1 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 2 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 3 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 4 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 5 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 6 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 7 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 8 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases ?2-+%*&5-+F;"&"#",%=#$*%*:*,;**&#-#*:"..-/*&$"-7;%7*%#-",& # @? -+%*& .-,0 !$"+$ +,&#"#;#*& =%*#$-, 2L #$*##-. -+F;"%*0 .-,05#$*0*#*%=",-#",!"#$%*&7*+###$*%*:*,;**&#-#*:"..-/*&$"-%7;%5 -.%*-0A(**,=-0*(A#$"&;%#:"0*0*+"&",0-#*07-&&*0", !"#$%&& !"#$%&& !"#$%&& !"#$%&&'''' ()*+#",2 ()*+#",2 ()*+#",2 ()*+#",2''''2 2 2 25,**0&#(*#%*-#*0-& #$*(*&#7"*+**:"0*,+*%#$*7;%7&*0*#*%=",-#",=-%E*#:-.;*$*%*", GH ;%#$*%=%*5 %= #$* *:"0*,+* -:-".-(.* , %*+%0 ", #$* %= -&#*% .-,*!$-,0"/-%$&"#*7.-,D '? 5"#"&*:"0*,##$-##$*%*:*,;* *&#-#*:"..-/*&$"-%7;%"&.+-#*0,#$*'-0%"N,#-.-0 -,0"& );&# -0)-+*,# # #$* #$*% %*&"0*,#"-. -,0 +==*%+"-. -%*- ", #$* +.&* :"+","#A5 0*:*.7*0 (A #$* 7%":-#* .,"N*%& ,-=*.A5 =-D* -,0 .#;& *&"0*& "#5 #$* %*:*,;**&#-#*&:"..-/*&&$"-%7;%-,0-E"7;%-%*-(;##",/-,0-0)",",/*-+$ #$*%5#$;&+-%%A",/;,"%=.+-#",-.-,07#*,#"-.-0:-,#-/*=7%#-,#.A5;,0*% #$* 7%*:";& -+F;"&"#", #$* +-%:",/ ;# ' -0 .*-0",/ %= ;..-,7;% -%"(0-&& # 8;%-."'6"!-, ';,+#", !$"+$ -.& -(;#& #$* %*:*,;* *&#-#* :"..-/*&$"-%7;%$-&/,*,#-00&;(&#-,#"-..A##$*7#*,#"-.:-.;*#$* 7%*&*,#-+F;"%*0+$;,E-)%7%#",+"#A'"&",-+#.+-#*0*D-+#.A, #$*&-"0%-0 GH $;&5#-E",/",#-++;,##$*.+-#",-.-,07#*,#"-.:-.;*-##-+$*0 # #$* -+F;"%*0 .-,0 ", #$* 7%*&*,# +-&*& 5 % #$* #"=* /-7 (*#!**, #$* #! ,#""+-#",&0-#*0-,0?!$"+$"&@A*-%&-,0=,#$&5-, -77%*+"-#",K?L7*%-,,;=,**0&#(*-!-%0*0,#$*=-%E*#:-.;*-&&*&&*0 &525@5<'7*%-+%* !$"+$+=*&#&?5?@55<'7*%-+%*$*%*."-,+* !"#$%*&7*+###$*7*%+*,#-/*-77%*+"-#",K?7*%+*,#"&7.-+*0;7,#$*+-&* 8%"&$" #7-0-, -,0" 6-="#" 6-$-&!-, "&# -0-;, $% #& 6*+%*#-%A :& 8%"&$" #7-0-, -,0" 6-="#" 6-$-&!-, "&# -0-;, $% #& 6*+%*#-%A :& 8%"&$" #7-0-, -,0" 6-="#" 6-$-&!-, "&# -0-;, $% #& 6*+%*#-%A :& 8%"&$" #7-0-, -,0" 6-="#" 6-$-&!-, "&# -0-;, $% #& 6*+%*#-%A :& MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.26 10:16 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 9 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 10 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 11 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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⅓-,0",&=*+-&*&.*&&#$-,⅓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⅓0*0;+#", O*",0#$-##$* "/$;%#!-&%"/$#-,0);&#""*0",0",/&J GH %= #$*0"&+;&&",=-0* $*%*",-(:*5 -,0#-E",/",# -++;,# #$* -+# #$-# #$* -+F;"&"#", ", #$* 7%*&*,# +-&* $-& (**, +-%%"*0 ;# % #$* 7;(."+ 7;%7&*&*##",/;7*&"0*,#"-. %(-,&#-#* $-&*'5",#$*-%*-;..-,7;%5 *$&".8$-%-%5"&#%"+#66-/-%$-." 5-&;"#-(.*0*:*.7=*,#+;#,**0&# (* -77."*0 #!-%0& #$* *D7*,0"#;%* ",+;%%*0 (A #$* -77*..-,#'-;#$%"#A % 7%:"0",/-..(-&"+",%-&#%;+#;%-.-=*,"#"*&##$*-..##**&!*:*%5E**7",/", MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.26 10:16 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 12 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 13 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment 14 RFA No.3096 of 2017 (O&M) with other connected cases @ !"#$ R '' ? !"#$R '' @@ !"#$ R '2' @ ?2 !"#$R '' ? @? !"#$ R '@' ? !"#$R '' @ !"#$ R '' 2 ? !"#$R '' @ !"#$ R '' @ ? !"#$R '2' @ @2 @ ? !"#$R '' @ @ !"#$ R '' @@ ? !"#$R '2' @? ? !"#$ R '' @ ?@ !"#$R '?' @ !"#$ R '?' @2 ?? !"#$R '' @ 2? !"#$ R '@' ? ? !"#$R '@' ? ?? !"#$ R '' ? !"#$R '?' ? ? !"#$ R '' ?@ @ !"#$R '2' ?? ? !"#$ R '?' ? ? !"#$R '' ? ?2 O"#$R '' ?2 ? ? O"#$R '@?' O"#$R '?@' O"#$R '' @ O"#$R '' 86 86 86 86 *(%;-%A *(%;-%A *(%;-%A *(%;-%A2 2 2 25 5 5 5 #"E MOHMED ATIK 2026.02.26 10:16 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment

GREATER MOHALI AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (GMADA) THROUGH ITS ESTATE OFFICER v. ARMINDERJIT KAUR AND ANR.

Judgment text