Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2013 DAILYLAW 1804 (PNJ)

NIRMAL SINGH v. MUNISH GROVER

FAO/4200/2013 · 2026-03-10

Harkesh Manuja

body2013

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

FAO NO.4200 OF 20                                            &&&&     ((((     ---- .$+ .$+ .$+ .$+ )$++! 1 )$++! 1 )$++! 1 )$++! 1 2222 */3 */3 */3 */3 !"#3 !"#3 !"#3 !"#3   5  5  5  5 6  6  6  6 $5 $4   0+$             7  7  7  7 894   1**"'"  *'#$',! * ' '$ < $*'? '+  !00$ ,/  =4;:4&;;4     8&94    *$ $', 2013 (O&M)                            +4 +4 +4 +4----                    !"#$$%  !"#$$%  !"#$$%  !"#$$%  !"#'  !"#'  !"#'  !"#')$++! 1 )$++! 1 )$++! 1 )$++! 1  !"#'!)*++  !"#'!)*++  !"#'!)*++  !"#'!)*++ $+*/+)$'%)$+0 !"# $+*/+)$'%)$+0 !"# $+*/+)$'%)$+0 !"# $+*/+)$'%)$+0 !"# 1+$$0!** !"#' 1+$$0!** !"#' 1+$$0!** !"#' 1+$$0!** !"#' /3'0/3+0)$++! 1#+0 /3'0/3+0)$++! 1#+0 /3'0/3+0)$++! 1#+0 /3'0/3+0)$++! 1#+0 3$+$+04 3$+$+04 3$+$+04 3$+$+04 6 4  7 6 4  7 6 4  7 6 4  7 $4'*+'3%+1 +$))**4 )+AB)$4  CCCC    34  34  34  34  )$ ))* ' )$0$$  $  :4;24&;( ) *3+"3$,/1+#)'+ < => )$ !# 0$+#    "$ ' 0%+!$ +0 $)+  $)+@1*'# '   1*'#@$)+3,'"' $',! * )$/'" 0+$ "$ +0 1+#                 -&;; -&;; -&;; -&;;+0 +0 +0 +0&; &; &; &;( ( ( (D EF D EF D EF D EF   G)) G)) G)) G))** ** ** **  G )+ G )+ G )+ G )+     &4;& &4;& &4;& &4;&4444&;& &;& &;& &;&:::: 1 1 1 1 ;;;;4;4;4;4;((((4&;&: 4&;&: 4&;&: 4&;&: +,' +,' +,' +,' ;;;;4;4;4;4;((((4&;&: 4&;&: 4&;&: 4&;&: #' #' #' #' ')$++! 1 ')$++! 1 ')$++! 1 ')$++! 1 !** !** !** !** +00!** +00!** +00!** +00!** +))*'1,* +))*'1,* +))*'1,* +))*'1,*          ,/  ))**B'$#* '  ,/  *$ ++$ 11' ++! +0 43((3;;;@B*+  +0 0'*'" +0  1*'# )''+ @1*'# + 11+!  +0 ' !$  #++$ %'1!*$ 11'  ' !$ 0'*  1*'# )''+ ,0+ +#)'+ + 11+!  +0 ' !$ 1  '" ' *+"  '** !$'  0+$ !$' MOHMED ATIK 2026.03.10 16:30 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment