    ,        ,    *           , !)  *  ! *&*  ,              ??4 & ! 1   *  ,     , *  @ &  1     &,   , &* * &    , ,  ,  ,   , ,   GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019  ??        !)    *  @  &     *',"4   &            &      ! . &      & *      &          *       !%   * *    * %*   !     &+  &    !.*    ! 5!  )          4     *        -9- ??4*&   &    !)  *           !.   ,              ,          ! '(-$,./, -0* &  &   *     &  &                   *       ,+       !               *  &  &                 ',"*       ',           ,  ,  &         !         GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019      *         *     &   &  ! 1     (    !.          $! *    @ *    +/   * & &     -! >  *          *    & ( &    A      B'           & ! 9    &   *      A,"$  * !   *       *         (/ . . /  -10- *       &    *            !'(-$,./, -0 !       !.*        !    & *+      *    &     ,  !       ! )   &           *    !* '1:(*      & =  !  9*       *    (        *         !)        , (/.C!/ !% !  (       !       ,   *   *   ) , !  GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019   &  &     &  1  @    *   &       @    *       *      ; *    ;&   / 4  2/  3* #* &   *   9  * *       *     &     &   *       !.    /*  E !   9  /      4 *  2   / $#D &      +   F E 2   3  -11-  +!' :?*      (/.     "# $! *   (        *     !/     *   , &4! $*###:, !   *&  !4 &  *"# 02034/4    $#D   ,     !       ,  (    ; ,  &  , &*      (       *& ;E&    F    F! ?     !"##=2034/ , 3*   +     &  * !.         ,  $!     , !  4 , ! , , ,      ,  *  , GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- =  %!      !   "    29    +   2 E   "   9" "         " !("  (  @ +  "+ 2017 (O&M) & 2019   *   *  &        !.        $ +     + " 1 !  " ("   ""  +" "( (  21+"++(     "     "   & 9" "   + "     +   1 5"(      " 1 &"  %" %!  "     + F2  ( 9" "   ! "     D "& "  ( ("  !" %  "#,"  $ & ( %"  + !!    -13- * *    ,       *    *        !6      "9  " " " /    1(+"++(2 (1"  %"  %!    + F2  *("&  (     !  "  !  ( (   "  !     "   2      +     3         1 &  "   " + " ( 2(  + " D  %!    9   " & ((+D    " ++ "     + !  !  ,    "  2   "& " " 2   & "       GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-          9" "  2017 (O&M) & 2019  +3(  " 7     B;! *  " 8-6/ " 9  +    2 H!9       +       9  /  *       ! ; &@       /             +    2:03& "0*,2:53 & 5-* ,     &+ !   &  *        &  *  *    + * &        &             &    &   !>   *     &           ! ) -15- "   9      + !   6/0*" 2 %0"('! !,,9&  " 1 +  &      &    *          ;         /*           *        * & ,    &  &     2:$3&  +!  &              ! ) * $#D             &     ! *           *     23   &   *&            & )  &      & +        ,      )           &  GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019 2.3 ?        K 2(3      2/3 . &   2?3 4  &     *       K 23 >       G      ! %" 1+" ( H) .    (*           4 L! )     + *4 *##*### *##*###      ! 9      + !9 ? *             &     &        @   ! .  @      ! 9   &   +*    &         & &      ! 9    ! *      -17-    +       K    K    *  *      + *           &K  ,     + (    2 *    *       +    4!"$*###         4                      !94          ! 9      *     *   &  &     &    ! 8  *         &           &   &             *         !9    9   &  &     &+        &        *     4     *   &            GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019 * &          &    &   !9*  ! )        *         4!5#*### 4! $*###          &     &    @     &            #D      &    ! M   M )+!             *   &  &   9    &0 & 5# $#  & $#- $D!.     +! )+&!)    +   *        &  &  5#   -18-          @   *          &     +  &       &       *    *    +    & 4! $*###* ##   !9         &    !(  , @ , ! &       &         &        !      &       M  M M  *    $#D                5#  * & ! 0#D*      ! )        -#  *    &  &          ,  23     5#D    &          !.   "$D   &    #*   !   &    D   !   &       GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019  O* O    O!9    *  *  *    *              "! !'('!             O  *  *      "!"! ('!       *  *    O! "!0!  ('!          !.            !9         *  *       ! ! /       &   %         E               ! %   &   -20-    O*  O        *   *    *       ! *      +   ! '!           & ,           *  *     O! '!       * O   *   *   *                                          !/                               !  ,        +                                 !       *             !      GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- =  >"    %! 9 2017 (O&M) & 2019           *   ! 9 % F                *       &                                   &  ! &! 9        &          '          *  4  ! $    + "  ( 9 *("9 - +( 1 " (""# !  " ("  " -21-   !9            *     !  .   &            * !)        *  &        !'         .!.; /      ! ;*            &             &     &         O    O   L!)  *      45#*###    9 1  " "   & "+" &9" " #6GEF4>)%"+"  +. "    *   *                & " "  GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019     )  / 2"# 3-//-A#! $!99 &                  ! @     *"5*#0":,     ;  /                      + 4!   & ; / -! 9     /                  /  ! 9   /        *     !       &          ! 9   / &      &       &         -23-    1   ! '    *    4! A*#0*$ ":,   &    ,  &     4!  !9; /          4!   ##D   &  ! 9     4! 5   *    *,  *      , *       *""*0$-:,!9   , / 4!0"*5-*0AA:,! /              ,  &              / . +   ,     )  /            ?    &   ,          &     @ ,     ,                "##   !             /  .   * , , !   !   , ,   ,  ,   ,    ,  , ,  #     GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- .  4/  5 "    2017 (O&M) & 2019 +                                        /  .   &    *    &  4!$*###:,       &  0*0$":,!.  4!$*###     *  &  &    ##D  &   24!$*###:,P 5#DP "P   4! 5         *""*0$-:,    4    Q=D        *  ; /  &         !6  D "&B;! "*  5/3 4 ( 6 3   + "    9" 9  -24-      ,  ! 9      &          & *         !   & , . *      *    . *      *       "## *  ,         4! ##:,   *   &   '    * 5#D   !9       &4! $* "*###:, "P A3!9  &     &   ;  /       +   4! 4! 5#*05*0$-:,! 9         & 9 & R &  & & ,        ,  8!!      7 , )3 "  3 "   (    #$     ,     ,    , !  D  ,   !    , ,   "   GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- !  ?* 2 2017 (O&M) & 2019 * "2%&(=%" 1+ ! %./9*                   %/.     &  *   "#*###        $#        S AT 4!0"*5#*###!          ! A! 9; /*   %./9          *  * A*###     ! =! )          4! =*55*###! #! 9           ; /     &  ) /!1!!'      &             ! !  ) *               4!"#*###!9 -25- +"     2      *         & *, .  *        &    4!    "0  *     ! 9*             *      *            *      4!             &      ; /&  /*  *            *"# ./U" ##2 /3*        &  &    ,  & %./9*         &       2   ,   ! *       !    &     & ,  &   GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-   +" ?   "  " +     +  !  4  " ?=     33 0 1$  F"" F"" 2017 (O&M) & 2019 (" @-A ++ (+  " %"  2      +  9""% "+ + +  !  " +    2!  4  5   5  " %!   (  6 )&+& -         " 3(42 3(J 45 "!   J -28-  ""   "+  K         " %!  9"+9 +"  (%"%!      (9" "  9%"  2 +  ""!3   &    +  /   "    " 2  GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document