Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2017 DAILYLAW 3334 (PNJ)
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. v. RAMANJIT KAUR AND OTHERS
XOBJC/88/2019 · 2026-03-23
Sudeepti Sharma
body2017
[ 2017 DAILYLAW 3334 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2017 DAILYLAW 3334 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
'()& #" *
/ 2017 (O&M) & 2019
FAO-47 XOBJC
, " ! "# '( %
*+%'$
#0&$1
& +" 2
#3&$1
+
2!
45 67!
5..8-) 22 ,- ./ %" "! !" #$ " 6+"& :" %! ;) +"#,"
$
&-. +
!
-1- 4764-2017 (O&M) & OBJC-88- 2019 $
"# $%& %)
"%&%0&1 2 &(33 %'$ $%&3
5 +("9 %! &6<
"
+ -..&"(+( (
"(" & " 4
4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
4 4 55 !
4
06.04.2017 pa Judge), Mohal Section 166 o "
+= " + > = ? !
+ 9 , *("& (9
! >" %" " ( 2017 (O&M) & 2019
9 " ! 5 ,6 %"
2!
" 6 5 " passed by the learned Motor Accid Mohali (for short, 'the Tribunal’) in 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 +
&(" =&?
&42 (9"@ " *(" # , *
" + !" + !"
4
2! ! " 4 55,6
>+ +
+ "
" (9"9(( !( ( >=2$ *("9(
91! ( ( $ ! .? -2- "
" ! + !
2 ) ( " 9 r Accident Claims Tribunal, (District l’) in the claim petition filed under t, 1988 !" %! &+ "
2!
4
" @A
+ ,"
$
&
"
2
(+" %! & "+& 1"
( " =& >" (#" +""& $2 ?& 1 ! "
&"(" ? & 9" "
"
2 strict nder
" + 2 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
!9 1( " 9"
& + 9
"# 3 1 0 &"( *
-&# !" = "+ +!"
" 2017 (O&M) & 2019
"(&3"#"
" ( ( (!"++" & + & 9" " # ("" 1 B & "2& #" & + ("&+%"+&" #" &+!&!
" C
+ "
+
+
D " ( + " " %! 2 ! (
% ! '(,-$./, -0
& ''
"!)
!
*
*
* ''
-3- &"&9" 1 "(" & & "!3+" 9"+& >" *(" " &
( >"*("9 & + 9"& " 9 + &"93#B & "
11
2 & & " + 9( 9
! "!"#$ % &
! 1
*+
&
" & 2 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2 2
2
& " =&? &42 >" "
+ " . " " ! %! " ( (1 "D 9 <<9 !" 2017 (O&M) & 2019
203
'4! 253!
'4! 2$34
!6 $+3(
" %! " 9 2 (9"@A *("" 2 1
+" ( 9 ! " ! ! !B " (""
1(+"++(1"
9(9"
"
&9"
"&
("
"
-4-
&
!
1
*
* " ("1
" +
+"+
9" ! B
&"
8
" %! ( +"(""
""
+"! " (
&! "
* + + GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
- "
9&! ""(" %! " +
" 4
2! " 9 " ! %"+&" + ! " ? 9"
2017 (O&M) & 2019
B+"
"&
" (+
+"( (
" !(""
+" 9"++
!B+ 9( =A9+
+ "
& A "("+"+ ! 9"(
+
"" 91!" %! " (" " "
"
"""
2! " 2
!"
9
"1 "
+ +"
-5- " 1 !
& +"++(1"
6
)
! !
"1 "/+
"! +"
"" +
&9"&" & " (" "1! !&" (9!! + + " 5 !" %! "
B+"
"
" 2
4 5 !
! 9 ! + + " "
& )
" +
" GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
1 2017 (O&M) & 2019
>+
(+"&9 +"92 7)8! #! 9 &
*
"*
+!'":.!
+!'":.*
!
"!" 1
!'(-$,./, -0 (
! ;
&
!
*<<
*
* *
(
* &
&
*
-6- !
"
+
4
', :.!9
, &
,
"!"#$!;
,
&
-0*
*
,
&
, *! 1
&
! '
!
*
, *
=! "!"#$!;
! *
" , , , , , , ! ,
* GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
& -0!>*' *
(
!(
*
& 1
*
! 9 *
&
*!
1
&
&&
*
!
"! *
&
&
!) !%*
*
-7-
! '(-$,./,
*
!"*
&
!"
, +!':(!* ??4 +!':>*
& !
&
!
,
*&*
*!)
*
&,
!'("0,%, -0*
* &+
&
&
& ,
**, !)*>)4& *! * ??4* &
, ,
! , ) ,
, , GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
&
! !)
* &
! 0 ;*
& * >)4
* &! 1
,@
!)
>)4
!
! 9 &&
*
& ??4
!)
& !
@
*
!)
*
-8- *
& )
*
&, &
!**
&
,
!&* & * & *
& >)4
&
,
,
*
, !)* ! *&*
,
??4& ! 1
*
,
, *
@
&
1
&, , &* * & , , , , , ,
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
??
!)
*
@&
*',"4
&
&
! . &
& *
&
*
!%
**
* %* !
&+ &
!.*
! 5! )
4
*
-9- ??4*&
&
!)
*
!. ,
,
! '(-$,./, -0* & &
*
&
&
*
,+
!
*
& &
',"*
',
, , &
!
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
*
*
&
& ! 1
(
!.
$! * @ * +/ * & & -! > * * & ( & A B' & ! 9 & * A,"$ * ! * * (/ . . / -10- * & * !'(-$,./, -0 ! !.* ! & *+ * & , ! ! ) & * !* '1:(* & = ! 9* * ( * !) , (/.C!/ !% ! ( ! , * * ) , ! GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019 & & & 1 @ * & @ * * ; * ;& / 4 2/ 3* #* & * 9 * * * & & * !. /*
E ! 9 / 4 * 2 / $#D & + F E 2 3 -11- +!' :?* (/. "# $! * ( * !/ * , &4! $*###:, ! *& !4 & *"# 02034/4 $#D , ! , ( ; , & , &* ( *& ;E& F F! ? !"##=2034/ , 3* + & * !.
,
$!
, ! 4 , ! , , ,
, * , GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
*
&
!
& ;E&
"#02034/42/
3* #*
&
/*
*
!& (
! ;.?
2
3
2
3 $#D&& 2
3 :"!!2
3& + 2
3 /
A
2F3 1
99.1/%'.9) ..4?? A .
1
&
!'(-$,./,-0. 4*
&
*&
-12- &
*
A<
4!4&
* @
& & *
4! *##*###:,9*
* *
G, /.1/81.9) 4G$*###:,! 24!$*###H4! $##3 4!""*$##! 24!""*$##,*"$#3I 4!*"$#:, 24!*"$#+"+A3I 4G"5*0#*###:, 4!*##*###:, 4!"$*0#*###,
@
* ! % *
+!
@
!"
! 9,
*
*,
! +! , , GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
= %!
!
" 29 + 2 E " 9"
"
"!("
( @+ "+ 2017 (O&M) & 2019
*
*
&
!.
$
+ + " 1 ! "("
"" +""( ( 21+"++(
" "
& 9" "
+ "
+
1 5"(
"1&" %" %!
"
+ F2 ( 9" "
! "
D"& "
( ("
!" % "#,"
$
& (
%"
+ !!
-13- **
,
*
*
!6
"9 " " "
/
1(+"++(2 (1"
%" %! + F2 *("&
(
! " ! ( (
" !
"
2
+
3
1
& " " + " ( 2( + " D %! 9 " & ((+D
"++
"
+ ! !
,
" 2
"&
"
" 2 &
"
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
!%" ! . +"<< 9 ( ++( 1 ! %" 1
! - ++(1" "
(
"(" & ""
23" "+>" "
+ 4 55 4
2017 (O&M) & 2019
&"
&" G/ &" %!
"
!( ! 21 " +& 1"
"
"& "
!"
*(+
&23"1 1"
"!E
&+ " 1 ("
"
91+
(
19+"
(
!" %!
" 3"1 *(" 61 + " ++ "*("%"+( !
+ 9&"+&9 ,6 $1( 9 " 2!
3("
-14- "1
+
"(" "(" " ""
"&
9"" +& 9" 9 " 1 + " ! 1( " + + " "9 !
"1*("&!("1+" E "
9"
" "9!E
1"
&" %! " 1
!"
2 ! &1
"( (1(+2 +( 1"
)& ( "
!" %!
+ 1
+
. 2!
+ ! " +
&"
"
" +
"
"
" 2 2
"
" GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
9" "
2017 (O&M) & 2019
+3(
" 7
B;!
*" 8-6/ " 9+
2 H!9
+
9
/*
! ; &@
/
+
2:03&
"0*,2:53 &
5-*,
&+ !& *
& * *
+* &
&
&
&
!> *
&
! )
-15- " 9
+ ! 6/0*" 2 %0"('!
!,,9& " 1+
&
&
*
;
/*
*
* & , &
&
2:$3&
+! &
! )
* $#D
&
!
*
*
23
&
*&
& ) &
& +
,
)
& GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
? !"# " 9 "+ 9 2017 (O&M) & 2019
* &
* &
*
*& ! 9
&
* * $#D &
+& !;*
,
& + &
&,
! % % % &
/ 253
9J* 9
$"#""$
*
%, 0$ *%,$0-5# %,05-$# *
*
*%,$
*%, --$ B;!
* " # "$8- * & ?2$ . 9( 2 -16- & & ! & & & & $#D & & * & * , & ! % % % & & & & 2 & J* 9 / / 3* A 2 "$ 3*& "-0# *%, -0 *%, 55 5$ * & $ $$ *%,=$--# %,$-- # ! " + '( 8- , /, 5 9" + .+"#," $ &-..& & & 3* -# ( ..& GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019 2.3 ? K 2(3 2/3 . & 2?3 4 & * K 23 > G ! %" 1+" ( H) . (* 4 L! ) + *4 *##*### *##*### ! 9 + !9 ? * & & @ ! . @ ! 9 & +* & & &
! 9 ! * -17- + K K * * + * &K , + ( 2 * * + 4!"$*### 4 !94 ! 9 * * & & & ! 8 * & & & * !9 9 & & &+ & * 4 * & GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- 2017 (O&M) & 2019 * & & & !9* ! ) * 4!5#*### 4!
$*###
&
& @
&
#D
& ! M M )+!
* && 9
&0 & 5# $# &$#- $D!. +! )+&!)
+ *
& & 5#
-18-
@
*
&
+& &
* * + & 4!
$*###* ##
!9
&
!( ,
@,
! &
& & !
&
M M M
*
$#D
5# * &! 0#D*
! ) -# *
& & , 23
5#D &
!.
"$D
& #* ! & D ! & GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
&!0"'&1 (= "! 8,5
"'&': (= +" 2017 (O&M) & 2019
&
&
!9&
+! )+)! >
& F
)+,9
9&
F ! )+-! 9
! )+.!4&
* & 4 $*###*
!9 #D
B;!
* " %2*'&: ;2;( $ <! '&0 ,5-,5/ ,39 +
(=;-0*"'/" " 9
2 7!./
(
&
!)
-19- 5#$# #D & $# -# &
*
+*
&
& 0#0"
&!
&
N
5" & &
* *
+ #* 4 5#*### 4 $*###
& !6 "
+ '>2' & "'+ 0 '2 '+;'! =0="0 '2 . ( '"+' < "2'-!0*"'/ ((
1
/
'
L
!
*O
O
O
D -#
* ## '+ .
L
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
O* O
O!9
* * *
*
"! !'('!
O *
*
"!"!('!
*
*
O!
"!0! ('!
!.
!9
*
*
! ! /
& %
E
! % &
-20-
O* O
*
* *
! *
+ ! '!
&,
*
*
O! '!
* O
*
*
*
!/
! ,
+
! *
! GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
= >" %!
9 2017 (O&M) & 2019
* ! 9 % F
*
&
&
! &! 9
&
'
*4
! $ + " ( 9 *("9-+( 1
"(""# ! "(" "
-21-
!9
*
! .
&
* !)
* &
!'
.!.;
/
! ;*
&
& &
O
O
L!)*
45#*###
9 1 " "
& "+"
&9"
" #6GEF4>)%"+" +."
* * &
"
" GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
! + "
" ! " "9" "
( 9(+ "
%" 2017 (O&M) & 2019
$ +" + "
((+>$+0 & "! !
"( " " /
/ + ""
+ "
("
/
+(
"B;! /*0 ,+)
(
! 1 +((+ + "
! %" 1+" 75! 9 +
!9
)
!99
& 0*00=:,&
! 9 ;
/
*
*
/ /
A
-22- 1 ""
9 01 (&#" "
" " 9
+
B91& " +"
= / +
+"
;!
"*
0 /1) ,&23 1" (2 +
! + " ! + "
(!/ )
/.,
&
4!
& /
@
, /
/.!9;
4!0*0$":,!
9
& * ;
/
, & /
(
&23 2
, ! , ,
GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
2017 (O&M) & 2019
) / 2"# 3-//-A#! $!99
&
!
@ *"5*#0":, ; / + 4! & ; / -! 9 / / ! 9 / * ! & ! 9 / & & & -23- 1 ! ' * 4! A*#0*$ ":, & , & 4! !9; / 4! ##D & ! 9 4! 5 * *, * , * *""*0$-:,!9 , / 4!0"*5-*0AA:,! / , & / . + , ) / ? & , & @ , , "## ! / . * , , ! ! , , , , , , , , # GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- . 4/ 5 " 2017 (O&M) & 2019 +
/ . & * & 4!$*###:, & 0*0$":,!. 4!$*### * & & ##D & 24!$*###:,P 5#DP "P 4! 5
*""*0$-:,
4
Q=D
* ;
/&
!6 D"&B;!
"* 5/3 4 ( 6 3 + " 9" 9 -24- , ! 9 & & * ! & , . * * . * * "## * , 4! ##:, * & ' * 5#D !9 &4! $* "*###:, "P A3!9 & & ; / + 4! 4! 5#*05*0$-:,! 9 & 9 & R & & & , , 8!! 7 , )3 " 3 " ( #$ , , , ! D , ! , , " GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- ! ?* 2 2017 (O&M) & 2019 * "2%&(=%" 1+ ! %./9* %/. & * "#*### $# S AT 4!0"*5#*###! ! A! 9; /* %./9 * * A*### ! =! ) 4! =*55*###! #! 9 ; / & ) /!1!!' & ! ! ) *
4!"#*###!9 -25- +" 2 * & *, . * & 4! "0 * ! 9* * * * 4! & ; /& /* * *"# ./U" ##2 /3* & & , & %./9* & 2 , ! * ! & & , & GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88- - & %"+&" (" "+ ?
" +"
!+ ? ( (9 "9/ ?
"!1+ 2017 (O&M) & 2019
$#& %./9* &5#
!;*+* & %./9
;
/!9
+
&4!5* 0#*"5*###
("+"!1+ &"+
"
+"
("
!
3( $+" +"9 (=A+9 B91&" +
$ +" + " 9 " " + +
""+ + /+
(
19+" 9 9! +(&" +
-26-
&,
&,
& 4!"#*###
5#,
$#, 5*###!9
4! ! (&" "
+"
4.39:!& " +"("( 1 "" %! +
"
9
&@ 1 " "(" +" 9 + E%"+&
+" !"B;! * + !"
, , & , , ! & ( & GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
$;!2;!!
$ "
2! 06.04.2017 "
"22 #" D ? < E % = # $ . D - D %('+ 2%0 ";A0 &='& ?? * ,63, 2017 (O&M) & 2019
$!(1+&9" !
4 5 +
( %"
"
0 "
@A
9 I
<
+G GE + E ('+%2* &!'(;%&
%0&(B'"$ $A:(= ;A0&'+
='&1 $'2%0&(
- * + " /; < 3,4 -/ C 0*" 2 %0"(
-27- 9"
2!
+ ! '++%B $ %" 9
2!
4 5 "
!> . 42 426A+. ) 426=74) 426=8) . &&42677.) =&42 =&42 . &42 !53,? !C3? !3,? -!53,C3/
& " ! B;! <= "!/ ! !' '! ! , "
2!
4
! ) ! 4 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
FAO-4764-20 XOBJC-88-
+" ?
"
"+
+
!
4 " ?= 33 01$ F"" F"" 2017 (O&M) & 2019
("@-A ++ (+
" %" 2
+
9""% "+
+
+ ! "+
2!
45 5
" %! (
6)&+& -
"3(423(J45
"! J
-28- ""
"+ K
" %! 9"+9 +"(%"%! (9"" 9%"
2 +""!3
& + /
"
" 2 GAURAV ARORA 2026.03.27 16:13 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document