Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2016 DAILYLAW 3837 (PNJ)
HARYANA URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY NOW HARYANA SHEHRI VIKAS PRADHIKARAN THROUGH ITS ADMINISTRATOR v. OMBIR AND ORS
CR/5848/2023 · 2026-03-18
Harkesh Manuja
body2016
[ 2016 DAILYLAW 3837 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2016 DAILYLAW 3837 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
CM No.5413-CII of 20
! !"# ,( # ,( ,( ( 12 ( 12 ( 12 ( 123333 '7 '+#9'/%'#!(,&! (#
" <&$"'* '--/$+'"#
-( 8'%!$"#&!'--/ ,( #&!-' #$! )#& ( >1>(,4 ( >1>(,4 ( >1>(,4 ( >1>(,4 @A 7 (" #$#9#$("(, <7#&!/!' "!% f 2016 in/& CR No.5848 of 2023 (O&M) ( 1 ( 1 ( 1 ( 1 ( ( ( ( > > > > '#!(,! '#!(,! '#!(,! '#!(,!
$%%&'"# ( ')%*(+'#! ( #&!-!#$#$("! '"%!!-
';' &&'&%' )%* ( ! -("%!"#( #(2 <&$"'*'/$') )' 7'" ( ! -("%!"#( 24'"%22 BBBB ) . '/0 ) . '/0 ) . '/0 ) . '/0 (,4546 (,4546 (,4546 (,4546 '7! 8'%!$"#&$ '--/$+'#$("9"% &!' $":(,#&!8'$" !*$ $("-!#$#$( (#$+!(,#&!'--/$+'#$("
" ' ;$": (, #&$ (9 #) '/$') ) ' 7'"') '++!- -(" &!' $": /!' "!% +(9" !/ ,( --/$+'#$(")#&! '8!$ '//(=!% )#&!8'$"+' !$ #';!"9-#(%'7 ,4542. ?0 ,4542. ?0 ,4542.
?0 ,4542. ?0 7 ='7 (, - ! !"# !*$ $(" -!#$#$( ,"%$')+&'//!":!&' <!!"/'$%#( %%$#$("'/$ # $+#9%:!) (&#'
12 12 12 123333(,4546$"C'"% (,4546$"C'"% (,4546$"C'"% (,4546$"C'"% >1> >1> >1> >1>(,454 (,454 (,454 (,4542222. ?0 . ?0 . ?0 . ?0 !+$ $(" !+$ $(" !+$ $(" !+$ $(" > > > > 55552222 454 454 454 4546666
!#$#$("! !#$#$("! !#$#$("! !#$#$("! ! -("%!"# ! -("%!"# ! -("%!"# ! -("%!"# %*(+'#! '"' 9"%! !+#$("
$ ,( ,$D$ $#$(" $%%&'"# ( ') %*(+'#! ' !-# "(#$+! (" <!&'/, (, #&! "( ( #&! -' #$! '"%$"*$!=(, - '7 $#&#&!+(" !"#(,/!' "!%+(9" $#$(" ,$/!% 9"%! #$+/! 44 (, # #(#&!( %! %'#!%25 45>-' &#';3+983D!+9#$":(9 #)=&! ! 1
$D$": '"%
"("3 '7! 9" !/ , #&! ' !% ! !<7 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.23 09:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CM No.5413-CII of 20 ! -("%!"# ( ,(9"% !"#$#/!% 44))555C3 - (*$ $(" (, #& /!' "!% !,! !"+ ( * #'#!(, %'#!$"( '"% F @4A !$" -!#$#$(" @2A !' ! -("%!"# C/'"% 4>3(,#&!'" <!"!,$#(,!"&'" '+G9$ !%/'"%8! @1A &' <((; @A &! (9 #*$%!%!+$ 4546 .H /- .0 4546 .H /- .0 4546 .H /- .0 4546 .H /- .0 ' 7'"'#'#!" ' 7'"'#'#!" ' 7'"'#'#!" ' 7'"'#'#!" I I I I)=&! !$"#& <7#&!+(3 &' ! : '"#!%$",'*(9 f 2016 in/& CR No.5848 of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
!*!/(-8!"#( -( '#$("$8$#!% !*!/(-8!"#( -( '#$("$8$#!% !*!/(-8!"#( -( '#$("$8$#!% !*!/(-8!"#( -( '#$("$8$#!% !"-/!' !%#(9-&(/%#&!+/'$8 8' , $8$/' '8(9"#(,+(8-!" '#$(" +G9$ !%/'"%)&(=!*! ) ! # $+#!%# 2
=! ! (, !*'"# 7 #&! &'"% !*!" ' 7'"' $ $(" $*'#! > ( %#&! ( #&! -'-! -!D 2J>(, 2J>(, 2J>(, 2J>(, ! 9 ! 9 ! 9 ! 9 $#!%? $#!%? $#!%? $#!%? 8'%! ("' %#&! MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.23 09:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CM No.5413-CII of 20 '=' % (, $"#! ! 2 5 4546' !! @6A "* #&!- ! !"#-!#$#$ f 2016 in/& CR No.5848 of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
"*$!=(,#&!',( ! '$%%!+$ $(" !" #$#$("<!$":%!*($%(,8! $# $ &! ! , (8 #&! ',( ! '$% %!+$ $(" %'#
" $",( 8!% '# #&! ' <7 #&! /!' "! '--!//'"# ) =&$+& $ "(# ! $(9 / !"$( +(9" !/ '--!' $": ,( #& &! /'"% =&$+& =' '+G9$ !%) &' <!! ( 8'#$("(,$"%9 # $'/ $#! '"%'//(##! ( %'"+!=$#&#&! 9/! #&!"- !*'/!" $": <(%7 $ '/ ( <!"!,$#!% #( +! #'$ !"#'/$#7 (, #&! #'#! &9 ) #&! +'/! +!"' $(
" $%! !% *$!= #&'# '-' # , (8 #& =(9/%<!!"#$#/!%#(#&!$"#! ! #,( +;("!%, (8#(%'7<'+;=' % '"%= #&!'--!//'"# ' !"(#!"#$#/!%,( '" !=(9/%'/ (&' #!"#('%%#&'##& % #( '// (#&! +(" !G9!"#$'/ <!"!,$# , +(8-!" '#$(" '"% #&! ! -("%!"#. !+(8-!" '#$("' &' <!!"%!#! 8$"! !+#$(">(,#&!+#'"%C( 8(%$,$! 9 #$"!D! +$ !(,'--!//'#!K9 $ %$+#$(" $(" &'// <! 8'%! <7 #&! '9#&( $#$! !=$#&$"'"(9#! /$8$#(,#& !!8("#&
"%#&!'8(9"# (%!#! 8$"!% &'//< /$8$# (, #& !! 8("#& ,( 9+ -!+$,$!%#&! !$" /$"!=&$+&&' <!!",$D!%<7#&$ (9 ! -("%!"#. 0 '9#&( $#$! ) #&!7 &'// < $"! -!
+!"# .JN0 (" #&! '8(9"# 9+&%!#! 8$"'#$(" I !"%! !%<7#&!("F</!-!D(9 ! !<7%$ 8$ !% 3
%'#!% ' "!% (9 /7 #&! <!!" (##!% '/!"# #'$" +'/! #&! ,( ' %=! '"7 '##&!
"!,$#
"#. 0 $"!% $,$!% #$(" $#$! ("#& //<! 9+& (9 # // <! # ( (9 #) MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.23 09:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CM No.5413-CII of 20 @A &! +(8-!" '#$(" '8 ;!!-$": $" *$!= . 9- '0) ! -!+$' ! -("%!"# ( '--/$+'"#. 0 =&( +#)>J1'"%!" /'"%(="! &'/ %!#! 8$"!%=$#& @>A !" ' +& ' +& ' +& ' +&> > > >)454 )454 )454 )4546666 #$; &! &! f 2016 in/& CR No.5848 of 2023 (O&M) &!/!' "!%D!+9#$":(9 #$ ! '8(9"# $" ,'*(9 (, ! -("%!" != #&! -!+$,$+ '"% +'#!:( $+ %$ +$'//7 =&!" $# &' "(# <!!" %$ #( 23/'"%(="! &'--!"! &( - !,! !% !,! !"+! 9"%! ! !"&'"+!8!"#=' ( %! !%$"#&!$ '//'/ (<!!"#$#/!%#(#&!'=' %( $#& ! -!+##(#&! !/'#!%'+G9$ $#$(" !"%$":'--/$+'#$(". 0)$,'"7 &'//' &!#&! -!';$":C !' ("!% ! C &!#&! !-( #'</! ! C
!G9! #!%#(!D-!%$#!#&! !/!' ! !"# ( #( 23/'"%(="! =& %$ !+#$(" $ 9!% $" '8-&'/F +' '8-&'/F +' '8-&'/F +' '8-&'/F +' %$ -9#!% <7 #&! -!#$#$("! . 0 #& !"!% #( <! #&! +(3 &' ! (, # !+#$(" > (, #&! '"% +G9$ $#$ &!$ ,'*(9 ! -("%!"#( #( %(,8' ;!#*'/9!=&$+&=' ,$"' $(" //'/ ( #'"%%$ -( !%(, . 0 . 0 . 0 . 0 ! C( ! C( 4
!(, =&$/! +' ! +' ! +' ! +' ! #&'# , #&! $#$(" (23 $"'//7 MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.23 09:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment